My Full Review:
Even though I wasn’t the biggest fan of Matched, I read Crossed, which suffered from Middle Book Syndrome, in my opinion. However, I still held some hope for the final book in this trilogy, and I dislike leaving things unfinished (especially series) so I picked up the last book. While Reached was definitely better than its predecessor, it wasn’t as good as I was hoping it would be.
Reached showcases Ms. Condie’s growth as a writer. I enjoyed the complexity of this book, especially towards the end. I’ve felt as if the first two books are so cookie-cutter basic, everything being essentially as it’s described. But in this book, I enjoyed how not everything was as it seems, and the conceptual aspects of some things, like the Pilot. There were also some other complex scenes that I thought were wonderfully written, and different from Condie’s normal writing. The depth in some parts of the book I found was really refreshing and gave me something to really mull over.
The ending was also great. Even if it was a bit on the open-ended side, I think that it wrapped many of the loose threads that I was wondering about. Also, I liked the bittersweet touch that it had. The loss was never fully covered up, but the hope was still present. This balance between grief and excitement for the future was a tough balance to strike, but I think it was executed well. I thoroughly enjoyed the ending of this book, and it partially redeemed the book for me.
However, the matter of the fact is nothing happens in this book for the first 300 pages. It’s like there is absolutely no plot whatsoever. When I was updating my status about this book around page 300, I could almost find nothing to say, since nothing happened. There was pretty much one slightly major event that happened in these pages, but other than that, I felt as if the writing was just rambling. Honestly, I’m surprised I kept going, but it was only the slight intrigue of who Cassia was going to end up with that kept me going, even if I knew in my heart who it would be. But other than that, there’s a complete lack of plot in those first 300 pages, which is a lot of pages.
Also, there were some confusing parts of this book. During those first three hundred pages where all we’re getting is information and random thoughts (with no plot, I may add), there’s some info-dumps, and confusing info-dumps at that. I had to reread several parts to fully understand what these characters were talking about. There’s a ton of medical talk in this one, and while I was able to eventually understand it, not only was it frustrating to have to go back and reread parts, but some people aren’t going to fully understand everything. My dad being in the medical field, I know a lot about medical-related things, but I’m sure that there are going to be some people that don’t understand, just because it was complicated and not explained well enough.
Overall, Reached was a decent conclusion to this series. I got many of my questions answered, and the ending was fabulous, especially the writing. However, it can not be ignored that over half the book didn’t really contain much of a plot, not to mention the medical jargon that confused me. I’d only recommend this one to those who have read the first two books and are curious to see what happens, or perhaps the occasional teenager who is just beginning to read YA, but other than that, this series is pretty meh. I can’t say that I’d recommend it to anyone else, even if I did enjoy some aspects of the series.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
(Pre-release thoughts)
I think the cover is pretty nice, although it's not my favorite cover in the world, and I still like the first cover better. But I like this cover more than the second book's. AND, it's supposed to be from the POV of XANDER [yay!], Ky, and Cassia. So we shall see...
Here are the questions that I have in my head after reading Crossed. They better be answered in this book!
[Note: Beware of spoilers if you haven't read Crossed yet!]
What's up with Cassia at the end? Where is she? Why did they send her back in to Society? What's her job there? How does being back in Society help the Rebellion? What are the trades that she does? What does she need to get from the trades? How does the Society not get suspicious that she just magically reappeared back from the farmlands? What about her family? Where does she live? Does she continue talking to her family? Who is she supposed to meet at the end? Why did we skip months at the end? Why not just end the book at Ky's POV? Why extend the book to Cassia's POV, giving me a bunch of questions? Has Cassia been able to talk to Ky? Has Ky sent her a message yet? Where is Ky? What happened to him? Did he do his job? What exactly is his job? How does it help the Society? Did he miss Cassia? Did Cassia ever find out Xander's secret? Is Ky going to find a way to meet her again? Why is he so jealous of Cassia? Why was Cassia totally unaware of everything during Crossed? Why didn't he tell her anything? What about the Rebellion? How does the Rebellion even work? What do they do? When are they actually going to, you know, Rebel? How is Xander still a part of this? What does Cassia feel for Xander? Didn't she make it clear that she loves Ky? So then why is she still obsessed about Xander? What does Xander feel about her? How does this all have anything to do with the mysterious 'choice' Cassia is supposed to make? Can they make the cover pretty like Matched's cover? Why was Crossed's cover not pretty? Will they make this book's cover pretty??
Yep, Condine has left me with a lot of questions...