Stars: 3.5 rounded up to 4
MMC(s): Kade, Liam
Tropes: ADHD rep, Grumpy/Sunshine, found family, sea monster and Selkies, ace rep, second chance romance, queer rep
> Reviewer add: Other partners, sweet consent kings
Perspective: Dual
Plot or character driven: Both, heavier lean on plot
Spicy scenes breakdown:
> Present? Yes
> Detailed? Yes
> Multiple, with only one character? No
> Multiple, with both/multiple characters? Yes
> Personal favorite? There are multiple water scenes.
> Anything else to note?
Burn speed: Medium, about 50%
Can this be read as a stand-alone: This is the first in a series.
Re-Readability: You will likely need to for subsequent works.
Content/Trigger Warnings/Enticements: Parental loss, homophobia, societal flaws
I received an advanced reader copy of this book, and this is my voluntary, honest review.
“The way merfolk society operated reminded Liam of his own people. Though they shared plenty of differences, there were common threads that tied them together. The way they cared for one another, their homes, and their community. The way their children played and aggravated the adults. The way they formed social groups and caught up on the latest gossip. It was comforting to Liam to know that he wasn’t living in an alien world, but a parallel one.”
As teenagers in high school, Liam and Kade met through an exchange program. Kade withdraws from their relationship, and leaves Liam questioning and lost. Years later, they meet again when Kade discovers something amiss within the merfolk of Promeiya.
This novel was a beast. I'm going to divide this up into three pieces.
Plot wise: Massive. This world is really fascinating to me in both layers, interactions between the humans and merfolk, and the merfolk and other denizens of the sea. The history of the merfolk is also complex and I feel like we're going to learn more in subsequent novels. There are some unanswered questions in this book that leave room for answers in the following books.
Relationship between Kade and Liam: this is definitely a second chance relationship. They were both young for their first chance and they made youthful mistakes, which I found to be very realistic no matter their species. They have to deal with what happened before but also their feelings that still exist. And their emphasis on both consent and safety/comfort of their partner? These sweet consent kings. Loved it.
Characters: Liam was so insecure, especially in the beginning that it made his part of the story hard for me to read. However, getting to see him blossom and gain more confidence was GLORIOUS. Kade on the other hand was the confident one, but there was the sense of something missing from him and his life and that's Liam.
What needed work: at certain points in the story the pacing felt off: either too slow, or too fast (particularly the end). And at other points, especially in Liam's perspective, it felt more like we were being told or narrated to, instead of shown which nearly always broke me out of the story.
I feel like I want to re-read this story again. We’ll see how I feel in a couple weeks.