Second year starts, but our gang is only incrementally wiser, if any. But said second year is going to bring new friends, open old wounds, and maybe change the world. At least if Mitsumi has anything to say about it, or maybe somebody near her.
Short review:pages 165-174, automatic five stars.
Long review:
Skip & Loafer can occasionally be a heavy read, just because of how much it gets right when it comes to the emotional damage you can accrue during high school. It may not be my experience right on the page, but it always feels like a pastiche of people I used to know.
Having formed such a strong cast, here comes the infamous class change to throw it all into turmoil. And, unlike many stories that might throw a softball at this, we get a massive upheaval in where everybody is spending their time and how they’re handling it. It’s set to explore the fragility of friendship and how easy it is to just drift apart.
Then the fallout comes and, oof, if somebody gets put through the wringer this time around, it’s poor Yuzu, who winds up reliving her worst nightmare a second time around, but now with extra hormones dolloped on top.
While seeing her suffer isn’t great, as a narrative conceit it’s absolutely brilliant. It addresses the fact that trauma or negative experiences don’t just get solved and turn into nothing, they can come back in an instant and Yuzu finds herself dealing with everything that caused her to change schools last time (that one guy deserves a massive smack for his attitude).
Watching her friends, especially her unexpected best friend, both notice something is up and go out of their way to try and fix things and look out for her, is heartwarming. And there’s a nice reminder that this doesn’t take the problem away, but it can make it tolerable at least.
Mitsumi is struggling with her general enthusiasm brushing up against her tendency to awkwardly over think and over estimate her skills. The student council’s advice service goes roughly as well as you’d expect and I love her frequent fantasy sequences that show both her hopes and insecurities, depending on the moment (they’re especially prevalent in this section).
Shima is off in a different class, surrounded by other girls (the poor guy can’t catch a break and he clearly hates his popularity but isn’t going to say anything), which helps emphasize my earlier point about how even a little distance can separate friends quickly if they don’t work at it.
But this is Mitsumi, of course she’s going to work at it! Seeing the cast we’ve met as they stick together mixed with the addition of some interesting newcomers (is that a rival in the making?) is a heck of a juggling act, but there’s a quiet confidence to this series that it happily exudes as it weaves all of this together into one smartly done tapestry.
Some of our characters get more time than others, but that’s what we have subsequent volumes for. There is an elegance to this awkwardness that makes it so enjoyable from start to finish, even when the tears are flowing or it’s at its most cringe.
And, yes, those last pages. Which not only make for a very earned cheering moment, but also feature a hilariously well done sight gag to wrap everything up in a good laugh until the next volume shows up.
5 stars - this might be the best manga about the high school experience I have ever read and it feels like it’s always tackling weighty stuff, but not to the point of wallowing in misery. Perfectly balanced, perfectly done.