Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book
Rate this book
Could Alexander Hamilton be at the center of a vast murder plot engulfing Old New York? As his widow, Eliza, pieces together the puzzle, she unearths a heartbreaking secret that threatens to tear her family apart.

Perfect for fans of Sherry Thomas and Deanna Raybourn, taking us from the city’s gilded mansions to its meanest streets, Mollie Ann Cox’s debut historical mystery transports readers to center stage in a time of grave political danger.

New York, 1804. America’s beloved Alexander Hamilton lies dead after a duel with Aaron Burr. Meanwhile, Eliza Hamilton’s eighteen-year-old son, Alexander Jr., was seen fighting with a man in a tavern the night before his father’s duel and quickly comes under suspicion for murder when the man turns up dead.

Eliza searches for ways to clear her son’s name, even as she is grieving, but as she combs through her late husband’s papers, she finds evidence of a plot to steal money from the government during his tenure as secretary of state. Hamilton was accused of stealing that money, and it was a scandal that almost broke the family—but is Eliza now holding proof of Alexander’s innocence?

Deep in debt and despair, with eight children to support, Eliza turns to selling her handmade lace—and is drawn into a mysterious network of widow lacemakers who are intimately connected to New York’s high-society families. They know their dead husbands’ secrets—and soon, Eliza begins to piece together the truth.

There’s a dark plot connected with the duel, as one by one, witnesses to the bout are being killed. Now, Eliza must not only clear her husband’s and son’s names but keep herself out of the killer’s sights.

320 pages, Hardcover

Published December 12, 2023

47 people are currently reading
3878 people want to read

About the author

Mollie Ann Cox

2 books36 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
71 (16%)
4 stars
151 (35%)
3 stars
156 (36%)
2 stars
45 (10%)
1 star
5 (1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 129 reviews
Profile Image for Tracey .
896 reviews57 followers
October 6, 2024
This is an entertaining, well-written, historical fiction, mystery novel. It is a fictional story based on actual persons, and has vividly described settings, a likable, intelligent female protagonist, supportive family and friends, murder, mystery, intrigue, and a satisfying conclusion. I learned of this delightful novel, which is the first in a series, as a subscriber to Ms. Cox's newsletter. I am looking forward to reading the next installment with great anticipation.
Profile Image for LORI CASWELL.
2,863 reviews328 followers
February 3, 2024
Dollycas's Thoughts 

Eliza Hamilton is grieving her beloved husband Alexander Hamilton's death following his duel with Aaron Burr when she learns her eighteen-year-old son, Alexander Jr. is under suspicion of murder after he was witnessed fighting with a man in a tavern who later was found dead. Determined to clear his name she starts by going through her beloved's papers and she finds papers covering a plot to steal money from the government. Something he was accused of while serving as Secretary of State. But the papers prove what she already knew. Her husband didn't steal that money.

Hamilton did leave Eliza in dire straights. With little money and deep in debt Eliza doesn't know how she will be able to pay her bills and provide for their eight children. When Eliza reconnects with a woman, Alice, whom she helped after her own husband's death she finds high-quality handmade lace is in demand. She decided to sell some of her family's lace as well as make some herself to sell.

Reconnecting with Alice had another benefit, it connected her other widow lacemakers who knew their husbands' secrets and are tapped into New York’s high-society families and their secrets and they are willing to help her prove her son's innocence and her husband's too. But as more witnesses to the duel are killed Eliza realizes her own life is in danger along with the lives of the women that are helping her.

____

Ms. Cox has written such a captivating story featuring a strong and compassionate woman in trying times. Eliza Hamilton loved her husband and would go to great lengths to provide and protect her children. Following her beloved's death she exhibited such strength, a strength that she built up from her childhood. A strength that got her through the loss of a son, her husband's death, and in this story clearing a son accused of murder. Within the pages, we get just a peek at Eliza's works to help women and children. Alexander Hamilton was not a perfect man but she was devoted to him and looked past his indecretions and imperfections. One of her daughters struggled with mental illness and that tested her but she handled it as best she could. She truly was an amazing woman for her time.

In addition to Eliza, we meet her sister Angelica who came to help her right after Alexander's death and was grieving in her own right. Angelica's husband John took on Alexander Jr's case to keep the young man out of jail. We also meet Alice Rhodes who Eliza helped through the Widow's Society. Alice introduces Eliza to the four women she shares a house with, each with their own special talents. The characters are well-crafted and distinct. They are believable and develop throughout the book.

The story is well-plotted with an excellent flow. The mysteries are complicated but Ms. Cox's writing style takes her readers right into the story so that we can untangle the clues right along with the characters. The twists and turns were well-placed and my interest continued to build with each turn of a page. Eliza was determined and resilient in her quest for the truth. I enjoyed the way the women pulled together to do almost anything to help her even when the situations turned grim.

While this is a fictional story the author truthfully depicts women's lives in the 1800s. Eliza, Alice, and her friends were unique. The Author's Note at the end of the book reveals the liberties she took with history to build this wonderful story and how she strived to stay as historically accurate as possible. I know she did extensive research to do just that. Before I read this book I didn't know much about Eliza Hamilton. I learned so much while reading The Lace Widow and what I learned piqued my desire to know more.

The Lace Widow tells the story of some strong, confident women and the situations they faced in 1804. Ms. Cox's reimagination of the weeks following Alexander Hamilton's death is compelling. The scenes were described in detail, the dialogues were crisp, and the mysteries were riveting. I truly escaped back in time with Eliza Hamilton and believe this book deserves more than 5 stars. It is my first Best Read of 2024. It is a must-read for fans of historical mysteries.
1,802 reviews34 followers
December 10, 2023
The Lace Widow by Mollie Ann Cox is a gorgeously-written Historical Fiction peppered with mystery, intrigue, heartache and hope.

The author (do read her notes) bases her story on the incomparable Eliza Hamilton, an intrepid and compassionate widow with eight children in 1804 New York who finds herself in financial trouble. She must rely on herself to earn money for her family and discovers economic and emotional help in a lace-making network. Meanwhile, one of her sons is accused of a murder and a daughter often believes her beloved father is still alive. Eliza goes to unusual measures to prove her son's Innocence. Her strength and fortitude are incredible and the otyer characters are realistic.

My favourite aspect is the focus on a real-life heroine who, in the midst of her own agony, comforts others. The story is vividly drawn and very believable with flaws and hardships.

If you seek a unique perspective during a fascinating era in history, do prioritize this book. Immerse yourself completely.

My sincere thank you to Crooked Lane Books and NetGalley for providing me with a digital copy of this engrossing novel.
Profile Image for Moonkiszt.
3,030 reviews333 followers
July 20, 2024
If ever there was an understated heroine Eliza Hamilton would be my first on the list. Behind every great man, etc.

Despite his many gifts to the US, Alexander Hamilton made some questionable choices - Eliza was not one of them. I enjoyed this read that considers how and what her life looked like after her famous husband's death at the hands of a fellow politician (who would have suffered a similar fate if Alexander had won the duel - would he have been a hero or a scoundrel as Burr became? we'll never know). The read presents some interesting questions, and although it was mild as it relates to history and mystery, I carried through to the end because of Eliza and her willingness to keep her family together and Alexander's name unsmirched.

*A sincere thank you to Mollie Ann Cox, Crooked Lane Books, and NetGalley for an ARC to read and review independently.*
Profile Image for Cindy Spear.
597 reviews45 followers
August 10, 2023
I absolutely adored The Lace Widow historical mystery by Mollie Ann Cox. It is a fascinating, riveting story with Eliza Hamilton as its lead character. Like many, I have seen and loved the Hamilton musical so it was a delight to read a book that focuses on Eliza and the amazing woman she truly was. Although this is fiction, from what I have read of her, Mollie has captured her essence extremely well. It is easy to believe she was fiercely protective of her family and the lengths she would go to keep them safe. It is also understandable why she would work hard to restore the Hamilton name to good standing.

This novel also shows the enduring love Eliza had for her late husband and the grief she experienced in losing him in the crazy duel. It was evident she knew Alexander was not perfect, yet we sympathise with her realisation that he did not prepare for the possibility he might die. He left his wife and children with debts and no funds to sustain them through the trials ahead. But Eliza was a resourceful woman and despite the ugly facts, her faith and love gave her the grace, forgiveness and courage to find solutions and to overlook any imperfections. I found her portrayal both realistic and enlightening. It made me think how I would react in such a situation.

Part of Eliza’s solution to remedy her financial loss was in using the lace she had inherited from her wealthy grandmother. The title The Lace Widow hints at this. I found this an ingenious and unselfish plan on her part. She was always caring for others, providing for those in need, putting others ahead of herself—even giving up something so dear to her—for the greater good. Her faith was part of her inspiration, even though there were times when her beliefs were shaken. This is a realistic human view. As even the most solid Christian will have moments of doubt. But she never lingered on these thoughts long and charged forward with the best of intentions. Love was always at heart of her actions. Her motto: “To help others any time ‘she’ could—it was the Christian thing to do.”

The Lace Widow provides a clear depiction of women’s roles in the early 1800s and the attitudes toward the female mind. The weak thinking of the time is certainly heard in the men’s responses to Eliza’s brilliant observations. More than once when she has made astute suggestions, we see her state of mind questioned. Is she ill or overcome by grief? Did she need to lie down, see a doctor or take medicine? Yes, she was heartbroken over losing her husband but it certainly never hindered her decision making ability! In reality, she was smarter than most and their demeaning attitudes were challenged and proven wrong in the course of the novel’s events.

Everything about this novel is accomplished and rendered by an experienced hand. The plot moves at a thoughtful pace. The mysteries are carefully rolled out and solved at appropriate times. It is well written with excellent dialogue, atmospheric settings and meticulous descriptions. I was completely transported to New York of 1804. I could even imagine the heat waves that Eliza found challenging! The characters are distinct and brilliantly fleshed out. I felt as though I knew Eliza, her sister Angelica, her friend Alice and many of the other women who assisted her. There are a few admirable supportive male figures, too, and quite a daring lot of villains! A good mix of surprises and twists in the plot to keep interest high. I comfortably slipped into this story and followed the journey of justice led by the marvellous Eliza. She sought to clear her son of the false murder charge and find the real person behind it and the other deaths. Plus, she needed to expose the real thief who stole the government funds of which her husband was wrongly accused. Our heroine never gave up until the real culprits were exposed and she defied convention in doing it. Yes, she put herself in danger but her quick thinking and nimble actions brought down their vicious plots.

I will say it again, I loved The Lace Widow! It was everything I hoped and more. And now it has joined the ranks of one of my all-time favourite historical mysteries! I highly recommend this novel and give it a Bold 5 Stars. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Thanks to Crooked Lane Books and Netgalley for such a fabulous review copy.
Profile Image for Janalyn, the blind reviewer.
4,607 reviews140 followers
December 10, 2023
This is a historical fiction book about Eliza Hamilton trying to clear the name of her son Alexander Junior when he was accused of murdering one of the witnesses at his fathers dual that just happened a month before the book starts end it goes in to them having money issues and him needing his school fees paid and so Eliza start selling her lace. I found this a good read and I love reading a book where I notice names of people that owe worth mentioning from history and although the Author did have a few historical discrepancies like Eliza saying she argued with Alexander before he left for the dual and that isn’t true because he stayed in the apartment above his office with his oldest boys who went to school in the city and he left Eliza a note that ended with the Best of wives the Best of women I don’t know why authors and historians like to keep playing on this narrative that she woke before he left for the dual because that never happened having said that which is a minor part of the book and has no place in the plot it just irritates me this was still a good book and I think as long as you don’t have historical facts mapped in your head one you will enjoy. I want to thank the publisher and NetGalley for my free arc copy please forgive any mistakes as I am blind and dictate my review.
Profile Image for Star Gater.
1,863 reviews57 followers
January 18, 2024
Stars: 4.5

Narrator: Nicol Zanzarella

I thoroughly enjoyed this book. The combination of writing, story, main and supporting characters, as well as Zanzarella was the perfect recipe.

Eliza is the woman I want in my mind when I read period books. No names, and there are only a couple that fit, are coming to me right now; most authors write whiny women. Hip Hip Hooray for Cox -- Eliza is a great character. With that said, the other ladies are perfect as well. Everyone had a role and each played it beautifully. This is a book I would love to see as a series. The author has written solid characters with multiple interests; there doesn't have to be a murder in every one. I like the role that the lace played. I teared up a couple times.

As far as narration, I felt like the book was being read to me with few voice changes, and loved it. It didn't feel performed. Zanzarella was the perfect choice. In my head, she is what I think I sound like when I read aloud -- calming and caring.

I would gift this to everyone. This is for teens going into adult books, adults. and elderly. It would make a worry-insult free audio book gift as well (nursing home). The language is classy.

Thank you HighBridge Audio for accepting my request to read and review The Lace Widow on NetGalley.
Profile Image for PugMom.
542 reviews3 followers
January 2, 2024
If you love historical mysteries with a strong and well written main character then this one is for you. It is evident that the author researched the people she wrote about and then brought them to life. The historical details and well-planned mystery made for a 5 star read.
Profile Image for Jan.
6,531 reviews102 followers
August 2, 2023
The daughter of a prominent New York family, the widow of Alexander Hamilton found herself in debt and worse. The witnesses to the fatal duel are being murdered and answers need to be found. To support herself and her eight children she is selling the very valuable labor intensive beautiful lace made by her elders (tatted, pillow, crochet, and woven as kitted lace was not done at that time). She is also trying to find answers with the help of those whom she has helped during the course of her life.
The story is well crafted and the characters are very clearly brought to life as are the civil liberty problems of the day and the unfair advantages of the wealthy. A good read with intensive research evident.
I requested and received an EARC from Crooked Lane Books via NetGalley. Thank you!
Profile Image for Andria Potter.
Author 2 books94 followers
June 2, 2024
The writing was fine but I just wasn't drawn in to it. 3.5 ⭐
Profile Image for Fred.
1,012 reviews66 followers
December 13, 2023
The Lace Widow is the first book in the An Eliza Hamilton Mystery series by Mollie Ann Cox.

This series deals with the life of Eliza Hamilton, the widow of Alexander Hamilton. Read the Author’s Note to learn the author’s approach to the series.

The story starts shortly after the Hamilton-Burr duel. Eliza Hamilton is on her way home when her carriage is stopped. Eliza gets out to see what the problem is and sees that the body of John Van Der Gloss is being dragged from the river. She knows he was murdered as she sees that Van Der Gloss's throat has been cut. It hits her hard as he was a good friend of Alexander and to be murdered so soon after her husband's death. Arriving at home, Eliza finds that a constable brought Alexander Jr. home, saying Alexander had been in a fight with Van Der Gloss the previous evening. Alexander claims he only hit him once and ran from the tavern. The constable will take Alexander, Jr. into custody for the murder of Van Der Gloss. When another of Alexander’s friends dies from hanging, Eliza suspects that someone or a group is trying to discredit Alexander and get rid of those who know the truth.

Eliza will start asking questions to clear her late husband’s and her son's names. She will work with the Widow’s Society, a group of widows who need help and live in a home on Pearl Street. When Eliza experiences a rock thrown through her bedroom window, she feels this is a threat to her life and takes up residency at the Widow’s Society home. From there, she will go undercover in search of the people who are trying to frame her son for murder.

The book is well-written, plotted, historically accurate, and moves at a good pace. The author does an excellent job showing how men treated their wives and women in the 1800s. The characters are well-developed, believable, and engaging. There were enough twists and turns that kept me guessing until the end.

I’m looking forward to seeing what adventures Eliza will have next.
Profile Image for Blue.
337 reviews5 followers
July 8, 2023
Elizabeth Hamilton, the wife of Alexander Hamilton has lost her husband to a duel. Aaron Burr is responsible for the lost of the man she loved dearly. This death has shot her into the real world where rumors fly and accusations are not questioned. You have a winning card if you are wealthy and are well known. Almost before Mr. Hamilton is buried she finds herself in a fight to survive with her children and all in her household. She is no weakling. She is strong and ready to do battle. It is not the first time strangers had knocked on her door and came in to defame the Hamilton.

It is an alien world and a time when women were thought of as hysterical. Make a significant statement that pertained to your family and a state's truth and find yourself shunned. She would not allow the stereotype to take away her mind. It did hurt but she did not allow the accusers to smack her fingers and lock her behind an embroidery frame. There were so many questions not answered at this very moment. n Those questions must resound in the streets. She must take her first punch. Lace? Did I hear the word "lace?" At least, we can now vote into power those who will fight for us and with us.
Profile Image for Laura Hundley.
839 reviews48 followers
August 4, 2023
The Lace Widow by Mollie Ann Cox
Publisher Crooked Lane Books
Release Date December 12, 2023
Genre Historical Fiction

Characters: 5/5
Plot: 5/5
Pace: 4/5
Overall Enjoyment: 5/5

The first thing about this book that I enjoyed was the historical descriptions that the author was able to include in order to make the book more appealing to its readers. Cox has an uncanny ability to take a era and write as though we were in that time period. This book contains murder, grief, and the tenacity to fight for a son. I was intrigued by the way that the author pulled me into the story and did not let go. I love historical fiction and mystery and I was blessed with both in this book. The build up to the main premise is done expertly as is with the characters. They are very well developed and flawed. I will say that this is a slower paced book though. You will not be disappointed at all.
Profile Image for Roger.
418 reviews
May 29, 2024
Lin-Manuel Miranda'a HAMILTON introduced Eliza Hamilton to our national story and now Mollie Ann Cox jumps through that open door with a mystery set in the early weeks after the infamous Hamilton/Burr duel. In her "Acknowedgements", Cox forthrightly notes the connections between the musical and her inspirations, but this novel isn't simply an opportunistic bit of fluffery. Cox has produced an engaging cozy that has Eliza Hamilton driving an investigation into a series of murders, unveiling a complex conspiracy in the process.

To set up the story, Eliza is in the midst of mourning (an extraordinarily constrained existence at the time) shortly after her husband's death when her oldest remaining son is implicated in the murder of an old family friend, who also happens to be a witness to the Hamilton/Burr duel. Soon after, another witness, and another friend of Alexander's, is found dead. Eliza starts to ask questions despite societal expectations about what her life should be whilst mourning. Eliza's early questions become an off-the-cuff investigation into the deaths, firstly as a way to save her son and then as a means to clear her husband of accusations that he stole from the Treasury in the 1790s. Eliza's persistence and her connections to a set of women who can roam the city little-noticed quickly uncovers clues others have missed, and becomes a catalyst to violent responses from the conspirators.

Much of the action occurs out of sight, as Eliza is an observer with limited access to the powers-that-be and almost no access to the rooms where it happens. But, she does experience real peril during this story, proving herself to be an inteprid agent. The novel is at its best in depictions of life in New York City during the earliest years of the 19th century, especially life for both women who have means and working-class women.

Fans of the musical will recognize familiar themes and that does help produce a fast immersion in the story, but still knowledge of HAMILTON is not a requirement before you open this book. It is a comfortable cozy all on its own. Cox, in the process, has set the stage for additional books in the series with a wide range of supporting characters and a compelling protagonist.

Your work may be long
remembered, but it still takes
money to survive.
Profile Image for Robyn.
2,370 reviews131 followers
May 5, 2024
So this was about Eliza Hamilton, the wife of Alexander Hamilton as she attempted to fictionally clear her son, Alexander Jr. from a possible scandal that would have changed the course of his life.

The assumption is that Alexander Jr. was suspected of killing the witnesses to his father and Aaron Burr's dual. The book had a great plot and was interesting and entertaining. I guess that it might have been possible.... we will never know.

It was worth the read.

4 stars

Happy Reading!
Profile Image for Alyssa Mohring .
391 reviews51 followers
January 7, 2024
Thank you to Kate Rocks Book Tours and Mollie Ann Cox for a copy of The Lace Widow in exchange for my review.

This historical fiction novel was magic in my hands. Mollie Ann Cox does a beautiful job of weaving the story and historical accuracy together. It flowed so well together. I was entranced from start to finish.
All the characters fit into the story nicely. I enjoyed all the characters. Learning about Eliza Hamilton and the type of person she was made me love her as a historical figure. Her rebellious side and her heart of gold is the best. She was a strong woman who stood up for what was right and what she believed in. I loved McNally. I also loved all the Widows of Pearl Street. Alice was fun and loveable. She cracked me up. All the women in this story were strong women who proved you can do anything. I want to be their friend.
The storyline/ mystery was so fun. I love the way it progressed throughout the story. I enjoyed all the shenanigans all the women got themselves into.
I really hope there is another adventure soon. The author did an amazing job.
Profile Image for Nursebookie.
2,888 reviews451 followers
January 1, 2024
TITLE: THE LACE WIDOW
AUTHOR: Mollie Ann Cox
PUB DATE: DEC 12, 2023 Now Available

THE LACE WIDOW by author Mollie Ann Cox is a Historical Mystery debut about widow Eliza Hamilton who uses her wit and investigative prowess to clear her husband’s name and prove her son’s innocence. I enjoy reading historical mysteries because of how facts are weaved into a fictional murder mystery tale set in 19th century New York, and a heroine to root for.

This is a perfect read for anyone looking for a compelling mystery steeped in history and those still wanting more after seeing Hamilton, here you go!
Profile Image for Barb reads......it ALL!.
910 reviews38 followers
January 13, 2024
Actually 3.5 ⭐️s.
I loved this story and naturally now I need to read more about Eliza Schuyler Hamilton. I always think it's gutsy to build a fictional tale around a historical character and deserving on a ⭐️ just for that.
I look forward to more sleuthing by Mrs General Hamilton.
Profile Image for Carol.
754 reviews29 followers
December 30, 2023
For Hamilton fans

Eliza Hamilton has lost her beloved husband. She is grieving with her family when men her husband knew start being killed. She feels Aaron Burr may be part of it and decides to investigate on her own. She receives some help from fellow widows from the widows' society. Meanwhile she discovers she may be short on funds and starts selling lace her grandmother had made.
Profile Image for Melmo2610.
3,617 reviews
December 29, 2023
As someone who’s a HUGE fan of Hamilton, this was a must read for me. I was thrilled when I saw this pop on NetGalley, a cozy where Eliza Hamilton is the sleuth? Yes, please! I thoroughly enjoyed this cozy. The fact that the mystery ties in to the duel where Alexander Hamilton lost his life was one that I was all in for. The mystery was fantastic and the supporting characters were perfect for the story. I can’t wait for another case with Eliza and her friends.
160 reviews
February 26, 2024
While the historical detail is present, the plot behind the mystery is obtuse and the writing is redundant ... How many times to we need to know the characters enjoyed a glass of lemonade?
Profile Image for Dawn (noladawnreads).
377 reviews43 followers
December 20, 2023


THE LACE WIDOW
𝙼𝚘𝚕𝚕𝚒𝚎 𝙰𝚗𝚗 𝙲𝚘𝚡
12/12/24

🪡 𝚂𝚢𝚗𝚘𝚙𝚜𝚒𝚜:
New York City, 1804. Eleven days ago Alexander Hamilton met his fate in a duel with Aaron Burr, making Eliza Schuyler Hamilton a widow. Eliza’s oldest surviving son, Alexander Jr. has been seen fighting with a man who has now been found dead. But, not just any man, a witness to the duel. Suspicions arise.

Eliza is desperate to find a way to clear Alexander’s name so she searches through Alexander’s desk and papers for any clue she can find. Instead she finds evidence of a plot to steal money from the government when Alexander was Secretary of State. He was accused of this himself and he and his family barely survived the slander.

As each witness to the duel slowly starts disappearing, Eliza realizes she may be the next target. But, Alexander left them with no money and she needs to clear both Alexander’s names. Will she be able to raise the funds to restore the dignity to the Hamilton name? Can she outsmart the killer?

📜𝚃𝚑𝚘𝚞𝚐𝚑𝚝𝚜:

I was immediately drawn to this book because, like so many others, I was bitten by the Hamilton bug almost 8 years ago. So when I saw this was a story from Eliza’s perspective I knew I had to read it and I was not disappointed. This was filled with lots of great historical facts (great authors note!) but it also has just the right amount of fictional twists and characters that seem so realistic. If I didn’t know better I could believe this was all factually based. The side characters, especially Alice, are truly delightful. I’d love an entire book about Alice!

I did a tandem read with the print and audio versions and the audio kept me fully invested. Nicol Zanzarella has such a captivating voice. Between the story itself and the narration I was so transfixed I reorganized my pantry!

🖤𝚁𝙸𝚈𝙻:
-Historic events
-Mystery and intrigue
-Strong FMC
-Hamilton ⭐️

🗝️Thank you @katerockbooktours for including me on the book tour and @molliebryan @crookedlandbooks and @highbridgeaudio for the early review copies.
These thoughts are my own.
#supportindieauthors
758 reviews1 follower
June 23, 2025
Still deep in mourning, Eliza Hamilton returns home to find that her eldest remaining son and his father's namesake is embroiled in a murder investigation after being seen getting into a brawl with a man who turns up dead the following day. Eliza catapults herself into trying to get to the bottom of this and prove her son's innocence. When more people, more who witnessed the duel that took her husband's life, end up dead it becomes even more clear that the family connection may go deeper than she initially thought.

Threatened by killers, trying to stave off debts she had not known of, and deal with her own grief, Eliza persists finding new ways and the help of old company to bring light into the shadows of her world.

This book would work as a decent crossover to cozy mystery for historical fiction fans or vice versa. It was a decent little piece of intrigue with domestic features but also social. There are a group of widows who, in a very masculine dominated world, are learning to keep their own. A mix of mothers, daughters, and even grandmothers are an insight into the lesser fortunate of the time.

I confess a slight disappointment in the work as a whole. From the setup I was anticipating a far deeper exploration of an intrigue than a rather sudden and quick wrap up of the situation. While it was sufficient I felt there was more opportunity. there was also a threat concerning Eliza's daughter Angel that may have tipped this into magical realism that was left unresolved potentially so that the author can explore this as supernatural or psychological going forward. It was a rare instance in me seeing where there was setup for more potential adventures, yet wanting more in the moment born of still waiting for something rather than hungering for the next mystery.
Profile Image for Lauralee.
Author 2 books27 followers
September 24, 2025
Alexander Hamilton was killed in a duel with Aaron Burr. Shortly after the duel, one of the witnesses of the famous duel winds up dead. The main suspect is Alexander Hamilton Jr, who was seen fighting with him at the tavern. Alexander Hamilton’s widow, Eliza Hamilton believes her son is innocent. She is determined to find the killer. As she investigates, she quickly learns that her meddling has caused the real killer to be nervous. The real killer vows to stop her even if it means to kill her.

Eliza is a really admirable protagonist. Throughout the book, she grieves over the death of her husband. She is also a very loving mother and wants to protect her family. I liked her determination in trying to find the killer. She is very daring. At times, she is very reckless and impulsive. Nevertheless, Eliza had a very keen intellect in trying to solve the mystery. I also liked how she worked closely with her sister, Angelica, and her friend, Alice to find the killer. They both came up with many fascinating schemes to investigate the case.

Overall, this novel is about loss, family, and friendship. I liked all the characters and thought that they were very realistic. There were times that I thought the novel was very repetitive. The mystery was a bit disappointing at the end because the killer just wound up into Eliza’s hands through her own recklessness rather than her solving the mystery itself. Therefore, I thought the unraveling of the mystery was rather lazy on the author’s part because I wanted Eliza to use her own reasoning. Nevertheless, it was an enjoyable and cozy read! I read it in one sitting! I’m looking forward to reading the sequel! I recommend this for fans of The Turncoat’s Widow, Cry of the Innocent, and Lost in the Shadows!
(Note: I read an ARC copy of this book in courtesy of Netgalley.)
Profile Image for Lindsey Sanford.
Author 4 books34 followers
December 28, 2023
3.5

I admittedly don't know much about the history of Alexander Hamilton save for what I've learned from the HAMILTON musical. But one thing I do know is that Eliza was such a strong, patient, kind woman who was left with a bunch of kids and scandal behind her name when Alexander passed. I was excited to read "The Lace Widow" by Mollie xx because it focused on Eliza post-duel and tossed her into a mystery full of murder and corruption. I admired the strong mama bear that Eliza was in this book, especially during a time when being a woman meant you were supposed to be meek and quiet and stay out of "man stuff".

I would describe this book as a Cozy Historical Mystery. There isn't a lot of violence or high-stakes moments, but the short chapters help move the story along well. While I prefer my mysteries to be a bit darker and twistier, this was an enjoyable read, especially for those who love historical fiction. I particularly loved the women Eliza associated with and the sort of underground detective agency they created.

My biggest disappointed was the lack of scene setting / descriptions throughout the book. I am such a visual reader and love being transported into the story, especially when it's back in time. I found the descriptions of the world to be a bit lacking in this book. Which is such a bummer because this time period really lends well for stunning visuals.

Overall, though, this was a really entertaining debut novel by the author. I'm not sure if this is intended to become a series, but I will absolutely read more in this world if that becomes the case. If you're looking for a quick historical mystery that features rebellious women but isn't too stressful, this would be a great read for you!

I was gifted a copy of the book as part of a book tour. My thoughts and opinions are entirely my own.
Profile Image for Jame_EReader.
1,452 reviews1 follower
December 31, 2023
Thank you @katerockbooktours @crookedlanebooks @mollieanncox for having me on this historical fiction booktour.

This mystery historical fiction is intense and dark. While reading this book, I was thinking of the broadway show, Hamilton and more. This is about the duel that Burr killed him, the scandals at the backstory, Eliza’s unveiling secrets, Hamilton’s son and his innocence or not, the financial struggles of feeding eight children and the way to find the truth. When we read historical fiction, we often read about the main character neglecting to discuss about wives and this one, we see it from Eliza Hamilton’s point of view. I like this intense mystery and the historical context behind the aftermath of Hamilton’s death and her heroic actions and struggles to make light of the tragedy.
Profile Image for Rachel.
2,352 reviews99 followers
December 3, 2023
The Lace Widow by Mollie Ann Cox and audiobook Narrated by Nicol Zanzarella is a great history fiction that was quite entertaining.

I enjoyed the author’s use of making Eliza Hamilton the main character and to place her in a murder mystery. Being famous, but also now an ametheur sleuth, gave her plenty of material, real and fictional, to craft a nice mystery.

Eliza is forced to investigate the mysterious deaths of two men who were associated with the infamous duel that led to her husband’s death. Her son has been implicated in one of the questionable deaths and it is Eliza’s job to find the culprit, help release her son from imprisonment, and try to begin to pick up the pieces after losing her husband so suddenly.


4/5 stars

Thank you NG and Highbridge Audio for this wonderful arc and in return I am submitting my unbiased and voluntary review and opinion.

I am posting this review to my GR and Bookbub accounts immediately and will post it to my Amazon, Instagram, and B&N accounts upon publication on 12/12/23.
268 reviews2 followers
June 17, 2024
3.75
The first in what will be a series, this mystery is set in New York City in 1804. Eliza Hamilton has very recently been widowed when a serious accusation is leveled against her son, Alexander. Eliza vows she will clear his name as well as uncovering who was behind a theft from the US treasury years before which cast suspicion and dishonor on her late husband.
I enjoyed reading about life in the city at this time and how Eliza, helped by other brave women , works to expose the men behind several murders, even as she becomes endangered herself.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 129 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.