What do you think?
Rate this book
The Soul Mark Duology #1
The Soul Mark
Nineteen-year-old Sela is a murderer.
After being sentenced to death for the accidental killing of a wealthy, well-connected man, Sela Meriweather is offered another option—to be stripped of her soul and sentenced to lifetime exile on Azazel, the vast prison-island. There, alongside "dangerous" criminals like herself, firstborn children of the Old Town chosen by the lot are sent to atone for the sins of their families.
As one of the elected Righteous, Caleb Alexander's path to widespread renown is guaranteed so long as he can endure a year as an overseer on Azazel, preventing the other guards from fraternizing with the prisoners. But as he finds himself drawn to Sela, Caleb wrestles with the implications of his new role and the laws forbidding contact between jailer and prisoner. Could a woman like Sela truly be soulless?
While Caleb tries to resist his growing attraction, Sela struggles with the weight of her sins and the past she has kept from Caleb. But when mutiny against the Old Town brews on Azazel, Sela and Caleb must work together to stay alive...and to uncover the truth behind the very powers that created Azazel in the first place.
After being sentenced to death for the accidental killing of a wealthy, well-connected man, Sela Meriweather is offered another option—to be stripped of her soul and sentenced to lifetime exile on Azazel, the vast prison-island. There, alongside "dangerous" criminals like herself, firstborn children of the Old Town chosen by the lot are sent to atone for the sins of their families.
As one of the elected Righteous, Caleb Alexander's path to widespread renown is guaranteed so long as he can endure a year as an overseer on Azazel, preventing the other guards from fraternizing with the prisoners. But as he finds himself drawn to Sela, Caleb wrestles with the implications of his new role and the laws forbidding contact between jailer and prisoner. Could a woman like Sela truly be soulless?
While Caleb tries to resist his growing attraction, Sela struggles with the weight of her sins and the past she has kept from Caleb. But when mutiny against the Old Town brews on Azazel, Sela and Caleb must work together to stay alive...and to uncover the truth behind the very powers that created Azazel in the first place.
425 pages, Kindle Edition
Published May 15, 2023
12 people are currently reading
342 people want to read
About the author
J.J. Fischer
13 books288 followersJasmine’s writing dream began with the anthology of zoo animals she painstakingly wrote and illustrated at age five, to rather limited acclaim. Thankfully, her writing (but not her drawing) has improved since then. She is a clinically-trained psychologist but no, she cannot read your mind. When she isn’t killing defenseless house plants, Jasmine enjoys devouring books, dabbling in floristry, playing the piano, eating peanut butter out of the jar, and wishing it rained more often. Jasmine is married to David, and together they make their home a couple of hours’ north of Sydney, Australia, where they live to satisfy the every whim of their ginger overlord cat, Simba.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 39 reviews
June 5, 2024
I think this would have been 5 stars, but I wasn't invested in the romance for some reason and that's a big thing for me. Also one of my favorite characters 😭💔💔
And the cliffhanger 😭😭😭😭😭
And the cliffhanger 😭😭😭😭😭
June 15, 2024
WHAT. THE ENDING. WHAAAAT?!!!!!!!
December 9, 2025
3.5⭐️, rounded down as it took me more than halfway into the book to feel invested. Also, the unfamiliar old-time words and the made-up words were a distraction.
However, Fischer’s ability to draw deep and nuanced characters drew this character-driven reader in once again.
I am glad I have book 2 waiting in my kindle! Whew! What an ending!😬
Expecting book 2 to be higher rated since I am already invested.🥰 And I cannot wait for more of Prince Magnus!🤩
However, Fischer’s ability to draw deep and nuanced characters drew this character-driven reader in once again.
I am glad I have book 2 waiting in my kindle! Whew! What an ending!😬
Expecting book 2 to be higher rated since I am already invested.🥰 And I cannot wait for more of Prince Magnus!🤩
April 30, 2023
This book hooked me instantly and didn’t let me go! I absolutely adore the characters—so much depth and personality. Both the physical and internal action and arc of this story are so well written and deeply true.
I HUGELY recommend this story and this author. I didn’t want this book to end, and now I’m going to be desperately waiting for when the sequel comes out!
Fantastic read, all round.
(NOTE: I received a complimentary e-copy from the author and was not required to write a positive review. All opinions expressed are my own.)
I HUGELY recommend this story and this author. I didn’t want this book to end, and now I’m going to be desperately waiting for when the sequel comes out!
Fantastic read, all round.
(NOTE: I received a complimentary e-copy from the author and was not required to write a positive review. All opinions expressed are my own.)
April 11, 2023
I have to admit it took me a minute to get into this one but once I was in I was done for.
The romance is perfection. The stakes are high. My heart is so broken.
I wouldn't call this a pirate book but it is full of gunslinging, sword wielding baddies.
I've never read a book that so perfectly shows the failure and evil that is man corrupted religion while still perfectly showing that God is completely separate to that in every way. He is good, loving, merciful, just and full of grace.
The romance is perfection. The stakes are high. My heart is so broken.
I wouldn't call this a pirate book but it is full of gunslinging, sword wielding baddies.
I've never read a book that so perfectly shows the failure and evil that is man corrupted religion while still perfectly showing that God is completely separate to that in every way. He is good, loving, merciful, just and full of grace.
March 18, 2025
This book blew me away!! It deserves more than five stars, no joke! Seriously so good, I'm almost speechless! 😉
From the start, there's excitement and action. Immediately dropping you into the story and you won't get back out until the story is done, and trust me you won't want to. At first I was a little confused as I got my bearings and could grasp the story, but once I did I was hooked!
You meet a bunch of characters, and there is three total POV's with it mostly being from Sela's perspective. The other two are from Caleb the MMC and love interest and Leeran her older brother. She has so much sadness, hurt, anger, and doubt in The Carver (which is Representative of Jesus in this world). She goes through so much in this story but also grows as well.
I loved Sela's character she is brave, strong, so loving and caring. She cares for those no one else would and fights for the helpless. Wrongs are committed against her, but she grows stronger from it, she sees the underlying good. Selfless to the core, she would sacrfice herself in a heart beat if it meant saving someone she loves. She even by the end comes to see the truth of The Carver, at least partially. I think she still has some learning to do but she trusts Him and believes He can be merciful.
Caleb is part of the righteous(more on that in a bit), he is supposed to be her enemie, and their love is forbidden. But he can't stop protecting her, and he's such a great guy. He's kind, strong, and wants to do what's right. In this story he learns of his world's corrupt thinking and though he thought he was on the right side, he comes to the realization that maybe they aren't as good and moral as he has believed. He loves Sela from the beginning and gives her so many kindnesses and constantly seeks her out despite it being against the rules.
Their romance is sweet and wholesome, full of saving each other, and helping the other to grow.
The world building! My goodness she did such an amazing job! Not only in the descriptions of the world which is very well detailed, but in how the world works. There is two main settings in the book, the Old Town, and Azazel. Even the government, and world system it was all so interesting! There are the Righteous as I mentioned before, they pretty much run the place, and tell everyone else about The Carver and His will and what they are supposed to do. And in this world the first born child once they've reached the age of eighteen go into a lot to determine if they are souless or not. One child is picked each year by the Righteous, branded on the hand, and exhiled to Azazel. There is more to it but you'll just have to read to find out 😉
But all of that to say that this story covers messages about mercy, forgiveness, false prophets, truth. The characters discover that The Carver (Jesus) does not consider them any less worthy because they are branded, He does not make them souless. He loves them, cares for them, and does have true mercy not what they are taught is His mercy. I cannot put into words how well this was done and how ingrained in the story it was. Seriously it was amazing, such beautiful messages, and an amazing story!
This book was one thing after another, plot twists everywhere, excitement, romance, and things bigger than any of them happening, there's more to be learned in the next book. And I can't wait! This is a new favorite and a must read in my opinion!
Content: No-Spice/kisses only, no swearing, attempted rape(nothing happens), death, murder, violence, branding of people(process isn't described), prostitutes, suggestive comments, a side character has an abusive husband(only aftermath bruises are described), wounds, a character gets whipped on the back, (nothing is gory or graphic).
From the start, there's excitement and action. Immediately dropping you into the story and you won't get back out until the story is done, and trust me you won't want to. At first I was a little confused as I got my bearings and could grasp the story, but once I did I was hooked!
You meet a bunch of characters, and there is three total POV's with it mostly being from Sela's perspective. The other two are from Caleb the MMC and love interest and Leeran her older brother. She has so much sadness, hurt, anger, and doubt in The Carver (which is Representative of Jesus in this world). She goes through so much in this story but also grows as well.
I loved Sela's character she is brave, strong, so loving and caring. She cares for those no one else would and fights for the helpless. Wrongs are committed against her, but she grows stronger from it, she sees the underlying good. Selfless to the core, she would sacrfice herself in a heart beat if it meant saving someone she loves. She even by the end comes to see the truth of The Carver, at least partially. I think she still has some learning to do but she trusts Him and believes He can be merciful.
Caleb is part of the righteous(more on that in a bit), he is supposed to be her enemie, and their love is forbidden. But he can't stop protecting her, and he's such a great guy. He's kind, strong, and wants to do what's right. In this story he learns of his world's corrupt thinking and though he thought he was on the right side, he comes to the realization that maybe they aren't as good and moral as he has believed. He loves Sela from the beginning and gives her so many kindnesses and constantly seeks her out despite it being against the rules.
Their romance is sweet and wholesome, full of saving each other, and helping the other to grow.
The world building! My goodness she did such an amazing job! Not only in the descriptions of the world which is very well detailed, but in how the world works. There is two main settings in the book, the Old Town, and Azazel. Even the government, and world system it was all so interesting! There are the Righteous as I mentioned before, they pretty much run the place, and tell everyone else about The Carver and His will and what they are supposed to do. And in this world the first born child once they've reached the age of eighteen go into a lot to determine if they are souless or not. One child is picked each year by the Righteous, branded on the hand, and exhiled to Azazel. There is more to it but you'll just have to read to find out 😉
But all of that to say that this story covers messages about mercy, forgiveness, false prophets, truth. The characters discover that The Carver (Jesus) does not consider them any less worthy because they are branded, He does not make them souless. He loves them, cares for them, and does have true mercy not what they are taught is His mercy. I cannot put into words how well this was done and how ingrained in the story it was. Seriously it was amazing, such beautiful messages, and an amazing story!
This book was one thing after another, plot twists everywhere, excitement, romance, and things bigger than any of them happening, there's more to be learned in the next book. And I can't wait! This is a new favorite and a must read in my opinion!
Content: No-Spice/kisses only, no swearing, attempted rape(nothing happens), death, murder, violence, branding of people(process isn't described), prostitutes, suggestive comments, a side character has an abusive husband(only aftermath bruises are described), wounds, a character gets whipped on the back, (nothing is gory or graphic).
May 12, 2023
I’m sorry, but cliffhangers should be illegal if the next book isn’t ready to be released asap. This book hooked me from page one and I could not put it down! My head is still trying to wrap itself around how this book ended and honestly I am not okay. I really want certain characters to die and I really need certain characters to get all kick butt.
The Soul Mark was an exciting book with so much allegory woven throughout this story. I loved it so, so much!! I really cannot wait for the next book to see how far the allegory will go with another character who we just got introduced to! The world building and plot to this book were so unique and I loved how Mrs. Fischer wrote it! Caleb and Sela were honestly such great characters and I loved getting to see them grow and develop individually and together. Ugh, I don’t even have words to describe my love for them!!
This book was just so good and exactly what I needed to kick start my summer reading after finishing school. I cannot wait for the second book…like I literally need it right now!! So GOOD!
*FTC: I received a copy of this book from the author in exchange for my honest opinion. All thoughts are my own. I was NOT required to write a positive review.*
The Soul Mark was an exciting book with so much allegory woven throughout this story. I loved it so, so much!! I really cannot wait for the next book to see how far the allegory will go with another character who we just got introduced to! The world building and plot to this book were so unique and I loved how Mrs. Fischer wrote it! Caleb and Sela were honestly such great characters and I loved getting to see them grow and develop individually and together. Ugh, I don’t even have words to describe my love for them!!
This book was just so good and exactly what I needed to kick start my summer reading after finishing school. I cannot wait for the second book…like I literally need it right now!! So GOOD!
*FTC: I received a copy of this book from the author in exchange for my honest opinion. All thoughts are my own. I was NOT required to write a positive review.*
May 16, 2023
Soul Mark is the second of JJ Fisher's books I've read, and I had high expectations when I received it to pre-view before release day.
It was everything I hoped for. Though it's hard to tell anymore than the description already has without giving away some of the story, I can say the character growth of both Sela and Caleb once the arrived on the island made me cheer. Especially Caleb as he came to grips with the truth of what was really happening around him and then started to question the convictions he'd been conditioned to believe.
For me, this story paints a strong allegory of one Christian denomination, however, we are all guilty of many of the assumptions and behaviors highlighted so clearly in this story. Ms. Fischer does an excellent job of reminding us all that the mercy of our God is so much larger than we humans allow for.
I look forward to the next book!
It was everything I hoped for. Though it's hard to tell anymore than the description already has without giving away some of the story, I can say the character growth of both Sela and Caleb once the arrived on the island made me cheer. Especially Caleb as he came to grips with the truth of what was really happening around him and then started to question the convictions he'd been conditioned to believe.
For me, this story paints a strong allegory of one Christian denomination, however, we are all guilty of many of the assumptions and behaviors highlighted so clearly in this story. Ms. Fischer does an excellent job of reminding us all that the mercy of our God is so much larger than we humans allow for.
I look forward to the next book!
May 30, 2023
You’d never imagine that phrases “pirate infested”, “dystopian”, “steamy romance” and “anti-religion-pro-God” could all describe the one novel, but indeed they do!
This book is gripping till the last page and is filled with elegant and thoughtful exchanges between characters.
And did I mention there is a fox?
I loved every second and I cannot wait until the next one!
This book is gripping till the last page and is filled with elegant and thoughtful exchanges between characters.
And did I mention there is a fox?
I loved every second and I cannot wait until the next one!
June 22, 2023
Surprise after Surpise!
After being sentenced to death for the accidental killing of a wealthy, well-connected man, Sela Meriweather is offered another option—to be stripped of her soul and sentenced to lifetime exile on Azazel, the vast prison island. There, alongside “dangerous” criminals like herself, firstborn children of the Old Town chosen by lot are sent to atone for the sins of their families.
When I started reading this novel, I thought I could plot its course—Hunger Games meets Tolkien. But I was wrong. J J Fischer turned the corner quickly, leading her characters into almost inescapable conflicts, setting the reader on edge. At times I thought the story had gone to a dead-end with no way out for the character, only to see the author find a rabbit trail out of it.
She also weaves the fantasy world with character passions very well, using excellent prose. For example, I love these kinds of sentences that bring the reader into the world and minds of the characters. “In the near dark, the tips of the waves already frothed and curled, the ship shuddering and groaning as it glided through a roiling, heaving mass of black. Rain spewed from a bloated sky, soaking her hair and gown, while a rogue wave smacked against the side of the ship and splattered her with icy salt spray.”
Ms. Fischer also weaves in Christian analogy into the story’s religion. The book is set in a society that has distorted the fundamentals of their religious belief. She raises the blood pressure of the reader, who would object to the distortion of truth and justice that the reader may feel as a Christian.
Regarding characters, Ms. Fischer creates strong male and female characters, gently balancing their virtues and flaws. She unpeels the onion exposing layers of traits that magnify themselves as circumstances change.
I highly recommend this, not only to fantasy fans but to romance and adventure readers. Well done!
I received a review copy courtesy of the author through Interviews & Reviews for an unbiased and objective review.
After being sentenced to death for the accidental killing of a wealthy, well-connected man, Sela Meriweather is offered another option—to be stripped of her soul and sentenced to lifetime exile on Azazel, the vast prison island. There, alongside “dangerous” criminals like herself, firstborn children of the Old Town chosen by lot are sent to atone for the sins of their families.
When I started reading this novel, I thought I could plot its course—Hunger Games meets Tolkien. But I was wrong. J J Fischer turned the corner quickly, leading her characters into almost inescapable conflicts, setting the reader on edge. At times I thought the story had gone to a dead-end with no way out for the character, only to see the author find a rabbit trail out of it.
She also weaves the fantasy world with character passions very well, using excellent prose. For example, I love these kinds of sentences that bring the reader into the world and minds of the characters. “In the near dark, the tips of the waves already frothed and curled, the ship shuddering and groaning as it glided through a roiling, heaving mass of black. Rain spewed from a bloated sky, soaking her hair and gown, while a rogue wave smacked against the side of the ship and splattered her with icy salt spray.”
Ms. Fischer also weaves in Christian analogy into the story’s religion. The book is set in a society that has distorted the fundamentals of their religious belief. She raises the blood pressure of the reader, who would object to the distortion of truth and justice that the reader may feel as a Christian.
Regarding characters, Ms. Fischer creates strong male and female characters, gently balancing their virtues and flaws. She unpeels the onion exposing layers of traits that magnify themselves as circumstances change.
I highly recommend this, not only to fantasy fans but to romance and adventure readers. Well done!
I received a review copy courtesy of the author through Interviews & Reviews for an unbiased and objective review.
May 17, 2023
"Because I could not bear the thought of a future in which you were not living."
How can I put into words how much I loved this book?! 😍
From beginning to end, I was hooked. I literally forgot that I was reading.
The spiritual themes are so on point (I highlighted a lot), I loved the chemistry of Caleb and Sela (just when I thought Michael Hosea of Redeeming Love by Francine Rivers, is the perfect man, well, I am wrong), a bit slow paced but understandably, and all characters are well written!
My heart ached at the last few chapters! 😭
I need book 2 now!
Highly recommended!
Received a copy from the author but I am not required to leave a positive review.
I really enjoyed this book and I have now added it to my list of physical copies to buy.
How can I put into words how much I loved this book?! 😍
From beginning to end, I was hooked. I literally forgot that I was reading.
The spiritual themes are so on point (I highlighted a lot), I loved the chemistry of Caleb and Sela (just when I thought Michael Hosea of Redeeming Love by Francine Rivers, is the perfect man, well, I am wrong), a bit slow paced but understandably, and all characters are well written!
My heart ached at the last few chapters! 😭
I need book 2 now!
Highly recommended!
Received a copy from the author but I am not required to leave a positive review.
I really enjoyed this book and I have now added it to my list of physical copies to buy.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
February 11, 2024
So good! I’ve been in a pirate fantasy mood lately, and this checked all the right boxes. Sela and Caleb are adorable, and I’m so excited to see where their arcs lead. Just like Calor, The Soul Mark snatched my attention and didn’t let me go, and it left me wanting to stay in the story world even once I’d finished. Absolutely can’t wait for book two!!
~I received an early copy of this book from the author for launch purposes and was not required to leave a positive review.~
~I received an early copy of this book from the author for launch purposes and was not required to leave a positive review.~
July 26, 2024
The story was great, I just wish it hadn't ended before anything was resolved. Cliffhanger endings are a pet peeve of mine.
dnf
April 26, 2025Just not for me.
April 28, 2023
This book had a really intriguing premise! There was also a full cast of awesome characters, especially Sela and Caleb. Their romance was the best. Sela and Caleb were such a cute couple and I loved how perfect they were for each other.
The first half of the book moved a little slow for me, but once the second half hit, things really picked up. The ending also sets up the second book really well.
CW: there were a couple of times that men tried to take advantage of Sela and force their attentions on her; there is also a side character that gets physically abused. Nothing graphic for either of these things, but it is there.
The first half of the book moved a little slow for me, but once the second half hit, things really picked up. The ending also sets up the second book really well.
CW: there were a couple of times that men tried to take advantage of Sela and force their attentions on her; there is also a side character that gets physically abused. Nothing graphic for either of these things, but it is there.
August 6, 2023
The very frustrating, bitter sweet, cliff hanger ending of this book is making me feel a wide range of emotions right now. Book two can’t come out soon enough.
July 31, 2023
If you’re a fan of Pirates of the Caribbean, Laura Frantz, or C. S. Lewis (or all three), this book is right up your alley with its Colonial-era swashbuckling, sweet (and clean) romance, and rich, Christian allegory.
I don’t know where to start. The unique setting of a tropical paradise island turned hellish lifelong prison? The multi-layered romance of mutual attraction and misconceptions worthy of Jane Austen? The deep, thought-provoking themes of allegory that bring old truths into new light? The intricate plot with the perfect amount (and perfect timing) of twists, turns, and connections? (Oh, and what about the main character whose pet animal is a FOX?)
If these things don’t intrigue you yet, let me sing Fischer’s praises a little louder. I’m picky with romance and even pickier with allegory, but Fischer delivers both elements of this story with marvelous heights of skill, creativity, and thoughtfulness. In the romance, Sela and Caleb stand out as real people with real obstacles to a real relationship—facing fears, assumptions, and difficulties that any of us might face in our own pursuit of love. I delighted in the front-row seat to their heart journeys from strangers to reluctant confidants to—well, I won’t give everything away. :)
In the allegory, Fischer uses a tasteful mix of recognizable Bible content and original imagination, veering close enough to reality to give the story depth and power, while keeping enough distance to avoid literary heresy or bad writing. Truly, this allegory will touch the hearts of all readers as, no matter where we are in our spiritual walk, we seek to understand God’s mercy side-by-side with His justice, yield to His sovereign goodness over bad people and events, and ultimately find the worth of all our souls before Him.
My last word of praise for this book is that everything feels so real. Besides the spiritual truths that ARE real, the characters and places feel as authentic as my neighborhood on my morning walk. This authenticity is what pulls me into Fischer’s stories from page one, keeps me inside until the end, and brings me back for second and third (and more) reads. Even with the scary jungle nights and the villains like Uriah Smith, I want to live in the world of The Soul Mark—a world whose story, in and through the struggles and messes, promises beauty, love, freedom, and redemption.
The beginning captivated me with a premise like The Hunger Games’ Reaping with spiritual overtones. The chapters that followed carried me on the irresistible current of good writing through perfectly balanced action, romance, and allegory. The themes spoke to my heart and led me to new worship. The ending—the ending gave me chills.
Read this book for yourself and you’ll see what I mean—and why I’m greedier than Uriah Smith and Lord Auberon combined to get my hands on the next book (due to release March 2024). J. J. Fischer is a paragon author of Christian fantasy and I’m genuinely proud to have The Soul Mark on my bookshelf.
Warning: Consumers of this product may experience feelings of rage, helplessness, impatience, anxiety, and/or thoughts of harm toward the author during the final pages. Suggested treatments include repeating consumption of the product, following the author on social media, and pre-ordering the sequel product.
I don’t know where to start. The unique setting of a tropical paradise island turned hellish lifelong prison? The multi-layered romance of mutual attraction and misconceptions worthy of Jane Austen? The deep, thought-provoking themes of allegory that bring old truths into new light? The intricate plot with the perfect amount (and perfect timing) of twists, turns, and connections? (Oh, and what about the main character whose pet animal is a FOX?)
If these things don’t intrigue you yet, let me sing Fischer’s praises a little louder. I’m picky with romance and even pickier with allegory, but Fischer delivers both elements of this story with marvelous heights of skill, creativity, and thoughtfulness. In the romance, Sela and Caleb stand out as real people with real obstacles to a real relationship—facing fears, assumptions, and difficulties that any of us might face in our own pursuit of love. I delighted in the front-row seat to their heart journeys from strangers to reluctant confidants to—well, I won’t give everything away. :)
In the allegory, Fischer uses a tasteful mix of recognizable Bible content and original imagination, veering close enough to reality to give the story depth and power, while keeping enough distance to avoid literary heresy or bad writing. Truly, this allegory will touch the hearts of all readers as, no matter where we are in our spiritual walk, we seek to understand God’s mercy side-by-side with His justice, yield to His sovereign goodness over bad people and events, and ultimately find the worth of all our souls before Him.
My last word of praise for this book is that everything feels so real. Besides the spiritual truths that ARE real, the characters and places feel as authentic as my neighborhood on my morning walk. This authenticity is what pulls me into Fischer’s stories from page one, keeps me inside until the end, and brings me back for second and third (and more) reads. Even with the scary jungle nights and the villains like Uriah Smith, I want to live in the world of The Soul Mark—a world whose story, in and through the struggles and messes, promises beauty, love, freedom, and redemption.
The beginning captivated me with a premise like The Hunger Games’ Reaping with spiritual overtones. The chapters that followed carried me on the irresistible current of good writing through perfectly balanced action, romance, and allegory. The themes spoke to my heart and led me to new worship. The ending—the ending gave me chills.
Read this book for yourself and you’ll see what I mean—and why I’m greedier than Uriah Smith and Lord Auberon combined to get my hands on the next book (due to release March 2024). J. J. Fischer is a paragon author of Christian fantasy and I’m genuinely proud to have The Soul Mark on my bookshelf.
Warning: Consumers of this product may experience feelings of rage, helplessness, impatience, anxiety, and/or thoughts of harm toward the author during the final pages. Suggested treatments include repeating consumption of the product, following the author on social media, and pre-ordering the sequel product.
December 31, 2023
Absolutely magnificent.
Plot: Every scene has a purpose - either nee information is brought to light, characters wrestle with their beliefs and actions, or something occurs to throw a wrench in what we thought was going on. I read this book in less than 24 hours. I could hardly put it down! This story reaches back 6 years and brings us forward to the current timeline. The histories of characters are somewhat woven together and sometimes authors do this sloppily. Not J.J. She manages to bring together each thread with enough intention that it all clicks together beautifully.
Characters: The characters are relatable and likable!!! Caleb Alexander and Sela Merriweather each have their own convictions, and I appreciated how they did their best to protect one another. They have a mutual respect for each other and are caught up in a “justice system” that one of them is beginning to question slightly. Like they’re not getting the whole picture. Caleb has to wrestle with the balance of justice and mercy, while Sela deals with guilt and fears of her own. All this is done in a way that is not preachy. There are a host of other characters that bring plenty of life and dimension to the story, each with their own history. It flashed back to Liron a few times - I would have liked to read more about his story. However, I’m betting book 2 will include his narrative even more. Uriah Smith, Liri, Tucker - so many great characters whose stories matter in the big picture! Caleb & Alexander’s story is especially sweet. Love love love the characters. The stakes are high, the romance is sweet, the action is non-stop and the political/justice systems are just beginning to be questioned!
Writing: J.J.’s writing is some of the most beautiful and descriptive I’ve ever read. I could see the depth of each landscape, make out the colors of the sunsets, feel the temperature of the place and smell the surroundings. She weaves bits of familiar scripture into the story so that truth is something of the groundwork but more in the background than a front-runner of the story.
I found myself gaining gratitude for God’s justice and mercy as I read this book. He is the perfect balance of everything we fail to be. The writing of this book is lovely - she describes things with dimension and simplicity at the same time. Some of my faves:
“Mercy and justice are strange bondmates, my son. Only the Carver understands the intricacies of their Binding.”
“Do we not all have shadowed corners of our hearts that would frighten even ourselves, should they ever be viewed by the light of day?”
“I don’t claim to understand the Carver’s will, Sela.”
“If you don’t understand it, then how can you truly walk in it?”
The ending? Jaw drop. I didn’t realize I’d have to wait SIX more months to get the ending of this duo series. How will I manage?
Plot: Every scene has a purpose - either nee information is brought to light, characters wrestle with their beliefs and actions, or something occurs to throw a wrench in what we thought was going on. I read this book in less than 24 hours. I could hardly put it down! This story reaches back 6 years and brings us forward to the current timeline. The histories of characters are somewhat woven together and sometimes authors do this sloppily. Not J.J. She manages to bring together each thread with enough intention that it all clicks together beautifully.
Characters: The characters are relatable and likable!!! Caleb Alexander and Sela Merriweather each have their own convictions, and I appreciated how they did their best to protect one another. They have a mutual respect for each other and are caught up in a “justice system” that one of them is beginning to question slightly. Like they’re not getting the whole picture. Caleb has to wrestle with the balance of justice and mercy, while Sela deals with guilt and fears of her own. All this is done in a way that is not preachy. There are a host of other characters that bring plenty of life and dimension to the story, each with their own history. It flashed back to Liron a few times - I would have liked to read more about his story. However, I’m betting book 2 will include his narrative even more. Uriah Smith, Liri, Tucker - so many great characters whose stories matter in the big picture! Caleb & Alexander’s story is especially sweet. Love love love the characters. The stakes are high, the romance is sweet, the action is non-stop and the political/justice systems are just beginning to be questioned!
Writing: J.J.’s writing is some of the most beautiful and descriptive I’ve ever read. I could see the depth of each landscape, make out the colors of the sunsets, feel the temperature of the place and smell the surroundings. She weaves bits of familiar scripture into the story so that truth is something of the groundwork but more in the background than a front-runner of the story.
I found myself gaining gratitude for God’s justice and mercy as I read this book. He is the perfect balance of everything we fail to be. The writing of this book is lovely - she describes things with dimension and simplicity at the same time. Some of my faves:
“Mercy and justice are strange bondmates, my son. Only the Carver understands the intricacies of their Binding.”
“Do we not all have shadowed corners of our hearts that would frighten even ourselves, should they ever be viewed by the light of day?”
“I don’t claim to understand the Carver’s will, Sela.”
“If you don’t understand it, then how can you truly walk in it?”
The ending? Jaw drop. I didn’t realize I’d have to wait SIX more months to get the ending of this duo series. How will I manage?
September 9, 2023
“At the bottom of the pit I found myself I , I discovered the Carver. His grace… His mercy. Or rather, He found me… The Carver is everywhere, Sela… And no matter how dark the world grows, He always leaves a remnant.”
Synopisis: Sela has spent the past six years grieving the loss of her sister to The Lot- the exile of one to save the rest from their sins. Now Sela finds herself on her way to the same island of exile, but for murder. While simply trying to survive the depravity that now surrounds her, Sela’s path is crossed by Caleb: a member of the Righteous who sentenced her live out the rest of her days in exile without a soul. While questioning the Will of the Carver and His purpose in such a forsaken place, they both must trust each other simply to survive.
My take: In true @jjfischerauthor style, the gospel is woven into this fictitious world beautifully and obviously. It’s the main plot of the whole story, and everything else supports the theological points. The story is clean, but there are some intense action scenes. Heavy topics are discussed-abuse, sinful choices/lack there of, loss of children, murder- but these are discussed with the weight they are due and not graphically. That said, this is only book one and the cliffhanger that this book leaves on has left me practically in tears for the past week! Not kidding! It’s worth it though. If you’re looking for an adventure with a gospel message and Pirates of the Caribbean vibes, I highly recommend this one!!!
Synopisis: Sela has spent the past six years grieving the loss of her sister to The Lot- the exile of one to save the rest from their sins. Now Sela finds herself on her way to the same island of exile, but for murder. While simply trying to survive the depravity that now surrounds her, Sela’s path is crossed by Caleb: a member of the Righteous who sentenced her live out the rest of her days in exile without a soul. While questioning the Will of the Carver and His purpose in such a forsaken place, they both must trust each other simply to survive.
My take: In true @jjfischerauthor style, the gospel is woven into this fictitious world beautifully and obviously. It’s the main plot of the whole story, and everything else supports the theological points. The story is clean, but there are some intense action scenes. Heavy topics are discussed-abuse, sinful choices/lack there of, loss of children, murder- but these are discussed with the weight they are due and not graphically. That said, this is only book one and the cliffhanger that this book leaves on has left me practically in tears for the past week! Not kidding! It’s worth it though. If you’re looking for an adventure with a gospel message and Pirates of the Caribbean vibes, I highly recommend this one!!!
February 25, 2024
There are so many emotions crashing through me right now. The Soul Mark is an incredible story filled with hard questions and gripping, relatable characters. Set against a stunning backdrop of a tropical island, the story forces readers to examine their own beliefs and actions.
Sela felt a bit like a version of my younger self—fiery, loyal to family above all else, willing to fight for what she believes in, and incredibly stubborn. Her anguished questioning of the goodness of the Carver, who supposedly mandated the Lot—and indisputably allowed it—is real and raw, and gives her an amazing depth of character.
Caleb’s deep love for the Carver, and subsequent wrestling with whether the Carver he’s been taught versus the Carver he’s discovered in The Book of Souls is right when confronted with the depravity of Azazel, are so well-written his POV could be taken from a journal. The conflict between what he wants, what he knows is right, and what he’s being told is right kept me turning pages, eager to know what he chose.
The added brief POVs from siblings served to enrich this story, along with the rich history of Australia’s start as a penal colony. The enthralling world and tale remind me of The Lion, The Witch, and The Wardrobe, but with deeper questions aimed at adults who have lived much longer, pain-riddled lives.
Sela felt a bit like a version of my younger self—fiery, loyal to family above all else, willing to fight for what she believes in, and incredibly stubborn. Her anguished questioning of the goodness of the Carver, who supposedly mandated the Lot—and indisputably allowed it—is real and raw, and gives her an amazing depth of character.
Caleb’s deep love for the Carver, and subsequent wrestling with whether the Carver he’s been taught versus the Carver he’s discovered in The Book of Souls is right when confronted with the depravity of Azazel, are so well-written his POV could be taken from a journal. The conflict between what he wants, what he knows is right, and what he’s being told is right kept me turning pages, eager to know what he chose.
The added brief POVs from siblings served to enrich this story, along with the rich history of Australia’s start as a penal colony. The enthralling world and tale remind me of The Lion, The Witch, and The Wardrobe, but with deeper questions aimed at adults who have lived much longer, pain-riddled lives.
March 30, 2023
The Soul Mark is a Christian fantasy by author J. J. Fischer. It is installment #1 in The Soul Mark Duology.
Each year children who reached the age of accountability, eighteen years, went into the lot. Out of hundreds of children, only twelve were chosen to receive the Soul Mark, soul stain. The twelve would then go to Azazel never to be seen again. Once a soul mark is given it cannot be ungiven. Teodoir was a man of honor yet Sela couldn’t understand why he bore a love for the Soul Carver.
Sela murdered a man to protect her honor. She is subject to Azazel and possibly a hanging. Will Prince Magnus reverse the punishment?
The Soul Mark did not appeal to me as I thought it would. There was talk of women possibly losing their honor yet it wasn’t graphic. It was a slow, dry read. I give The Soul Mark 3*/5*.
Disclaimer: I receive complimentary books from various sources, including, publishers, publicists, authors, and/or NetGalley. I am not required to write a positive review and have not received any compensation. The opinions shared here are my own entirely. I am disclosing this under the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255
Each year children who reached the age of accountability, eighteen years, went into the lot. Out of hundreds of children, only twelve were chosen to receive the Soul Mark, soul stain. The twelve would then go to Azazel never to be seen again. Once a soul mark is given it cannot be ungiven. Teodoir was a man of honor yet Sela couldn’t understand why he bore a love for the Soul Carver.
Sela murdered a man to protect her honor. She is subject to Azazel and possibly a hanging. Will Prince Magnus reverse the punishment?
The Soul Mark did not appeal to me as I thought it would. There was talk of women possibly losing their honor yet it wasn’t graphic. It was a slow, dry read. I give The Soul Mark 3*/5*.
Disclaimer: I receive complimentary books from various sources, including, publishers, publicists, authors, and/or NetGalley. I am not required to write a positive review and have not received any compensation. The opinions shared here are my own entirely. I am disclosing this under the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255
September 2, 2024
I could not get into this book. About a quarter of the way in I stopped reading and started skimming, though I did skim all the way to the end. The overall story idea intrigued me, which is what kept me skimming, and I wanted to like the characters. However, there was little to no payoff within book one.
In the very beginning something traumatic happens to the main character, and it just goes downhill from there. Things will start looking slightly up, and then they plummet downward again. One villain is introduced, and then another, and neither is actually dealt with within this book. In my opinion, books need to have a balance of shorter-term problems with solutions/struggles with payoffs and the overarching story arc problem and solution that lasts throughout the series, otherwise it gets bogged down. Had this story truly contained some of those brighter spots where smaller issues get resolved, I think I would have enjoyed it a lot more and wanted to read book two. As it happens, I'll just assume things work out in the end.
In short, the book has a lot of promise, but failed to deliver for me.
In the very beginning something traumatic happens to the main character, and it just goes downhill from there. Things will start looking slightly up, and then they plummet downward again. One villain is introduced, and then another, and neither is actually dealt with within this book. In my opinion, books need to have a balance of shorter-term problems with solutions/struggles with payoffs and the overarching story arc problem and solution that lasts throughout the series, otherwise it gets bogged down. Had this story truly contained some of those brighter spots where smaller issues get resolved, I think I would have enjoyed it a lot more and wanted to read book two. As it happens, I'll just assume things work out in the end.
In short, the book has a lot of promise, but failed to deliver for me.
January 21, 2024
A fascinating take on how humans take the grace bestowed on us and turn into something that is controllable and unattainable. Reminds me a little of Hunger Games and how the firstborn are chosen to pay a debt for everyone else. A lot allegory that is well written. The island is made up of soulless people who have been left to fend for themselves with all hope stripped. I love how this story demonstrates that there is always a faithful remnant to fan the embers of hope. Selah is a delightful character who refuses to settle for the status quo. She is fiery and passionate and wants answers. Caleb has always lived his life above reproach, but as he studies the histories, he begins to question everything. I was fully engaged in the journey of both Selah and Caleb. Despite being on the same island, they have different truths to learn. Together, they made my heart smile. There is action, romance, pirates, and many deep truths to be soaked up. Also, a delightful little fox! This is definitely a duology and does end on a cliff hanger. I cannot wait for the next book to see how it all comes together.
March 21, 2024
~3.5 stars rounded up~
While I loved the premise of The Soul Mark and found the characters to have reasonable depth and motivation for their actions, I struggled to get through this. It's a very heavy read, in terms of religious responsibility and felt more like a historical, Puritan era story rather than the fantasy I was expecting.
Overall, if you enjoy overtly Christian/religious themed fantasy with a heavy emphasis on navigating the rights and wrongs of religious law, you should give this book a chance. It didn't quite tick all of my fantasy boxes, though.
I received this book from the author. All comments and opinions are entirely my own and this review is voluntary.
While I loved the premise of The Soul Mark and found the characters to have reasonable depth and motivation for their actions, I struggled to get through this. It's a very heavy read, in terms of religious responsibility and felt more like a historical, Puritan era story rather than the fantasy I was expecting.
Overall, if you enjoy overtly Christian/religious themed fantasy with a heavy emphasis on navigating the rights and wrongs of religious law, you should give this book a chance. It didn't quite tick all of my fantasy boxes, though.
I received this book from the author. All comments and opinions are entirely my own and this review is voluntary.
March 1, 2025
Such a moving book
Fiction that is excellently written while also encouraging, engaging, romantic, funny and heartwarming is such a rare find. The Soul Mark is that book. Sela is a main character that you can’t help but love. She roots for others, she’s selfless, feisty and incredible. The pace of this book keeps you on the edge of your seat. I was transported to a new world and the Christian elements were truly the cherry on top. I have nothing bad to say I loved it so much.
Fiction that is excellently written while also encouraging, engaging, romantic, funny and heartwarming is such a rare find. The Soul Mark is that book. Sela is a main character that you can’t help but love. She roots for others, she’s selfless, feisty and incredible. The pace of this book keeps you on the edge of your seat. I was transported to a new world and the Christian elements were truly the cherry on top. I have nothing bad to say I loved it so much.
May 10, 2023
A dazzlingly written allegorical story that pulled me in from the start. Alluring and stunning descriptions, witty dialogue, compelling characters. It felt like a nod to early Australian colonial times, but even greater than that were bits of faith and love woven beautifully throughout. Highly recommend and cannot wait for book 2.
April 15, 2024
The Soul Mark is a rich tale that will have you questioning what it means to be pure and what it is to love someone when simply touching them can cost you your soul. It is filled with romance, pirates, and characters who fight for each other at their own risk. I loved it and can't wait to read book two.
June 5, 2023
Authors aren't meant to pick favorites of their books.
But this is mine. My absolute favoritest.
(Yes I know, that isn't a word.
Yes, I spell/use words correctly in the actual book.)
- Jasmine xo
But this is mine. My absolute favoritest.
(Yes I know, that isn't a word.
Yes, I spell/use words correctly in the actual book.)
- Jasmine xo
May 31, 2024
Excellent read. I loved Sela's boldness and strength. She was a captivating protagonist who made me genuinely care about her story. JJ Fischer is a wonderful storyteller, and this book is definitely worth reading!
June 3, 2025
Very well done
This book has a bit of everything: clean romance, action, intrigue, betrayal, redemption, and salvation. I highly suggest reading it. I'm immediately reading the second book myself.
This book has a bit of everything: clean romance, action, intrigue, betrayal, redemption, and salvation. I highly suggest reading it. I'm immediately reading the second book myself.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 39 reviews