Winner of the 2023 Shirley Jackson Award for Best Novella
Jada Morris was the fierce and resilient leader of a social movement against the theft of young women’s uteruses before she committed a violent crime. Now, in 2040, the 24-year-old is serving time at The Center for Future Leaders, an alternative to prison for young leaders who committed crimes as a response to gender-based violence. The Center supposedly provides training, education, therapy, and reduced sentences to the convicted in order to return them to their communities as leaders. But as Jada begins her therapy, she realizes all is not as it seems, and memory is thorny at best. Can she trust her android therapist and the terrifying path down which she’s taking her? And what will she find at the other end?
Jordan’s novella is a gripping and terrifying look at our reproductive future that sends shudders through our reproductive present.
This is a chilling and compelling look at a dystopian but all too realistic future, where POCx who committed gender-based crimes are given a different pathway than prison. Though this novella is short, there is a lot to unpack here. I found Jada to be incredibly relatable, even though my experiences are worlds away from hers. Confronting the idea of how certain people are treated, especially women and those who identify as women, and then especially persons of colour, and what people do in their darkest hours, and then subsequently looking at what their potential is, really is fascinating and terrifying and so important given the current climate. I’d say this is a must read, and I would love to see a full-length novel about the Center and the Leaders it “creates.”
LaToya Jordan manages to make a dystopian novella timely and compelling by touching on themes of gender based crimes, reproductive rights, race and misogyny. She managed to make an entertaining and curious read a broader dialogue of pressing social injustices. At only 80 some pages, she packs in a punch worth your time. This little novella will get you thinking critically long after you finish reading it.
This is the dystopian feminist post-Roe book I had been waiting for. The book is a page turner I read in one night. The protaganist is a young Black woman who's uterus has been stolen, not by the government, but by an unethical company for sale on the black market. Considering the lengths people will go to become pregnant and the history of ob/gyn experimentation on Black women in America, the premise is uncomfortably close to possible. The world building with new tech and AI are rich with detail and create a compelling futuristic world. The character, Jada, is a clear-eyed, emotionally astute activist, and a feminist hero for today.
Stolen organs. AI shrinks. A futuristic women's prison—purportedly progressive—but ultimately revealing the limits of left politics run through the meat grinder of institutional capture. Wild, expansive and somehow contained in novella format. Morally complex, no tidy conclusions, much to chew on.
What a great read! Got more and more compelling as it went on and it comes to an exciting conclusion. I recommend this novella and I’m looking forward to Jordan’s next work of fiction.
The novella “To the Woman in the Pink Hat” by LaToya Jordan @latoyajordanwriter was a brilliant read. If you adore dystopian stories, strong female leads, fighting for what’s right, and engaging writing, then do yourself a favor and buy copies for you and your book club. This novella is certainly a conversation starter and absolutely thought-provoking. I would love to see this as a series as I am sitting here wondering what happens next for the protagonist and supporting characters. Brava, LaToya Jordan!
Another novella in the ever-fascinating 'Conversation Pieces' series from Aqueduct Press covering feminist science fiction, this is the first that I've wanted to be more substantial. It looks towards a time that's frustratingly believable as not far into the future from our own and then throws out a new dystopian twist that I haven't seen before. That's largely because I'm male and white and the vast majority of science fiction authors I read in my youth were too. LaToya Jordan is neither male nor white and so her horrifyingly plausible future isn't mine, which is great because I want to read stories by people who aren't me.
Jordan's primary character is Jada Morris and, because this is only a novella, clocking in at only eighty pages, she's the only character we really get to know, even though she's merely one of the women currently serving time at the Center for Future Leaders. That means that she's committed a crime as a response to violence against women, a crime that's not remotely acceptable to society but is understandable to anyone who looks at it without resorting to a kneejerk absolutist response. It's ostensibly a way for them to be rehabilitated rather than punished and then returned to society in a condition that would qualify them for leadership roles.
The biggest problem I had with the book is that Jada is only one of many women at this mysterious Center and I wanted to hear their stories too. It isn't just that Jordan didn't have space to do them all justice, so made the entirely logical choice to focus in on a single character; it's that she chose a particular ending that removes her flexibility to write companion volumes with a similar impact. It wouldn't have the same effect because we know what's going on now. If she has a desire to return to this world, it would need to be with a different story that takes a different angle.
That's the primary reason why I wanted more from this than Jordan was able to bring and another is that it unfolded in too straightforward a manner to do the complexity of the issues she brings to our minds justice. Maybe, if it does well enough, she could expand it into a full novel form. I firmly believe it would benefit from more breadth and more depth, things that are nigh on impossible to cram into eighty pages. It's not Jordan's fault. It's a problem inherent in the format she's writing.
I adored the beginning. The Center provides therapy sessions through AI-driven robot therapists, which deliberately don't look human because that's illegal. However, the technology is there and, in an effort to tackle Jada's trauma, which involves a white woman called Sarah Jacobs, Ayana, a black-skinned robot therapist, transforms her features into Sarah's while Jada's eyes are closed. Of course, it's a huge shock when she opens them and the experience leaves Jada curled up on the floor. It's definitely futuristic and something that would translate well into a short film.
It also makes us wonder what the Center is trying to do, whether it's as well intentioned as it says in its mission statement. Again, I'd like to have seen the Center from the perspectives of many of the women serving there, but I'll settle for Jada's view. And we see that in sections that alternate with a flashback exploration of what brought her to this point, in the form of her recording a cloud journal for her therapists. It's a relatively simple approach, another one that would translate well into a short film. I hope someone picks up the option and does it justice.
This isn't a spoiler, because it's on in the back cover blurb, but that background has to do with her going to EmGest for a birth control study. Hey, she got paid $10,000 and it was supposed to stop her period. All good, right? Except the FBI show up one day to check her out and let her know that her uterus was stolen. This is a thing, it seems, in this future: the uteruses of young black women are removed without consent or even knowledge. Jada had no idea her uterus was gone. Of course, it isn't a simple organ harvesting scam, because this is further into dystopia. There are reasons why this surgery was done, reasons plural, and they have everything to do with race.
For all that I wanted it to be much longer and more in depth, this is a powerful novella that I have no doubt will stay with me. I'm male and now over fifty, so childbirth doesn't remotely factor into my life, but I felt for Jada and, by vague extension, her fellow inmates at the Center. She certainly committed a heinous crime herself, but in response to a heinous crime that was done to her, one I feel even more acutely because she didn't even know that it had happened. She'd have found out, at some point, of course, had the FBI not shown up to expose it, but it would have taken years and much heartbreak to get there and that makes the theft not only of a piece of flesh but of all that it would have done. And, without delving into spoilers, it goes deeper than that.
I can't be remotely close to the target audience for these slim 'Conversation Pieces' volumes, but I'm appreciating every one that I read. This is #87 in the series and I hope it continues for years to come.
I'd call this devastating tale of institutional misogynoir "Get Out" meets "The Handmaid's Tale." Except that it's more realistic than both.
A young Black woman is caught up in an organ-stealing scam: young people of color are enticed into testing for a new contraceptive method; when it is "implanted," the doctors are actually stealing their uteruses. When the scam is discovered, Jada joins a protest movement ... until the first white woman to receive a stolen uterus--and have a baby with it--comes forward. The (exclusively white) women who received the organs were also lied to; and this one is the first to speak out. But Jada's rage and grief overwhelm her, and she murders the woman.
This lands her in a "leadership center," a correctional facility for women who have committed murders which were arguably justified by abuses the perpetrators had suffered. Through Jada's recordings of her therapy sessions, we learn the back story, and live through Jada's confused passions. And we also eventually learn the Center's secret purpose.
It's in the revelation of that secret purpose in the last few pages of the book that the story loses its driving momentum and undercurrent of horror. In our world, and the near-future world proposed here, it's hard to believe that a secret, leftist revolutionary plot could flourish in the middle of America's "justice system." Everything else: the stolen organs, the medical targeting and exploitation of people of color, the protest movement, etc. is believable bc it's happened before. But this one was a bridge too far for me.
I 100% recommend this book, however. It's a gripping, harrowing read.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
To the Woman in the Pink Hat by La Toya Jordan is a powerful and thought-provoking novella that delves deep into the complexities of reproductive justice and the consequences of gender-based violence. Set in a chillingly plausible future where young women's uteruses are stolen, the story follows Jada Morris, a resilient leader fighting against this injustice, who finds herself imprisoned for a violent act. As she navigates her time at The Center for Future Leaders, an alternative to prison, Jada confronts the true nature of the institution and grapples with her own memories.
Jordan's narrative grips you from the start, weaving together themes of social activism, trauma, and the manipulation of memory. Through Jada's eyes, we're taken on a journey that challenges our understanding of justice and humanity. The android therapist adds an intriguing layer to the story, blurring the lines between technology and empathy, leaving readers questioning the reliability of memory and the intentions of those in power.
The prose is sharp and evocative, pulling you into Jada's world and keeping you on the edge of your seat until the very end. While the subject matter is undeniably heavy, Jordan handles it with sensitivity and nuance, offering moments of hope and resilience amidst the darkness. To the Woman in the Pink Hat is a must-read for anyone interested in exploring the intersections of social justice, technology, and the human experience.
I'm overdue in posting about LaToya Jordan's TO THE WOMAN IN THE PINK HAT, a novella about a society with a woman president and the triumphal pink pussy hats of a second women's march, two decades after the first--and an escalation of the racialized violence of reproductive injustice. Reproductive freedom and opportunity for some has always gone hand-in-hand with the coercion and theft of choice for others: the book asks over and over what "rehabilitation" for this could look like, and goes in necessary directions to ask on whose terms freedom can and should be won, and by and for whom. Favorite passage from the conclusion (SPOILER!): . . . > > > "Was it better for her to be a pawn for the greater good of her community, or was a pawn always just a pawn?.... She wondered who'd fall in line and who'd be forced to leave. She remembered their Peace Atrium lessons, how the wildflower hemlock's dainty clusters of white mirrored the flowers of Queen Anne's lace but packed a deadly poison. As their voices faded, she wondered who'd join her in becoming wildflowers: they'd look and act the part of pawns and bide their time until they found a way, by any means necessary, to be free."
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
These 85 pages packed a punch. I was literally sobbing by the end. Set in the near future, women of colour are asked to participate in a birth control study where, unbeknownst to them, their uteruses are removed and sold to infertile, rich white women. The FBI catches wind, and starts to notify the victims which in turn, creates a movement of women called the SUs (stolen uterus) who are seeking justice.
We follow Jada’s story, one of the leaders of the SUs, as she recounts her crime while undergoing therapy in The Centre. An alternative to prison that houses only women of colour and features human and AI robot therapists to unlock hidden potential in “future leaders”. I’ll leave it at that so as not to give anything away.
Deciding between four and five stars was tricky for this one. This novella left me wanting more. A different author would have turned this idea into a trilogy of young adult novels, but I don't think that trilogy would have been so expertly written. The author created a realistic world without very many pages. I think the strongest aspect of the writing is the pacing. The novella is split between the main character telling the story of the crime she committed and her going about her day, and I was equally interested in both story threads. The pacing felt very organic, and it never gave me the feeling that the author was keeping something from me.
In this examination of a post-Trumpian dystopia, LaToya Jordan pulls the curtain away from the social activism of the 'Resistance' to reveal the hypocrisy and harm of giving lip service to anti-racism. She explores the human failings that compel people to sacrifice their values and the autonomy of others if it allows them to get what they most want in the world. The woman in the pink hat will march for a progressive future even as her actions destroy lives. Unless someone stops her.
LaToya Jordan writes like a poet and but plots like a crime novelist – this dystopian novella is both propulsive and compulsive read. It also has a premise that is disturbingly close to possible, and the questions it provokes will stay with you long after you’ve finished it.
This novella packs a powerful punch. The heart of this story is its main character and her resolve to rise above the cruelties and abuse of those in power. A message much needed in our society today. Fantastic!
Impressive novella for being just under 90 pages. Dystopian but also not so far away from the current world we are living in. Enjoyed the read from start to finish.