Where do I begin? All I can say is that the 4.5 stars I'm giving this book is SO deserved, and if you have Kindle Unlimited, don't hesitate in rushing to download this book. It far surpassed any expectations I had of an underrated book by such a young author, and I wish more young people could write with this level of passion and understanding.
'The Prosperous Exams' is a sort of dystopian book, in a way. Set in an unnamed country with an exam system set up to fail, it looks at the unnecessary pressures of the academic system, the affect it has on people with mental health issues, such as Cyrus, the love interest, and people with dyslexia and other learning disabilities, such as Aiden, the misunderstood "popular" guy at school. There's racial bias, shown by side character Johnny's struggles, and a lack of opportunities for those who might mess up on the day of exams and never find an opportunity to excel at life again, which is shown through the tragic story of protagonist Raelynn's relative, who committed suicide.
I really enjoyed the way the PEs, as they were abbreviated, were shown to be a representation of exam structures across the world. The mimic the English GCSE system, in a way, with the kind of pressures one set of exams place on students across the board. I'm sure (from my extensive Derry Girls education) that the school system with its uniform and strict teachers in some way was inspired by the education system over in Ireland, which is where the author grew up. Rules are exaggerated in the book to prove their ridiculousness, as the book becomes an example of what society could become without support for teens with their own individual life struggles, and so on.
I really enjoyed that there were so many other sub-plots, however, which made the book not just inspiring, but enjoyable and heartwarming and quick to read. There was an emphasis on Cyrus's anxiety, which I found so sweet, and on terminal illness and grief, which was done so beautifully. Isabel's writing is tender and lovely and she writes her characters with a real rawness many authors struggle to capture, which was so nice to read.
Being Isabel's first book, I couldn't give the book a full five stars, because there were a few elements I think would be improved should she look back and edit the book in a few years time, with more understanding and hindsight. I could tell the book was written with the anger and passion of a student still at school, meaning a few things, such as rules about not talking back to teachers, strict uniform codes, and a general awkwardness about sex education lessons were written about with a distaste not entirely fair. The education system has a power divide for a reason, especially given the immaturity of Raelynn's peers at school, and I can understand that while some teachers are unkind for no reason, it's often necessary to keep boundaries in place. Rules around exams, homework and uniform are also important in maintaining discipline, and I think that could've been emphasised - as well as the importance of sex ed. I would've really enjoyed it if Isabel had laid out more of an example of how she thought the education system should be structured, as this was a little hazy and ambiguous.
Maybe I only picked out these things because I'm a few years older than the target audience... and haven't been in "school" as it were for about four years! But aside from a few minor issues I had, I honestly loved this book, and it'll definitely be up there as one of my top ten reads this year.
I'm so excited to see what Isabel does next!