Thank you to the author Myrium Gurba, publishers Avid Reader Press and Simon and Schuster, also to NetGalley, for a digital review copy. All views are mine.
Three (or more) things I loved:
1. I adore the trip down memory lane with the 80's toys, Barbies and Cabbage Patch Dolls and Garbage Pail Kids!
2. She captures the fleeting and elusive nature of childhood and everything in it, even death, in a single image: Quote loc. 972.
3. She provides some really interesting and important information on prisons and ex-prisoners in the essay entitled "Locas," like that ex-prisoners are hired less often than their counterparts without a prior conviction, but they tend to have lower turnover and get promoted faster. Also, it's assumed by many that time in prison is the debt ex-prisoners pay to society, but they have to keep paying once they're released-- restitution, return of damages, and for their state provided defense, if they used such. loc.1278
4. "White Onion" contains the most fascinating and meaningful discussion of cannibalism I ever expected to encounter.
5. I adore the note about the power and necessity of literary analysis and criticism: Quote loc. 2225.
6. Gurba writes deeply insightful passages about the experience of SA and sexual trauma, such as loc. 3240. I won't quote it here, to protect those sensitive to triggering.
7. These essays don't read or feel like nonfiction. They're riveting in style and surreal in places. They remind me so much of bits of magical realism. She reminds me so much of like of Brando Skyhorse and Sherman Alexie had little literary kittens.
Three (or less) things I didn't love:
This section isn't only for criticisms. It's merely for items that I felt something for other than "love" or some interpretation thereof.
1. The essay on Didion is probably my favorite. It explores some interesting stylistic, but more importantly ethical questions about perhaps the US's formost creative essayist: Quote loc. 2200. What bothers me about this piece is the tone. It's so academic, so removed, not like Gurba's other work at all. Is she mimicking Didion, mocking her? Hard to tell here. Still a great piece, but hard to ingest.
A few words on each essay:
1. "Tell" An essay about how children's games can be deadly, and how deadly games can create deadly men. Gurba writes about a fascinating case of three brothers who accidentally kill a nanny during a game, and all go on to become remarkable individuals.
2. "Cucuy" is a brilliant essay on the serial killer The Night Stalker, who was active where Gurba lived when she was only a little girl.
3. "Locas" is an essay about abuse. Big abuse, the kind an organization does to an individual. Little abuse, the kind an individual does to a littler individual. What it's like to be abused. What it's like to know someone who is abused. What it's like to live with abuse and after you've been abused. Top 3!
4. "Mitote" is an essay about home as a place, as people, and as conflict.
5. "The White Onion" is an unforgiving and eye opening analysis of Joan Didion's creative nonfiction work as both racist and willfully closeminded.
6. "Navajazo" is about gendered violence and the states failure to protect women from violence twice: first, repeatedly, from the men closest to them, and second, only once usually, from themselves when they commit capital crime in self-defense.
7. "Waterloo" is about one of the author's really racist exes and her really racist family, but it's also about knowing what you want and respecting your own boundaries.
8. "Slimed" is about comedy with a capital C and misogyny. Here is my trigger warning for extreme language describing SA and violence against children and women.
9. "Itchy" is an extremely powerful essay about racism in education and how hard reforms must be fought for. “Mexican-Americans,”writes the essayist E. Michael Madrid, “tend to be identified not by what they are, but what they are not.”In this way, Mexican-Americans are like lesbians, another group of people who tend to be identified not by what they are, but what they are not. I belong to a diaspora defined by deficiency, and I keep a running list of things I’m supposedly missing. Loc. 3484 Top 3!
10. "Pendeja, You Ain't Steinbeck" is about the challenges of finding success for writers who are women of color, and what Gurba has experienced in her own career and striving for greatness.
11. "Creep" is an essay about how social and cultural structure help to reinforce institutional misogyny, from sexual harassment in the Supreme Court to domestic violence that leads to murder. Gurba details her own horrific experience with domestic violence. (Note: this story is harrowing.) Top 3!
Rating: 👁👁👁👁👁 creeping eyes
Recommend? Yes!
Finished: Aug 31 '23
Format: Digital arc, Kindle, NetGalley
Read this book if you like:
🎞 nonfiction
📃 essays
👨👩👧👦 family stories, family drama
👭🏽 intersectional feminism
💇♀️ girls' coming of age