This one is impossible to rate. On the one hand, as an actual practical guide (as it was originally meant to be), it's completely out-of-date - almost every website I went to, based on her recommendations, no longer existed, and neither did the companies behind them. On the other hand, the way she writes about shopping is delicious, and I read the whole book with a lot of enjoyment despite the fact that I completely disagree with her on many, many fronts (e.g., importance of make-up, appearance, etc., etc.). So...is it 1-star or 4-5 stars?