What do you think?
Rate this book
A Case of Madness [or The Curious Appearance of Holmes in the Nighttime]
Andrew Thomas just got sacked. He's permanently drunk. He's got cancer. Is inescapably gay. Was hit by a bus. And he's fallen in love with a stranger whose life he saved.
As a newly-unemployed Sherlock Holmes scholar, Andrew knows only Holmes can help him untangle the madness his life has become, but Holmes isn't real. Except he absolutely appeared in Andrew's house, told him he's in love with a man he just met…and then in a fit of pique Andrew sent him away. Sure Holmes is probably a hallucination or a specter or a ghost, but now Andrew desperately needs his help. So to find the answer to his case and the man of his dreams, Andrew takes to chasing a fictional character through London with his very own Watson.
As a newly-unemployed Sherlock Holmes scholar, Andrew knows only Holmes can help him untangle the madness his life has become, but Holmes isn't real. Except he absolutely appeared in Andrew's house, told him he's in love with a man he just met…and then in a fit of pique Andrew sent him away. Sure Holmes is probably a hallucination or a specter or a ghost, but now Andrew desperately needs his help. So to find the answer to his case and the man of his dreams, Andrew takes to chasing a fictional character through London with his very own Watson.
272 pages, Paperback
Published March 20, 2023
10 people are currently reading
2715 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 89 reviews
June 5, 2023
Ah, this book! This book right here is a precious, underrated, little gem that needs to be added to everyone's TBR.
I really want to do the book justice and write an intelligent review, but my brain won't cooperate today. So here's some rambling instead.
I love how clever this story is. It's also so freaking funny (I don't think I've ever saved so many lines in a book before), and sprinkled with several deeper emotions like fear, sadness, regret or shame.
I read somewhere that this is a Sherlock Holmes retelling, but even if we get a lot of great info about the detective and his cases/life and Andrew's relationship with Mina (his best friend) is reminiscent of the Sherlock/Watson dynamic, I didn't see it as that. I actually thought of it as a self discovery/coming to terms with your sexuality journey.
The main character, Andrew, is the most precious human ever. He's extremely introverted, he hates socialising, he has cancer, he's just got fired from his job, and on top of that, he's hallucinating and trying to solve a case with Sherlock Holmes himself. I think that idea was brilliant, honestly. To have Andrew's fictional hero as the catalyst and main device for this journey of self acceptance.
I did have a bit of trouble with the insta love vibes that I was getting from Andrew and Matt, but I decided it wasn't a major inconvenience. I do wish Matt was a little bit more fleshed out as a character, though. Because he is a sweetheart and he deserves the world. 🥺
The diversity in the book is amazing. The side characters were all wonderful and played a very important role in Andrew's development.
I loved this so much. Buy it! Read it! Love it! Recommend it! Thank you. ❤️
I really want to do the book justice and write an intelligent review, but my brain won't cooperate today. So here's some rambling instead.
I love how clever this story is. It's also so freaking funny (I don't think I've ever saved so many lines in a book before), and sprinkled with several deeper emotions like fear, sadness, regret or shame.
I read somewhere that this is a Sherlock Holmes retelling, but even if we get a lot of great info about the detective and his cases/life and Andrew's relationship with Mina (his best friend) is reminiscent of the Sherlock/Watson dynamic, I didn't see it as that. I actually thought of it as a self discovery/coming to terms with your sexuality journey.
The main character, Andrew, is the most precious human ever. He's extremely introverted, he hates socialising, he has cancer, he's just got fired from his job, and on top of that, he's hallucinating and trying to solve a case with Sherlock Holmes himself. I think that idea was brilliant, honestly. To have Andrew's fictional hero as the catalyst and main device for this journey of self acceptance.
I did have a bit of trouble with the insta love vibes that I was getting from Andrew and Matt, but I decided it wasn't a major inconvenience. I do wish Matt was a little bit more fleshed out as a character, though. Because he is a sweetheart and he deserves the world. 🥺
The diversity in the book is amazing. The side characters were all wonderful and played a very important role in Andrew's development.
I loved this so much. Buy it! Read it! Love it! Recommend it! Thank you. ❤️
![Profile Image for Andrea ☾ [is inconsistently consistant].](/_next/image?url=https%3A%2F%2Fi.gr-assets.com%2Fimages%2FS%2Fcompressed.photo.goodreads.com%2Fusers%2F1642113904i%2F116166019._UY200_CR2%2C0%2C200%2C200_.jpg&w=128&q=75)
May 11, 2023
3.5 ⭐ This book was painful.
It made me cry. And while it's not the first time that's happened, and I'm sure it won't be the last, I usually end up loving those books. This one, though, was just sad and depressing for the most part. A Case of Madness is a truly apt name for this. It's such a weird book. Odd in good ways and in bad. I'm still unsure about it. I think I hated it. I think I loved it. I think Andrew's metal health is hardly talked about, even when the book is based on him having wild hallucinations about Sherlock Holmes. Is it autism mixed with a cancer that has spread to his brain? Is it schizophrenia? We shall never know.
This is a sit down and cry about the state of our society and civilisation kind of book. Maybe you'll find some reprieve in the literal final sentence of the book. Or maybe not (like me). The ending hardly feels satisfactory enough to make up for the rollercoaster of pain that the book puts you through.
Here's the list of the TWs I can think of (but there's probably more):
This was an eARC -so thank you so much to the author and Net Galley for providing it for me!
It made me cry. And while it's not the first time that's happened, and I'm sure it won't be the last, I usually end up loving those books. This one, though, was just sad and depressing for the most part. A Case of Madness is a truly apt name for this. It's such a weird book. Odd in good ways and in bad. I'm still unsure about it. I think I hated it. I think I loved it. I think Andrew's metal health is hardly talked about, even when the book is based on him having wild hallucinations about Sherlock Holmes. Is it autism mixed with a cancer that has spread to his brain? Is it schizophrenia? We shall never know.
This is a sit down and cry about the state of our society and civilisation kind of book. Maybe you'll find some reprieve in the literal final sentence of the book. Or maybe not (like me). The ending hardly feels satisfactory enough to make up for the rollercoaster of pain that the book puts you through.
Here's the list of the TWs I can think of (but there's probably more):
This was an eARC -so thank you so much to the author and Net Galley for providing it for me!
March 25, 2023
My expectations for this book reached a surprising conclusion not unlike some of our great literary mysteries. While I expected more of an old school murder mystery whodunit I was pleasantly surprised by a more humanistic character study and an endearing story of finding more of yourself while falling in love.
I loved the pacing and the character building of this story. It forced me to slow down and appreciate intricacies in detail and in each character as each chapter added more layers. I loved Andrew’s best friend Mina’s confidence and loyalty, and how much of a real character Andrew’s hallucinations of Sherlock felt, and the insight Sherlock provided toward Andrew as an extension of himself. I also just loved Andrew as a character; his anxiety and self-doubt and social awkwardness was so relatable and authentic to so many queer experiences.
While their relationship is somewhat “instant love”, Andrew and Matt make sense as more of their backgrounds are revealed and their bond deepens. And the scene of Andrew rescuing Matt is one of the most tender I’ve read in a while and shows Andrew’s true compassion that exists alongside his insecurities and quirks.
This book also reignited my interest in finally reading my original Sherlock Holmes novels and checking out some classic adaptations. The research and passion for the character is also shown throughout.
Like classic mysteries, this book encouraged me to reflect on life. Is the greatest mystery of our lives resting within? How much have we suppressed to fit into other people’s expectations and labels? Why am I asking you? I’ll wait for the sequel to think about this more, or ask whatever specter may appear while I’m pouring my morning coffee.
Well done to this author and an extra thank you for a copy for this honest review.
I loved the pacing and the character building of this story. It forced me to slow down and appreciate intricacies in detail and in each character as each chapter added more layers. I loved Andrew’s best friend Mina’s confidence and loyalty, and how much of a real character Andrew’s hallucinations of Sherlock felt, and the insight Sherlock provided toward Andrew as an extension of himself. I also just loved Andrew as a character; his anxiety and self-doubt and social awkwardness was so relatable and authentic to so many queer experiences.
While their relationship is somewhat “instant love”, Andrew and Matt make sense as more of their backgrounds are revealed and their bond deepens. And the scene of Andrew rescuing Matt is one of the most tender I’ve read in a while and shows Andrew’s true compassion that exists alongside his insecurities and quirks.
This book also reignited my interest in finally reading my original Sherlock Holmes novels and checking out some classic adaptations. The research and passion for the character is also shown throughout.
Like classic mysteries, this book encouraged me to reflect on life. Is the greatest mystery of our lives resting within? How much have we suppressed to fit into other people’s expectations and labels? Why am I asking you? I’ll wait for the sequel to think about this more, or ask whatever specter may appear while I’m pouring my morning coffee.
Well done to this author and an extra thank you for a copy for this honest review.
May 29, 2023
AHHHH, I loved this book!!
First off, I would like to thank the Author, Yvonne Knop, to provide me with a review copy of this wonderfully unique story. Thank you!
Turns out that this book completely exceeded all and any expectations I had going into it. All I knew of this book, after reading some things online, was that it was a "Sherlock Holmes Retelling" which isn't necessarily true. Or if you want to count it as that, it's definitely not all there is to the book.
I loved the writing style for this, as it instantly integrated me into the character and the plot and kept me hooked throughout the entirety of it. The characters as well as the plot were developed and well thought through, which was evident when it came to the dynamics of the whole book, it worked out wonderfully.
Personally, I'm not a fan of the whole instant-love trope, which is happening in this book, but it just fits into the story so well that it barely bothered me at all. I loved the relationships in the book generally, romantic and platonic ones alike.
In my opinion, we need more books like these and I'm excited to see what comes next by this author!
If you haven't already, PLEASE give this book a shot!
First off, I would like to thank the Author, Yvonne Knop, to provide me with a review copy of this wonderfully unique story. Thank you!
Turns out that this book completely exceeded all and any expectations I had going into it. All I knew of this book, after reading some things online, was that it was a "Sherlock Holmes Retelling" which isn't necessarily true. Or if you want to count it as that, it's definitely not all there is to the book.
I loved the writing style for this, as it instantly integrated me into the character and the plot and kept me hooked throughout the entirety of it. The characters as well as the plot were developed and well thought through, which was evident when it came to the dynamics of the whole book, it worked out wonderfully.
Personally, I'm not a fan of the whole instant-love trope, which is happening in this book, but it just fits into the story so well that it barely bothered me at all. I loved the relationships in the book generally, romantic and platonic ones alike.
In my opinion, we need more books like these and I'm excited to see what comes next by this author!
If you haven't already, PLEASE give this book a shot!
March 30, 2023
When you feel you've read all the Holmes variations that could possibly exist, it's time to read one more that takes those expectations, turns them inside out and delivers something bright and fresh - Yvonne Knop's A Case of Madness.
The story begins with a Holmesian academic, Andrew Taylor, just as he's fired from his university job. It may not be the worst thing that's happened to him, but it's a brutal icing on a pretty rough cake of a lifetime of social anxiety, self doubt and loneliness, capped with a recent diagnosis of cancer.
For all his challenges, Andrew is a complex and often compassionate character, and his dry wit is one of the best aspects of this captivating bookk. Another is the depth of his friendship with Mina, in many ways a Watson to his Holmes - their affection for each other, and frequently funny exchanges, provide a warming lift to a plot that can sometimes be very dark.
Some of that darkness comes when Andrew stumbles upon several thugs viciously attacking a young gay man. Andrew succeeds in saving Matt, and so begins an awkward love story that can only be pursued when Andrew begins to hallucinate the VIctorian Sherlock Holmes himself, who regards Andrew as a case. Andrew knows that this Holmes is a product of his own mind, but that doesn't make it any easier to explore what Holmes means by 'case' and what actions he might take to solve it. Especially when other, even less predictable characters join Holmes in urging Andrew to deal with his issues.
While A Case of Madness is occasionally dark, it is never bleak or without light and hope. In fact, so many lines are delightfully perfect I frequently highlighted them to look back on later, from the wonderful 'People are such beautiful beings when they show you their passions' to the wickedly funny. (I'd share more but... spoilers, sweetie).
For Holmesians, there are plenty of Holmesian facts and grace notes scattered about, but never so many that they become awkward and intrusive. They are a solid part of Andrew's intellectual and even emotional life, and he's fully aware that many others back off when he gets too into lore and lecturing.
There are also many parallels between Andrew's life and that of the Great Detective (from his Watson-esque friend Mina to the occasional lapse into drug use) but mostly this is a book about finding the courage to identify and face your fears, and to live your life as your true self, without which happiness will remain elusive.
I don't know if Yvonne Knop has thoughts for a sequel, but I missed Andrew, Matt, Mina and the others the moment I finished the book, and it would be a treat if, sometime in the future, I could spend time with them again.
The story begins with a Holmesian academic, Andrew Taylor, just as he's fired from his university job. It may not be the worst thing that's happened to him, but it's a brutal icing on a pretty rough cake of a lifetime of social anxiety, self doubt and loneliness, capped with a recent diagnosis of cancer.
For all his challenges, Andrew is a complex and often compassionate character, and his dry wit is one of the best aspects of this captivating bookk. Another is the depth of his friendship with Mina, in many ways a Watson to his Holmes - their affection for each other, and frequently funny exchanges, provide a warming lift to a plot that can sometimes be very dark.
Some of that darkness comes when Andrew stumbles upon several thugs viciously attacking a young gay man. Andrew succeeds in saving Matt, and so begins an awkward love story that can only be pursued when Andrew begins to hallucinate the VIctorian Sherlock Holmes himself, who regards Andrew as a case. Andrew knows that this Holmes is a product of his own mind, but that doesn't make it any easier to explore what Holmes means by 'case' and what actions he might take to solve it. Especially when other, even less predictable characters join Holmes in urging Andrew to deal with his issues.
While A Case of Madness is occasionally dark, it is never bleak or without light and hope. In fact, so many lines are delightfully perfect I frequently highlighted them to look back on later, from the wonderful 'People are such beautiful beings when they show you their passions' to the wickedly funny. (I'd share more but... spoilers, sweetie).
For Holmesians, there are plenty of Holmesian facts and grace notes scattered about, but never so many that they become awkward and intrusive. They are a solid part of Andrew's intellectual and even emotional life, and he's fully aware that many others back off when he gets too into lore and lecturing.
There are also many parallels between Andrew's life and that of the Great Detective (from his Watson-esque friend Mina to the occasional lapse into drug use) but mostly this is a book about finding the courage to identify and face your fears, and to live your life as your true self, without which happiness will remain elusive.
I don't know if Yvonne Knop has thoughts for a sequel, but I missed Andrew, Matt, Mina and the others the moment I finished the book, and it would be a treat if, sometime in the future, I could spend time with them again.
May 3, 2023
I wish i could give half ratings. I'd say this was a 3.5/3.75 to be ultra specific. This was a wonderful story that i could happily read more of. I loved the mc (most of the time) and all the side cast. I knew next to nothing about Sherlock and this was a nice way to read about it. I enjoyed the writing too. It was so full of life!
The only thing is that i found it too fast paced i guess, i was shocked it was only a few days. I wish there were more of the side characters too as i thought they were pretty interesting.
I'm grateful to netgalley for the advanced copy :)
The only thing is that i found it too fast paced i guess, i was shocked it was only a few days. I wish there were more of the side characters too as i thought they were pretty interesting.
I'm grateful to netgalley for the advanced copy :)
December 13, 2023
It’s difficult to explain this reading experience but I would simply describe it as fresh and different.
It has been a pleasant journey, plenty of cultural references and passion for many topics involving the characters and their psychology. It feels like a novel well-written and thoughtfully developed in terms of plotting, structure and locations. I loved that and the dialogues with Sherlock Holmes and its literary references, it felt like a dream come true being able to talk to a so-famous fictional character in a fun and diverse way. I think we all relate to some characters and it is amazing to make this exercise of communicating with them and think about them as entities in our daily lives.
Moreover, I enjoyed the main character and the difficulties to express his feelings and to own his identity. It is very common to find young characters in this situation but… what happens when you are married and realize you are not happy at all? What if you do not feel the same anymore? Difference and out-of-the norm is socially punished and this book talks openly about it.
Finally, I would have loved to have 50 pages more because the ending felt rushed in a way, but it is just VERY PERSONAL, and the last 3 chapters are amazing… the investigation process to find Sherlock, that idea of not losing part of yourself and your mistakes but embrace them, the idea of life as a party to celebrate just for being who we are… that was pure joy for me as a reader and I recommend it without any doubt.
It has been a pleasant journey, plenty of cultural references and passion for many topics involving the characters and their psychology. It feels like a novel well-written and thoughtfully developed in terms of plotting, structure and locations. I loved that and the dialogues with Sherlock Holmes and its literary references, it felt like a dream come true being able to talk to a so-famous fictional character in a fun and diverse way. I think we all relate to some characters and it is amazing to make this exercise of communicating with them and think about them as entities in our daily lives.
Moreover, I enjoyed the main character and the difficulties to express his feelings and to own his identity. It is very common to find young characters in this situation but… what happens when you are married and realize you are not happy at all? What if you do not feel the same anymore? Difference and out-of-the norm is socially punished and this book talks openly about it.
Finally, I would have loved to have 50 pages more because the ending felt rushed in a way, but it is just VERY PERSONAL, and the last 3 chapters are amazing… the investigation process to find Sherlock, that idea of not losing part of yourself and your mistakes but embrace them, the idea of life as a party to celebrate just for being who we are… that was pure joy for me as a reader and I recommend it without any doubt.
April 24, 2023
A Joyfully Jay review.
4.25 stars
This deeply introspective novel digs into Andrew’s deepest fears after a lifetime filled with mediocrity. He’s disappointed himself, his ex-wife, his family, and most recently Mina. Andrew is a quirky character, one who seems just one more disappointment away from complete collapse. I was fully invested when his life just got worse. Andrew’s character is the kind of sad that gives one secondhand embarrassment, but also the hope for better. I adored Andrew’s journey to the bottom of his psyche, spurred on by a ruthless Holmes and a furtive Watson. I felt immersed in London, personal catastrophe, and Sherlock–but not the modern version.
Read Veronica’s review in its entirety here.
4.25 stars
This deeply introspective novel digs into Andrew’s deepest fears after a lifetime filled with mediocrity. He’s disappointed himself, his ex-wife, his family, and most recently Mina. Andrew is a quirky character, one who seems just one more disappointment away from complete collapse. I was fully invested when his life just got worse. Andrew’s character is the kind of sad that gives one secondhand embarrassment, but also the hope for better. I adored Andrew’s journey to the bottom of his psyche, spurred on by a ruthless Holmes and a furtive Watson. I felt immersed in London, personal catastrophe, and Sherlock–but not the modern version.
Read Veronica’s review in its entirety here.
March 10, 2023
Thank you so much to the author Yvonne Knop for gifting me this ARC in exchange for an honest review! I stayed up until 3am to finish this.
This is a book about a man called Andrew who has cancer, has just been fired from his job and is struggling with the fact that he is gay. He is also a massive Sherlock Holmes fan. You can imagine his surprise then when Sherlock himself turns up in his living room to solve “his case”. While outside the university he’s just been fired from, Andrew meets Matt, an actor. He later saves his life after he is attacked by a group of homophobic men and a beautiful relationship blossoms. However, Andrew needs to face his fears if he is to fully flourish.
Oh my God Yvonne this was perfect! The writing, the characters, the story! Everything was perfect! The main character Andrew is probably the most relatable character I have ever been inside the head of. I am autistic and although it’s not explicitly stated, I think Andrew is too (and also Sherlock Holmes is thought to be autistic too!). His love of everything Sherlock and his passion for talking about and trying to bring it up in every conversation is literally me with K-Pop. Also I really appreciated his dislike towards the BBC show “Sherlock” because I happen to highly dislike that version as well. The only TV adaptation that Andrew likes is also my favourite! Andrew’s sense of “humour” is like mine, I was cracking up at so many of his comments because I was thinking “that’s exactly what I would say”.
I suppose I should go into my history with Sherlock Holmes. I was literally brought up on it. My Mum loves it and has now gifted me her beautiful boxed set of the original stories by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. When I was 17 I went on a residential field trip to Buckfastleigh and stayed right next to the ruined church that inspired the Hounds of Baskerville. We went to the church in the dark which as you can imagine was a fun time. The TV series with Jeremy Brett was regularly on our television and even now when I visit I regularly see his face!
All that is to say I really appreciated the research that Yvonne has done to complete this novel. They have obviously left no stone unturned and the result is an extremely factually correct depiction of Sherlock Holmes and his cases. You can see the passion that was put into writing this beautiful book.
The characters were so lovable and this friend group was amazing. There was so much LGBTQ+ representation in here. I especially enjoyed the representation of a man struggling with his sexuality later in life. There are many people who need to see that representation. What I love about this book as well is Yvonne takes the time to educate the reader on what terms such as “non binary” and “pansexual” mean. I love this because it leaves no room for ignorance and may also help people to be more accepting and conscious of using correct pronouns.
I really hope this book gets the success it deserves and reaches the audiences that need it most. It’s released on 20th March 2023 and all pre-orders will have a portion donated to the LGBTQ+ charity MindOut which is a charity that provides mental health services to anyone under the LGBTQ+ umbrella. It’s a really important charity so please consider pre-ordering! I throughly enjoyed this and would wholeheartedly recommend it to EVERYONE.
This is a book about a man called Andrew who has cancer, has just been fired from his job and is struggling with the fact that he is gay. He is also a massive Sherlock Holmes fan. You can imagine his surprise then when Sherlock himself turns up in his living room to solve “his case”. While outside the university he’s just been fired from, Andrew meets Matt, an actor. He later saves his life after he is attacked by a group of homophobic men and a beautiful relationship blossoms. However, Andrew needs to face his fears if he is to fully flourish.
Oh my God Yvonne this was perfect! The writing, the characters, the story! Everything was perfect! The main character Andrew is probably the most relatable character I have ever been inside the head of. I am autistic and although it’s not explicitly stated, I think Andrew is too (and also Sherlock Holmes is thought to be autistic too!). His love of everything Sherlock and his passion for talking about and trying to bring it up in every conversation is literally me with K-Pop. Also I really appreciated his dislike towards the BBC show “Sherlock” because I happen to highly dislike that version as well. The only TV adaptation that Andrew likes is also my favourite! Andrew’s sense of “humour” is like mine, I was cracking up at so many of his comments because I was thinking “that’s exactly what I would say”.
I suppose I should go into my history with Sherlock Holmes. I was literally brought up on it. My Mum loves it and has now gifted me her beautiful boxed set of the original stories by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. When I was 17 I went on a residential field trip to Buckfastleigh and stayed right next to the ruined church that inspired the Hounds of Baskerville. We went to the church in the dark which as you can imagine was a fun time. The TV series with Jeremy Brett was regularly on our television and even now when I visit I regularly see his face!
All that is to say I really appreciated the research that Yvonne has done to complete this novel. They have obviously left no stone unturned and the result is an extremely factually correct depiction of Sherlock Holmes and his cases. You can see the passion that was put into writing this beautiful book.
The characters were so lovable and this friend group was amazing. There was so much LGBTQ+ representation in here. I especially enjoyed the representation of a man struggling with his sexuality later in life. There are many people who need to see that representation. What I love about this book as well is Yvonne takes the time to educate the reader on what terms such as “non binary” and “pansexual” mean. I love this because it leaves no room for ignorance and may also help people to be more accepting and conscious of using correct pronouns.
I really hope this book gets the success it deserves and reaches the audiences that need it most. It’s released on 20th March 2023 and all pre-orders will have a portion donated to the LGBTQ+ charity MindOut which is a charity that provides mental health services to anyone under the LGBTQ+ umbrella. It’s a really important charity so please consider pre-ordering! I throughly enjoyed this and would wholeheartedly recommend it to EVERYONE.
March 21, 2023
A Case Of Madness is an original, heartwarming and slightly quirky read from a new author for me.
Firstly I absolutely loved Andrew and enjoyed following him throughout the book. He’s the kind of person I’d love to be friends with in real life as he’s such a lovable character. He’s got a lot of stuff happening in his life but is always there for his friends and willing to stand up for what he believes in.
The book covers a range of LBGTQ topics that I found fascinating to learn more about. It was shocking at times to realise what the community has to deal with and it’s definitely opened my eyes to the problems or prejudice that the LBGTQ community face.
I thought this book was very fast paced and there always seemed to be something happening to keep me reading. I really enjoyed following Andrew and his best friend Mina through London with some of their exploits making me laugh out loud. The ending was beautiful and hints at a possible sequel which I’m excited about as I’d love to spend more time with the characters.
Huge thanks to Kelly from Love Book Tours for my copy of this book and to the publisher for my copy of this book.
Firstly I absolutely loved Andrew and enjoyed following him throughout the book. He’s the kind of person I’d love to be friends with in real life as he’s such a lovable character. He’s got a lot of stuff happening in his life but is always there for his friends and willing to stand up for what he believes in.
The book covers a range of LBGTQ topics that I found fascinating to learn more about. It was shocking at times to realise what the community has to deal with and it’s definitely opened my eyes to the problems or prejudice that the LBGTQ community face.
I thought this book was very fast paced and there always seemed to be something happening to keep me reading. I really enjoyed following Andrew and his best friend Mina through London with some of their exploits making me laugh out loud. The ending was beautiful and hints at a possible sequel which I’m excited about as I’d love to spend more time with the characters.
Huge thanks to Kelly from Love Book Tours for my copy of this book and to the publisher for my copy of this book.
June 11, 2023
I saw this book so hyped up by friends, and it did not disappoint. A Case of Madness was a book with such a unique premise, and it pulled that premise off so well. What I loved most was that in addition to the main plot, we got so many other elements. The book gave commentary on homophobia, embracing your identity, the fear that surrounds coming out, mental and physical health, and the joy that comes from embracing existence.
As a cancer survivor, I felt that the portrayal of the anxiety and fear and existentialism that comes along with learning of your diagnosis was spot on. Andrew questioning mortality and suicide and whether or not he truly wanted to live his life as fully as he possibly could added a powerful emotional undertone to the story that I really appreciated.
There were some heavy themes covered -- suicide, hate crimes, cancer, mental illness. But those topics were approached with sensitivity and care.
I also have to say -- Matt was the absolute sweetest little angel. I think I"m president of his fan club. He was so charming, so kind, so grateful, and I loved watching him work on his self-worth. The scenes with him were my favorite parts of the book.
I started Pride Month with this book, and it was so fitting. Reading this was a true delight, and I am so impressed by Yvonne Knopp's writing. If you're looking for a book with an unconventional premise filled with emotionality, mystery, and love -- this is for you.
As a cancer survivor, I felt that the portrayal of the anxiety and fear and existentialism that comes along with learning of your diagnosis was spot on. Andrew questioning mortality and suicide and whether or not he truly wanted to live his life as fully as he possibly could added a powerful emotional undertone to the story that I really appreciated.
There were some heavy themes covered -- suicide, hate crimes, cancer, mental illness. But those topics were approached with sensitivity and care.
I also have to say -- Matt was the absolute sweetest little angel. I think I"m president of his fan club. He was so charming, so kind, so grateful, and I loved watching him work on his self-worth. The scenes with him were my favorite parts of the book.
I started Pride Month with this book, and it was so fitting. Reading this was a true delight, and I am so impressed by Yvonne Knopp's writing. If you're looking for a book with an unconventional premise filled with emotionality, mystery, and love -- this is for you.
March 10, 2023
I would like to thank Yvonne Knop for reaching out to me and giving me the opportunity to read this fabulous book before its release on 20/03/2023. Pre-order it now and a donation will be made to mindoutlgtq, an organisation based in Brighton (UK) providing mental health services to LGBTQIA+ communities.
This sweet little romcom was a delight to read. I gotta be honest, I was never a person that wanted to read Sherlock Holmes, but boy, I want to now. I would think if you have read Sherlock Holmes, you would really appreciate this novel.
What can I say about the MC Andrew. A hero, a survivor, a nerd? Maybe all three, ah YES. He is such a strong character, and an inspiration. Come on, the man has cancer, lost his job and is hallucinating (Sherlock Holmes, and even Sir Elton John)! And is still able to get out of bed and find love. I love the message this sends! Showing that through the worst times and circumstances, you can and should fight for what you want!
Yvonne touches on some of the current LGBTQIA+ topics and gives insight to what they go through on a regular basis. The POV that Yvonne approached these topics from is that of an older gentleman (Andrew). Both endearing and informative.
This was a great 4/5 stars for me. Personally, I was left with so many questions at the end but I think it is more curiosity than anything else. I’m not sure what Yvonne’s plans are but I think they have left room for a sequel.
This sweet little romcom was a delight to read. I gotta be honest, I was never a person that wanted to read Sherlock Holmes, but boy, I want to now. I would think if you have read Sherlock Holmes, you would really appreciate this novel.
What can I say about the MC Andrew. A hero, a survivor, a nerd? Maybe all three, ah YES. He is such a strong character, and an inspiration. Come on, the man has cancer, lost his job and is hallucinating (Sherlock Holmes, and even Sir Elton John)! And is still able to get out of bed and find love. I love the message this sends! Showing that through the worst times and circumstances, you can and should fight for what you want!
Yvonne touches on some of the current LGBTQIA+ topics and gives insight to what they go through on a regular basis. The POV that Yvonne approached these topics from is that of an older gentleman (Andrew). Both endearing and informative.
This was a great 4/5 stars for me. Personally, I was left with so many questions at the end but I think it is more curiosity than anything else. I’m not sure what Yvonne’s plans are but I think they have left room for a sequel.
July 29, 2023
This was such an unexpected and unusual book.
I imagine this book is like if you took Notting Hill but mixed it with the main character having an existential crisis and it manifesting through hallucinations of Sherlock Holmes- and then made it queer.
It was a fascinating lens to view the experiences and challenges that people in the queer community face on a regular basis. All the while, also trying to tackle heavy topics of death, suicide and cancer. What a rollercoaster of a combination.
Also while not explicitly stated (I don’t believe) the main character presents as autistic, which was a pretty unique narrative voice for my experience.
3.5 stars. Unique and a little odd.
I imagine this book is like if you took Notting Hill but mixed it with the main character having an existential crisis and it manifesting through hallucinations of Sherlock Holmes- and then made it queer.
It was a fascinating lens to view the experiences and challenges that people in the queer community face on a regular basis. All the while, also trying to tackle heavy topics of death, suicide and cancer. What a rollercoaster of a combination.
Also while not explicitly stated (I don’t believe) the main character presents as autistic, which was a pretty unique narrative voice for my experience.
3.5 stars. Unique and a little odd.
June 13, 2023
4.5⭐
It's just so great to get a queer romance & Holmes together.
Andrew as a main character is something that makes this book so amazing, because even when he's in the worst situation, his thoughts are never dull and give the story an interesting pace. I loved his old fashioned style and his fascination and adoration of Holmes. The authors own love for the detective can be easily spotted in the text with all the extensive knowledge of the stories, and that's something I can't help but love. This book is a work of passion and projects like these are simply the best kind.
Andrew hallucinating Holmes, and later two more people, was such an interesting concept and delivered, at least in my opinion, the best parts of the story. Especially the way how Andrew and Holmes's dynamic shifted throigh the story and their banter was extremely entertaining.
For the other characters, I must say it was really easy to like them and the friendships were so nice.
And even though I would pass away if I got to that kind of situation, I loved the final scene so much. Andrew finally finding the confidence to properly confess to Matt and also apologize for the things he did was a great closing to the story and the development of their romance.
Note: Thank you to the author for gifting me this book in exchange for a review, I really appreciate it!
It's just so great to get a queer romance & Holmes together.
Andrew as a main character is something that makes this book so amazing, because even when he's in the worst situation, his thoughts are never dull and give the story an interesting pace. I loved his old fashioned style and his fascination and adoration of Holmes. The authors own love for the detective can be easily spotted in the text with all the extensive knowledge of the stories, and that's something I can't help but love. This book is a work of passion and projects like these are simply the best kind.
Andrew hallucinating Holmes, and later two more people, was such an interesting concept and delivered, at least in my opinion, the best parts of the story. Especially the way how Andrew and Holmes's dynamic shifted throigh the story and their banter was extremely entertaining.
For the other characters, I must say it was really easy to like them and the friendships were so nice.
And even though I would pass away if I got to that kind of situation, I loved the final scene so much. Andrew finally finding the confidence to properly confess to Matt and also apologize for the things he did was a great closing to the story and the development of their romance.
Note: Thank you to the author for gifting me this book in exchange for a review, I really appreciate it!
April 4, 2023
When Andrew finds himself freshly unemployed, with a new cancer diagnosis, a nicotine dependency that rivals a chain smoker, and a figment of his imagination showing up in the form of Sherlock Holmes, he realizes with Holmes’ help, he needs to get his life back on track.
Holmes helps Andrew solve the most important case one can undertake. With the help of a few other characters, including the cute man that Andrew saved from a violent hate crime, things become even hazier before clarity can be found.
Yvonne Knop did a great job of creating a plot that included both mystery and romance. The level of detail made me feel like I was racing around London with Andrew, Mina, and the rest of the gang.
Knop seamlessly crafted a tale with inclusivity, hilarity, and some rather heavy topics.
I’ve never read a Sherlock Holmes novel, and have only been exposed through the show Elementary, so I learned quite a bit through this book and thoroughly enjoyed myself.
A special thank you to Yvonne Knop for providing me with an advance reader copy to read and review. As always, all thoughts and opinions are completely my own.
Holmes helps Andrew solve the most important case one can undertake. With the help of a few other characters, including the cute man that Andrew saved from a violent hate crime, things become even hazier before clarity can be found.
Yvonne Knop did a great job of creating a plot that included both mystery and romance. The level of detail made me feel like I was racing around London with Andrew, Mina, and the rest of the gang.
Knop seamlessly crafted a tale with inclusivity, hilarity, and some rather heavy topics.
I’ve never read a Sherlock Holmes novel, and have only been exposed through the show Elementary, so I learned quite a bit through this book and thoroughly enjoyed myself.
A special thank you to Yvonne Knop for providing me with an advance reader copy to read and review. As always, all thoughts and opinions are completely my own.
May 22, 2023
On the Fence
I'm a bit on the fence about this one. I did enjoy a lot of it but there were also things that I didn't enjoy. In the end though, I'm glad I read it. Please mind the trigger warnings for this.
I'm a bit on the fence about this one. I did enjoy a lot of it but there were also things that I didn't enjoy. In the end though, I'm glad I read it. Please mind the trigger warnings for this.
May 8, 2023
This is one of those books that just has me wanting to make inarticulate happy sounds just thinking about it. Not particularly the best headspace to be in when you’re trying to write a coherent review, but definitely the place you want to be from a reader’s perspective.
A Case of Madness is one of those books I just kept hearing about. No matter when I was scrolling on Instagram, there it was! Calling to me. Reminding me there, there was a book I told myself I would read.
Like most things, I took my time about picking it up because my memory is shot full of holes, even when I’m being constantly reminded of something. I’m so glad A Case of Madness kept showing up on my feed. If it hadn’t, I would have missed out on a great read that gave me the happy feels for days, and left me bitterly wanting more when it ended.
I think what instantly grabbed me about A Case of Madness was the main character, Andrew Thomas. He reminds me so much of myself in so many ways: completely obsessed with and in love with fictional characters, adores pens, has exactly one real life friend who loves him and would kill for him, is utterly socially awkward (Oh, the horror of it all), just wants to be home in his own pajama all the time. Oh. And he’s gay. So totally, and sweetly gay.
A few paragraphs in and I was hooked by this fictional character that resonated with my soul. And that was fantastic because a few pages in and he swept me off on a grand adventure about life, love, and finding our place in a world that feels too big and scary for us. A world we just might not understand and that makes us want to go home and read a book in our pajamas.
Reading this book was like finding bits of my own life strewn across paper, and it made me feel I just might be strong enough to maybe face some of the heartache going on in my own life.
Thinking he’s going to die, knowing he’s gone mad, but going on despite it, Andrew Thomas talks with Sherlock Holmes, meets a whole cast of fabulous, queer found family, and delights with his anxious wit (Oh, the horror of it all). I spent a good three days (nights, actually) reading this book for hours on end and smiling like an idiot at my phone.
Honestly, my only complaint was that the ending seemed to come too soon and had a slightly rushed feel to it. There were a few story threads that I felt weren’t fully wrapped up and an extremely limited amount of confusion around the ending that I felt a couple extra pages could have remedied. The beginning of the book is incredibly detailed and exquisitely paced; some of that was lost near the end. I will say, I was privileged enough to read an advance reader copy (an ARC), so these issues could very well be resolved in the fully edited version. I have no way of knowing, until I get a physical book in my hands.
But let’s face it, if my biggest complaint is, “I wish there was more of this!” it isn’t much of a complaint.
A Case of Madness is well written, absolutely delightful, and something I highly recommend for anyone who just wants to read a beautifully crafted book and feel good while doing it. (Oh, the pleasure of it all.)
A Case of Madness is one of those books I just kept hearing about. No matter when I was scrolling on Instagram, there it was! Calling to me. Reminding me there, there was a book I told myself I would read.
Like most things, I took my time about picking it up because my memory is shot full of holes, even when I’m being constantly reminded of something. I’m so glad A Case of Madness kept showing up on my feed. If it hadn’t, I would have missed out on a great read that gave me the happy feels for days, and left me bitterly wanting more when it ended.
I think what instantly grabbed me about A Case of Madness was the main character, Andrew Thomas. He reminds me so much of myself in so many ways: completely obsessed with and in love with fictional characters, adores pens, has exactly one real life friend who loves him and would kill for him, is utterly socially awkward (Oh, the horror of it all), just wants to be home in his own pajama all the time. Oh. And he’s gay. So totally, and sweetly gay.
A few paragraphs in and I was hooked by this fictional character that resonated with my soul. And that was fantastic because a few pages in and he swept me off on a grand adventure about life, love, and finding our place in a world that feels too big and scary for us. A world we just might not understand and that makes us want to go home and read a book in our pajamas.
Reading this book was like finding bits of my own life strewn across paper, and it made me feel I just might be strong enough to maybe face some of the heartache going on in my own life.
Thinking he’s going to die, knowing he’s gone mad, but going on despite it, Andrew Thomas talks with Sherlock Holmes, meets a whole cast of fabulous, queer found family, and delights with his anxious wit (Oh, the horror of it all). I spent a good three days (nights, actually) reading this book for hours on end and smiling like an idiot at my phone.
Honestly, my only complaint was that the ending seemed to come too soon and had a slightly rushed feel to it. There were a few story threads that I felt weren’t fully wrapped up and an extremely limited amount of confusion around the ending that I felt a couple extra pages could have remedied. The beginning of the book is incredibly detailed and exquisitely paced; some of that was lost near the end. I will say, I was privileged enough to read an advance reader copy (an ARC), so these issues could very well be resolved in the fully edited version. I have no way of knowing, until I get a physical book in my hands.
But let’s face it, if my biggest complaint is, “I wish there was more of this!” it isn’t much of a complaint.
A Case of Madness is well written, absolutely delightful, and something I highly recommend for anyone who just wants to read a beautifully crafted book and feel good while doing it. (Oh, the pleasure of it all.)
April 10, 2023
The thing that struck me first about A Case of Madness, debut novel by Yvonne Knop, was the voice of the protagonist and how it so perfectly reflected his personality, bringing the awkward, nerdy Andrew Thomas to life on the page.
'For most of my teenage years, I questioned why I was so different from the others. Everyone else was colourful fruit salad, and I was the oatmeal.'
Andrew Thomas, a Sherlock Holmes obsessed academic has just been fired. He is also going to die – whether from illness or his own hand is to be determined. Thomas is an old school conservative nerd by nature, but harbours a deep secret about his sexuality that he can’t even admit to his best friend Mina.
'When asked to describe herself, she’s always quick to reply that she’s just like her favourite coffee: dark, bitter and too hot.'
Free spirited, Pakistani Mina, whom Thomas describes as a ‘stray cat’ compared to himself as ‘a scared house cat,’ is the only person who can bring him out of his shell. Mina is his complimentary opposite, his personal Watson, his only real friend, with whom he shared a flat for a period following his divorce.
Thomas is a man so deep in the closet that he ‘turns into a plank’ when anyone touches him, drinks away his personal angst and can only admit his attractions to his imaginary friend, Sherlock Holmes – and even then it’s a struggle. That is until he meets the theatrical Matt after rescuing him from a homophobic attack in the street.
'I had always run away from feelings, and the urge to just jump right out the bathroom window was overwhelming.'
Sherlock, Thomas’s obsession comes to life via random appearances in which he cajoles Thomas, offering him unsolicited advice or insults in an attempt to help him ‘solve his case’.
'I leaned back and looked at the ceiling. I was up against Sherlock Holmes cool intellect. I wish I’d made another fictional character my psychiatrist.'
A Case of Madness is a story about coming out, coming into yourself, and the transformative power of love. There is some lovely magical realism scattered throughout this novel in the form of Thomas’s hallucinations, which are essentially his subconscious speaking to him to try and save him from himself. There are plenty of Sherlock references throughout, but you don’t have to be a Holmes fan to enjoy this sweet queer romcom.
Thanks to Yvonne for the ARC!
A Case of Madness or The Curious Appearance of Holmes in the Nighttime
'For most of my teenage years, I questioned why I was so different from the others. Everyone else was colourful fruit salad, and I was the oatmeal.'
Andrew Thomas, a Sherlock Holmes obsessed academic has just been fired. He is also going to die – whether from illness or his own hand is to be determined. Thomas is an old school conservative nerd by nature, but harbours a deep secret about his sexuality that he can’t even admit to his best friend Mina.
'When asked to describe herself, she’s always quick to reply that she’s just like her favourite coffee: dark, bitter and too hot.'
Free spirited, Pakistani Mina, whom Thomas describes as a ‘stray cat’ compared to himself as ‘a scared house cat,’ is the only person who can bring him out of his shell. Mina is his complimentary opposite, his personal Watson, his only real friend, with whom he shared a flat for a period following his divorce.
Thomas is a man so deep in the closet that he ‘turns into a plank’ when anyone touches him, drinks away his personal angst and can only admit his attractions to his imaginary friend, Sherlock Holmes – and even then it’s a struggle. That is until he meets the theatrical Matt after rescuing him from a homophobic attack in the street.
'I had always run away from feelings, and the urge to just jump right out the bathroom window was overwhelming.'
Sherlock, Thomas’s obsession comes to life via random appearances in which he cajoles Thomas, offering him unsolicited advice or insults in an attempt to help him ‘solve his case’.
'I leaned back and looked at the ceiling. I was up against Sherlock Holmes cool intellect. I wish I’d made another fictional character my psychiatrist.'
A Case of Madness is a story about coming out, coming into yourself, and the transformative power of love. There is some lovely magical realism scattered throughout this novel in the form of Thomas’s hallucinations, which are essentially his subconscious speaking to him to try and save him from himself. There are plenty of Sherlock references throughout, but you don’t have to be a Holmes fan to enjoy this sweet queer romcom.
Thanks to Yvonne for the ARC!
A Case of Madness or The Curious Appearance of Holmes in the Nighttime
April 18, 2023
TW: homophobia, homophobic attacks, cancer, mental health issues, suicide ideation and more.
“It wasn’t that I didn’t like the company of others, it was that I struggled in the company of others”
I just want to start this off by saying thank you to the author for reaching out and sending me a copy of this book, I loved it🖤
as a gay person obsessed with Sherlock Holmes, I knew I would love this book- I just didn’t understand how much. following Andrew through his difficult life, navigating his traumatic experiences and issues facing his own sexuality was a storyline that highlighted the rawness of what it is to be human- and it hurt. i equally loved and hated Andrew because he was written so well that I became frustrated with his actions because they were so real. this wasn’t a book where the characters magically got better and dealt with their issues overnight, this showed what it’s like to constantly be fighting an uphill battle and having times where you almost give up. it showed the realness of what it is to be gay as well as the beauty that surrounds accepting yourself.
I loved the fun little trivia facts about Sherlock scattered throughout and it was so cool to see references that I understood from a series I love🖤 I really enjoyed how even now after finishing the book I’m still not sure what was going on, was it a ghost? a hallucination? I think it allowed the reader to interpret it how they wanted and gave so much room for opinion throughout.
at first I wasn’t a big fan of the romance because of the mentioned age gap and the trauma Andrew was going through- but as it grew and blossomed it became another thing I loved. again, I think this was written in such a beautiful way because it wasn’t perfect. their struggles and trauma got in the way, the issues of their past obstructed the flawless love we all dream of having but at the end of the day? It was real. It was messy and flawed and kinda difficult, but it was worth it. with the help of your very own Watson and the realisation fear is not enough to stop you, you can enjoy a life full of love and happiness.
I adored this book and think it was such a cool unique premise- so happy I read it and I recommend to others
“It wasn’t that I didn’t like the company of others, it was that I struggled in the company of others”
I just want to start this off by saying thank you to the author for reaching out and sending me a copy of this book, I loved it🖤
as a gay person obsessed with Sherlock Holmes, I knew I would love this book- I just didn’t understand how much. following Andrew through his difficult life, navigating his traumatic experiences and issues facing his own sexuality was a storyline that highlighted the rawness of what it is to be human- and it hurt. i equally loved and hated Andrew because he was written so well that I became frustrated with his actions because they were so real. this wasn’t a book where the characters magically got better and dealt with their issues overnight, this showed what it’s like to constantly be fighting an uphill battle and having times where you almost give up. it showed the realness of what it is to be gay as well as the beauty that surrounds accepting yourself.
I loved the fun little trivia facts about Sherlock scattered throughout and it was so cool to see references that I understood from a series I love🖤 I really enjoyed how even now after finishing the book I’m still not sure what was going on, was it a ghost? a hallucination? I think it allowed the reader to interpret it how they wanted and gave so much room for opinion throughout.
at first I wasn’t a big fan of the romance because of the mentioned age gap and the trauma Andrew was going through- but as it grew and blossomed it became another thing I loved. again, I think this was written in such a beautiful way because it wasn’t perfect. their struggles and trauma got in the way, the issues of their past obstructed the flawless love we all dream of having but at the end of the day? It was real. It was messy and flawed and kinda difficult, but it was worth it. with the help of your very own Watson and the realisation fear is not enough to stop you, you can enjoy a life full of love and happiness.
I adored this book and think it was such a cool unique premise- so happy I read it and I recommend to others
May 3, 2023
Wow, there’s a lot to unpack in this one! A Case of Madness isn’t at all the journey I anticipated at the outset. I wrongly assumed the plot would be more traditionally Holmesian; that is, there’d be a crime which prompted a lot of sleuthing. Oh, and it has a romance, so maybe with kissing? Instead, what begins as a sedate story of a Sherlock Holmes scholar struggling to navigate a constantly shifting landscape quickly becomes a race against time. The mystery here isn’t at all a classic whodunnit, but rather the mystery of life. (Spoiler: there is definitely kissing.)
The events of this book are told from Andrew’s point of view and center around his scholarly pursuit of - and dare I say obsession with? - Sherlock Holmes, his sexuality and his recent medical diagnosis, each of which directly impacts the other. Factor in hallucinations of Holmes himself, and it’s no wonder so many complexly interwoven storylines would result in a case of madness. Holmes appears to be there to help Andrew solve a case, and we spend quite a bit of time trying to ascertain just exactly what that case might be. Through Andrew’s journey as well as more than a few twists and turns, Knop reveals the problem and its inevitable solution on the way to a satisfying conclusion.
When I say this book is about the mystery of life, it’s because throughout Knop contrasts life and death at every turn. Faced with his own mortality, Andrew is increasingly aware of each moment, its impact and what it means for the future. His interactions with Holmes at times are existential, asking the question of just what our purpose is, whether our lives matter, and what our lives will have meant long after we’re gone. I was struck more than once by the dichotomy between fighting to survive and the many ways that something in life - society, illness, tragedy, and other issues - is simultaneously working against it. It’s there in the homophobia these characters face, the decision Andrew makes regarding his health and in the potential and capacity for love, if only we choose to embrace it.
*I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book*
The events of this book are told from Andrew’s point of view and center around his scholarly pursuit of - and dare I say obsession with? - Sherlock Holmes, his sexuality and his recent medical diagnosis, each of which directly impacts the other. Factor in hallucinations of Holmes himself, and it’s no wonder so many complexly interwoven storylines would result in a case of madness. Holmes appears to be there to help Andrew solve a case, and we spend quite a bit of time trying to ascertain just exactly what that case might be. Through Andrew’s journey as well as more than a few twists and turns, Knop reveals the problem and its inevitable solution on the way to a satisfying conclusion.
When I say this book is about the mystery of life, it’s because throughout Knop contrasts life and death at every turn. Faced with his own mortality, Andrew is increasingly aware of each moment, its impact and what it means for the future. His interactions with Holmes at times are existential, asking the question of just what our purpose is, whether our lives matter, and what our lives will have meant long after we’re gone. I was struck more than once by the dichotomy between fighting to survive and the many ways that something in life - society, illness, tragedy, and other issues - is simultaneously working against it. It’s there in the homophobia these characters face, the decision Andrew makes regarding his health and in the potential and capacity for love, if only we choose to embrace it.
*I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book*
May 14, 2023
"A Case of Madness" is a very special book, it deals with very diverse topics, from mental health, toxic relationships, healthy relationships, the value of good friendships, the search for identity and the fear of the unknown. Yvonne masterfully tells a story that many can relate to and makes us empathise with each and every one of the characters.
Andrew, the protagonist is a character with great psychological depth and upon meeting Matt he enters a world he has only seen through the peephole, but never up close, he meets a diverse group of characters and with the help of the phantom of Sherlock Holmes, learns to navigate this new situation in his life, though it can be turbulent, it helps him to find meaning.
It makes me so happy to read adult characters with healthy relationships and where mental health issues are dealt with by normalising them and exposing them not as a bad thing but as just another part of the journey, because a large percentage of people in the LGBTQ+ community suffer from mental illness, and it is so important that this aspect is made visible and not seen as something that is wrong.
Another aspect that I love in the novel is that it shows that it is not only in young adulthood that happiness can be found, but that even if life is hard, there are moments of happiness to be found at any time. Yvonne conveys this feeling beautifully.
I came out of this reading with a feeling that in this world so full of fear of what is different and so full of hate... We need more novels like this one, that teach us to exist, to love freely, and to break the rules by finding what moves us and takes us out of our hiding place, to be able to live our lives without fear.
Thank you Yvonne for this amazing novel. If you like romance, inclusivity, and Sherlock Holmes, this novel is for you. It's very important to help authors who are starting out, so you can find this novel in its paper and digital editions through Improbable Press and Amazon. Give it a chance, I guarantee you will fall in love with Andrew and Matt and all their wonderful friends and hallucinations.
Andrew, the protagonist is a character with great psychological depth and upon meeting Matt he enters a world he has only seen through the peephole, but never up close, he meets a diverse group of characters and with the help of the phantom of Sherlock Holmes, learns to navigate this new situation in his life, though it can be turbulent, it helps him to find meaning.
It makes me so happy to read adult characters with healthy relationships and where mental health issues are dealt with by normalising them and exposing them not as a bad thing but as just another part of the journey, because a large percentage of people in the LGBTQ+ community suffer from mental illness, and it is so important that this aspect is made visible and not seen as something that is wrong.
Another aspect that I love in the novel is that it shows that it is not only in young adulthood that happiness can be found, but that even if life is hard, there are moments of happiness to be found at any time. Yvonne conveys this feeling beautifully.
I came out of this reading with a feeling that in this world so full of fear of what is different and so full of hate... We need more novels like this one, that teach us to exist, to love freely, and to break the rules by finding what moves us and takes us out of our hiding place, to be able to live our lives without fear.
Thank you Yvonne for this amazing novel. If you like romance, inclusivity, and Sherlock Holmes, this novel is for you. It's very important to help authors who are starting out, so you can find this novel in its paper and digital editions through Improbable Press and Amazon. Give it a chance, I guarantee you will fall in love with Andrew and Matt and all their wonderful friends and hallucinations.
June 3, 2023
Y’all, I loved this book. It’s. So. Good! A Case of Madness grabbed me at the first page and didn’t let go. The writing is so evocative. I’m not a book highlighter, but I found myself dog-earring corners (yes, I bought the paperback) to remember them.
The story begins with Sherlock scholar Andrew Thomas on his way to be fired from his university lecturer job. He collides with adorable Matthew Lewis, scattering his leaflets everywhere “I like theater,” he blurts, and after some brief flirting heads to his doom. Andrew is a hot mess, but I loved him.
They meet again that night when Andrew saves Matthew from a beating, taking a head-but and calling for help.
Oh, and introverted Andrew sees Sherlock Holmes, who is ready to help him with his case. And he has cancer. And doesn’t really want to be gay after seeing Matt being beaten. His best friend Mina (shades of Dr. Watson) has the best responses, reminding him, as only someone who loves you can, no one likes him anyway.
Matt is a charming, soap opera actor with mega wealthy and famous parents. And prone to anxiety attacks. His flat mate Bev is a wonder. Everyone needs a Bev in their lives.
Andrew and Matt are good together, but Andrew infuriatingly doesn’t feel he deserves nice things and blows it. Leaving sweet cinnamon roll Matt heartbroken.
It takes Holmes, Elton John, and a city bus for him to see the error of his ways. And all of their friends to help get them back together. In the most public declaration, which does wonders for his social anxiety, Andrew admits his feelings and starts his HEA.
I love a good mystery and the Holmes facts Andrew can’t help himself from sharing we’re fun and so in character. His lack of pop culture and social media made perfect sense for someone who’s spent their career studying a Victorian detective. The representation is organic and perfect. (Andrew may not understand being non-binary, but he respects the person.)
It’s sweet, sexy, and will give you all the feels. And I really want Dracula Holmes to be a thing.
Read this. You’ll love it. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
The story begins with Sherlock scholar Andrew Thomas on his way to be fired from his university lecturer job. He collides with adorable Matthew Lewis, scattering his leaflets everywhere “I like theater,” he blurts, and after some brief flirting heads to his doom. Andrew is a hot mess, but I loved him.
They meet again that night when Andrew saves Matthew from a beating, taking a head-but and calling for help.
Oh, and introverted Andrew sees Sherlock Holmes, who is ready to help him with his case. And he has cancer. And doesn’t really want to be gay after seeing Matt being beaten. His best friend Mina (shades of Dr. Watson) has the best responses, reminding him, as only someone who loves you can, no one likes him anyway.
Matt is a charming, soap opera actor with mega wealthy and famous parents. And prone to anxiety attacks. His flat mate Bev is a wonder. Everyone needs a Bev in their lives.
Andrew and Matt are good together, but Andrew infuriatingly doesn’t feel he deserves nice things and blows it. Leaving sweet cinnamon roll Matt heartbroken.
It takes Holmes, Elton John, and a city bus for him to see the error of his ways. And all of their friends to help get them back together. In the most public declaration, which does wonders for his social anxiety, Andrew admits his feelings and starts his HEA.
I love a good mystery and the Holmes facts Andrew can’t help himself from sharing we’re fun and so in character. His lack of pop culture and social media made perfect sense for someone who’s spent their career studying a Victorian detective. The representation is organic and perfect. (Andrew may not understand being non-binary, but he respects the person.)
It’s sweet, sexy, and will give you all the feels. And I really want Dracula Holmes to be a thing.
Read this. You’ll love it. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
March 31, 2023
I’ve been messaging with Yvonne about their book after reading the synopsis - a modern queer coming out story featuring Sherlock Holmes & Elton John (as hallucinations)?! Sign me up! They were kind enough to gift me a copy on the promise of an honest review AND that my review photo features Lady with their book! 😂 🐶
In short - I really liked this unique original story! There is a mystery and case, but not the who-done-it type mystery you’d normally assume. It’s a humanizing look at the adult LGBTQ+ experiences in life and love.
The writing style, humor, quips, and pacing kept me intrigued and entertained - it was a refreshing change from what I’ve been recently reading. There were great details sprinkled throughout about both London & Sherlock Holmes. I kept pausing to google more.
Andrew was a great, flawed, character - uncomfortable with himself yet humorous. Recoiling into himself as defense to keep others away… his life is going downhill FAST! The Sherlock Homes scholar was just let go from his job, has cancer, no friends (except one, Mina), divorced, and secretly gay. He fatefully meets Matt - and is drawn to him more than he’s ever experienced to anyone before. Matt’s a very lovable character, you just want to hug him - but is much deeper than he initially was presented. The charter building was top notch.
I would have loved to get to know Matt a little better, maybe get his POV. Also I wish we saw the relationship develop a little more slowly, but the instant-love/romance kinda worked for me. I’ve heard from the author that a sequel is in the works… so here’s to hoping. 🤞
It’s fade-to-black other than kissing.
Certain parts of this book is reminiscent of 𝙁𝙞𝙧𝙨𝙩 𝙏𝙞𝙢𝙚 𝙛𝙤𝙧 𝙀𝙫𝙚𝙧𝙮𝙩𝙝𝙞𝙣𝙜 by Henry Fry - but only brief moments made me think of FTFE, the rest is totally original.
Pickup this book if you’re looking for an original unique story of self-acceptance, adult coming out, age gap romance, or just interested in Sherlock
Holmes.
In short - I really liked this unique original story! There is a mystery and case, but not the who-done-it type mystery you’d normally assume. It’s a humanizing look at the adult LGBTQ+ experiences in life and love.
The writing style, humor, quips, and pacing kept me intrigued and entertained - it was a refreshing change from what I’ve been recently reading. There were great details sprinkled throughout about both London & Sherlock Holmes. I kept pausing to google more.
Andrew was a great, flawed, character - uncomfortable with himself yet humorous. Recoiling into himself as defense to keep others away… his life is going downhill FAST! The Sherlock Homes scholar was just let go from his job, has cancer, no friends (except one, Mina), divorced, and secretly gay. He fatefully meets Matt - and is drawn to him more than he’s ever experienced to anyone before. Matt’s a very lovable character, you just want to hug him - but is much deeper than he initially was presented. The charter building was top notch.
I would have loved to get to know Matt a little better, maybe get his POV. Also I wish we saw the relationship develop a little more slowly, but the instant-love/romance kinda worked for me. I’ve heard from the author that a sequel is in the works… so here’s to hoping. 🤞
It’s fade-to-black other than kissing.
Certain parts of this book is reminiscent of 𝙁𝙞𝙧𝙨𝙩 𝙏𝙞𝙢𝙚 𝙛𝙤𝙧 𝙀𝙫𝙚𝙧𝙮𝙩𝙝𝙞𝙣𝙜 by Henry Fry - but only brief moments made me think of FTFE, the rest is totally original.
Pickup this book if you’re looking for an original unique story of self-acceptance, adult coming out, age gap romance, or just interested in Sherlock
Holmes.
March 16, 2023
Thank you so much to Yvonne for letting me read your book a little bit early to review! I loved it! It’s so well written and full of amazing characters, dialogue, & excellent pacing!
Andrew is a man who has pretty much given up. He has cancer, he just got fired from his job at the university, & he’s struggling with being gay. All he knows is Sherlock Holmes and being socially anxious. After he meets a beautiful stranger on the streets named Matt and then later saves his life after a homophobic beating, he thinks he might be in love. It’s then that the great detective Sherlock Holmes appears to convince Andrew to solve the case of his miserable life. Andrew thinks he’s gone mad, but decides to follow Sherlock while the game is afoot.
Even though I’ve only ever seen the Robert Downey Jr movies and haven’t really consumed much Sherlock media or stories, I really enjoyed this book. Yvonne goes into great detail about the cases and history of Sherlock and Watson so you don’t feel left out if you’re not used to the lore. I loved how passionate Andrew was about Sherlock.
I also absolutely loved like every character here. Matt’s friends were colorful and delightful. I wish I had a friend group like this. Mina was also adorable and I’m glad Andrew had her to fall back on. She was so sweet. I have no idea how I’d react to being around Liz & Bev but they were both so awesome I would have wanted to party with them. I’m glad Andrew had so many people in his corner, even if he didn’t realize it at first. I understand a lot where Andrew was coming from with his anxiety to trusting people and being in love. I can unfortunately relate a lot to that. The big ending scene almost had me crying. Such a great way to finish off this story.
I hope this book reaches fans of LGBTQA+ stories as well as fans of Sherlock and similar media. I really applaud Yvonne for their debut. Thank you again!
Andrew is a man who has pretty much given up. He has cancer, he just got fired from his job at the university, & he’s struggling with being gay. All he knows is Sherlock Holmes and being socially anxious. After he meets a beautiful stranger on the streets named Matt and then later saves his life after a homophobic beating, he thinks he might be in love. It’s then that the great detective Sherlock Holmes appears to convince Andrew to solve the case of his miserable life. Andrew thinks he’s gone mad, but decides to follow Sherlock while the game is afoot.
Even though I’ve only ever seen the Robert Downey Jr movies and haven’t really consumed much Sherlock media or stories, I really enjoyed this book. Yvonne goes into great detail about the cases and history of Sherlock and Watson so you don’t feel left out if you’re not used to the lore. I loved how passionate Andrew was about Sherlock.
I also absolutely loved like every character here. Matt’s friends were colorful and delightful. I wish I had a friend group like this. Mina was also adorable and I’m glad Andrew had her to fall back on. She was so sweet. I have no idea how I’d react to being around Liz & Bev but they were both so awesome I would have wanted to party with them. I’m glad Andrew had so many people in his corner, even if he didn’t realize it at first. I understand a lot where Andrew was coming from with his anxiety to trusting people and being in love. I can unfortunately relate a lot to that. The big ending scene almost had me crying. Such a great way to finish off this story.
I hope this book reaches fans of LGBTQA+ stories as well as fans of Sherlock and similar media. I really applaud Yvonne for their debut. Thank you again!
March 19, 2023
Was lucky enough to read this from the early stages - and it was such an intriguing read.
Despite my first impression I really came round to love the main character, especially for his relatable struggles. After all we meet him in a really grim situation: after learning he has cancer, losing his job and struggling with coming to terms with his sexuality , the outlook does not seem all too easy. But don't worry, as luckily Sherlock Holmes arrives in time to solve the case of Andrew (our mc)!
And in the end, wouldnt we all benefit from talking to Sherlock Holmes from time to time!? This book has wonderful London scenery, lovable characters (Mina, my gal!) and an inspiring coming out story - definitely recommend.
The author nailed a great mix between emotional and hilarious dialogue, they made a wonderful debut with this book!
Merged review:
Was lucky enough to read this from the early stages - and it was such an intriguing read. Despite my first impression I really came round to love the main character, especially for his relatable struggles. After all we meet him in a really grim situation, after learning he has cancer and losing his job struggling with coming to terms with his sexuality, the outlook seems not too easy. But don't worry, as luckily Sherlock Holmes arrives in time to solve the case of Andrew (our mc)! And in the end, wouldnt we all benefit from talking to Sherlock Holmes from time to time!? This book has wonderful London scenery, lovable characters (Mina, my gal!) and an inspiring coming out story - definitely recommend.
The author nailed a great mix between emotional and hilarious dialogue, they made a wonderful debut with this book!
Despite my first impression I really came round to love the main character, especially for his relatable struggles. After all we meet him in a really grim situation: after learning he has cancer, losing his job and struggling with coming to terms with his sexuality , the outlook does not seem all too easy. But don't worry, as luckily Sherlock Holmes arrives in time to solve the case of Andrew (our mc)!
And in the end, wouldnt we all benefit from talking to Sherlock Holmes from time to time!? This book has wonderful London scenery, lovable characters (Mina, my gal!) and an inspiring coming out story - definitely recommend.
The author nailed a great mix between emotional and hilarious dialogue, they made a wonderful debut with this book!
Merged review:
Was lucky enough to read this from the early stages - and it was such an intriguing read. Despite my first impression I really came round to love the main character, especially for his relatable struggles. After all we meet him in a really grim situation, after learning he has cancer and losing his job struggling with coming to terms with his sexuality, the outlook seems not too easy. But don't worry, as luckily Sherlock Holmes arrives in time to solve the case of Andrew (our mc)! And in the end, wouldnt we all benefit from talking to Sherlock Holmes from time to time!? This book has wonderful London scenery, lovable characters (Mina, my gal!) and an inspiring coming out story - definitely recommend.
The author nailed a great mix between emotional and hilarious dialogue, they made a wonderful debut with this book!
May 21, 2023
"Without you, I would only be
a figure pressed between yellowed pages."
📚
If you are Sherlocked like me, you will love this book! It's queer and sweet and relatable and sad and uplifting, everything you'd want from a book, and a bonus: character who is obsessed with Sherlock Holmes.
My whole life I was only once attending a party, I wasn't having fun because it wasn't my thing, but I found a bookshelf and while I was browsing I noticed Arthur Conan Doyle section and spent the whole evening reading in that room, that's when my obsession started.
I am obsessed with everything Sherlock Holmes too, not on the same level as main character, Andrew, but I've read and watched most of the books and shows/movies about him and can never have enough!
I'm just like the MC, I'd rather avoid all interactions altogether and read at home.
"Introverts have rechargeable batteries and
mine is empty." He was exactly describing me when he said that about himself.
And the found family 🥹 the best queer found family! They all were so different and so loving and supportive, I wished I had that too.
And the love interest is the cutest cat dad who deserves everything best and I would hug him if I could.
I devoured this book and left no crumbs, I even loved the acknowledgement section, especially the last part 🥹
This book is a little bit madness, little bit awkwardness and a whole lot of captivating and lovable story with diverse cast of characters and a cat named Hercules!(I love that cat!)
Also while Andrew was thinking about writing a book, I got so excited, he was right, Dracula Holmes is definitely a bestseller material, I'd read that.
I loved this book and will definitely reread again, and will look forward to new books from the author 🥰
a figure pressed between yellowed pages."
📚
If you are Sherlocked like me, you will love this book! It's queer and sweet and relatable and sad and uplifting, everything you'd want from a book, and a bonus: character who is obsessed with Sherlock Holmes.
My whole life I was only once attending a party, I wasn't having fun because it wasn't my thing, but I found a bookshelf and while I was browsing I noticed Arthur Conan Doyle section and spent the whole evening reading in that room, that's when my obsession started.
I am obsessed with everything Sherlock Holmes too, not on the same level as main character, Andrew, but I've read and watched most of the books and shows/movies about him and can never have enough!
I'm just like the MC, I'd rather avoid all interactions altogether and read at home.
"Introverts have rechargeable batteries and
mine is empty." He was exactly describing me when he said that about himself.
And the found family 🥹 the best queer found family! They all were so different and so loving and supportive, I wished I had that too.
And the love interest is the cutest cat dad who deserves everything best and I would hug him if I could.
I devoured this book and left no crumbs, I even loved the acknowledgement section, especially the last part 🥹
This book is a little bit madness, little bit awkwardness and a whole lot of captivating and lovable story with diverse cast of characters and a cat named Hercules!(I love that cat!)
Also while Andrew was thinking about writing a book, I got so excited, he was right, Dracula Holmes is definitely a bestseller material, I'd read that.
I loved this book and will definitely reread again, and will look forward to new books from the author 🥰
March 23, 2023
(4.25)
thank you to improbable press and netgalley for providing me with a free digital arc of this book. i am leaving this review voluntarily and all opinions are my own.
"it's weird how quickly one person can change everything. what a lovely and inconvenient coincidence it was to meet him."
this book has made me feel it all—sadness, hope, joy, love. with a case of madness yvonne knop has managed to craft a story that seamlessly weaves together the sadness and hoplessness the main character faces with the joys life has to offer. the attention paid to each and every detail of andrew's character and the way he experiences not only the world but his own emotions is incredibly unique, and it was a delight to follow him through the ups and downs of his life.
the queerness in this book made me tear up more often than i'd like to admit. while there are more and more queer books being published, it is rare to find ones featuring older characters. andrew proves that no, you don't have to have everything figured out and it's never too late to be your true, honest self. his conversation with sherlock holmes, whose appearances and commentary i absolutely adored, about having to face death without dying will for sure stick with me for a long time.
if you're looking for a queer romcom with endearing characters and aren't scared of conversing with a fictional detective that suddenly appeared in your living room, this book is for you.
a love letter to being queer and to being alive.
thank you to improbable press and netgalley for providing me with a free digital arc of this book. i am leaving this review voluntarily and all opinions are my own.
"it's weird how quickly one person can change everything. what a lovely and inconvenient coincidence it was to meet him."
this book has made me feel it all—sadness, hope, joy, love. with a case of madness yvonne knop has managed to craft a story that seamlessly weaves together the sadness and hoplessness the main character faces with the joys life has to offer. the attention paid to each and every detail of andrew's character and the way he experiences not only the world but his own emotions is incredibly unique, and it was a delight to follow him through the ups and downs of his life.
the queerness in this book made me tear up more often than i'd like to admit. while there are more and more queer books being published, it is rare to find ones featuring older characters. andrew proves that no, you don't have to have everything figured out and it's never too late to be your true, honest self. his conversation with sherlock holmes, whose appearances and commentary i absolutely adored, about having to face death without dying will for sure stick with me for a long time.
if you're looking for a queer romcom with endearing characters and aren't scared of conversing with a fictional detective that suddenly appeared in your living room, this book is for you.
a love letter to being queer and to being alive.
April 11, 2023
2 / 5 ⭐️‘s
"A Case of Madness" by Yvonne Knop
This one wasn't for me. While the book's synopsis promised an intriguing plot with elements of mystery and romance, I found myself struggling to connect with the story due to the heavy reliance on the hallucination of Sherlock Holmes.
As a self-proclaimed Sherlock Holmes scholar, Andrew Thomas, the protagonist, is depicted as a complex character with a slew of challenges including being unemployed, battling cancer, and struggling with his sexual orientation. However, when Holmes appears in Andrew's life as a hallucination, claiming to be in love with a man he just met, the story takes a bizarre turn.
The concept of chasing a fictional character through London with his own Watson could have been an interesting twist on the classic Sherlock Holmes narrative, but it didn't resonate with ME. The constant blurring of reality and hallucination left me feeling disconnected from the story, and I found it difficult to fully immerse myself in Andrew's journey.
The book's writing style was well-crafted, and the author's creativity in weaving together elements of mystery and romance was commendable. However, the overarching theme of Andrew's obsession with a hallucinatory version of Sherlock Holmes didn't resonate with my personal reading preferences.
While this may appeal to readers who enjoy unconventional narratives and are fans of the Sherlock Holmes idea, it ultimately wasn't a book that I vibed with.
This ARC audiobook was provided by @Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.
"A Case of Madness" by Yvonne Knop
This one wasn't for me. While the book's synopsis promised an intriguing plot with elements of mystery and romance, I found myself struggling to connect with the story due to the heavy reliance on the hallucination of Sherlock Holmes.
As a self-proclaimed Sherlock Holmes scholar, Andrew Thomas, the protagonist, is depicted as a complex character with a slew of challenges including being unemployed, battling cancer, and struggling with his sexual orientation. However, when Holmes appears in Andrew's life as a hallucination, claiming to be in love with a man he just met, the story takes a bizarre turn.
The concept of chasing a fictional character through London with his own Watson could have been an interesting twist on the classic Sherlock Holmes narrative, but it didn't resonate with ME. The constant blurring of reality and hallucination left me feeling disconnected from the story, and I found it difficult to fully immerse myself in Andrew's journey.
The book's writing style was well-crafted, and the author's creativity in weaving together elements of mystery and romance was commendable. However, the overarching theme of Andrew's obsession with a hallucinatory version of Sherlock Holmes didn't resonate with my personal reading preferences.
While this may appeal to readers who enjoy unconventional narratives and are fans of the Sherlock Holmes idea, it ultimately wasn't a book that I vibed with.
This ARC audiobook was provided by @Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.
April 30, 2023
To preface this review, Sherlock Holmes and his cases have always been a favorite read for me. I read about Holmes and Watson's adventures regularly.
That being said I fell in love with this book at the very beginning. Knop's writing is reminiscent of the classic Sherlock Homes stories by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. I enjoyed reading snippets and facts about Holmes throughout this story. The cast of characters were very fitting to the story, with the side characters as equally well developed. The story is told from a single POV, but you get a good sense of each one's personality. This book touches on some heavy topics in the LGBTQIA+ community. The Most important one for me though is learning to be one's true self. I was skeptical at first about a queer love story featuring Sherlock Holmes, but as I got a feel for Knop's style in the first two chapters I was hooked. In my opinion they did a great job with this story, it's inclusive to the whole community, and I look forward to rereading this, and other works from them in the future.
We meet Sherlock Holmes expert, Andrew Thomas, at a point where his life is falling apart. When things couldn't get any worse he starts to have hallucinations of Sherlock Holmes. With Holmes' help Andrew learns how to be his true self. With the help of his best friends, both real and fictional can Andrew solve his case before it's too late?
I loved this quote:
"Why is it you're so ashamed of who you are when you seem to care so little about the opinions of others?"
That being said I fell in love with this book at the very beginning. Knop's writing is reminiscent of the classic Sherlock Homes stories by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. I enjoyed reading snippets and facts about Holmes throughout this story. The cast of characters were very fitting to the story, with the side characters as equally well developed. The story is told from a single POV, but you get a good sense of each one's personality. This book touches on some heavy topics in the LGBTQIA+ community. The Most important one for me though is learning to be one's true self. I was skeptical at first about a queer love story featuring Sherlock Holmes, but as I got a feel for Knop's style in the first two chapters I was hooked. In my opinion they did a great job with this story, it's inclusive to the whole community, and I look forward to rereading this, and other works from them in the future.
We meet Sherlock Holmes expert, Andrew Thomas, at a point where his life is falling apart. When things couldn't get any worse he starts to have hallucinations of Sherlock Holmes. With Holmes' help Andrew learns how to be his true self. With the help of his best friends, both real and fictional can Andrew solve his case before it's too late?
I loved this quote:
"Why is it you're so ashamed of who you are when you seem to care so little about the opinions of others?"
Want to read
April 5, 20234.5⭐️
“People like you keep me alive. Without you, I would only be a figure pressed between yellowed pages. I owe you my life.”
CW: Suicidal thoughts, homophobia, hate crimes, terminal illness, addiction
This book is so many things wrapped into one. It’s a book for Holmes lovers, it’s a romance, it’s a ghost story, its heavy, and it’s about becoming your true self. The characters were rich and well developed. The plot was easy to follow while also being surprising and intriguing. I truly enjoyed reading this.
We meet Andrew during a mid-life crisis, when absolutely everything is going wrong. But Sherlock Holmes shows up to help him solve the case of himself.
I enjoyed that even the side characters were well developed. Despite the book only being from Andrews pov, you still get a really strong sense of all the cast. I really enjoyed the plot too: the mystery of the note, the romance subplot, and everything that Andrew deals with. If you’re wondering, the romance came into play heavily about 40% in.
I did find the dialogue hard to follow at times, it felt like I just didn’t understand the discussion, but for most of the novel this wasn’t an issue.
Overall, if you enjoy Speculative Fiction, coming of age, a mid-life crisis, or romance sub-plots, I think you should give this book a try!
Thank you to NetGalley, Improbable Press, and Yvonne Knop for this eARC in exchange for an honest review.
“People like you keep me alive. Without you, I would only be a figure pressed between yellowed pages. I owe you my life.”
CW: Suicidal thoughts, homophobia, hate crimes, terminal illness, addiction
This book is so many things wrapped into one. It’s a book for Holmes lovers, it’s a romance, it’s a ghost story, its heavy, and it’s about becoming your true self. The characters were rich and well developed. The plot was easy to follow while also being surprising and intriguing. I truly enjoyed reading this.
We meet Andrew during a mid-life crisis, when absolutely everything is going wrong. But Sherlock Holmes shows up to help him solve the case of himself.
I enjoyed that even the side characters were well developed. Despite the book only being from Andrews pov, you still get a really strong sense of all the cast. I really enjoyed the plot too: the mystery of the note, the romance subplot, and everything that Andrew deals with. If you’re wondering, the romance came into play heavily about 40% in.
I did find the dialogue hard to follow at times, it felt like I just didn’t understand the discussion, but for most of the novel this wasn’t an issue.
Overall, if you enjoy Speculative Fiction, coming of age, a mid-life crisis, or romance sub-plots, I think you should give this book a try!
Thank you to NetGalley, Improbable Press, and Yvonne Knop for this eARC in exchange for an honest review.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 89 reviews