Edited 11/18/2023:
As an audiobook, this one was confusing, number-crunching, and nonsensical. Mostly game development stat sheets. No plot or character progression. Only 5% of this story was interesting and made sense to me, in audiobook format. Most of the time, I literally could not understand what was happening at all, even if I rewinded multiple times.
Super disappointed and frustrated. Try to refocus on the story at least more often than the mechanics, like in the first 8-10 books in this series.
Please write separate books, not in this series, to explain detailed game mechanics and the most highly detailed parts of tabletop role playing decision-making (like: Which abilities do I want? How do I calculate damage on this hit and in this situation?) that should be happening *behind the scenes*, not front-facing.
Please instead write ttrpg rulebooks or add-ons to explain rules and calculations.
Thank you. I'm sorry this is so harsh. I have followed all the books in this series and related Divine Dungeon and Completionist Chronicles series with devotion and joy for years.
I care deeply about the world, the characters, and what happens in the story.
I'm being critical in this review with the intent to guide or suggest improvement in the hopes that this series won't continue to seemingly lose its way but will instead course correct at least a little to retain readership.
There's magic in this series and most of its books, in the sense of an emotional, connective, brilliant creative work kind of normal real world magic. I don't want this series to lose that special, unique magic that makes this series wonderful amongst minutae. Or to have the autbors stop writing this series because they lose too many readers and get discouraged without understanding what could be considered to be done to stem that.
I took a break from the series for awhile kind of in protest and frustration. I just returned to listen to the next audiobook, Amenacida, and am encouraged that it seems like the authors are making an effort to reduce number crunching and nearly speaking directly to us readers about our feedback.
I'm sorry if I hurt the feelings of the authors or added to discouragement, was too harsh or scathing in my negativity.
I appreciate what they have done to course correct already in Book 15 and purchased Book 16 with renewed hope that they're listening and trying to adapt at least somewhat without losing their individual type and style of writing and voice and purpose.
I'd rather have a few stumbles like this book and then see them get their stride back than have the books stop because of poor reviews like mine was before editing. Please keep at it!