I absolutely loved my first reading of Seventeen: Magic Is Real. On the surface, Claudette seems like just your average new girl in an average high school setting, but soon becomes clear that neither are average. Claudette has lost her mother, and her resulting depression and suicidality colors so much if her decision making throughout this fairytale-like story. And Mashalville is no cheery welcoming small town -- everything from the family Claudette's father chooses for them, to the focus of the town's youth, reminded me of fairytales' dark undercoats.
Claudette reached right into my heart and set up her sparkly, magical bedroom. Watching the other characters and story elements push and pull her was so intense! When she comes into her own personal power and starts pushing and pulling back, exerting her own will on the story and characters, the book grew even more exciting. In this character trajectory, McMillian beautifully expresses a story of a girl's grief, and her struggle to show herself and the world that she exists despite the hole right through the middle of her.
This book ends on a cliffhanger, which I don't usually enjoy, but McMillian does the audience a boon by first addressing the main story conflict. She gives us a wonderful showdown, and then leaps directly off of that into the conflict for the second book, it is such good storytelling! I'm looking forward to the next installment of the series.
McMillian provides trigger warnings at the outset of her book, be sure to read them! My trigger warnings here are for death of family, grief and bereavement, possible SA, suicide, and bullying.
Like fairytales, this book pulls you in with both sparkles and shifting shadows. Such an entertaining and thrilling read!
Rating: ✨️✨️✨️✨️✨️ / 5 secret magics
Recommend? Absolutely!
Finished: May 27 2023
Format: Digital, Kindle
Read this book if you like:
👗 Cinderella
🪄 Fairy tales
👩🏽🤝👨🏾 YA
🎓 Dark academia