Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Winter in Moscow

Rate this book
This 1934 fictionalized account of Stalin's Moscow presents an Orwellian nightmare satirized, as Western journalists blithely overlook starving peasants and support the utopian claims of one of the bloodiest regimes in human history. 5 cassettes.

222 pages, Paperback

First published January 1, 1934

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Malcolm Muggeridge

108 books292 followers
Thomas Malcolm Muggeridge was an English journalist, author, media personality, and satirist. During World War II, he was a soldier and a spy. In the aftermath of the war, as a hugely influential London journalist, he converted to Christianity and helped bring Mother Teresa to popular attention in the West. He was also a critic of the sexual revolution and of drug use.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
14 (43%)
4 stars
11 (34%)
3 stars
4 (12%)
2 stars
2 (6%)
1 star
1 (3%)
Displaying 1 - 7 of 7 reviews
Profile Image for Kierkegaard's Pancakes.
12 reviews20 followers
March 30, 2015
"Winter In Moscow" is seen by some as one of the first popular critiques of Soviet Communism. Muggeridge, criticized communism before other notables like Orwell. If for no other reason, this can be seen as an important novel.

Muggeridge is a "Forest Gump" type, knowing many important people of the 20th century, participating in some notable episodes of history and observing/commenting on many of the social trends, from politics to religion.

Muggeridge is probably fading from the memory of most, but his writing offers the reader an introduction to many personalities and points of 20th century history. Any book of Muggeridge's is worth the read.
Profile Image for Wendy Welch.
Author 15 books143 followers
November 26, 2008
It's history and human nature combined. I like the book in and of itself, and I like reading books about the context surrounding when this book was written. History really does repeat itself, more' the pity.
Profile Image for John Geddes.
205 reviews8 followers
Want to Read
August 30, 2025
[Full quotes can be found here https://archive.ph/36Hls]
The vast army of sympathetic critics of the Soviet regime have done more to enhance its prestige than all its paid agitators and subsidised publications put together. By being sympathetic they have accepted its premises; and once the premises are accepted, criticism becomes irrelevant. As a Jew in the Soviet Foreign Office said to me once, with a wink, "Those that are not against us are for us."
-p.19-20
Beatrice was a veteran in the revolutionary struggle. It appeared that Trotsky had once made advances to her in a taxi. He had, she often recounted, rested his historic hand on her knee; and she, perhaps mistakenly, had withdrawn the knee from his grasp. Besides this, she had stood shoulder to shoulder with the toiling masses of Russia for no less than ten years in their struggle to create a classless, socialist society. "How do you like being back?" she shouted gaily to Claude Mosser, a Jew with a soft, romantic face; somehow a little hard, even shifty, underneath its softness. "Marvellous," he answered. "How stimulating everything is! How exciting! Admit the faults; but the life, the movement, the exhilaration of it all! A new society going through its birth pangs. A new civilisation." Beatrice nodded. This kind of thing was her speciality. She hoped Mosser was not going to encroach on her territory. "I suppose you'll be visiting the old village and the old folks again?" she said, her voice solemn, religious. Mosser had already written three books about revisiting the old village and the old folks. It was just like Beatrice, he thought, to imagine that a theme was never exhausted. The books had been excellent sellers, certainly; but there was no point in flogging a good horse to death. Besides, ever since it had been suggested, unkindly and quite groundlessly, that the Treaty of Versailles had put his birthplace in Poland he had been touchy about the old village and the old folks.
-p.22-3
In most Russian towns there are certain shops whose windows are well stocked with food and clothing. They are called Torgsin shops. People stand outside them in little wistful groups looking at tempting... delicacies that are for them unobtainable. They cannot buy in the shops because only gold or foreign currency is accepted, and most Russians possess neither. Even if they do possess a little gold it is dangerous to disclose the fact. The shops are mostly patronised by foreigners and by Russian Jews who receive remittances from relatives abroad. For the general public, like the special Ogpu stores, and the special Red Army stores, and the special stores for important Communist officials, they are closed shops. One day an elderly man drove up in a droshky to the main entrance of a Torgsin shop in the centre of Moscow. Before the Revolution he had been the captain of a small merchant ship. Now he earned a poor living by teaching languages. His friends still called him Captain Andreyev, which he liked because it reminded him of the past when, it seemed to him now, he had been very happy... The shop smelt of scent; and somewhere a gramophone was playing. In the pay-desk a Jewess; her face heavily powdered and rouged; a grotesque swollen mask, weighed gold; examined currency notes, and paid out Torgsin bonds. By her side sat an expert whom she consulted when she was in doubt. The expert wore rimless pince-nez and had a long straight nose. Captain Andreyev shuddered and fortified himself by looking round at the counters where food was arranged. He and his family had eaten nothing but bread; very little of that, for some months... An old woman; wizened, bent, a shawl over her head, stood muttering to herself while the Jewess examined a tiny gold coin she had given her. When she handed back the coin and shook her head, the old woman pleaded: " Please take it. It's gold. I know it's gold." The Jewess ignored her and looked enquiringly at the next in the queue. "You pig! You devil! You filthy Jew!" the old woman shrieked, her voice cracked and venomous. Then, when she noticed the doorkeeper; an old man in a brown uniform and with a divided beard, move towards her, she slunk out of the shop and joined the little crowd staring at its window display in the street outside... "I have," Captain Andreyev said when his turn came, "some gold to sell. Rather a lot." He unwrapped his parcel and displayed the model of a ship; made of gold; each detail perfect; even the name Katya printed in minute letters on its prow. The Jewess half rose from her place; and the expert examined the ship eagerly, taking off his rimless pince-nez and screwing a magnifying glass into his eye. "You'd better come and see the manager," he said. The manager was polite. He laughed nervously, and said, "If you don't mind we'll go and see the director. It's a lot of gold. Too much for me to handle." They drove in a car to see the director, the gold ship on the seat between them. When the car drew up at the headquarters of the Ogpu, Captain Andreyev smiled. "I thought the director probably lived here," he said. An orderly showed them into the commandant's office. He was in uniform; very smart; scented like the Torgsin shop; a dark, quick man whose features seemed to push out of his face and whose body seemed to push out of his uniform. He began to question Captain Andreyev. "How do you come to have so much gold when you know the Government needs it?" "I've got papers," Captain Andreyev answered, producing them. The commandant looked over the papers. "I see the ship was a presentation." "Yes, from an American liner. It caught fire; and I was able to be of some service." "So it appears. In fact, you saved the lives of the crew and passengers." "Some service," Captain Andreyev muttered. There was a pause. The commandant seemed to be thinking. "Why didn't you sell it before?" he suddenly asked. "I was fond of it. Such a lovely thing. So perfectly made. So accurate. And I liked to have it in my room, and to show it off to people. Besides, it's an exact copy of my own ship that I sailed for twenty years." "And now?" Passion swept over Captain Andreyev's face like a wind, twitching his mouth, trembling the corners of his eyes, drawing the skin over his cheekbones. "Now I need food. My wife and children need food very badly. She persuaded me. But I should have sold it in any case." An orderly brought in a dossier, and the commandant looked it through quickly. "I see there has already been a house search and a cross-examination." "I begged for the ship, and told them it was made of brass and no use to anyone except to me. They let me keep it." The commandant shut up the dossier and gave Captain Andreyev back his papers. "You're liable to arrest for having hoarded gold," he said. "Also the gold is liable to confiscation. As a class enemy with bourgeois antecedents you'd get a long sentence if I charged you. In view of the circumstances, however, I shan't charge you; and I shall allow you to have a third of the gold's value in Torgsin bonds." He smiled patronisingly. Captain Andreyev did not smile back, but bowed stiffly and left the room.
-p.147-52
Wraithby was not surprised to find Bramwell Smith and a Jewess sitting in the hotel lounge one evening. It was inevitable that Bramwell Smith should some time or other find his way to Moscow. "You'll be happy here," he said, "and appreciated here. It's just the place for you." Bramwell Smith told him that he was off to the Krimea. His small, blond, acute head was fastened on to his body without a neck. As he spoke his fingers splayed over the Jewess's knee. "Doris and Olga and Derwent and the children are coming out, too... he said. Already he saw himself advising the Dictatorship of the Proletariat; finger on its pulse; head cocked on one side; prescribing. "And you?" he asked. "I hate it," Wraithby said. "Some people can't see beneath the blunders and mistakes," the Jewess murmured. "I know," Wraithby said. "Back of this and back of that." "I felt bad myself when I first came," she went on. "Little things annoyed me. For instance, it annoyed me that they couldn't make beds. It got on my nerves so that I thought I'd have to leave. Now it doesn't any more. Isn't it queer that they can't make beds?" Like Muskett, she had her grievance against the Dictatorship of the Proletariat. "Why do you hate it?" Bramwell Smith asked. "Not," Wraithby answered, "because they're starving; or because they live in filthy nearness to one another; or because their lives are dull and unhappy; or because of the din of monotonous, shoddy propaganda; or because the bosses are megalomaniac fools and the rest terrorised into imbecility; or because you like it. In its very texture something absurd and trivial and barbarous. Every stale idea vomited up again. Everything that you believe in and that I hate. All the dingy hopes that have echoed and re-echoed over Europe for a century and now are spent. The poor little frightened soul of the Dictatorship of the Proletariat is what I despise. Not its works." "Supposing two or three million peasants do die this winter," the Jewess said mechanically, getting up. "What of it?" She was off to a lecture on the Film and the Class Struggle. As she revolved with the revolving hotel doors, red lips flashing like a lighthouse lamp, Wraithby understood pogroms.
-p.234-5
A party of German Jews sometimes drove out to the next-door house. They were fat, jolly men who played ball and did exercises in the garden. After dinner they would light their cigars, and drink a liqueur or two, and put on the gramophone. The Dictatorship of the Proletariat was irrelevant as far as they were concerned. They had their motor-cars and their girl friends, and did business in Moscow.
-p.240-1
Profile Image for Aaron Michael.
1,241 reviews3 followers
March 27, 2021
Firsthand account of 1930s Dictatorship of the Proletariat, mainly from the perspective of a western journalist, but Muggeridge does employ various perspectives. The book gives a taste of what happens when ideologues conduct their experiments in the name of ‘progress’. It is essential to recognize the impact ideology has on real, flesh-and-blood humans, even when the dogma is humanitarian. It is also important to realize how difficult it is for ideologues to reject their ideology when it is all they have hope in.
Profile Image for Bradley Brincka.
90 reviews
December 4, 2025
"...scarred and worthy veterans of a hundred battles for truth and freedom - all, all chanting the praises of the Dictatorship of the Proletariat. It was as though the Salvation Army had turned out with band and banners in honour of some ferocious tribal deity, or as though the organ of a vegetarian society had issued a passionate plea for cannibalism."

A biting and at times laugh-out-loud black comedy and satire of the early Soviet Union. Muggeridge lampoons the journalists, diplomats, and fellow travelers who fell for the regime's propaganda even as the country was in the throes of man-made famine and terror in the countryside. The fictional Western protagonists-amalgams of real journalists Muggeridge knew as a correspondent in Moscow-are equal parts cynical and credulous. Their character flaws and obsequiousness are reminiscent of the partygoers in Tom Wolfe's memorable 'Radical Chic.'
198 reviews
November 18, 2020
Much of this "story" is familiar. In 1974 I, spent about 10 days in the USSR visiting Moscow and Leningrad with about 20 Austrian university students. I was the only American and my German was limited. Moscow was as described in this book. We were closely watched with no opportunity to meet Russian citizens. Lenin's tomb was as described with the head appearing to radiate light. The cities were grey with monolithic buildings, mostly nondescript. Our guides kept us together. We took a train from Moscow to Leningrad. Cameras were not allowed in larger buildings and pictures from these heights were forbidden. The underground was cement, no graffiti or murals. This book took place at a much earlier time but the overwhelming feeling of being observed was the same. The advantage we had was youth and a certain foreignness.
Displaying 1 - 7 of 7 reviews