As a debut romance novel from a new author, it was good. I wouldn’t say it was the best romance book I’ve ever read, but it was good, thus giving it the 4 stars. It DID have me smiling by the end. 😊 The characters COULD have been flushed out more, especially Laniey, the main female lead. I felt like the author could have SHOWN rather than TOLD with her much more. For example, we are TOLD from almost the very beginning, that Laniey is “running” from a bad breakup & a bad relationship & at one point, we are also TOLD that he (her ex-) made all the decisions of their past relationship rather than just SHOWN it like through a flashback or something like that. I did also feel like the couple’s (the main couple of the story, that is, Laniey & Colin) little “breakup/break” in the middle felt a little bit unnecessary to have in the story & felt like the author was just forcing conflict to happen just for the sake of having conflict in the story. Like, yes, Colin (the male lead) needed to work out some issues in regards to his mom’s health decline (not gonna say what exactly is wrong with her here because that would be too much of a spoiler 😉), but why couldn’t Laniey have been there to help him work through it?? That would have worked so much better & shown (again, SHOW, not tell) their love for each other so much more, in my opinion! However, I DO really like what he did to get her back towards the end; it was a creative & really sweet thing for him to do! 🥰 And I also really like that he took responsibility for messing up & that he was truly sorry for doing so! 😍 So, again, overall, it’s a good debut romance novel in the end! 👍🏻 And I’m really looking forward to Mallory’s & Tyler’s story next; I have a feeling it is going to be better than this 1st one!! I especially want to know why Mallory’s so jumpy & scared; my guess is that she’s a Domestic Violence survivor. That’s the vibe I get by how jumpy she is & how hesitant she was at first. But we’ll see … 🤔 Also I wish the author would write a story about how Sam (Laniey’s BFF) & Owen first got together, too! Maybe it could be just like a little short-story prequel of how they first met or something like that?? But who knows? We may get more info on their story in Book 2!! 😅