“In this vibrant story about the power of the printed word and the strength of found families, every page is bursting with life and detail.” —Ethan Aldridge, creator of the bestselling Estranged “Fabulous!” —Dan Santat, award-winning author of A First Time for Everything “Glorious! This empowering read is absolutely unforgettable.” —Ellen Oh, acclaimed author of Finding Junie Kim Every secret is a story waiting to happen. From New York Times bestselling author Marieke Nijkamp and illustrator Sylvia Bi, this debut middle grade graphic novel celebrates the power that everyone—even those often overlooked—has to create change. In a vibrant city, two girls from very different walks of life join forces to fight censorship and protect the people they love. Eleven-year-old Cinzia is a printer’s apprentice. She adores Mestra Aronne for taking her in—most guilds don’t have room for apprentices with a crippled leg—and she loves life in the raggedy workshop that smells of paper and printing, where secrets and stories are always circulating. So when Mestra Aronne is imprisoned for publishing accusations against the ruling family, Cinzia will do anything to prove that Mestra Aronne only told the truth. Elena is the exact same age as Cinzia, but she’s forced to keep to her rooms and garden. To protect her, according to her mother. To protect the city, according to her uncle. Because Elena is not the charming, powerful noble her family wants her to be. According to them, she doesn’t communicate well. She’s too gullible and literal and struggles to understand other people. After unexpectedly meeting face-to-face, the girls follow a trail of clues through their golden city, drawing supporters and learning more about their home and each other than they ever could have imagined. If one person—no matter how young—can change the course of history, just imagine what a whole flock of them could do. Bestselling author Marieke Nijkamp and debut illustrator Sylvia Bi have crafted an indelible, vibrant story about finding and using your voice, perfect for fans of Lightfall , Tidesong, and The Prince and the Dressmaker.
I really hope that we get a sequel to this one because it was fun, exciting, and really highlighted the power of both the press and community.
This could be me reading too much into this graphic novel, but Ink Girls is perfect for conversations that the global community has been having about the power of media. It follows Cinzia who is a printer's apprentice. After her Mestra is arrested for making allegations against the ruling family, Cinzia seeks out the help of others to prove that Mestra Aronne was simply telling the truth. With the help of a fun cast of characters, Cinzia is able to help uplift the voices of her community to demand change from those in power. This is such a vital message for younger readers to see to help them understand the power that they have in making effective change. I know that even as an adult there have been moments where I've felt helpless, but with the power of trustworthy and truthful press as well as the unification of community, things can change. Nijkamp outdid themselves with this graphic novel. The illustrations were absolutely gorgeous, rich in color, and vibrant and showcased the Italian inspirations behind the story. Sylvia Bi was able to perfectly capture the words that Nijkamp put to page. Ink Girls is not a graphic novel that you want to miss!
I absolutely fell in love with the art work in this graphic novel, which I would give a glowing 5 stars. It's just so stunning. The story fell a little flat for me though, and I would rate that closer to a 3 star. I found it pretty confusing and pretty slow for a middlegrade, although I did enjoy the historical setting and the central friendships.
I read Ink Girls by Marieke Nijkamp, art by Sylvia Bi yesterday, and I loved it. While I've never seen it listed among books that have been banned or challenged, I think it's a great middle grade graphic novel for kids to read during Banned Books Week because of its themes.
Set in a fantasy world inspired by late medieval/early Renaissance Italy, the story is about a disabled girl named Cinzia who works as a printer's apprentice. The master printer is arrested for publishing news that makes a crooked political leader look bad and is arrested for treason. Cinzia teams up with other girls to fight censorship, reveal the truth, and to free the printer. The historical fantasy elements are excellent, the disability rep is excellent (Cinzia is physically disabled and uses a cane, her friend Elena is autistic coded although the word is not used in this world), the characters are relatable, the story is engrossing, and the messages around opposing censorship, doing the right thing even if it isn't the easy thing, and achieving more with community are more relevant than ever. It also addresses, through both the story and the note at the end that medieval and Renaissance Europe was much more diverse than is usually portrayed, and we see that reflected in this story, especially in regards to race and disability. Also the art is fantastic.
I very much enjoyed this one, and I definitely recommend checking it out (again, especially if you're looking for something with great anti-censorship messaging for Banned Books Week).
This story was really cute, I enjoyed it more than I expected! It didn't absolutely blow me away but it's good light fun!
It's marketed as middle-grade. On one hand, I can see this. The plot is pretty solidly girl-power, power of friendship, found family, "easy" resolution, happy ending, and just light fun. I actually really liked this aspect of it.
However, it also had some more complex politics and pretty nuanced themes. This can definitely be enjoyed by older readers as well. The story is also solidly written. The plot is good, clear, and well paced. It reads easily and quickly.
The art is absolutely stunning and one of the main reasons I bought the book. It's in full color and the use of it is beautiful. The paneling is dynamic but very readable. The character designs aren't fully period accurate but still evoke the mood. The setting is beautiful and beautifully drawn.
Also, no CWs or content at all! The upside of being marketed to a younger audience 😂
de art van dit boek was zooo mooi, echt volle pagina’s. ik miste alleen echt wat diepte in het verhaal, maar misschien ook omdat dit voor 8-12 jaar is. het is heel avontuurlijk, waarbij vriendschap een grote rol speelt.
Justice through journalism and speaking up in an Italian Renaissance-inspired setting! A great tale about the power of the press and doing what's right paired with beautiful illustrations. Also, a subtle-smooth representation of women of color and disabled people. I also really loved reading the author's note at the end about some of the history of journalism in the Middle Ages/Renaissance.
I think this is the most gorgeous graphic novel I have ever seen. Unfortunately the story itself lacked a little depth. I think it was wonderful that the story centers around friendship, girl power and community driven actions. But it felt a little flat. It could've had more depth, especially around freedom of speech and speaking the truth always.
In the European-style city of Siannerra, Cinzia works as a printer’s apprentice. Her mentor, Mestra Aronne, writes and distributes avvisi, pamphlets with the latest news. When she distributes one that reports on the actions of the lord magistrate and reveals his secrets, Aronne and Cinzia draw his wrath. Cinzia manages to escape, but her Mestra is imprisoned.
Cinzia is determined to find proof to back up her Mestra’s words. Finding new and unlikely allies as she goes, the girls are up against the full might of the ruling family as they fight for truth and against censorship.
I was delighted to receive a copy of Ink Girls by Marieke Nijkamp to review, and it was everything I hoped it would be, and more. Illustrated beautifully by Sylvia Bi, Ink Girls is a graphic novel about friendship, being yourself and not allowing anyone to stop you from speaking the truth – including your own truth. In a time when so much censorship is happening, it is a topic that we should be ensuring the next generation understands what it means and what is at stake.
Nijkamp has created a wonderful story that does just that, and Bi brings her characters to life with her bold and colourful style. There is so much representation in Ink Girls, which comes hand in hand with telling a story about censorship. There is so much representation that I’m not quite sure how some readers managed to miss it. Cinzia is disabled and uses a mobility aid, Elena is neurodivergent, Aneeqah wears a headscarf suggesting she is a Muslim and I read Carlotta as non-binary, possibly trans based on their character design.
I was even more certain of Cartlotta’s identity when they explained to Cinzia that not every home is a home for some people. The two girls talk about building one’s own family and how Carlotta has built one for people like themselves. Found family is a common feature in many marginalised people’s lives, especially within the LGBTQIA+ community.
I was instantly drawn to Elena. I often say when talking about middle-grade books with disabled and neurodivergent representation that “I wish this had existed when I was younger” and for me, Elena particularly strikes a chord. I see a lot of her in myself. I hope seeing neurodiversity represented through her will help other girls learn about themselves and understand that there is nothing wrong with them.
It was thrilling to see such an active disabled character on the pages! A massive thank you to Bi for how joyously she portrays Cinzia’s disability. This is what young people need to see! To the reviewer who complained that the girl with the cane “didn’t do anything”; she was doing plenty, but your ableism prevented you from noticing.
I think it’s essential that Nijkamp included historical information at the end. Not just so that any interested children can learn more about our communities’ history, but so they know that if they identify with any of the characters, those feelings are valid and no one can take that away from them.
Ink Girls is a fabulous read for all ages, although please do keep in mind that this is designed for younger readers. There are plenty of comics and graphic novels aimed at adults that will probably suit your tastes a lot better, if you find this one too “easy”.
----
Follow me for more book reviews that discuss disabled and neurodivergent representation!
♦ repDISND ♦ Join us every July to discuss disabled & neurodivergent representation!
Cinzia works as a printer’s apprentice. Her mentor, Mestra Aronne prints a newspaper, where she tries to show there is corruption at the top of the government, and she has proof. The problem is, when the government soldier’s raid the shop, and haul her away, Cinzia has to find those people who gave the proof of corruption. But now, no one will talk. Cinzia needs to tell the people in the palace that they have made a mistake that her employer would never print something that isn’t true. While trying to figure out how to get int, she means Elena, who is the daughter of the nobility, and when she hears what is going on, she agrees to help get to the bottom of it all.
Good story. Great illustrations, as a good graphic novel should have. Good adventure. The power of friendship, as always, and determination to make things right.
Thanks to Netgalley for making this book available for an honest review. This book will be out on the 21st of November 2023.
This is a great story of self-empowerment, where a group of young girls take on corrupt city government when the printer is arrested for printing the truth about the magistrate's crimes. It is uplifting and a good reminder that doing what you believe is right can bring about change no matter how powerful your opponent.
The illustrations are gorgeous, with a great deal of diversity: there are varying skin tones, features, and ethnicities represented, and the main character uses a cane despite being young. The characters are all distinct and easily recognizable with clear personality that comes through in the illustrations. The colors are jewel-tone and vibrant, helping to bring the story to life.
I read through this in one sitting and was engrossed the whole time.
*Thanks to NetGalley, HarperCollins Childrens' Books and Greenwillow Books for providing an early copy for review.
This graphic novel was everything and seriously may be one of my favorite graphic novels of all time. I am so thankful I got an earc of Ink Girls from Netgalley and got to experience this story early. This story focuses on the importance of journalism and truth, political control and corruption, strength in solidarity, and that young girls can do anything they set their minds to. This story features a diverse cast of characters both racially and socioeconomically. Disability representation (cane user) and neurodivergent rep is also prevalent! There's even some casual queer representation in the town and background of the story. This story is truly great for all ages and really reminds people that we have the power and we might not be able to do it a single person, but together we can make change.
Ink Girls is full of girl power and the power of the press. After the arrest of the town’s printer for spreading truth about the misdeeds of a high authority, her appearance befriends several young women of different classes to fight for her freedom and the freedom to tell the truth in the paper going forward. Although set in a fictional, old fashion styled city, the same challenges as today apply: people with less power and wealth are treated as “less than,” women are underestimated, and many people fear spreading the truth if it throws off the current status of the world. Anyone looking for some girls speaking out and kicking metaphorical butt will enjoy this read. Plus, the art is colorful and had a really diverse cast of characters, including a main character with a physical disability. Thanks to NetGalley for the ARC!
I feel like the idea is there and the artwork is absolutely top tier but the actual execution of the plot didn't quite reach favorite status for me. I found it a little bit hard to follow at first and wish there had been more explanations of the characters in the world building. I will 100% read another book in this series and I love the disability representation and the idea of fighting back and activism but I wanted to still a little bit more context.
When two young women from different parts of the city must come together to stand for the truth and save Cina’s teacher, there is a wild chase, some hunting for proof and lots of great edge of your seat moments. This was such a fun graphic novel. I know it will be popular with my students!
4.25⭐️ “there’s magic in paper and ink.”💌🤍 rep: neurodivergent, cane user
Thank you so much to the author for sending me this adorable book! I really enjoyed reading this-while a middle grade graphic novel, the story is definitely one of importance and meaning! The power of the plot is great and sends a strong message to readers🫶🏻 loved the girl power!! And the artwork in this is so pretty!
Cinzia is an apprentice printmaker whose mentor was just imprisoned and sentenced to hang for telling the truth. She and a Renaissance group of girls band together to fight for justice.
A longer, girl centric, extremely slow version of newsies. I have to say that the art in this is phenomenal, Sylvia Bi has some spreads in here that are evocative and gorgeously rendered, but all of that was inhibited by a long and meandering story. There was a lot of focus on girl power, which was hard for me to parse when the world was Renaissance based, aka NOT the most feminist time. Might be good for a youth journalism class, but it's hard to see the truth holding this much power in the here and now. Definitely check this out for Bi's artwork (how did she get such vibrant colors in CYMK?? Witchcraft!) but my attention span couldn't hold the plot.
Thank you to Netgalley and the Publisher for an e-arc of this book.
This has such gorgeous illustrations and a fun and powerful story about the people taking back from a corrupt leader and using the power of words to spread the truth.
I really enjoyed this book. It was a little too focused on the revolutionary aspects at times to the point where I felt the characters suffered a bit. I did like it a lot overall though.
I am still working towards my goal of getting all of my completed reads or DNF’d reads reviewed by the end of the year (while still reading new books, but those may be counted in 2024). Today we are going to talk about an E-ARC for an upcoming graphic novel I am very excited about (thank you so much to the publisher for the E-ARC in exchange for my honest opinions). I have read and reviewed novels by this author before but never a graphic novel so I am very excited to chat about this author’s newest work!
SPOILERS AHEAD
Cinzia is living in a big city working as an apprentice for a printer. This printer makes a newsletter or newspaper about the city and what is happening. This time when they are preparing to print the newsletter, Cinzia learns that they are going to be printing some not-so-favorable things about the ruling family but they are all true and verified by sources. She decides to discuss this with the person she is apprenticing for and they both know that this story will lead to trouble but decide telling the truth is worth the risk. This risk of truth leads them both to being escorted by guards to the palace, Cinzia is able to escape into the palace and then the city but the guards are looking for her and she only has a short amount of time to try to prove what they wrote was true and save the person she apprentices for from death.
I really enjoyed this story. I am not sure if the author has written other graphic novels but I know they have written several other novels and I enjoyed them as well. (I think I still maybe have one or two to read from their back catalog). This graphic novel tells a story of censorship, friendship, and how coming together can truly make a difference not just to one person but to multiple people in a community. I am definitely planning to pick up a copy to add to my shelves!
Goodreads Rating: 5 Stars
***Thank you so much to the publisher for the E-ARC in exchange for my honest opinions.
“It isn't telling the truth that's harmful. It's not listening.”
Eleven-year-old Cinzia is a printer’s apprentice. Her and Mestra Aronne are arrested for printing an unflattering truth about the corrupt Lord Magistrate. Cin soon finds allies in young Contessina Elena, pirate Carlotta, and hijabi Aneeqah; together they fight to free Mestra while also investigating the Magistrate’s corruption to restore trust throughout Siannerra.
I’m a sucker for strong female friendships and found family, so I really enjoyed this one. The girls were diverse and each had a very distinctive personality, and they were relatable in many ways.
It’s disappointing to find out that the city you love isn’t what you think it is, but no voice is too small to speak out for what is right. The text felt very relevant to the ongoing problems in the world. Vulnerable people are exploited for others to gain wealth and power, women are underestimated, and many people fear spreading the truth because it makes them uncomfortable.
The artwork was colorful and vibrant, and really brought the Italian Renaissance-inspired setting to life! I really appreciated the author’s note and how it provided historical context of journalism during the time period.
I am going to need a sequel to see what adventure these girls go on next.
Rep: Cinzia walks with a cane, Elena is neurodivergent, Aneeqah wears hijab, Carlotta is queer, all the girls are Brown but there are no labels used
An Italian vibes graphic novel? Sign me up! While the Italian town and plot are largely fictional, both are loosely based on history per the author's note at the end of this stunning graphic novel!
Cinzia is a printer's apprentice and she loves her job and her teacher. But it's hard to take a stand against corruption and evil when those in power can shut down your press, arrest you and even kill you. The city harbors a corrupt magistrate and all those who point out his evils wind up disappearing or dead or shunned. Cinzia's teacher publishes about it after gathering evidence from various reliable sources and is arrested for treason. Cinzia manages to escape the palace with the very unlikely help of the princess herself! Can Elena and Cinzia work together to expose the truth, save her mestra and weed out all that's wrong in the city?
What I loved most: the power of voice and words that glows throughout this novel, the empowerment to take a stand against what is wrong, ways to peacefully and legally stand up for what is wrong it the world, how young people have the power to change the world, and the girl power friendships in this novel
*This is one of the first graphic novels I've read where the protagonist has an impairment. Cinzia uses a cane throughout this novel and it shows her strengths and struggles without highlighting the use of it. It's utterly brilliant!*
Ink Girls: three stars. Interesting setting and lively, colorful art style. However, the writing wasn't the strongest--lots of unsubtly repeating the book's messages throughout (and the fact that Cinzia is committed to them from the very beginning robbed her of potential growth), and the ending felt rather facile. I also found it a bit odd that the author's note talked about the historical accuracy of including queer/trans and disabled characters, when there wasn't much of them in the actual story. There's one crowd scene where two unnamed boys are holding hands. Cinzia is drawn as using a cane, but it's not mentioned much. Elena is described as "odd" or "different" a few times, and there're a couple mentions of her not having very strong facial expressions, but she didn't otherwise strike me as neurodivergent/autistic (I'm only guessing that's the intention since I know that author Nijkamp is autistic).
“I may be a coward, but at least I’m not foolish enough to think that three girls can change the world.”
Ik denk dat dit citaat Ink Girls goed samenvat, want hallo, natuurlijk kunnen meisjes de wereld wél veranderen!
In de fictieve wereld die centraal staat in deze uitbundige Engelstalige graphic novel gelooft Cinzia dat er niks belangrijkers is dan de waarheid vertellen, zelfs als dat betekent dat je daarvoor een pamflet tegen het strenge regime moet publiceren. Wat volgt is een duizelingwekkend avontuur van Cinzia en haar nieuw gevonden bondgenoten om de waarheid te bewijzen en misschien zelfs de loop van de geschiedenis te veranderen.
Op de achterflap van dit boek staat de adviesleeftijd van 8+, maar zelf zie ik dit meer als een 10+ vanwege de politieke thematiek en de iets chaotische uitwerking van het verhaal.
Thanks to NetGalley, HarperCollins Children's Books and Greenwillow Books for the eARC.
This was a great read! The art style is vibrant and expressive, something I find very important when reading a graphic novel. The story itself was also excellent, I really liked the way the author portrayed censorship and prosecution of journalists in a realistic and digestible way for the age range it is intended for. The message is empowering, touching on trust, community, power disparity, and friendship. The main character, Cinzia, uses a cane, and I think Elena is neurodivergent, which was great to see in a story like this. Overall, a powerful and compelling read.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for allowing me to read this book in exchange for an honest review!
What a cool read. I didn't realize going into this book that it was meant for an upper elementary/lower middle school audience (8-12 years), but to be honest, it doesn't feel like it's meant for younger readers necessarily. As an adult and a high school teacher, I enjoyed so much about this book and had something to learn too!
I enjoyed the positive message of standing up for the truth, even when it's difficult. It feels really timely. It's not shared in a way that felt preachy, but it feels important. I'd love to share this with my students!
Big props for ethnic diversity and disability representation! The illustrations are rich and lush, and readers can learn a lot about civics and how governments change from the story. It's not didactic at all -- with so much adventure, kids will barely notice that they are learning.
This beautiful graphic novel begs the question; even though you know the truth, can you act on it and do what’s right? Through the power of free speech, one young girl attempts to save her teacher (and an entire city) from the lies of a crooked politician.
After her mentor decides to publish an article that makes the city aware of the crimes that the Magistrate has been committing, Cinzia (and her mentor, Mestra Aronne) are taken into custody by the monarchy and detained. Luckily, even though she uses a cane to walk, Cinzia is able to escape, running into a tiny garden. Here is where she meets the Princessa’s daughter and next in line for the throne, Elena.
Their adventure takes them all over the city to find the same proof that the Mestra was able to find, meeting many people, and uncovering the lies of the Magistrate, while also trying to get Cinzia’a mentor released from jail.
I loved that not only do we get to experience their world through the eyes of a girl with a disability, but there is a lot of diversity and inclusion. I love that we get so many different characters with different backgrounds, just like you would see in real life. Ink Girls not only told a story that I loved, but it also has so many amazing meanings and morals written between the words that children can learn and grow from.
Ink Girls ticks a lot of boxes for me with its storyline, illustrations, characters and deep underlying messages.
The story is told from the perspective of a young girl named Cinzia who works as an apprentice printer. It takes a juvenile-friendly approach to explore the relationship between media censorship, politics, power, and corruption. This is implemented really well as the themes can be easily understood by children, while still being engaging and enjoyable for adult readers.
Cinzia and her group of newly formed friends team up to fight censorship and political corruption. Their passion and determination reminded me of being a young teenager - full of hope and belief that the world could be a better place. The story is empowering and reminds us that together we can work together to create change.
The relationships between the characters is heartwarming. I especially enjoyed the lines about what truly makes a family. It was great to see disability representation (both physical and implied neurodivergence) as well as diversity in race and gender.
rep: cane user, neurodivergent This was a super cute MG graphic novel featuring two disabled young girls- Elena who is neurodivergent and Cinzia who uses a cane. The two girls together are, essentially, trying to overthrow the kingdom with the power of writing. I think this book does a great job of teaching young kids specifically young girl, how important it is to stay true to yourself, but also having faith in the community around you. Storytelling is an important thing a knowledge is power and I loved how this book demonstrated that! The disability representation was woven pretty casually into the story, but it was still there, which I did appreciate. the art style and general layout of this book was gorgeous truly so many stunning pages. Overall, this was a super fun read for disability December. It was quick and short, but I did enjoy the story a lot!
*Thank you to the author, Marieke Nijkamp for sending me a copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are 100% my own*
Thank you so much to Harper360YA for providing me with and ARC! All thoughts/opinions are my own.
This was a really fun and relevant graphic novel. My arc edition wasn't in full color but the drawings in themselves were stunning so I can only imagine how beautiful the finished product will be 🤩 I loved the emphasis on truth, especially when it comes to the media. The setting in this book is based off of Medieval Italy and it's amazing how the messages and stories from that time period are still the same ones that are so important today. I did find that there were a few teensy plot-holes along the way and the fragile political state of the country might be confusing for younger readers to follow but overall I think that this book contains great messages which have been presented in such a visually stunning way so I would recommend it! Happy Reading :)