Harlan Ellison is one of the most quotable living authors that still walks this Earth today. He follows in the greatest of traditions - the writer who does not simply have something he writes, but the one that has something to honestly say. When I was a kid, I devoured books of quotes and still pick up a few to this day - you can see my few reviews I have done on Goodreads to see some examples...go ahead and check if you wish... I have time and they invented the back button on your browser for a reason...back? Okay...on with it - and I always lamented that there seemed to have been these icons who were infinitely quotable and seemingly commented on every thing and every response to those things. Twain regaled me, Wilde quipped very well, and there were so many others, but where was anyone still alive who quipped. Then, by sheer dumb luck, someone said, "You like science fiction?" When I applied in the affirmative, they pulled an old library copy of Approaching Oblivion and handed it to me with only one more piece of advice - "Read the introduction." I went off, wondering what tales of spaceships and blasters and the like I would read. I was 12 or 13 at the time. When I read the introduction, it changed my view of the genre of science fiction even at that age, because Harlan, I realized, was our age's angry Twain with the humorous notions that Wilde used.
So, when I found this book, I knew I would know many of the quotes. I was correct in that, yet I do not regret my purchase. Arnie Fenner as editor faced a daunting task in compiling a thin book of quotes from a prolific speaker and writer. Ellison's skill is much like Twain's - he has spoken at colleges, late night television shows, and the lot as well as having written several award winning works. So, as an Ellison reader, I knew Fenner was going to have to work hard to impress me. In the end, some quotes I loved were left out. There were a few I had not heard. All of them provoked a response, however, as Ellison, undoubtedly, would like them to do.
The other thing about this work that is nice is the listing of Ellison's works- novels, novellas, short story collections, collaborations, graphic novels, essays, screenplays, retrospectives, works he edited, and his audio collections are listed in the back in a section called the "Chronology of Books by Harlan Ellison" and while it is now outdated - Ellison keeps writing, a good thing for our species - it is a nice resource.
So, why 4 stars - because Fenner's task was impossible... There are quotes missing that feel needed if you know they exist. The trouble becomes, then, that the quip Fenner made about a sequel has not yet come to pass. Ellison is, to me, that person you meet that, whether you agree all the time or not, you always want to hear more from and about because you walk away knowing something more about not only that individual and the story they live, but also seemingly about yourself.
So, Mr. Fenner, should this review come before you for some odd reason, I give you the highest review I can because you did better than I thought possible, but for a book that advertised being only the "useless wit and wisdom" of Ellison, I thought there was a lot more quotes that I knew. That being said, you introduced me to a few I did not know. Also, in these days of Internet quote pages that have some of these quotes, you do something most of them do not - you cite them so the reader can go back and find the source material...and that is beyond vital in these days of unattributed and misquoted quotations pulled from online sources.
In short, if you like quotes, authors, or just clever phrases, you should stop reading my pedantic and banal review and pick this up - oh, and dig up a copy of Approaching Oblivion while you are at it...and read the introduction, okay?