This is YA Christian fantasy and I would let a teen read this, they might appreciate it more than I did.
The words underwhelming and dissatisfying are what come to mind... For 464 pages, I finished this with far more questions than I would have liked to have had. This being a first in a series, I imagine following books will reveal more, but to me it felt like the author gave the reader nothing. Every time I thought something epic could be happening finally, I felt faked out.
The writing was flowery at the expense of being cumbersome, in my opinion. On top of that, it is written primarily in third person limited while dabbling in third person omniscient. It revolved around Finockt's character, the female protagonist, and then without clear transition switching bird's eye view to another character briefly for no more than a few paragraphs at a time and sometimes for only a sentence, before returning to Finockt. It was hard to follow. I wish there had been more dialogue, that would have aided the storytelling (since the female protagonist knows nothing the entire book). My experience reading this was akin to someone telling me they had a cool secret but dragging it out that they were not able to tell me for no reason at all for the reading time of a full-length novel. I also felt like the first third felt disconnected from the rest of the book. At one point, I thought maybe a love triangle was being hinted at but it never really felt clear. So much of this book was just unclear to me. The faith content fell flat for me as well.
The atmosphere (and my held-out hope something exciting would happen) kept me reading. This utilizes Celtic influences and medieval aesthetic. Most of my reading tabs were just underlines of pretty atmosphere. That is where the flowery language was nice. So if you're in the mood for a hyper-atmospheric read shrouded in obscurity, in a Celtic-inspired medieval fantasy world following the unfolding story of a stubborn YA female protagonist then pick this up! I am quasi-interested in picking up the second book, but not any time soon.
In this book:
-quest
-kingdom clash
-betrayal
-lost identity
-prophecy/legend
-Celtic themes
Content Guide:
romance - clean/very light
language - clean
violence - non-graphic
faith - medium amount
fantasy - very low/non-magical; the author has an IG post about the magic elements in this book being reminiscent of Lord of the Rings type stuff like glowing objects, etc., but idk, maybe that just didn't translate concretely to me on-page. As I alluded to in the bulk of my review, almost everything about this book felt obscure to me. I prefer non-magical so that was fine.
Potential Content Warnings:
-claustrophobia
-stalking
-grief