The coming of modern historical research had religious consequences, especially in the more traditional churches to which history was very important and which themselves helped to create the historical sense. In this classic work, long unobtainable but now revised with a new introduction, Owen Chadwick traces the development of the notion that change in Christian doctrine was both possible and legitimate. Bossuet in the seventeenth century represented the opinion that Christian doctrine never or hardly Newman in the second half of the nineteenth century saw that its expression necessarily changed in a changing society. This book shows how one opinion changed into the other, and explains the difficulties and tensions behind Newman's attempt to persuade an inherently conservative institution to face reality. In so doing it thus illuminates one vital aspect of the arrival into European thought of a distinct historical sensibility.
William Owen Chadwick, OM, KBE, FBA, FRSE, was a British Anglican clergyman, academic, writer and prominent historian of Christianity. He was also a rugby union player. He was Master of Selwyn College, Cambridge, from 1956 to 1983, Dixie Professor of Ecclesiastical History from 1958 to 1968, and Regius Professor of History from 1968 to 1983.
A great book on church history detailing how the Roman Church's understanding of the relation between revelation, tradition and doctrine, changed from the Post-Tridentine polemics of Bosseut to Newman's theory of doctrinal development, a change necessitated by the new historical criticism which arose in the 19th century showing that the present doctrines of the Roman Church simply could not be identified with the teachings of the apostolic church. Before the Roman Church stridently insisted that everything they taught were either explicitly known to the apostles or could be logically deduced from their own teachings. Later churches could not possibly have a deeper, better, or even more "developed" understanding of the faith than the apostles themselves. Unto the apostles have been committed the fullness of revelation, the task of the Church was to pass down and translate that revelation, not expand, deepen or supplant it with deeper reflections. Newman's innovation consists of arguing that new doctrinal propositions could arise not only from logical deductions or mere translation of already known propositions, but by reflection by the Church upon some "wordless" sense of revelation committed to the apostles. In effect, we can come to realise more propositions than what the apostles themselves knew.
Overall an interesting book and quite revelatory of how much the Roman Church has changed, and adapted, since its initial polemics against Protestantism for "deviating" from tradition.