I have a lot of problems with this entire book, but the friendship was sweet enough for what should've been a middle grade read.
This was the first book I read for high school English. And like I said. Problems. Lots of problems. *Quotes Hamilton* This should be fun.
I'm sorry, this'll have spoilers, but at this point I need to rant:
Problem 1
The Characters:
Max: he spends way to much time walking for a 13 yr old. Just me?!
Kevin: I mean, he's fine. Like I felt sorry for him, but...
Gwen: is the only character I don't have a problem with. I even wrote a "why I admired this character" essay on her
"Killer" Kane: is a pyschopath who probably shouldn't have been in a book aimed supposedly at a middle grade reader
Problem 2
All the kids supposedly spend thier entire lives trying to make Max's life torture, bullying him about his learning disabilities (which I'll get to later) and his dad. Literally no one is that cruel. If you know something awful about someones family, you don't bully them, and make their lives hell
Killer Kane, Killer Kane, got a son who has no brain
Problem 3
When Max was three or four he saw, or possibly heard, his mum strangled to death by his dad. Obvioulsy his dad is imprisoned for it, and subsequently let out during the book, which he immediately breaks patrol and a restraining order, kidnapping Max from his house. Kevin (a kid on crutches, let me remind you) sneaks out of his house, saves Max, and Killer Kane is back in jail for life. For starters, this is jolty. There were maybe two mentions of his dad before this. Then the fact that it's wrapped up in time for a sweetly wrapped up ending. But wait. 20 pages left and... I'll talk yell about it later
Problem 4
Max clearly has a learning disablity, but the school doesn't make special modifications to the way his teachers, well teach him. No they berate him, and yell, and make him feel stupid like a goon (Because that's how they talk) There is a quote in this book that I can't seem to find, but basically the teacher (supposedly nice) says something along the lines of "we had you tested for dyslexia, but you didn't have it, so it was obvious that you were just stupid, but it's good Kevin has helped you be smart" What kind of school is this??!
Problem 5
Either, they talk like 8 years olds, using words like "goon" or they talk like an adult a wikipedia page. Not even adults talk like that!
Problem 6
Kevin's death isn't even that sad!! I'm sorry There's no emotionaly buildup, (a sentence I've been using a lot ) and the thing that usually brings me to tears is a characters thoughts and feelings over "what if I lose them?" There's none of that.
Problem 7
Max is so self absorbed. Not going to his friends funeral?? Not even realizing when said friends Mum moves away?? I was trying to be sympathetic, but I've just giving up.
Problem 8
Predictability. Need I say anything more?
Wrap Up
I've asked around in my class, and they either think the book is sad, and good, or bad, and still sad. Guess where I am. Neither. I'm literally the one person who reads. (I mean half the class didn't even read it!) and my opinion isn't even valid. (that's not true, my friend in class has heard me rant about this book many times, while still being uninterested)