3.75
I admittedly know fairly little about Free Books given out in the UK for World Book Day, other than we really need that here in the US, but presumably the book is meant to be a smaller simpler story than a complete novel. The Muslim author returns to her character from Boy, Everywhere in this story set in Manchester and focuses on teammates sticking together to address racism on the soccer field/football pitch at their school. The Syrian refugee Sami and his Desi friend Ali are presumably Muslim and they say "salam," but no hints about religion of any sort are in the book other than that and their names. I akin it to a Muslim in the illustration, but in a chapter book for middle grades when one sees the name Sami al-Hafez responding to a "Salam, bro."
The knocked star isn't so much for the simplicity, or length, or lack of Islamic or cultural rep, the book is 91 pages, I get that. I struggled a bit with year eight aged kids getting so hung up on being told, "sorry." I can understand wanting a genuine apology, or some reflection or determination to do better or change, but it came across so silly that the climax wanted a "sorry" being spoken. Other than that the book was a quick read and I think 2nd to 4th grade soccer/football fans particularly will enjoy the story.