2.5 ⭐️ (rounded down)
one word. eleven letters.
predictable.
i read it so you didn’t have to
THE REST OF THIS REVIEW WILL CONTAIN SPOILERS SO PLEASE DON’T CONTINUE IF YOUR GENUINELY INTERESTED IN THIS BOOK!!!
—————————————————————
okay let’s just start with a plot summary.
the story starts of with Penelope Richards, freshman at Spine Ridge University. she’s just transferred for the new year a few weeks after her sister (Eve) has died (suicide) and she wants to know what/who exactly caused her bright and colorful sister to make that decision. side note, before her sister died she sent Pen her diary that held all these “cryptic messages about people that hurt/bullied her.
Pen runs into the books namesake on campus, the Sick Boys. Felix, Dylan, and Alistair… honest thoughts? they have wannabe vibes. especially Felix. anyway, so it’s automatically pointed that they might have something to do with Eve’s death right from the start and so Pen gives them a hard time and doesn’t trust them. they steal Eve’s diary from Pen and she goes to get it back from them and they strike a deal which is basically “you let us use your body and we will help you in anyway we can” and she obviously lets them because you know…
Pen has her suspicions on this one guy, Nathan, because he had someone slide a bloody note that threatens her under her room door, and to help her the boys post copies of pages all over campus. including pictures of her. awfully hurting, but it works and they lure Nathan out. they torture him, he gives nothing up, they take a finger, Pen stops Felix from killing him blah blah blah. something to keep in mind is that Nathan is a Phantom which is a rivaling house to the Skull and Serpent Society (the house the boys belong to). so when the other serpents hear about this they go to attack Pen, Dylan, and Alister while they’re at a party and things go downhill. One of the guys (Kai) loses an eyeball and the other gets burned alive. They get caught for this but because Dylan’s dad is the dean they get off pretty easily (and also Pen spun the truth). Now Dylan’s dad is kinda suspicious because he keeps telling the boys to leave Pen alone and she’ll only harm them.
fast forward a little bit, Pen learns that the boys were actually involved with Eve. i’m talking foursome involved (yeah i was kinda grossed out that they claim to love Eve so much but like within months they’ve essentially replaced her with her sister), so Pen is obviously upset about this and then she learns that the day her sister died the four of them actually broke up. when she confront the boys about this they say that it was “mutual” and this upsets her because she doesn’t believe it and runs off. while she’s thinking of everything she now knows, she keeps thinking of this one part of her sisters messages to her. the numbers “303”. what could they mean? suddenly it hits her. Dylan’s dad’s office… she snoops around in his office and finds some papers with his handwriting on it and realizes that the note that was slid under her door by Nathan has the same handwriting. the dean was behind it. when she confronts him about it he threatens her so she leaves and goes to her parents’ where she gets her sister’s old phone. she looks through it and finds an email she had sent to the dean.
Eve was pregnant.
knowing this and having read the dean’s reaction (he told Eve to break up with the boys or leave and abort the baby) she takes her revenge and lights the school on fire. things go downhill fast, the boys are pissed at her when they find her, and they “torture” her until she finally breaks and tells them about Eve. they didn’t know so now they feel bad and angry at Dylan’s dad. the society house gets shot up by Pen’s dad because surprise, her last name isn’t actually Richard.
it’s Ricci and she’s the heiress to a mafia that’s not actually a mafia. (from what i gathered, they work to take down crime families so idk what you’d actually call them.)
while this happens, Dylan’s dad takes advantage of this to get Dylan out (kidnaps him) and Ali sneaks out with them to save his ass (Ali and Dylan are 🫶🏽. they’re basically in love. in this foursome you’ve got two mains. Felix and Pen. Ali and Dylan). the shootout at the society house stops when Pen convinced her dad to stop then her and Felix go after Dylan and Ali. Dylan and Ali get a confession out of Dylan’s dad that he was behind everything and pushed Eve to die, and this whole situation ends with Dylan’s dad dying a very poetic death. the same way Eve died.
—————————————————————
now that sounds pretty interesting right? well, it was but it was also so boring because a lot of was dragged. honestly, half of them book could’ve been cut and i figured out almost the entirety of the plot within first meeting Dylan’s dad.
second, i hated the boys. if i had to pick, Ali would be my favorite just because he seemed the sweetest. but i hated all of them. Felix seemed to possessive for a poly relationship. it just didn’t work. if i’m read a RH dude, i want to see the guys fucking the guys and the girls and not giving a shit. if not this then at least not being this possessive cause it just wasn’t hot.
third, the writing is so wattpad. the story. everything. the amount of times it was reiterated that the boys were “sick”… i lost count. that’s how much. and yk what’s funny? i’ve read a lot of dark romances, and what these boys did barely scratched the surface.
so yeah, there you go. i read it for y’all.
you’re welcome 🫶🏽