This review is about the novel, Deeply Buried, which was a second or third book, but worked marvelously as a standalone. The author, Ariana Lamber, clearly did so much research and it made this novel perfect. I was lucky enough to get an Advanced reader's Copy (ARC) of this novel and that is what my review is based off of.
The Book:
A grave, an investigator and a 12-year-old case.
On the Irish Beara Peninsula, incessant rain uncovers the corpse of a man. Its salvage unveils one of the cruellest incidents in Irish history: Apparently, years ago, several infants were buried there. The Irish police see themselves confronted with a mystery. The family of the deceased man secretively remains silent on his past. Only with Berlin lawyer Anna Schwarz they are willing to talk. But Anna promised herself never to return to the Emerald Isle. Can Anna help solve the mystery around the dead man? And can she confront the shadows of her own past that the Emerald Isle holds for her?
The Review:
TW: Sexual abuse, domestic abuse, child abuse, human trafficking, peeping tom/sexual deviancy without consent/stalkng.
We all know Ireland is home to many mysteries, fantasy worlds about fae, and more. Now, Deeply Buried is going in among them, immortalized with the best.
The story opens with a deceptive by the name of Jon Johnson who has history with the lead, Anna. Johnson calls her and gets her to volunteringly go back to Ireland after swearing it off to help solve a case that involves a cult leader and domestic abuser, dead children' bones, and a town that is clearly more than it seems. Oh, and Johnson, failing to mention to Anna, is her ex-love interest, Benjamin Black. We are introduced to the cult family members, Emily, Sadie, Lucy, Sky, and Kim. Kim and Anna have a history from the other books which is quickly recapped (thankfully), that also happens to involve the cult leader, Devlin. There are multiple side characters that get tied up in the mystery and murder. I won't go into any spoilers, so I will be stopping here.
Genre: 5/5
This is a perfect novel example of what the genre beholds in all novels under the genre. It is classified as a psychology thriller with twists and it is. I will also count this as a suspense and crime/mystery. It nails each of these genres on the head.
Characters: 4.7/5
I wanted to give a 5/5 but, we need to talk about the elephant in the room: Benjamin Black. He is problematic and I could not find redemption in him and I cannot give anything else away because it would be a spoiler. All other characters are perfect. Anna has a light problem being that she is sometimes rather clueless like not noticing her surroundings and being a bit gaga over Benjamin. Other than that, each character delivered their plot devices, well written, and mostly realistic (especially dealing with the nuances of the Devlin women/"family"). I just wish there was a few moments where Benjamin was more sincere and that Anna wasn't so teen love drunk brain as an adult woman. Also, we get to see into the revenge plot on Anna via internal dialogue of a character I will not name, again, spoilers, but boy, those were fun and disturbing and done in the style of Jo Goldberg's internal dialogue from the series You.
Plot and theme: 4.5/5
I loved everything except for the trigger warnings that the author should have placed somewhere in the book. I am NOT a fan of trauma bonding, gaslighting, making excuses while apologizing, and for women to be constantly written to immediately forgive or lust after the very man who hurt them. Anna would have been scored lower int he other category minus the fact at some point she called him on his bullshit (thank you, Ariana!) The crime and suspects were a bit easy to guess save the fact of Sky - I didn't see that one coming but after a bit I knew who did it. I knew the whole _spoiler here_ was _spoiler here_ and I knew who did Devlin in after a few chapters into the book and I also guess the motives correctly. I also knew about the pub that comes around the middle of the book and their iffiness. Again, I won't spill the tea because spoilers.
The themes that worked well were the messages of how children are often the victims of crimes for senseless crimes, the dangers and vileness of cults and domestic abuse, and of human trafficking. I loved how Ariana Lambert made sure the reader knows how disgusting it is and how some people look the other way, or try to minimize and invalidate the unfortunate people and women who fall victim to their damage and the pain left in their wake. I also loved how it shows that whole communities and police can be seedy, dirty, and disgustingly involved in ways that they'll go to cover it up.
There were no plot holes or inconsistencies that I picked up on - and I kept notations and still couldn't find a single thing wrong in this case. The ending was satisfying, it wrapped up the loose ends and let us know about the characters left and what they were doings post climax/reveal.
New review addition to theme and plot - Tropes used: Twists, redemption, villain victim, stalker plays with detective, and history returns.
All of the tropes were well utilized despite the list in the second sentence in the first paragraph of this section; the trauma bonding, etc.
I also enjoyed the twists despite being able to predict it, it was fabulously written to be thrilling and kept me on the edge a lot and had my heart and breathe go haywire.
The pacing: 5/5
She was brilliant in her pacing. Just absolutely amazing. It was not too fast and not too slow. Each chapter was only about 5-9 pages and some shorter ones being only 1-3. The shorter ones were reserved for setting changes or the stalker's POV via internal dialogue. Nothing more to say here other than there was zero drag and never felt rushed.
The prose: 4.8/5
Ariana Lambert is a master of writing. Very minor typos and even less in the grammar mistakes arena. Barely noticed them and they did nothing to negatively impact the flow of the story and were not distracting at all from being completely engaged to the plot and characters. I actually really loved her writing. I hated having to put the book down when I had to put it down. She flows and captivates in this book. Plus, can we say that the fact she uses real technical jargon of morticians and police is just a chef's kiss. One word: Hematomas - this should clue you in on how accurate she was during writing.
Overall: 4.8/5 rounding up to 5.
I HIGHLY RECOMMEND THIS BOOK!
This story will stay with me. I will most likely read the others then re-read this one. It is not necessary to read the priors so that is a plus to anyone JUST discovering Ariana Lambert's works. I believe that this book is my latest recommend, so far, for the year because of how much love and research she put into this book.