Some Kind of Love was about 28-year-old Amber (French) Williamson, a writer, and 30-year-old Fred "Freddy" Bale, the middle Bale brother, and the owner of a local garage.
Freddy and Amber met when she was 17 (he was 19) after her car had broken down on a cold, snowy night, which was the beginning of their relationship. A year later, Freddy was recovering from being hurt in an accident. It took him a minimum of six months to recover, during which Amber was at his side as much as possible to help and support him. On the day of her senior prom, she learned that he had been moved to a convalescing room in the hospital because he had improved enough that he was able to stand using crutches (sticks is what they called it). It was during the visit that she presented him with an acceptance letter to a local college. Before the accident, she had planned to attend a school far from their small town, but she made a different choice so that she could stay close to the boy she loved. Although she hadn't wanted to attend prom without him, he had convinced her to do so. But then she got the shock of her life when he showed up to dance with her. There was just one problem. Freddy wasn't smiling, and he seemed to be struggling with something. When she asked him about it, he told her he needed to take a break from their relationship and "see what else is out there in the world before we settle. So we're sure". The reason he gave her was that their love was "too easy" and that no one finds their HEA at 18 and 20 years of age. The way he worded things told her that her mother had gotten to him because she recalled a conversation between her and her mother where she was told she needed to "wait ten years before settling down". Even though Freddy denied it, she knew the other woman had gotten to him and interfered with their relationship. However, try as she might, Freddy didn't change his mind, so she told him there would be no second chances for the two of them. If he chose to search for other options, they were over for good. After telling her he wouldn't change his mind, they said their final goodbyes and she walked away, leaving not only Freddy behind but also her family and the small town she'd known her entire life. It would be ten years before they would see each other again, but things would never be the same.
Amber returned home to a mother who was succumbing to early onset dementia (her father had passed away the year before), a house that had fallen into disrepair (and could have made an excellent episode of the television show "Hoarders"), a nine-year-old son who didn't know his real father and a former BFF to whom she hadn't spoken in ten years. The only thing that wasn't made clear until much later was the fact she was that her husband hadn't agreed to a divorce.
The following day, she ran into her former BFF at the grocery store, who she learned had married Freddy's youngest brother, Grant. A few hours later, the doorbell rang, only for her to open the door and come face to face with Freddy. He welcomed her back home, using the name he used to call her "Amber French" (he always seemed to call her by her first and last names). She corrected him, then slammed the door in his face. The encounter threw her into a flashback of how their relationship started.
Her BFF showed up later that day with wine, and they chatted for a while. Amber later learned from her son that Freddy had returned while she was visiting with her friend, only for her mother to send him away with some very harsh words.
I hated that the story was told only from Amber's POV because then we didn't get to know what was going on with Freddy. There was also the fact that for the first 13 chapters of the story, the two main characters were rarely ever together and, when they were, they hardly said anything of significance. Then Freddy showed up after her estranged husband left, pulled her outside, told her he didn't care if she was married, and that he had been waiting for her to come home. Then he kissed her?! Which got interrupted by a freaking flashback and never returned to the scene?! No explanations, no conversation, nada! WTF?! It was frustrating as hell. Then there was the fact that, although she was separated and her son called the man "Dad", he was only mentioned but rarely took part in the story.
The night after they shared a kiss, Freddy showed up again, kissed her senseless...and met her son for the first time, they finally had the first intelligent and honest conversation they had ever shared in the entire book so far (and that's saying something because the FMC wasn't very articulate. She could barely string two words together to form a complete sentence. Why do authors write some of their characters to be stupid?!).
The story was okay. It had plenty of angst and more than enough drama, but it lacked in every other way. The emotional rollercoaster had very few twists and turns. There were no surprises to pique the reader's interest. Even the spice level was almost non-existent. The push/pull between the two main characters was weak and felt contrived. Any contention was like a paper towel that disintegrated at the first sign of water.
Neither of the main characters felt fully developed, and they certainly weren't mature for the ages they were supposed to be. The fact that the 9-year-old son was allowed to denigrate his mother was disappointing too, and he did it for most of the times he was in the story.
The language of the book was dated, making it feel like the characters were from the 1970s or 1980s, which was uncomfortable, to say the least. And, BOY, did I detest the timing of each flashback! Every. Single. One. Came at the worst possible time. They were not only disruptive, but they were out of place for the most part. Some of them didn't fit with the subject that the present timing ended before they flashed back. They also made the book longer than necessary. The flashbacks took time away from what could have been spent with the two main characters reconnecting, they were longer than the portions of the story that took place in the present. Everything told about the past could have been whittled down and told during conversations between the MMC and the FMC. I hated that Amber's BFF kept blaming her for how things went sideways 10 years earlier. Sure, she didn't have to leave the way she did, and she probably could/should have let her know she was okay. But it was Freddy who pushed her away. The fact that she was still an impressionable 18-year-old didn't help either. She wasn't the only one who made mistakes. Her BFF didn't make it easy on her by not supporting her relationship with Freddy when they first got together. Another huge issue was when Freddy learned he was Isaac's father, Amber demanded that no one should know...not even Isaac. She tried to pass it off as being worried about asking her son to bear too many burdens for a child his age, but the truth was she didn't want him to look at her differently. That was so very wrong. She let Isaac continue to call her estranged husband "Dad" (even though he knew he wasn't) when his REAL dad was standing in front of him.
There were too many things wrong with this book for it to be given a full five-star rating. I couldn't even honestly give it a four-star rating, and I struggled with whether or not to do three stars. I ended up giving it two-and-a-half stars, rounded up to three.