What do you think?
Rate this book
The Novice: A Timeless Buddhist Parable of Self-Discovery and Peace from Thich Nhat Hanh
Fans of Thich Nhat Hanh’s Peace is Every Step and Anger, and Deepak Chopra’s Buddha, will appreciate Hanh’s wisdom and storytelling in his novel The Novice, which contains universal themes that transcend all boundaries of faith, creed, country, and era.
Through the parable of a young woman who stays true to herself and her faith in the face of adversity, Vietnamese Zen Buddhist master and peace activist Thich Nhat Hanh enables readers to embark on their own path of introspection and self-discovery.
With his trademark insight, Hanh presents a path to greater awareness of the means to manifest peace both inside oneself and in the world at large.
Through the parable of a young woman who stays true to herself and her faith in the face of adversity, Vietnamese Zen Buddhist master and peace activist Thich Nhat Hanh enables readers to embark on their own path of introspection and self-discovery.
With his trademark insight, Hanh presents a path to greater awareness of the means to manifest peace both inside oneself and in the world at large.
162 pages, Kindle Edition
First published August 18, 2011
166 people are currently reading
1575 people want to read
About the author
Thich Nhat Hanh
982 books12.9k followersThích Nhất Hạnh was a Vietnamese Buddhist monk, teacher, author, poet and peace activist who then lived in southwest France where he was in exile for many years. Born Nguyễn Xuân Bảo, Thích Nhất Hạnh joined a Zen (Vietnamese: Thiền) monastery at the age of 16, and studied Buddhism as a novitiate. Upon his ordination as a monk in 1949, he assumed the Dharma name Thích Nhất Hạnh. Thích is an honorary family name used by all Vietnamese monks and nuns, meaning that they are part of the Shakya (Shakyamuni Buddha) clan. He was often considered the most influential living figure in the lineage of Lâm Tế (Vietnamese Rinzai) Thiền, and perhaps also in Zen Buddhism as a whole.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 203 reviews
February 9, 2024
The best way for me to explore spirituality is to be caught up in and swept along with another’s story of the journey.
This gem consists of two parts. The original story. Then the tale of those affected by this story who traversed Vietnam in war and peace (mostly war) to bring the message of healing and wholeness and forgiveness the original story embodies.
A young woman's marriage dissolves when she is falsely accused of trying to murder her husband. Leaving behind family and home Kim travels throughout the ancient land of Vietnam. Her greatest longing is to be a monastic and experience spiritual enlightenment. So she disguises herself as a man and attaches herself to a temple where she finds honor and acceptance.
Exceptional. I need more of this walk in my own walk. I need its call for mercy and peace.
This gem consists of two parts. The original story. Then the tale of those affected by this story who traversed Vietnam in war and peace (mostly war) to bring the message of healing and wholeness and forgiveness the original story embodies.
A young woman's marriage dissolves when she is falsely accused of trying to murder her husband. Leaving behind family and home Kim travels throughout the ancient land of Vietnam. Her greatest longing is to be a monastic and experience spiritual enlightenment. So she disguises herself as a man and attaches herself to a temple where she finds honor and acceptance.
Exceptional. I need more of this walk in my own walk. I need its call for mercy and peace.
January 7, 2013
It is amazing how a book sometimes finds it way to you when you need it most. I've read other books by Thich Nhat Hanh so I knew this would be a great story but I didn't expect it to have such an impact on me, I read it in one sitting. I needed to be reminded of how important it is to forgive. The story line is simple and yet so thought provoking. A young woman who wishes to be a buddhist monk disguises herself as a young man and becomes a novice. Another young woman in the village accuses the "monk" of raping her and inpregnating her. Further complicating matters, the monk then begins raising the baby allegedly conceived by the rape. If the monk reveals her secret, she will no longer be able to be a monk and achieve the buddha nature she so longs for. If she says nothing, then she tacitly endorses injustice and the false accusation. I won't tell the whole story here. :)
In addition to being a wonderfully simple story that is well written, this reminds each of us to reflect on the daily injustices, judgements and wrongs that occur in our daily lives. It helps us to understand how we can respond to such issues tactfully, with grace, and in such a way that order is restored. This book is a lovely way to introduce yourself or someone else to the Buddhist concepts of loving-kindness and compassion.
In addition to being a wonderfully simple story that is well written, this reminds each of us to reflect on the daily injustices, judgements and wrongs that occur in our daily lives. It helps us to understand how we can respond to such issues tactfully, with grace, and in such a way that order is restored. This book is a lovely way to introduce yourself or someone else to the Buddhist concepts of loving-kindness and compassion.
October 15, 2015
I stumbled upon this book because I'm planning a short story collection based on Vietnamese folk stories and renovated operas centered around women, and wanted to see if anyone had written a story about Quan Am Thi Kinh in English yet. I was pleasantly surprised to find that one had been written by Buddhist monk Thich Nhat Hanh, whose name is famous within the Buddhist community. I ordered it immediately.
The volume is thin, but packs a punch. Anyone looking for a bit of spiritual wisdom will benefit greatly from reading this. Having grown up around the Thi Kinh legend, I didn't think this would be anything new. On some levels it's not--the story is well known and this version doesn't mess TOO much with the original material. However, Thich Nhat Hanh pays attention to all the minor characters that one doesn't really hear much about in most retellings, and does so in a compassionate way that highlights their humanity.
In reading this, one should keep in mind that the author is not a novelist and that the book's purpose is to convey Buddhist teachings to the reader. There's a lot of explanation about the teachings of Buddha, the writing style is pretty basic, and it can be a tedious read for someone who reads a lot of good fiction. You likely won't find anything very commendable about the prose itself; it's the lessons one learns from the book that are important. I definitely struggled to read through it because it was so preachy, but I was glad I did read it.
Overall, a good book to read if you're curious about Buddhism but can't stomach nonfiction. I am not very religious, but I felt significantly more reverent after reading this book.
The volume is thin, but packs a punch. Anyone looking for a bit of spiritual wisdom will benefit greatly from reading this. Having grown up around the Thi Kinh legend, I didn't think this would be anything new. On some levels it's not--the story is well known and this version doesn't mess TOO much with the original material. However, Thich Nhat Hanh pays attention to all the minor characters that one doesn't really hear much about in most retellings, and does so in a compassionate way that highlights their humanity.
In reading this, one should keep in mind that the author is not a novelist and that the book's purpose is to convey Buddhist teachings to the reader. There's a lot of explanation about the teachings of Buddha, the writing style is pretty basic, and it can be a tedious read for someone who reads a lot of good fiction. You likely won't find anything very commendable about the prose itself; it's the lessons one learns from the book that are important. I definitely struggled to read through it because it was so preachy, but I was glad I did read it.
Overall, a good book to read if you're curious about Buddhism but can't stomach nonfiction. I am not very religious, but I felt significantly more reverent after reading this book.
March 21, 2021
Kinh Tam was a young girl who wanted to become a monk and study Buddhism. That path was blocked to her because of her gender. Her parents married her to a young man who was devoted to her, but had little motivation. When she attempted to cut wayward hairs from his beard, his parents accused her of attempted murder and forced her to leave the marriage. Her husband did not defend her.
Kinh Tam journeyed from her family home, dressed as a man, and eventually joined an abbey as a novice. She was exceptionally devoted to her work and grew in wisdom and compassion. A daughter from a wealthy family fell in love with Kinh Tam – who refused her.
Thi Mao, hurt and angry, slept with one of her servants and became pregnant. Thi Mao named Kinh Tam as the father. Kinh Tam was nearly killed by the town in their attempts to get her to admit she was the father – but she refused to tell a lie.
Thi Mao gave birth and delivered Thien Tam to Kinh Tam's care. This would identify Kinh Tam as the Thien Tam's father, yet she accepted him and agreed to serve as his "father-teacher." She was still living as a man.
All of this is no surprise and no spoiler. The reason one reads Thich Nhat Hanh is not about the story, but to learn how we can choose to respond to adversity, the adversity that all of us experience.
Kinh Tam chose to keep Thien Tam. When challenged, Kinh Tam argued, "Dear teacher, you have taught me that the merit to be gained through building an elaborate temple nine stories high cannot compare to that of saving the life of one person" (p. 6). One of the other novices asked her, “Why not save any other person, instead of saving that particular person?” (pp. 69-70). Nonetheless, Kinh Tam's sense of integrity and her compassion for all beings would not allow her to bypass the obstacles she faced in her life, the obstacles that the other people in this story faced and that destroyed her.
* * *
Quan Am Thi Kinh was a bodhisattva renowned for compassion extended to everyone, infinite forgiveness, and endless and patient forbearance. She is known by different names in different countries, although I know her as Kwan Yin. She is an inspiration for engaged Buddhism. She did not see meditation as an end in itself, but as something extended out into the real world. As Sister Chan Khong said, "I feel that we are very fortunate [despite frequent governmental attacks]. We are going through all these hardships, but our hearts’ compassion remains intact; we harbor no anger, not a single wish of retaliation or harm to anyone” (p. 125).
Kwan Yin's life – Thich Nhat Hanh's version – reminds us to practice in order to transcend adversity while behaving with compassion toward others.
Kinh Tam journeyed from her family home, dressed as a man, and eventually joined an abbey as a novice. She was exceptionally devoted to her work and grew in wisdom and compassion. A daughter from a wealthy family fell in love with Kinh Tam – who refused her.
Thi Mao, hurt and angry, slept with one of her servants and became pregnant. Thi Mao named Kinh Tam as the father. Kinh Tam was nearly killed by the town in their attempts to get her to admit she was the father – but she refused to tell a lie.
Thi Mao gave birth and delivered Thien Tam to Kinh Tam's care. This would identify Kinh Tam as the Thien Tam's father, yet she accepted him and agreed to serve as his "father-teacher." She was still living as a man.
All of this is no surprise and no spoiler. The reason one reads Thich Nhat Hanh is not about the story, but to learn how we can choose to respond to adversity, the adversity that all of us experience.
Kinh Tam chose to keep Thien Tam. When challenged, Kinh Tam argued, "Dear teacher, you have taught me that the merit to be gained through building an elaborate temple nine stories high cannot compare to that of saving the life of one person" (p. 6). One of the other novices asked her, “Why not save any other person, instead of saving that particular person?” (pp. 69-70). Nonetheless, Kinh Tam's sense of integrity and her compassion for all beings would not allow her to bypass the obstacles she faced in her life, the obstacles that the other people in this story faced and that destroyed her.
* * *
Quan Am Thi Kinh was a bodhisattva renowned for compassion extended to everyone, infinite forgiveness, and endless and patient forbearance. She is known by different names in different countries, although I know her as Kwan Yin. She is an inspiration for engaged Buddhism. She did not see meditation as an end in itself, but as something extended out into the real world. As Sister Chan Khong said, "I feel that we are very fortunate [despite frequent governmental attacks]. We are going through all these hardships, but our hearts’ compassion remains intact; we harbor no anger, not a single wish of retaliation or harm to anyone” (p. 125).
Kwan Yin's life – Thich Nhat Hanh's version – reminds us to practice in order to transcend adversity while behaving with compassion toward others.
June 27, 2013
If Buddhism or Guan Yin are not of interest to you, then a two or three star rating would be in order. The story of Kinh Tam and how she became known as Quan Am Thi Kinh (Guan Yin) is elaborated on by Thich Nhat Hanh in an uncomplicated, easy manner, as if he were talking to young people. This teaching style is deceptively simple because it covers several Buddhist principals. I was surprised at the end of the story when I had tears in my eyes. I'm not sure where the tears came from though I suspect that at least, in part, they were stimulated by my attempts to grasp the true meaning or what it is like to accept all people, whether they let you down, falsely accuse you, belittle you, ignore you, treat you like a non-person, and more. Kinh Tam, who experienced those judgments from others was able to maintain equanimity towards all beings by practicing Buddhist principles of compassion and non-judgment.
The 100 page story was followed by an essay by Sister Chan Khong, an expatriate Vietnamese Buddhist nun and peach activist who has worked closely with Thich Nhat Hanh for over 50 years. Part of the essay includes examples of how Vietnamese Buddhist monastics and social workers were discriminated against and even murdered by those in power in both the 1960s and the 2000s. There is a brief essay at the end of the book by Thich Nhat Hahn where he explains how, no matter what is happening to us from the outside, we can always find refuge in the true home within ourselves.
This book is obviously not for everyone, though I would recommend it to those whose curiosity has been aroused. Here is a link that discusses Guan Yin. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guanyin
The 100 page story was followed by an essay by Sister Chan Khong, an expatriate Vietnamese Buddhist nun and peach activist who has worked closely with Thich Nhat Hanh for over 50 years. Part of the essay includes examples of how Vietnamese Buddhist monastics and social workers were discriminated against and even murdered by those in power in both the 1960s and the 2000s. There is a brief essay at the end of the book by Thich Nhat Hahn where he explains how, no matter what is happening to us from the outside, we can always find refuge in the true home within ourselves.
This book is obviously not for everyone, though I would recommend it to those whose curiosity has been aroused. Here is a link that discusses Guan Yin. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guanyin
August 30, 2018
Libro cortito, que habla sobre budismo, meditación, la capacidad de perdón que todos deberíamos tener... Es una historia bonita y se lee muy rápido.
October 25, 2021
The non-fiction sections at the end were more inspiring than the text of the novel.
June 8, 2020
A Young woman (Kinh Tam) who wishes to be a Buddhist monk disguises herself as a young man and becomes a novice. Another young woman (Thi Mau) in the village accuses the "monk" of having a sexual affair that made her pregnant. If the monk reveals her secret, she will no longer be able to be a monk and achieve the Buddha nature she so longs for. If she says nothing, then she tacitly endorses injustice and the false accusation.
As intriguing as it may sound, the rest of the story doesn't really resonate with the story-conflict. Infact, it is more of a series of events that follow the secret life of Kinh Tam. On top of that, the Buddhist literature, the mantras & chants (My personal favourite The Great Bell Chant which you will find in Youtube) TNH tried to forcefully infuse into the story feels on the nose and out of place at times.
But having said so, there is something profound about the book that struck a chord in me, especially the bonus insight towards the end. Its relevance was only clear to me after reading it; the suppression of Buddhist religious leaders and followers by Police force & local Communists back in 1960s and how Thay and his student monks endured and fought back with loving-kindness and inclusiveness that resonated loudly in the book.
This is a small book, with a powerful message which is may well very-relevant to our times. Despite the shortcomings in its writing I still feel it's a beautiful read. 4/5
This World doesn't need more successful people. The World desperately needs more peacemakers, healers, restorers, storytellers and lovers of all kinds.
~Dalai Lama
As intriguing as it may sound, the rest of the story doesn't really resonate with the story-conflict. Infact, it is more of a series of events that follow the secret life of Kinh Tam. On top of that, the Buddhist literature, the mantras & chants (My personal favourite The Great Bell Chant which you will find in Youtube) TNH tried to forcefully infuse into the story feels on the nose and out of place at times.
But having said so, there is something profound about the book that struck a chord in me, especially the bonus insight towards the end. Its relevance was only clear to me after reading it; the suppression of Buddhist religious leaders and followers by Police force & local Communists back in 1960s and how Thay and his student monks endured and fought back with loving-kindness and inclusiveness that resonated loudly in the book.
This is a small book, with a powerful message which is may well very-relevant to our times. Despite the shortcomings in its writing I still feel it's a beautiful read. 4/5
This World doesn't need more successful people. The World desperately needs more peacemakers, healers, restorers, storytellers and lovers of all kinds.
~Dalai Lama
March 14, 2025
The story of "The Novice" highlights the significance of being caring and gentle when confronted with hardships. Focusing on Kinh Tam's life, the story highlights her virtuous character and spiritual awakening in the face of societal judgment as she becomes a highly respected monk. The story resembles a fable and delves into Buddhist ideas like meditation, mindfulness, and compassion.
It's essential to read this to shift your mindset on forgiveness and releasing resentment, helping you avoid carrying any burdens. It's a refuge you can always turn to when you need shelter from the unforgiving world, and realize that it will show you how to love the world once more.
It's essential to read this to shift your mindset on forgiveness and releasing resentment, helping you avoid carrying any burdens. It's a refuge you can always turn to when you need shelter from the unforgiving world, and realize that it will show you how to love the world once more.
March 2, 2021
2h 38'
Read
October 29, 2018A book filled with gentle wisdom and true compassion. A small life - faithfully lived - made large by the transforming power of love.
Brief though it may be, this story is not allegory or parable or empty didacticism. The characters breathe with their own life and truth, and the power and relevance of their choices come holistically through the telling. Yet the greatest treasure is probably Sister Chan Kong's summary of Thich Nhat Hanh's life which follows the narrative, and lends depth and credibility to the truth it contains - the hope that it offers.
As a final note, I find Thich Nhat Hanh's complete disregard for gender utterly refreshing. A soul is a soul is a soul. There is an unaffected egalitarianism in his writing (and teaching) that one rarely finds within the leaders of my own tradition (something I find myself thirsting for desperately).
Brief though it may be, this story is not allegory or parable or empty didacticism. The characters breathe with their own life and truth, and the power and relevance of their choices come holistically through the telling. Yet the greatest treasure is probably Sister Chan Kong's summary of Thich Nhat Hanh's life which follows the narrative, and lends depth and credibility to the truth it contains - the hope that it offers.
As a final note, I find Thich Nhat Hanh's complete disregard for gender utterly refreshing. A soul is a soul is a soul. There is an unaffected egalitarianism in his writing (and teaching) that one rarely finds within the leaders of my own tradition (something I find myself thirsting for desperately).
March 23, 2013
Unfortunately I have to agree with some of the reviewers that this book's writing is somewhat off-putting. TNH is one of my favorite authors, and I understand that this is meant as a Buddhist lesson. But still... I could never really get into the story because of the writing, so I might not have learned the lesson as well as I was supposed to... Not a bad book per se but I would basically recommend any other book by TNH rather than this one.
December 18, 2023
Buddhist teachings incorporated into a story which discovers the theme of love, marriage, gender et cetera.
Though it was short I drifted off so many times. I'm not blaming the novel. Maybe my cup overfloweth, the wisdom has been flowing and whispering "just say zen" but I'm just staring into the void.
I'm not sure if I'd recommend this, but I'm moving forward to some non-fiction by Nhat Hanh if it works a bit better.
Though it was short I drifted off so many times. I'm not blaming the novel. Maybe my cup overfloweth, the wisdom has been flowing and whispering "just say zen" but I'm just staring into the void.
I'm not sure if I'd recommend this, but I'm moving forward to some non-fiction by Nhat Hanh if it works a bit better.
February 6, 2022
"Surely anyone who has lived on Earth has had to experience injustice of one kind or another. If we allow hatred and revenge to dictate our response, then our suffering will only go on and on. How do we find a way out? How can we free ourselves? A person who feels injured by another typically harbors thoughts of revenge, wanting to punish the offender. But the Buddha taught that hatred is never removed by adding more hatred. The only stream that can wash away the pain of unjust acts is the sweet water of loving-kindness and compassion. Without loving-kindness and compassion, hatred and vengeance will continue to accumulate from one year, and one lifetime, to the next."
- The novice : A story of true love by Thich Nhat Hanh
.
.
The Novice” is based of Vietnamese folklore of a young monk who is repeatedly wronged, but who always does the right thing - not once held a grudge and accept it as part of of life. This young monk is Quan Am Thi Kinh or known as Kinh Tam. She is a beautiful young woman. Like other women back then, marriage seems the only way to progress to next stage of life so she ends up being married to a useless husband. Then, she was falsely accused by her husband and in-laws that she attempted to kill him while trying to shave his beard. She did not admit her guilt and as a repercussion, she was sent back to her own family in shame. Kinh Tam decided to leave town and disguised as a man. The reason of her disguise is due to her wishes to live the life of a monk. At the time, she knew that there are no roles for women in Buddhism unless she find a way to pursue her dream of studying Buddhist. She managed to gain entry to a monastery as a novice. She is devoted to the dharma. Years of service and joy in her calling, many people are inspired by her wisdom, devotion and humility. She becomes famous among the locals which unfortunately leads to another false accusation. Kinh Tam is accused by a local woman of causing her to be pregnant. She did not reveal her own gender and ended up up raising the child as her own at the monastery. She endured all the given punishment and slander by the community. In the end, she died peacefully and still forgiving everyone around her, including those that have victimized her is a true testament of her faith and devotion to Buddhist. An account by Sister Chan Khong at the end of the book did draw a connection between the novelist (Thich Nhat Hanh) and his protagonist (Kinh Tam). Sister Chan Khong did provide important events that happened when they tried to establish a monastery in Communist Vietnam and it did show that Thich Nhat Hanh has also endured great hardship, banishment and pain during that time. Overall, the story is fairly short. However, it did not take away anything important as someone who wanted to read and know more about the principles of non-violence, concepts of loving-kindness and compassion in Buddhism, i felt it did well in introducing me to it.
- The novice : A story of true love by Thich Nhat Hanh
.
.
The Novice” is based of Vietnamese folklore of a young monk who is repeatedly wronged, but who always does the right thing - not once held a grudge and accept it as part of of life. This young monk is Quan Am Thi Kinh or known as Kinh Tam. She is a beautiful young woman. Like other women back then, marriage seems the only way to progress to next stage of life so she ends up being married to a useless husband. Then, she was falsely accused by her husband and in-laws that she attempted to kill him while trying to shave his beard. She did not admit her guilt and as a repercussion, she was sent back to her own family in shame. Kinh Tam decided to leave town and disguised as a man. The reason of her disguise is due to her wishes to live the life of a monk. At the time, she knew that there are no roles for women in Buddhism unless she find a way to pursue her dream of studying Buddhist. She managed to gain entry to a monastery as a novice. She is devoted to the dharma. Years of service and joy in her calling, many people are inspired by her wisdom, devotion and humility. She becomes famous among the locals which unfortunately leads to another false accusation. Kinh Tam is accused by a local woman of causing her to be pregnant. She did not reveal her own gender and ended up up raising the child as her own at the monastery. She endured all the given punishment and slander by the community. In the end, she died peacefully and still forgiving everyone around her, including those that have victimized her is a true testament of her faith and devotion to Buddhist. An account by Sister Chan Khong at the end of the book did draw a connection between the novelist (Thich Nhat Hanh) and his protagonist (Kinh Tam). Sister Chan Khong did provide important events that happened when they tried to establish a monastery in Communist Vietnam and it did show that Thich Nhat Hanh has also endured great hardship, banishment and pain during that time. Overall, the story is fairly short. However, it did not take away anything important as someone who wanted to read and know more about the principles of non-violence, concepts of loving-kindness and compassion in Buddhism, i felt it did well in introducing me to it.
March 9, 2012
It is not a grand literary read.
However it is very peaceful, and quick and easy. One of those reads that really helps bring peace to the mind.
And it's great because one gets to learn about Vietnamese folk lore... I love to learn things.
However it is very peaceful, and quick and easy. One of those reads that really helps bring peace to the mind.
And it's great because one gets to learn about Vietnamese folk lore... I love to learn things.
January 13, 2018
De mis frases favoritas...
“El odio no se erradica añadiendo más odio. La única corriente que puede arrastrar los actos injustos es el agua dulce de la bondad y la compasión.”
“El odio no se erradica añadiendo más odio. La única corriente que puede arrastrar los actos injustos es el agua dulce de la bondad y la compasión.”
October 31, 2020
A very interesting parable that teaches how to deal with suffering and forgiveness. The story did talk to me personally by when dealing with despair and terrible conditions, do not keep going in that same direction but go home to yourself. The quote, "taking refuge in the island of self" that you need to find peace and comfort within yourself by changing directions so "you don't continue to lose yourself in the storms of outside circumstance" which can destroy you and the people around you.
February 9, 2021
This is classic Vietnamese folk story told through a Buddhist lens. The story gets lost at times because the storytelling focuses much more on Buddhism than the plot (but what can we expect, as this is written by a Buddhist monk). More like 3.5 stars. (I actually enjoyed the afterword more than the novel at times. This section is written by a Buddhist nun and explains the treatment of Buddhist monks in Vietnam during the war as well as in 2009.)
March 27, 2024
Ce livre décrit parfaitement l’expression « je ne m’attendais à rien, mais je suis quand même déçue ». Franchement, je m’attendais à un roman très philosophique avec de beaux messages et des réflexions profondes sur la vie, mais je n’ai récolté qu’un profond ennui et une envie irrépressible de sauter des pages pour en finir (je n’ai d’ailleurs même pas pris la peine de lire les annexes).
C’est assez rare que je n’aime pas une lecture, et j’essaie au maximum de ne pas abandonner en cours de route, mais là franchement, c’était une torture de le terminer. Alors peut-être que la philosophie du livre me passe au-dessus car elle ne me correspond pas, mais si la moralité est de laisser les injustices se faire sans parler et d’en plus pardonner ses bourreaux avec un grand sourire, merci mais non merci.
Dommage, la couverture était belle ! Je vous laisse le résumé en commentaire et je vais aller me changer les idées avec un peu de poésie !
Prenez soin de vous !
🔑 : Développement personnel - Moine - Féminisme - Vietnam - Ennui profond - Bouddhisme
C’est assez rare que je n’aime pas une lecture, et j’essaie au maximum de ne pas abandonner en cours de route, mais là franchement, c’était une torture de le terminer. Alors peut-être que la philosophie du livre me passe au-dessus car elle ne me correspond pas, mais si la moralité est de laisser les injustices se faire sans parler et d’en plus pardonner ses bourreaux avec un grand sourire, merci mais non merci.
Dommage, la couverture était belle ! Je vous laisse le résumé en commentaire et je vais aller me changer les idées avec un peu de poésie !
Prenez soin de vous !
🔑 : Développement personnel - Moine - Féminisme - Vietnam - Ennui profond - Bouddhisme
March 27, 2018
Hay libros que se leen en los momentos perfectos y este ha sido una linterna en medio de toda la agitación interna que tengo.
Es un libro sencillo, escrito de una manera dulce y delicada, pero lleno de mucha sabiduría.
De esos textos que hay que leerse muchas veces porque sabes que siempre encontrarás algo que no viste la última vez.
Es un libro sencillo, escrito de una manera dulce y delicada, pero lleno de mucha sabiduría.
De esos textos que hay que leerse muchas veces porque sabes que siempre encontrarás algo que no viste la última vez.
June 21, 2018
"Cuando nuestro corazón está lleno de bondad, compasión, alegría y ecuanimidad, su capacidad se torna ilimitada, inconmensurable. Con un corazón tan amplio, inmenso como el vasto mar, el sufrimiento y las flagrantes injusticias no pueden vencernos, así como un pequeño puñado de sal no vuelve salado un gran río."
April 26, 2023
Conmovedora novela corta sobre la tolerancia, la bondad, la generosidad y el amor.
April 30, 2024
I feel like I’m looking at the emperor and he isn’t wearing clothes - like, interesting story, get the moral here… but this wasn’t life-changing for me?
Read
November 8, 2018Reading Thich Nhat Hanh is like drinking from a cool stream.
December 26, 2022
Una novela que merece ser leída. Una narración que nos muestra como la generosidad, bondad y tolerancia son algunos elementos que nos llevan al encuentro con nuestro ser interior.
March 28, 2021
It was just okay to me. I was hoping for a deeper dive into Buddhism. I'm sure it delivered exactly what it needed to, but went over my head.
February 4, 2014
The Novice is the retelling of a Vietnamese folk tale about a young monk who is repeatedly wronged, but who always does the virtuous thing. As I read this book, I thought the story seemed familiar, and I realized that I read the same story as The Martyr by Ryūnosuke Akutagawa. Akutagawa does a much better job of story building. The Japanese writer doesn’t reveal to the reader that Lorenzo (his novice and the equivalent of Thich Nhat Hanh’s Kihn Tâm) is a female until the end—thus definitely resolving the claim that the young monk fathered a child out of wedlock and in contravention of vows f0r the reader at the same time as the characters in the story learn it.
Thich Nhat Hanh tells us that the novice is a female at the beginning, and he does so via backstory that serves both to give justification for why Kihn Tâm chooses to disguise herself and become a monk and to pile onto the injustice. We learn that Kihn Tâm’s female alter ego had been married, but the marriage ended with a false accusation of attempted murder of her husband. This backstory probably isn’t worth the drag for either of the aforementioned purposes—but the former is more justifiable than the latter.
What Thich Nhat Hanh lacks in gripping narrative structure, he gains in provoking thought. The Zen monk and poet gives the reader insight into how Kinh Tâm manages to be preternaturally virtuous. In The Martyr this is a black box affair. Hanh also encourages the reader to see Kihn Tâm’s accusers as the novice does, i.e. with compassion. Akutagawa does what any writer would do; he vilifies the accusers so as to make the story resonate with the average, petty, martyr-complex prone reader—as opposed to the enlightenment-aspiring reader. Hanh leaves the other monks in Kinh Tâm’s corner, i.e. when everyone else is condemning the novice, they still believe in her. Akutagawa does not present monastics in such a perfect light.
The book offers some interesting back matter. The most substantial of the appendices is an account by Sister Chan Khong of the works of Thich Nhat Hanh and his followers both during the war and afterword when they tried to establish a monastery in Communist Vietnam. The essay echoes the themes of loving-kindness and compassion that form the core of the novella, as does the essay by Hanh that brings the book to a conclusion. While this back matter is filler to make up for the fact that the story is not novel length, it nevertheless makes for interesting reading.
I’d recommend this book for those with an interested in Zen. If you’re looking for a good story, read Akutagawa’s The Martyr, but if you want to be inspired to compassion, read Thich Nhat Hanh.
Thich Nhat Hanh tells us that the novice is a female at the beginning, and he does so via backstory that serves both to give justification for why Kihn Tâm chooses to disguise herself and become a monk and to pile onto the injustice. We learn that Kihn Tâm’s female alter ego had been married, but the marriage ended with a false accusation of attempted murder of her husband. This backstory probably isn’t worth the drag for either of the aforementioned purposes—but the former is more justifiable than the latter.
What Thich Nhat Hanh lacks in gripping narrative structure, he gains in provoking thought. The Zen monk and poet gives the reader insight into how Kinh Tâm manages to be preternaturally virtuous. In The Martyr this is a black box affair. Hanh also encourages the reader to see Kihn Tâm’s accusers as the novice does, i.e. with compassion. Akutagawa does what any writer would do; he vilifies the accusers so as to make the story resonate with the average, petty, martyr-complex prone reader—as opposed to the enlightenment-aspiring reader. Hanh leaves the other monks in Kinh Tâm’s corner, i.e. when everyone else is condemning the novice, they still believe in her. Akutagawa does not present monastics in such a perfect light.
The book offers some interesting back matter. The most substantial of the appendices is an account by Sister Chan Khong of the works of Thich Nhat Hanh and his followers both during the war and afterword when they tried to establish a monastery in Communist Vietnam. The essay echoes the themes of loving-kindness and compassion that form the core of the novella, as does the essay by Hanh that brings the book to a conclusion. While this back matter is filler to make up for the fact that the story is not novel length, it nevertheless makes for interesting reading.
I’d recommend this book for those with an interested in Zen. If you’re looking for a good story, read Akutagawa’s The Martyr, but if you want to be inspired to compassion, read Thich Nhat Hanh.
October 11, 2011
I have to confess: I didn't finish this one. I didn't even make much headway into it because the writing was so amateurish and annoying. The author has written several books and is a poet, so I don't know what went wrong here.
An example of what I mean by amateurish writing, pages 1 and 2:
Waves of turbulent feelings arose rapidly within. Novice Kinh Tam reviewed the precarious situation. "I've taken the monastic vows of a novice. I've just been accused of having a sexual affair with Thi Mau, making her pregnant, and not owning up to the alleged offense." The thoughts tumbled on. "Who can possibly understand the predicament I'm facing? Doesn't anyone see the great injustice being done to me? Even though my teacher, the abbot of my temple, loves me, even though my two Dharma brothers care deeply for me, who knows whether they have doubts about my heart? And now the baby is here. Stubbornly refusing to bring the newborn to its true father, Thi Mau has brought it here to the temple. Everyone who already suspected that I'm the child's father will surely misconstrue my taking in the newborn. They will say I've admitted my guilt. What will my teacher think? How will my Dharma brothers react? And the people in the village?"
Talk about telling rather than showing. Talk about slamming the reader upside the head with a huge chunky summary that would have better been dished out slowly. People don't think that way, in any case.
I tried to go on, but I can't get into the book, finding the signs of bad writing all over the place.
An example of what I mean by amateurish writing, pages 1 and 2:
Waves of turbulent feelings arose rapidly within. Novice Kinh Tam reviewed the precarious situation. "I've taken the monastic vows of a novice. I've just been accused of having a sexual affair with Thi Mau, making her pregnant, and not owning up to the alleged offense." The thoughts tumbled on. "Who can possibly understand the predicament I'm facing? Doesn't anyone see the great injustice being done to me? Even though my teacher, the abbot of my temple, loves me, even though my two Dharma brothers care deeply for me, who knows whether they have doubts about my heart? And now the baby is here. Stubbornly refusing to bring the newborn to its true father, Thi Mau has brought it here to the temple. Everyone who already suspected that I'm the child's father will surely misconstrue my taking in the newborn. They will say I've admitted my guilt. What will my teacher think? How will my Dharma brothers react? And the people in the village?"
Talk about telling rather than showing. Talk about slamming the reader upside the head with a huge chunky summary that would have better been dished out slowly. People don't think that way, in any case.
I tried to go on, but I can't get into the book, finding the signs of bad writing all over the place.
November 29, 2014
This author is a far better Buddhist philosopher than he is a novelist. This is a good thing because there are a great many novelists but only one Thich Nhat Hanh. He provides such clear guidance for Westerners who wish to know the teachings of Vietnamese Zen Buddhism.
What interested me most about the folk tale of Kinh Tam is that the prefix Quan Am was added to her name after her death. This gives her an association with Quan Yin, the Boddhisattva of compassion. Perhaps she is the Vietnamese version of Quan Yin.
The aspect of this book that I found most valuable was the history of the persecution of Thich Nhat Hanh's monastery in Vietnam during the Vietnam War and under the Communist regime. His analysis of the reasons for persecution and why he considers it unimportant were also illuminating. His comment on the condition of exile seemed to be a particularly significant insight. "Your true home is within yourself." If you come to that realization, you can never lose your home.
What interested me most about the folk tale of Kinh Tam is that the prefix Quan Am was added to her name after her death. This gives her an association with Quan Yin, the Boddhisattva of compassion. Perhaps she is the Vietnamese version of Quan Yin.
The aspect of this book that I found most valuable was the history of the persecution of Thich Nhat Hanh's monastery in Vietnam during the Vietnam War and under the Communist regime. His analysis of the reasons for persecution and why he considers it unimportant were also illuminating. His comment on the condition of exile seemed to be a particularly significant insight. "Your true home is within yourself." If you come to that realization, you can never lose your home.
March 19, 2013
The book would be a boring insight into Buddhist Monastic life,if it was about a man.In the area of Vietnam where the Buddhist Monastery is they did not have nuns who practiced in the area,although in this time period they existed.To compare and contrast,if a person leaves his or her gender role,they commit a grave and mortal sin in the Catholic Church.Taking a false vow or a deception can be equally frowned on in Buddhism.Doing thing in a prayerful and relatively slow and mindful way is a lot like Saint Theresa of Lisieux,also known as the "Little Flower",meant when she said"Do little thing with great love",a Doctor of the Catholic Church,like she had gotten a Doctorate in Theology,while she was alive. Kinh Tam would do many hard duties,but ringing the Buddhist Monastery was one duty,that everyone enjoyed her doing.The book is a lot like a parable Jesus would of told and this book also includes a mini autobiography about Thich Nhat Hanh,the book is worth reading...
Displaying 1 - 30 of 203 reviews