Perfect set of epilogues for a perfect series. Pyland captured my interest with the celebrities series, had me waver a bit after I didn’t love the holiday series, but the Chicago series is a complete home run. I loved all of the character, the stories, and continued to have an internal battle with myself over which book/couple is my favorite. Melissa Moran was also the perfect narrator. I actually think her lack of narration on the holiday series played a big role in why I couldn’t connect to it as much as Chicago and Celebrities.
I do think I have a final ranking, but it was extremely tough because as I said, I love them all:
1) Love Walked Into the Lantern/Summer & Lena - I love, love, love these two and I wish I could experience this book for the first time again
2) The Best Lines/Ember & Eva - my middle selections will flip flop for years to come, but I have placed this one here because I find Ember to be such a compelling character
3) Fresh Start/Alyssa & Hannah - I adore Alyssa so much, I loved how Hannah was there for her. I also love Alyssa’s mom so much! I placed this as #3 for the purposes of the ranking, but it’s really tied for #2 with The Best Lines
4) Just Tell Her/Hailey & Charlie - this is easily my least favorite from the series, but it’s still a 5 star book. I just connected with the other couples more, but I still adore Hailey and Charlie so much.