What do you think?
Rate this book
Veil of Doubt
When a mother is charged with murder in a town already convinced of her guilt, can defense attorney Powell Harrison find truth and justice in a legal system where innocence is not presumed? Emily Lloyd, a young widow in Reconstruction-era Virginia, is accused of poisoning her three-year-old daughter, Maud. It isn’t the first death in her home: her husband and three other children all died of mysterious illnesses, so when Maud succumbs to an unexplained malady, the town suspects foul play. Soon Mrs. Lloyd is charged not only with poisoning the child but also with murdering her children, her husband, and her aunt. Enter Powell Harrison, a soft-spoken, brilliant attorney who recently returned to his Virginia hometown to help his brother manage their late father’s practice. Approached to assist in Mrs. Lloyd’s defense, Harrison initially declines, worried that an infanticide case might tarnish their family’s reputation. But as details about the widow’s erratic behavior and her reclusive neighbors emerge, Harrison begins to suspect that an even more sinister truth might lurk beneath the family’s horrible fate and finds himself irresistibly drawn to the case. Based on a shocking true story, Veil of Doubt is part true-crime thriller, part medical and legal procedural. Perfect for fans of Margaret Atwood’s Alias Grace and filled with rich period detail gleaned from exhaustive research, Veil of Doubt delves into the darkness of the South during Reconstruction, exposing intrigue, deception, and death.
368 pages, Paperback
First published October 10, 2023
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 171 reviews
November 7, 2023
4.5⭐️
Set in 1872, Leesburg, Virginia, Veil of Doubt by Sharon Virts is based on the true story of Emily Lloyd, a widow who stands accused of poisoning her three-year-old daughter Maud. Maud had been recovering from a bout of ill health when her condition suddenly deteriorates and the attending doctor voices his suspicions. Maud’s death had been preceded by the deaths of Emily’s three other children and other members of Emily’s family, which resulted in rumors with many convinced that Emily was somehow responsible. Though initially reluctant to take Emily’s case, Powell Harrison, a brilliant attorney who has experienced similar loss in the past, finds himself sympathetic to Emily’s situation and eventually agrees to take her case. The narrative follows her defense team, headed by Powell, as they leave no stone unturned in unraveling the mystery behind the deaths in Emily’s family and proving her innocence.
Veil of Doubt is an exceptionally well-researched and gripping work of historical fiction. Superb characterizations, consistent pacing, and a skillfully structured narrative that combines elements of social commentary, forensics, courtroom drama, and suspense make for an immersive reading experience. I found the details on forensics and the legal procedure/justice system of that era fascinating. Not only do we get a glimpse into the societal divide and resulting tensions and socioeconomic struggles in the post-Civil War era, but the author also addresses how issues such as mental health and women’s rights were perceived in those times. I was invested in the story from the very first page and as the story progressed, I found myself conflicted over the question of Emily’s innocence – sympathetic to Emily’s grief and losses she suffered and the judgment she faced but also suspicious of the inconsistencies in her story and her demeanor. Though I wasn't completely surprised by a few revelations toward the end, this did not detract from my overall reading experience.
Do read the brilliantly penned Author’s Note, where she discusses the true events that inspired this novel, the facts and fictionalized elements in the plot, and much more.
Overall, I thoroughly enjoyed reading this novel and would not hesitate to recommend it to fans of historical fiction based on real events.
This was my first time reading this author, and I look forward to exploring more of her work in the future.
Many thanks to Girl Friday Books for the digital review copy of this novel. All opinions expressed in this review are my own. Veil of Doubt was published on October 10, 2023.
Connect with me! ✏ Instagram ✏ My Blog ✏ The StoryGraph
Set in 1872, Leesburg, Virginia, Veil of Doubt by Sharon Virts is based on the true story of Emily Lloyd, a widow who stands accused of poisoning her three-year-old daughter Maud. Maud had been recovering from a bout of ill health when her condition suddenly deteriorates and the attending doctor voices his suspicions. Maud’s death had been preceded by the deaths of Emily’s three other children and other members of Emily’s family, which resulted in rumors with many convinced that Emily was somehow responsible. Though initially reluctant to take Emily’s case, Powell Harrison, a brilliant attorney who has experienced similar loss in the past, finds himself sympathetic to Emily’s situation and eventually agrees to take her case. The narrative follows her defense team, headed by Powell, as they leave no stone unturned in unraveling the mystery behind the deaths in Emily’s family and proving her innocence.
Veil of Doubt is an exceptionally well-researched and gripping work of historical fiction. Superb characterizations, consistent pacing, and a skillfully structured narrative that combines elements of social commentary, forensics, courtroom drama, and suspense make for an immersive reading experience. I found the details on forensics and the legal procedure/justice system of that era fascinating. Not only do we get a glimpse into the societal divide and resulting tensions and socioeconomic struggles in the post-Civil War era, but the author also addresses how issues such as mental health and women’s rights were perceived in those times. I was invested in the story from the very first page and as the story progressed, I found myself conflicted over the question of Emily’s innocence – sympathetic to Emily’s grief and losses she suffered and the judgment she faced but also suspicious of the inconsistencies in her story and her demeanor. Though I wasn't completely surprised by a few revelations toward the end, this did not detract from my overall reading experience.
Do read the brilliantly penned Author’s Note, where she discusses the true events that inspired this novel, the facts and fictionalized elements in the plot, and much more.
Overall, I thoroughly enjoyed reading this novel and would not hesitate to recommend it to fans of historical fiction based on real events.
This was my first time reading this author, and I look forward to exploring more of her work in the future.
Many thanks to Girl Friday Books for the digital review copy of this novel. All opinions expressed in this review are my own. Veil of Doubt was published on October 10, 2023.
Connect with me! ✏ Instagram ✏ My Blog ✏ The StoryGraph
November 4, 2023
Veil of Doubt, An Engrossing Courtroom Drama Thriller by Sharon Virts.
I love murder mysteries, courtroom dramas and psychological thrillers. Virts adds all these elements together in a very engrossing tale about a woman who is charged with murdering her husband and four children. Based on a real story, Veil of Doubt shines a light on a case that rocked a little town in post-Civil War Virginia in 1872. Emily Lloyd’s youngest child and only surviving family member has taken ill. The sheriff and many others feel that the earlier deaths of Emily’s husband and three children are extremely suspicious. Rumors have floated all over town that she has poisoned them all. After Maud, the youngest child, finally succumbs to her illness, the district attorney, the sheriff and doctors descend on the grieving woman and demand to do an autopsy on the child. Once they find evidence that Maud had arsenic in her system, they exhume the other daughter for further evidence and then charge Emily with the murders of her family.
Powell Harrison, a phenomenally gifted lawyer who has moved back to his hometown, is called to join the defense team. At first, his family is against him defending an accused child murderer. It’s a controversial case and Powell doesn’t want his family to bear the brunt of his decisions if the town turns against them. However, he has a strong sense of duty and believes that everyone deserves good representation. After meeting Emily, he finds she resembles his sister who died in an insane asylum - something in her mannerisms, something that causes him to feel overwhelming empathy for a woman who has been made to suffer at the hands of others. Against what everyone around him advises, he decides to lead her defense team. As Powell tries to piece the case together and dig into the history of Emily’s life, he begins to discover facts that will cast huge shadows of doubt about Emily’s guilt. However, he also finds hints of information that have him questioning who Emily really is.
Veil of Doubt moves at a really good pace while also adding details about the time period, the characters’ backstories, and the forensic science available in the 1870s. It reminded me of courtroom dramas like A Few Good Men, Primal Fear, and Suspect (each for different reasons that I won’t go into for fear of giving things away). I love Caleb Carr’s The Alienist and The Angel of Darkness and Virts has elements of that in developing her own historical fiction drama. While this book is based on a real event, she has made some changes in terms of creating some backstory, characters and a plot twist. However, her additions are pretty seamless and necessary to bring the story to life. Powell is definitely a hero in this story and if I ever needed a lawyer, I would want him to represent me. He’s brilliant and caring. Emily is a victim in so many ways and as Powell discovers all of the wrongs she has lived through, I felt more and more empathy for her and many women like her who were treated so poorly at that time.
I have always been fascinated by court cases and forensic science so I was intrigued by the many details that Virts included in the trial. Her level of research is impressive and I’m really glad she found a real case like this to focus on. I really had no idea how much forensics existed at this time. I also loved Virts approach to the plot twist element she added based on newspaper accounts that stood out to her during her research. Her blend of real events and creative license was really superb. I enjoyed reading this novel and would gladly try any of her others if this is what I will find each time.
Veil of Doubt is a perfectly paced courtroom thriller with flourishes of forensics that will excite fans of Caleb Carr’s Angel of Darkness or the TV series Law and Order.
I love murder mysteries, courtroom dramas and psychological thrillers. Virts adds all these elements together in a very engrossing tale about a woman who is charged with murdering her husband and four children. Based on a real story, Veil of Doubt shines a light on a case that rocked a little town in post-Civil War Virginia in 1872. Emily Lloyd’s youngest child and only surviving family member has taken ill. The sheriff and many others feel that the earlier deaths of Emily’s husband and three children are extremely suspicious. Rumors have floated all over town that she has poisoned them all. After Maud, the youngest child, finally succumbs to her illness, the district attorney, the sheriff and doctors descend on the grieving woman and demand to do an autopsy on the child. Once they find evidence that Maud had arsenic in her system, they exhume the other daughter for further evidence and then charge Emily with the murders of her family.
Powell Harrison, a phenomenally gifted lawyer who has moved back to his hometown, is called to join the defense team. At first, his family is against him defending an accused child murderer. It’s a controversial case and Powell doesn’t want his family to bear the brunt of his decisions if the town turns against them. However, he has a strong sense of duty and believes that everyone deserves good representation. After meeting Emily, he finds she resembles his sister who died in an insane asylum - something in her mannerisms, something that causes him to feel overwhelming empathy for a woman who has been made to suffer at the hands of others. Against what everyone around him advises, he decides to lead her defense team. As Powell tries to piece the case together and dig into the history of Emily’s life, he begins to discover facts that will cast huge shadows of doubt about Emily’s guilt. However, he also finds hints of information that have him questioning who Emily really is.
Veil of Doubt moves at a really good pace while also adding details about the time period, the characters’ backstories, and the forensic science available in the 1870s. It reminded me of courtroom dramas like A Few Good Men, Primal Fear, and Suspect (each for different reasons that I won’t go into for fear of giving things away). I love Caleb Carr’s The Alienist and The Angel of Darkness and Virts has elements of that in developing her own historical fiction drama. While this book is based on a real event, she has made some changes in terms of creating some backstory, characters and a plot twist. However, her additions are pretty seamless and necessary to bring the story to life. Powell is definitely a hero in this story and if I ever needed a lawyer, I would want him to represent me. He’s brilliant and caring. Emily is a victim in so many ways and as Powell discovers all of the wrongs she has lived through, I felt more and more empathy for her and many women like her who were treated so poorly at that time.
I have always been fascinated by court cases and forensic science so I was intrigued by the many details that Virts included in the trial. Her level of research is impressive and I’m really glad she found a real case like this to focus on. I really had no idea how much forensics existed at this time. I also loved Virts approach to the plot twist element she added based on newspaper accounts that stood out to her during her research. Her blend of real events and creative license was really superb. I enjoyed reading this novel and would gladly try any of her others if this is what I will find each time.
Veil of Doubt is a perfectly paced courtroom thriller with flourishes of forensics that will excite fans of Caleb Carr’s Angel of Darkness or the TV series Law and Order.
June 28, 2025
This review was first posted on Mystery & Suspense Magazine. Check it out for features, interviews, and reviews. https://www.mysteryandsuspense.com/ve...
This historical novel, set in the American Reconstruction Era, is based on real events.
In the aftermath of the American Civil War, the South is traumatized, angry, and facing economic difficulties. Mayor Robert Bentley of Loudoun, Virginia, up for reelection and under pressure from the taxpayers, looks at Negroes and indigent women as "millstones around the neck of the community."
So when widow Emily Lloyd, mother of four, files for her deceased husband's pension, Mayor Bentley says she doesn't need it, it's only greed.
The authorities, who already disdain Emily, become very suspicious when her family members die, one after the other. The official story, supported by Emily's physician, Dr. Randolph Moore, is that Emily's husband Charles died of heart failure in 1868; Emily's aunt, Elizabeth Hammerly - from whom Emily inherited a house - died from a flu in 1869; Emily's sons, 8-year-old Henry and 10-year-old Charles Jr., died from eating poisonous pokeberries, which they mistook for blueberries, in 1871; Emily's daughter, 5-year-old Annie, succumbed to cholera in February, 1872; and Emily's remaining daughter, 3-year-old Maud, died from a stomach malady in March, 1872.
This last misfortune is too much for the townsfolk, and Loudoun's Mayor Bentley and Sheriff Bernie Atwell decide to do something.
Mayor Bentley summons a coroner's inquest, and while little Maud's dead body is still warm, lying on her bed, two physicians cut the child open right in front of her mother. A subsequent analysis of the child's organs reveal that Maud consumed arsenic, and Emily is then accused of poisoning ALL her deceased family members, some of whom are exhumed for analysis.
For her part, Emily adamantly denies any wrongdoing and insists that someone else is responsible and that blaming her is a terrible mistake.
Attorney JW Foster decides to represent Emily.....
.....and asks his fellow lawyer, Powell Harrison to join him.
Foster insists, "Mothers don't kill their babies, and Emily Lloyd didn't poison hers. She's a decent woman and is entitled to fair representation."
Powell doesn't want to take on an infanticide case, but he feels he must, or Emily won't get a fair trial. In Powell's view, the prosecutor, Mort Kilgour, is not so much interested in finding the truth as he is in winning over the court of public opinion.
When Powell's wife tries to dissuade him from representing Emily by saying people will talk, Powell responds, "Let them talk. None of them give a cent about the truth. All they want is to dish out vengeance for all they lost during the war. When they aren't blaming the Yankees, they're blaming the Negroes or the poor."
In the end, Powell, who has experience trying cases against Prosecutor Kilgour, is lead attorney for Emily, with JW assisting, and Powell's law partner (and brother) Matt giving advice. A good part of the book is a courtroom drama, with jury selection; motions; testimony of experts; testimony of witnesses; and so on.
In 1872, many things were different than today. For example, the prosecution wasn't required to share discovery with the defense, and could actually withhold evidence; men had the 'right' to beat and choke their wives; property that a wife inherited belonged to her husband; and more. All this is relevant to the story.
As Powell and JW work on Emily's case, they recall Civil War events. JW was in a rat-infested Yankee prison camp.....
.....and Powell fought in the terrible Battle of Gettysburg, where he remembers the Yankees firing their big guns, grapeshot everywhere, riddled bodies dropping to the ground, and dying men being loaded onto wagons with limbs missing and gaping wounds.
A wartime tragedy also befell Powell's sister Alice. Union soldiers came to a farm where Alice was staying with a friend and ransacked the home, took the silver and all the winter stores, burned the barn, and seized the livestock. Later, three drunk soldiers returned and beat and raped Alice and her friend.
The novel is well-researched and has numerous references to real historical court cases as well as detailed descriptions of methods used to test for arsenic. The book has a strong religious bent, and the characters often quote the Bible and talk about God.
The suspense tale and the ambiance of 1872 Virginia will appeal to fans of historical mysteries.
Thanks to Netgalley, Sharon Virts, and Girl Friday Books for a copy of the book.
You can follow my reviews at https://reviewsbybarbsaffer.blogspot.com
October 15, 2023
A gripping, moving and shocking historical mystery based on a true story. I found the book to be well written, well thought out and paced. I appreciated the amount of research that the author did prior to writing this book.
Reconstruction-era Virginia
Emily Lloyd is a widow who has been accused of killing her three-year-old daughter, Maude. It is not the first time someone in her home has died. Her husband and their three children died mysteriously. Now that Maude has passed away as well, the town’s rumor mill is spinning. How could so many deaths have occurred in her home?
After Emily is charged, Powell Harrison, a diligent, hardworking and intelligent lawyer agrees to take her case. He will rely on his wits, the forensics at the time, and the interviews he conducts to represent Emily Lloyd and present his case in court.
I enjoy books based on real people and are inspired by real events. This one did not disappoint. I was instantly intrigued and wondered, like the characters in this book, how her entire family died in her home. How could this happen? I wanted to know more and enjoyed how everything played out. This book had a little bit of so many things that I enjoy in a book: mystery, forensics, legal/court procedurals, and the search for the truth!
Well written, gripping, and thought provoking.
Thank you to Girl Friday Books and NetGalley who provided me with a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. All the thoughts and opinions are my own.
Read more of my reviews at www.openbookposts.com
Reconstruction-era Virginia
Emily Lloyd is a widow who has been accused of killing her three-year-old daughter, Maude. It is not the first time someone in her home has died. Her husband and their three children died mysteriously. Now that Maude has passed away as well, the town’s rumor mill is spinning. How could so many deaths have occurred in her home?
After Emily is charged, Powell Harrison, a diligent, hardworking and intelligent lawyer agrees to take her case. He will rely on his wits, the forensics at the time, and the interviews he conducts to represent Emily Lloyd and present his case in court.
I enjoy books based on real people and are inspired by real events. This one did not disappoint. I was instantly intrigued and wondered, like the characters in this book, how her entire family died in her home. How could this happen? I wanted to know more and enjoyed how everything played out. This book had a little bit of so many things that I enjoy in a book: mystery, forensics, legal/court procedurals, and the search for the truth!
Well written, gripping, and thought provoking.
Thank you to Girl Friday Books and NetGalley who provided me with a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. All the thoughts and opinions are my own.
Read more of my reviews at www.openbookposts.com
October 20, 2023
Check out all my reviews at: https://www.avonnalovesgenres.com
VEIL OF DOUBT by Sharon Virts is an absolutely riveting historical fiction/crime mystery book based on true events surrounding the trial of a mother charged with the murder of her young daughter in 1872 Leesburg, Virginia. I could not put this book down from start to finish.
Emily Lloyd is accused and charged with poisoning her young daughter, Maud. The widow has tragically already had to bury three children previously and is considered odd even by her friends, who are few. The entire town suspects her of the crime.
Powell Harrison is a brilliant attorney who has returned to his hometown to partner with his brother in their late father’s practice. He is approached to take on Emily’s case. While he gets resistance from friends and even his own family, he feels he is the most experienced lawyer to help Emily. As the facts of the case emerge, Powell begins to suspect Emily’s erratic behavior might be hiding an even deeper secret.
This is one of my favorite historical fiction stories this year. I was completely engrossed from beginning to the end. The book is based around the investigation and trial for several murders supposedly perpetrated by Emily Lloyd. While some suspense/mystery books featuring court proceedings can be boring or dry at times, I never felt that way with this story. The way evidence was collected, tested, and evaluated was interesting and period appropriate. I knew where the character twist was headed before the ending, but still found it fascinating as well as discussions of other mental traumas related to the Civil War. The author’s research into the true crime case and the Reconstruction era is evident.
I highly recommend this compelling historical fiction/crime mystery based on a true story. Make sure you have time set aside because you will not be able to stop turning the pages.
VEIL OF DOUBT by Sharon Virts is an absolutely riveting historical fiction/crime mystery book based on true events surrounding the trial of a mother charged with the murder of her young daughter in 1872 Leesburg, Virginia. I could not put this book down from start to finish.
Emily Lloyd is accused and charged with poisoning her young daughter, Maud. The widow has tragically already had to bury three children previously and is considered odd even by her friends, who are few. The entire town suspects her of the crime.
Powell Harrison is a brilliant attorney who has returned to his hometown to partner with his brother in their late father’s practice. He is approached to take on Emily’s case. While he gets resistance from friends and even his own family, he feels he is the most experienced lawyer to help Emily. As the facts of the case emerge, Powell begins to suspect Emily’s erratic behavior might be hiding an even deeper secret.
This is one of my favorite historical fiction stories this year. I was completely engrossed from beginning to the end. The book is based around the investigation and trial for several murders supposedly perpetrated by Emily Lloyd. While some suspense/mystery books featuring court proceedings can be boring or dry at times, I never felt that way with this story. The way evidence was collected, tested, and evaluated was interesting and period appropriate. I knew where the character twist was headed before the ending, but still found it fascinating as well as discussions of other mental traumas related to the Civil War. The author’s research into the true crime case and the Reconstruction era is evident.
I highly recommend this compelling historical fiction/crime mystery based on a true story. Make sure you have time set aside because you will not be able to stop turning the pages.
February 14, 2024
Incredible! Great story, amazing writing.
Based on a true story. The author notes that there is more truth in Veil of Doubt than fiction.
Leesburg, Virginia, 1872
Emily Lloyd is on trial for allegedly poisoning her three-year-old daughter, Maud. In the span of eight months, Emily has lost two boys and two girls as well as her husband. She is now suspected of possibly having a hand in all of their deaths. Is Emily Lloyd a sociopath or just an unlucky widow?
With no one else willing to represent Emily, the local attorney, Powell Harrison, decides to take on her case.
...And she's alone. She has no man to take up her cause. She needs us. She needs you.
However, the further Mr. Harrison digs into this case, the more complicated it seems. Will he be able to convince a small-town jury of Emily Lloyd's innocence, or will the prejudices of the town prevail?
___________________________________________________________
I highly recommend this book! It's so good! I went back and forth on Mrs. Lloyd's innocence. It's such a complicated tale and so very well executed. Well done, Sharon Virts! You are now on my radar of authors to watch out for. 💞
Based on a true story. The author notes that there is more truth in Veil of Doubt than fiction.
Leesburg, Virginia, 1872
Emily Lloyd is on trial for allegedly poisoning her three-year-old daughter, Maud. In the span of eight months, Emily has lost two boys and two girls as well as her husband. She is now suspected of possibly having a hand in all of their deaths. Is Emily Lloyd a sociopath or just an unlucky widow?
With no one else willing to represent Emily, the local attorney, Powell Harrison, decides to take on her case.
...And she's alone. She has no man to take up her cause. She needs us. She needs you.
However, the further Mr. Harrison digs into this case, the more complicated it seems. Will he be able to convince a small-town jury of Emily Lloyd's innocence, or will the prejudices of the town prevail?
___________________________________________________________
I highly recommend this book! It's so good! I went back and forth on Mrs. Lloyd's innocence. It's such a complicated tale and so very well executed. Well done, Sharon Virts! You are now on my radar of authors to watch out for. 💞
October 2, 2023
3.5⭐️
Veil of Doubt is an historical, legal/medical fiction novel set in the late 1800s. Based on a true story, an insane amount of research has gone into this book. It is very detailed with medical information which was interesting. A totally different time in history, reading about the legal system and how things have changed for the better. Things that happened back then would not even be considered in todays world.
There is a huge emphasis on mental health in this book, and thankfully, much has change here too. I am thankful to be living now and not back then.
This is based on the story of Emily Lloyd, who was accused of murdering her family… her husband and 4 children. They say it was poison, they say she was insane, but was she? you will need ro read it to find out.
Thanks to Girl Friday Books for this advanced copy to read. I learnt a lot about this time period.
Veil of Doubt is an historical, legal/medical fiction novel set in the late 1800s. Based on a true story, an insane amount of research has gone into this book. It is very detailed with medical information which was interesting. A totally different time in history, reading about the legal system and how things have changed for the better. Things that happened back then would not even be considered in todays world.
There is a huge emphasis on mental health in this book, and thankfully, much has change here too. I am thankful to be living now and not back then.
This is based on the story of Emily Lloyd, who was accused of murdering her family… her husband and 4 children. They say it was poison, they say she was insane, but was she? you will need ro read it to find out.
Thanks to Girl Friday Books for this advanced copy to read. I learnt a lot about this time period.
September 19, 2024
I picked this one up on the recommendation of Carol at Book Reporter.com after she named it a Bookreporter Bets On Pick in 2023. I’m really glad I did!
Based on a true story about a young mother who was accused of poisoning her husband and young kids in the 1870s in Virginia, this is a mix of historical mystery/legal case/courtroom drama.
I enjoyed seeing the case unfold from the defendant’s lawyer’s perspective in great storytelling fashion. I also thought that the author (@sharonvirtsbooks) did a great job immersing readers in small town Virginia life and in bringing the courtroom scenes to life. There was also an unexpected great twist revealed near the end.
This was a slow-burn mystery but the author kept me engaged with an interesting plot clearly underpinned by research, fascinating characters and writing that just flowed off the page. I love historical fiction that brings events in the past to life, informing and engaging the reader. For example, it was interesting to see how flawed the 19th century state justice system was and how little was known about forensic science at that time and the impact it had on justice.
A really good read for those who enjoy historical fiction, mystery and courtroom drama! Make sure to read the very interesting Author’s Notes.
Based on a true story about a young mother who was accused of poisoning her husband and young kids in the 1870s in Virginia, this is a mix of historical mystery/legal case/courtroom drama.
I enjoyed seeing the case unfold from the defendant’s lawyer’s perspective in great storytelling fashion. I also thought that the author (@sharonvirtsbooks) did a great job immersing readers in small town Virginia life and in bringing the courtroom scenes to life. There was also an unexpected great twist revealed near the end.
This was a slow-burn mystery but the author kept me engaged with an interesting plot clearly underpinned by research, fascinating characters and writing that just flowed off the page. I love historical fiction that brings events in the past to life, informing and engaging the reader. For example, it was interesting to see how flawed the 19th century state justice system was and how little was known about forensic science at that time and the impact it had on justice.
A really good read for those who enjoy historical fiction, mystery and courtroom drama! Make sure to read the very interesting Author’s Notes.
April 11, 2023
3.5stars
Please refer to the synopsis if you are a reader who likes to know what to expect before picking up a book. There is a reference to Margaret Atwood which I can't speak to so the only comment I will make is that it is pretty much 100% a legal procedural drama and not a thriller.
The novel is a period piece set in the post Civil War America. The author clearly did a lot of research and combined it with her skill and passion as a writer, as a result her novel feels authentic and true to the historical period. Reading Veil of Doubt truly felt like I was right there with the characters and a part of the plot. The historical references contained within the novel are minimal so a reader can get away without knowing anything about the American Civil War, although I have to say some basic knowledge is helpful in understanding the bigger picture.
I pretty much devoured the book but if I had to point out any shortcomings it would be the lack of suspense. The synopsis promises a thriller but in my opinion the novel lacks the suspense entirely. You can clearly see the structure of the novel with its exposition, climax and the resolution but the writing style itself lacks the palpable rising action, the suspense, and the relief at the end. The novel is very easy to get into and has pretty much zero padding so the curiosity of how it ends takes over quite easily and carries you to the end.
Also, I am the kind of reader who appreciates when authors don't feel the need to overexplain. Which is not the case in Veil of Doubt. The novel misses multiple opportunities to use certain reveals as twists in favour of pretty much giving away the answer on the spot. Save for the ending itself, if you are not familiar with the true story of Emily Lloyd
The are also a couple of very interesting moral dilemmas being brought up, as well as an issue of mental illness, and it is such a shame these are not pursued in a more elaborate and creative way.
This is only Sharon Virts second novel so I would be eager to see how her writing evolves. I will definitely seek out her other novels.
*access to ARC via NetGalley
Please refer to the synopsis if you are a reader who likes to know what to expect before picking up a book. There is a reference to Margaret Atwood which I can't speak to so the only comment I will make is that it is pretty much 100% a legal procedural drama and not a thriller.
The novel is a period piece set in the post Civil War America. The author clearly did a lot of research and combined it with her skill and passion as a writer, as a result her novel feels authentic and true to the historical period. Reading Veil of Doubt truly felt like I was right there with the characters and a part of the plot. The historical references contained within the novel are minimal so a reader can get away without knowing anything about the American Civil War, although I have to say some basic knowledge is helpful in understanding the bigger picture.
I pretty much devoured the book but if I had to point out any shortcomings it would be the lack of suspense. The synopsis promises a thriller but in my opinion the novel lacks the suspense entirely. You can clearly see the structure of the novel with its exposition, climax and the resolution but the writing style itself lacks the palpable rising action, the suspense, and the relief at the end. The novel is very easy to get into and has pretty much zero padding so the curiosity of how it ends takes over quite easily and carries you to the end.
Also, I am the kind of reader who appreciates when authors don't feel the need to overexplain. Which is not the case in Veil of Doubt. The novel misses multiple opportunities to use certain reveals as twists in favour of pretty much giving away the answer on the spot. Save for the ending itself, if you are not familiar with the true story of Emily Lloyd
The are also a couple of very interesting moral dilemmas being brought up, as well as an issue of mental illness, and it is such a shame these are not pursued in a more elaborate and creative way.
This is only Sharon Virts second novel so I would be eager to see how her writing evolves. I will definitely seek out her other novels.
*access to ARC via NetGalley
February 5, 2025
VEIL OF DOUBT by Sharon Virts
Narration by Gary Hoffman was very good and I enjoyed listening to this. I also paired this with the book.
4.5 stars
A compelling read based on real events that pulled me in from the start. This is my first read by, Sharon Virts, and I enjoyed reading/listening to this story. Set in 1872 Virginia during the Reconstruction-era following the life of a young widow, Emily Lloyd. Within the first few pages, we learn of her unimaginable grief as three of her children have already passed away, and her daughter, Maud, is on the brink of death. The tragedy deepens as evidence suggests Maud was poisoned, leading to Emily's arrest for murder. Could this so called, loving mother really do the horrendous things she is accused of, or is there other evidence that could prove her innocence? You will be drawn into Emily’s story and her lawyer, Powell Harrison’s defense of her.
If you enjoy courtroom drama, you will love this read by, Sharon Virts, as you become invested in the case. Her research for this novel was extensive and well done. There is more truth in, Veil of Doubt, than fiction as you will read in the author’s notes at the end. The last sentence she writes in her notes is powerful and noteworthy. I’m looking forward to reading her new book, The Grays of Truth.
Narration by Gary Hoffman was very good and I enjoyed listening to this. I also paired this with the book.
4.5 stars
A compelling read based on real events that pulled me in from the start. This is my first read by, Sharon Virts, and I enjoyed reading/listening to this story. Set in 1872 Virginia during the Reconstruction-era following the life of a young widow, Emily Lloyd. Within the first few pages, we learn of her unimaginable grief as three of her children have already passed away, and her daughter, Maud, is on the brink of death. The tragedy deepens as evidence suggests Maud was poisoned, leading to Emily's arrest for murder. Could this so called, loving mother really do the horrendous things she is accused of, or is there other evidence that could prove her innocence? You will be drawn into Emily’s story and her lawyer, Powell Harrison’s defense of her.
If you enjoy courtroom drama, you will love this read by, Sharon Virts, as you become invested in the case. Her research for this novel was extensive and well done. There is more truth in, Veil of Doubt, than fiction as you will read in the author’s notes at the end. The last sentence she writes in her notes is powerful and noteworthy. I’m looking forward to reading her new book, The Grays of Truth.
October 10, 2023
4.5⭐️s rounded up to 5
Who would have ever thought I'd end up becoming a Historical Fiction fan? Honestly, it's become my 2nd favorite genre after thrillers. Now combine the two and I have a book I really like! This book did just that. It's a true crime thriller and medical/legal procedural that takes place in the late 1800s post Civil War. Based on a true story, I couldn't put this it down!
When Emily Lloyd's three year old daughter Maud dies of a mysterious illness, the town becomes suspicious. Maud is the 4th and last child of Emily's to die along with her husband and aunt. The town's people think that she may have poisoned them, and she is being charged with murder.
Attorney Powell Harrison is asked to lead the defense, but he initially declines. After he hears Emily's story, he believes something else is going on, and there is more to the truth. Can Powell help Emily and get to the truth?
This book was so interesting and completely held my attention. I was so fascinated with the characters and the trial. I thought the author did an amazing job with the legal/medical portion and telling the story of Emily Lloyd & Powell Harrison. Mental illness and how it was handled in that time period was also very intriguing. The author's notes are a definite must-read. I really enjoyed this book and highly recommend it.
Who would have ever thought I'd end up becoming a Historical Fiction fan? Honestly, it's become my 2nd favorite genre after thrillers. Now combine the two and I have a book I really like! This book did just that. It's a true crime thriller and medical/legal procedural that takes place in the late 1800s post Civil War. Based on a true story, I couldn't put this it down!
When Emily Lloyd's three year old daughter Maud dies of a mysterious illness, the town becomes suspicious. Maud is the 4th and last child of Emily's to die along with her husband and aunt. The town's people think that she may have poisoned them, and she is being charged with murder.
Attorney Powell Harrison is asked to lead the defense, but he initially declines. After he hears Emily's story, he believes something else is going on, and there is more to the truth. Can Powell help Emily and get to the truth?
This book was so interesting and completely held my attention. I was so fascinated with the characters and the trial. I thought the author did an amazing job with the legal/medical portion and telling the story of Emily Lloyd & Powell Harrison. Mental illness and how it was handled in that time period was also very intriguing. The author's notes are a definite must-read. I really enjoyed this book and highly recommend it.
October 12, 2023
What a great read! I am always on the hunt for a new thriller with a great twist and this book did not disappoint. The author brilliantly mixed fact and fiction into this well researched novel. While reading the book, you find yourself not knowing what to believe!
Read
August 25, 2023My newest client's second historical novel under a different publisher than her first.
September 24, 2023
*Paperback
This is a historical fiction, courtroom drama that centers around Emily Lloyd, a woman surrounded by deceased loved ones. Is she a murderer? Is she crazy? Is she innocent? Are there just a ton of coincidences, or is she a cold blooded serial killer?
This is in the same vein as The Murderess Must Die, which is another historical fiction courtroom drama. Both Murderess and Veil of Doubt are both excellent reads that will keep you entertained from start to finish.
I’m not usually a big historical fiction reader and courtroom drama is a tough genre to effectively write. However, I was totally engrossed by Sharon Virt’s Veil of Doubt. The testimony was interesting, especially that of the experts. I learned a lot about different chemical compounds and how they work, as well as learning about cross contamination of chemicals. The psych aspect of the story was also intriguing especially looking back in time over 150 years ago.
The ending was pretty cool but I read the authors note to make sure I was interpreting the ending right, and I was. It was eerie and just so well done.
I you have an interest in true crime (ok this isn’t true crime, it’s hisfic but has a lot of true crime elements), historical fiction, science, psych or legal thrillers you’ll probably enjoy this one. This would make a cool movie or mini series.
This is a historical fiction, courtroom drama that centers around Emily Lloyd, a woman surrounded by deceased loved ones. Is she a murderer? Is she crazy? Is she innocent? Are there just a ton of coincidences, or is she a cold blooded serial killer?
This is in the same vein as The Murderess Must Die, which is another historical fiction courtroom drama. Both Murderess and Veil of Doubt are both excellent reads that will keep you entertained from start to finish.
I’m not usually a big historical fiction reader and courtroom drama is a tough genre to effectively write. However, I was totally engrossed by Sharon Virt’s Veil of Doubt. The testimony was interesting, especially that of the experts. I learned a lot about different chemical compounds and how they work, as well as learning about cross contamination of chemicals. The psych aspect of the story was also intriguing especially looking back in time over 150 years ago.
The ending was pretty cool but I read the authors note to make sure I was interpreting the ending right, and I was. It was eerie and just so well done.
I you have an interest in true crime (ok this isn’t true crime, it’s hisfic but has a lot of true crime elements), historical fiction, science, psych or legal thrillers you’ll probably enjoy this one. This would make a cool movie or mini series.
October 12, 2023
If you love historical fiction, true crime, and legal thrillers, this one’s for you
“Veil of Doubt” (released date 10Oct2023) is a taut legal thriller filled with history, family relations, and more. Readers will be captivated by the crime, the investigation, and the startling conclusion.
Sharon Virts draws her engaging historical fiction - thriller intertwined with a legal procedural (based on a true crime) from newspaper columns, court cases, and local history accounts of life in 1872 Leesburg and Loundon, Virginia. She cleverly blends forensic science, medical practice, Reconstruction Era customs and cultural mores, and legal reasoning to investigate this complex case.
Story line:
“Veil of Doubt” is based on events are ripped from the headlines in 1872 in Reconstruction Era Virginia.
Emily Lloyd is accused of poisoning her young daughter Maud, her other children having died under mysterious circumstances, and perhaps causing the death of her husband. What about the other deceased members of her extended family? Did she hasten their deaths also? Did Mrs. Lloyd kill her family? Were the poisonings intentional or accidental? Who is the guilty party?
Local attorney Powell Harrison is known for his legal acumen. His keen mind turns to the puzzle of Emily Lloyd’s case. Harrison follows every clue from the complex autopsies to blood tests, from prescriptions to folk medicine. The tangled web of clues leads to some startling conclusions, all of which are detailed in the court case.
Sharon Virts also wrote
“Masque of Honor: A Historical Novel of the American South,” set in Loundon, Virginia in the years after the War of 1812 (published 2021) https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/5...
Thanks to the author, Sharon Virts, https://sharonvirts.com/ for an ARC to read and review
“Veil of Doubt” (released date 10Oct2023) is a taut legal thriller filled with history, family relations, and more. Readers will be captivated by the crime, the investigation, and the startling conclusion.
Sharon Virts draws her engaging historical fiction - thriller intertwined with a legal procedural (based on a true crime) from newspaper columns, court cases, and local history accounts of life in 1872 Leesburg and Loundon, Virginia. She cleverly blends forensic science, medical practice, Reconstruction Era customs and cultural mores, and legal reasoning to investigate this complex case.
Story line:
“Veil of Doubt” is based on events are ripped from the headlines in 1872 in Reconstruction Era Virginia.
Emily Lloyd is accused of poisoning her young daughter Maud, her other children having died under mysterious circumstances, and perhaps causing the death of her husband. What about the other deceased members of her extended family? Did she hasten their deaths also? Did Mrs. Lloyd kill her family? Were the poisonings intentional or accidental? Who is the guilty party?
Local attorney Powell Harrison is known for his legal acumen. His keen mind turns to the puzzle of Emily Lloyd’s case. Harrison follows every clue from the complex autopsies to blood tests, from prescriptions to folk medicine. The tangled web of clues leads to some startling conclusions, all of which are detailed in the court case.
Sharon Virts also wrote
“Masque of Honor: A Historical Novel of the American South,” set in Loundon, Virginia in the years after the War of 1812 (published 2021) https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/5... Thanks to the author, Sharon Virts, https://sharonvirts.com/ for an ARC to read and review
September 5, 2023
Emily Lloyd, a young widow in Virginia, is accused of poisoning her three year old daughter. What should be a horrible tragedy is being treated as a crime because Emily’s husband and three other children also died from mysterious illnesses. When attorney Powell Harrison is approached to defense Emily, he initially declines; he has just come back to his hometown to help his family and doesn’t want such a terrible case associated with his family’s name. But as Powell learns more about Emily and speaks to other members of the community, it is then he begins to wonder if something even darker is at play.
I was shocked to find out this is based on a true story! I had never heard of Emily Lloyd, but she was heavy on my mind after finishing this book.Set against the backdrop of a post-Civil War southern town, the mystery of what happened to Emily’s daughter unfolded. I love stories that are based in the South but have read little on this particular time period, so that was a refreshing change for me. What I found most intriguing was how Virts brought to light the subject of mental illness, the taboo that surrounded it and presented it in such an accurate light of the time. Sharon Virts clearly did her research and it showed! The author’s note at the end expanded on her creative process and added more information about the case as well.
Thank you to Sharon Virts for the ARC (and fabulous matching socks!) “Veil of Doubt”releases October 10, 2023.
I was shocked to find out this is based on a true story! I had never heard of Emily Lloyd, but she was heavy on my mind after finishing this book.Set against the backdrop of a post-Civil War southern town, the mystery of what happened to Emily’s daughter unfolded. I love stories that are based in the South but have read little on this particular time period, so that was a refreshing change for me. What I found most intriguing was how Virts brought to light the subject of mental illness, the taboo that surrounded it and presented it in such an accurate light of the time. Sharon Virts clearly did her research and it showed! The author’s note at the end expanded on her creative process and added more information about the case as well.
Thank you to Sharon Virts for the ARC (and fabulous matching socks!) “Veil of Doubt”releases October 10, 2023.
April 30, 2023
Veil of Doubt narrates the story of a woman on trial for the murder of two of her children. It’s a well told and well researched historical fiction. In fact, after reading this engrossing tald, I believe Virts could be either a chemist or lawyer considering all the details of both professions she seems so fluent in. In fact, the chemical procedures were so detailed that I admit, I got a little lost reading them. I think they could have been summarized and still maintain the readers’ interest. A few times, Virts refers to one or two jurors nodding off and I feel I did too, or at least I let my mind wander far from the page.
But in all, the book was fascinating, especially when you consider it’s based on actual historic facts. Themes of how women were viewed in late nineteenth century Virginia society, and how mental illness was treated were explored in depth and pulled back the layers that “polite” society used to conceal any actions behind closed doors.
A very worthwhile read and I appreciated all the sources included in the Acknowledgements if anyone wants to know more about the time period or facts surrounding this event.
I was given an advance reader copy and am delighted to write a review to recommend this book.
But in all, the book was fascinating, especially when you consider it’s based on actual historic facts. Themes of how women were viewed in late nineteenth century Virginia society, and how mental illness was treated were explored in depth and pulled back the layers that “polite” society used to conceal any actions behind closed doors.
A very worthwhile read and I appreciated all the sources included in the Acknowledgements if anyone wants to know more about the time period or facts surrounding this event.
I was given an advance reader copy and am delighted to write a review to recommend this book.
October 18, 2023
Another amazing and well researched novel by this author. The story she brings to life is based on true events. After her young daughter dies Emily Lloyd is charged with poisoning her and then further charged with the surprising earlier deaths of the rest of her family. Complicating matters is the issue of the state of Emily’s mental health and what was known about mental health in the time period after the Civil War. It was interesting to be transported back in time and to see how life was then and the limited amount of knowledge they had about so many things that we take for granted now. How would Emily’s case be tried today? As I said earlier an incredible amount of research went into writing this intriguing book. Pick this up if you are a historical fiction fan.
October 10, 2023
TITLE: VEIL OF DOUBT
AUTHOR: Sharon Virts
PUB DATE: 10.10.2023 PUB DAY
Happy Publication Day!
Based on true events of 1872 in the town of Leesburg Virginia, it's the story of a young widow accused of murdering her family and of the attorney who defended her.
I love historical fiction novels based on historical facts and events - this one has true crime twist, forensics work, with legal and courtroom drama - those of which make this book very difficult to put down, and has my fingers twitching to turn those pages.
There is a young widow Emily Lloyd, the accused, and Powell Harrison, the young but brilliant attorney who initially was reluctant to take the case, but the evidence surmounts to a case he eventually was drawn to. Emily is accused of poisoning her three year old daughter Maud and also the previous deaths of her aunt, her husband, and three other children.
I have always been intrigued with late nineteenth century forensics, and Virts exhaustive research on the case made the details feel like I’m a part of the investigative research of the time, and the legal-medical perspective writing was incredible.
If you enjoy reading historical novels, true crime, medical/ legal forensics, then grab a copy asap!
AUTHOR: Sharon Virts
PUB DATE: 10.10.2023 PUB DAY
Happy Publication Day!
Based on true events of 1872 in the town of Leesburg Virginia, it's the story of a young widow accused of murdering her family and of the attorney who defended her.
I love historical fiction novels based on historical facts and events - this one has true crime twist, forensics work, with legal and courtroom drama - those of which make this book very difficult to put down, and has my fingers twitching to turn those pages.
There is a young widow Emily Lloyd, the accused, and Powell Harrison, the young but brilliant attorney who initially was reluctant to take the case, but the evidence surmounts to a case he eventually was drawn to. Emily is accused of poisoning her three year old daughter Maud and also the previous deaths of her aunt, her husband, and three other children.
I have always been intrigued with late nineteenth century forensics, and Virts exhaustive research on the case made the details feel like I’m a part of the investigative research of the time, and the legal-medical perspective writing was incredible.
If you enjoy reading historical novels, true crime, medical/ legal forensics, then grab a copy asap!
May 22, 2023
I was really hoping this was going to be more suspenseful and thrilling than it ended up being, but with that said, it's still an interesting read. There is certainly no lack of detail within the pages, sometimes if felt a lot more of telling vs showing, and in some cases gave far too much away (if that makes sense as this is based on real events so if you are like me and were not aware of what it was based on, it just feels very over-revealing.) It's definitely more of a long-winded retelling of the real events rather than a thriller that kept my thumb at the corner of each page and I think that's where my biggest let-down lies.
March 25, 2024
3.75 rounded up to 4.
Okay sooooo I just finished Veil of Doubt which was kindly sent to me by her PR agent and I’ll admit, I was a little bit hesitant at first when they reached out to me. But after I read the synopsis I had a feeling I would enjoy this book and I was right! I was hooked, and I ended up reading the whole thing in one sitting late into the night and had so much fun annotating and guessing what actually happened.
Now despite really enjoying it I will say that the book went in a direction I’m not 100% sure that I love(will talk more about this in the spoiler section at the bottom of this review) The book is inspired by true events, although a good amount of liberties were taken which the author tells us about in the authors note at the end; which I really really appreciated.
There is talk of racism in the book due to the time period although the main characters are mostly progressive white savior types which I personally was cool with. And I’m glad there wasn’t any random racism unrelated to the plot (just mentions of types of people that feel negatively towards black people and women etc). There are a good deal of religious references made throughout the book which includes a good amount of bible quotes which usually isn't my thing but I didn't mind. Also the main character is a white male lawyer who has flashbacks to his service in the war which surprisingly wasn’t an issue for me as those moments were short and I ended up liking his perspective overall. (which seriously was a shocker after I realized that the book was not in Emily's perspective at all, ended up being a good choice end the end but I was questioning that decision at first)
I did listen to the audiobook as I was reading and annotating along with it and I think the audio was done well but I’m not picky in that department so take that with a grain of salt.
Lastly I had so much fun with the process of reading this book that I think I want to read more courtroom/true crime type books in the future cause it’s apparently my jam. I am hesitant to give the book a super high rating because it focuses on a thing that bothers me in books without deeper discussions on it. Regardless, I’d be lying if I said I didn’t still end up having a great time leading up to the reveals.
This is a book that I am really glad I gave a chance on cause my intuition was right and I ended up really liking it in the end. So on to the spoiler thoughts which are around the big reveal of the book so read on at your own risk:
Okay sooooo I just finished Veil of Doubt which was kindly sent to me by her PR agent and I’ll admit, I was a little bit hesitant at first when they reached out to me. But after I read the synopsis I had a feeling I would enjoy this book and I was right! I was hooked, and I ended up reading the whole thing in one sitting late into the night and had so much fun annotating and guessing what actually happened.
Now despite really enjoying it I will say that the book went in a direction I’m not 100% sure that I love(will talk more about this in the spoiler section at the bottom of this review) The book is inspired by true events, although a good amount of liberties were taken which the author tells us about in the authors note at the end; which I really really appreciated.
There is talk of racism in the book due to the time period although the main characters are mostly progressive white savior types which I personally was cool with. And I’m glad there wasn’t any random racism unrelated to the plot (just mentions of types of people that feel negatively towards black people and women etc). There are a good deal of religious references made throughout the book which includes a good amount of bible quotes which usually isn't my thing but I didn't mind. Also the main character is a white male lawyer who has flashbacks to his service in the war which surprisingly wasn’t an issue for me as those moments were short and I ended up liking his perspective overall. (which seriously was a shocker after I realized that the book was not in Emily's perspective at all, ended up being a good choice end the end but I was questioning that decision at first)
I did listen to the audiobook as I was reading and annotating along with it and I think the audio was done well but I’m not picky in that department so take that with a grain of salt.
Lastly I had so much fun with the process of reading this book that I think I want to read more courtroom/true crime type books in the future cause it’s apparently my jam. I am hesitant to give the book a super high rating because it focuses on a thing that bothers me in books without deeper discussions on it. Regardless, I’d be lying if I said I didn’t still end up having a great time leading up to the reveals.
This is a book that I am really glad I gave a chance on cause my intuition was right and I ended up really liking it in the end. So on to the spoiler thoughts which are around the big reveal of the book so read on at your own risk:
October 18, 2023
“Your task is to win. To win. And leave the rest to the courts of heaven.”
Reconstruction CSI. Before Powell Harrison can defend Emily Lloyd, he must discover who she really is. Everyone in his Reconstruction rural Virginia town thinks they know. He isn’t so sure. He’s not sure of lots of things. A well-told, convoluted tale of lies, murder (maybe), and for sure false lives. Not normally a fan of criminology procedurals, but Veil enthralls because it’s set 150 years ago yet tries to be true to the culture and technology of that day.
Having given up his talks with God, he was relying on the truth and his own wit to guide him. Tonight he had confidence in neither.
Though secondary characters tend toward stereotypical, the central cast is complex to the point of confusion. Intentionally. Accused may be crazy. Protagonist with feet of clay. Everyone in town has feet of clay, if not mud. Despite numerous Bible believers and quoters features the obligatory skeptic. Motives are mixed; realistic internal struggles.
“That’s motive. But to kill a child?” “I’ve witnessed enough senseless killings in the war to know better than to dismiss the possibility.”
Many social and cultural trends of the day are diminished if not directly relevant to the story. Little mention of the circumstances of Reconstruction in general or of the formerly enslaved specifically. Unfortunately that reduces the emotional impact of the story and minimizes the social injustices endemic to that time and place.
“When you’ve got facts, pound the facts. When you’ve got the law, pound the law. When you’ve got neither—” “I know, pound the table.”
Reconstruction CSI. Before Powell Harrison can defend Emily Lloyd, he must discover who she really is. Everyone in his Reconstruction rural Virginia town thinks they know. He isn’t so sure. He’s not sure of lots of things. A well-told, convoluted tale of lies, murder (maybe), and for sure false lives. Not normally a fan of criminology procedurals, but Veil enthralls because it’s set 150 years ago yet tries to be true to the culture and technology of that day.
Having given up his talks with God, he was relying on the truth and his own wit to guide him. Tonight he had confidence in neither.
Though secondary characters tend toward stereotypical, the central cast is complex to the point of confusion. Intentionally. Accused may be crazy. Protagonist with feet of clay. Everyone in town has feet of clay, if not mud. Despite numerous Bible believers and quoters features the obligatory skeptic. Motives are mixed; realistic internal struggles.
“That’s motive. But to kill a child?” “I’ve witnessed enough senseless killings in the war to know better than to dismiss the possibility.”
Many social and cultural trends of the day are diminished if not directly relevant to the story. Little mention of the circumstances of Reconstruction in general or of the formerly enslaved specifically. Unfortunately that reduces the emotional impact of the story and minimizes the social injustices endemic to that time and place.
“When you’ve got facts, pound the facts. When you’ve got the law, pound the law. When you’ve got neither—” “I know, pound the table.”
October 3, 2023
First I must thank @sharonvirtsbooks for my amazing package! This novel is based on the true story of Emily Lloyd and takes place in the 1800s. First let me say a crazy amount of time and research must have gone into this book. There is so much legal, medical and psychological information packed in.
It’s a slow burn with lots of color and well developed characters. I really enjoyed Powell and his forward way of thinking for that time/day. Emily makes for a sympathetic character and yet you never really know if she is guilty of innocent. Although this is a legal mystery, the pacing was well done and kept me reading forward.
I am going to have to go down a deep google dive now because the ending SHOCKED ME! I could not believe it and I definitely did not see it coming. What a wonderful way to experience this author first hand!
It’s a slow burn with lots of color and well developed characters. I really enjoyed Powell and his forward way of thinking for that time/day. Emily makes for a sympathetic character and yet you never really know if she is guilty of innocent. Although this is a legal mystery, the pacing was well done and kept me reading forward.
I am going to have to go down a deep google dive now because the ending SHOCKED ME! I could not believe it and I definitely did not see it coming. What a wonderful way to experience this author first hand!
October 9, 2023
I am not one who reads true crime often, I do not grab police procedurals and unless it's the Salem Witch Trials, I rarely (if ever) read courtroom dramas. But there is one author I would let drag me through each genre and pop out the other end loving every second of it. Meet Sharon Virts folks! This is my second novel by this talented author and I cannot sing her praises enough.
Veil of Doubt is based on the true story of Emily Lloyd. She's accused of poisoning her husband and little kids with arsenic in the late 1800s and noted in history as a serial killer. Over the course of the proceedings we witness testimony and behind the scenes questioning that lays the groundwork for a unique revelation at the end.
The research that went into this novel is exquisite. I seriously don't have another word for it. Using the setting, background and limitations of the era, Virts shows the painstaking efforts that went into each component of history, science and deduction to build two equally palpable testimonies. Novels like this typically go too slow for me, but each rebuttal and new reveal had me glued. I've never wanted to know an outcome as bad as I did this one.
I recommend looking at the true story after you finish reading. I'm impressed how much was spot on and how well Virts included the aspects surrounding mental health. The quotes, author's note and rich detail are some of my favorite parts.
I will note that a lot of the researched detail can occasionally feel like it takes over the narrative. I would've also liked a few more moments that showed the hints of Lloyd's predicament. Content mentions should include physical and verbal abuse, mentioned rape, mental illness, suicide, child neglect, animal cruelty and alcoholism to name a few.
Noted as perfect for fans of Margaret Atwood’s Alias Grace, I'd also like to add Hour of the Witch! Huge thank you to the author for considering me as a reviewer for her book baby. I cannot wait to see what she tackles next! If you enjoy any of the genres I listed, GET THIS BOOK! True rating 4.5/5.
Veil of Doubt is based on the true story of Emily Lloyd. She's accused of poisoning her husband and little kids with arsenic in the late 1800s and noted in history as a serial killer. Over the course of the proceedings we witness testimony and behind the scenes questioning that lays the groundwork for a unique revelation at the end.
The research that went into this novel is exquisite. I seriously don't have another word for it. Using the setting, background and limitations of the era, Virts shows the painstaking efforts that went into each component of history, science and deduction to build two equally palpable testimonies. Novels like this typically go too slow for me, but each rebuttal and new reveal had me glued. I've never wanted to know an outcome as bad as I did this one.
I recommend looking at the true story after you finish reading. I'm impressed how much was spot on and how well Virts included the aspects surrounding mental health. The quotes, author's note and rich detail are some of my favorite parts.
I will note that a lot of the researched detail can occasionally feel like it takes over the narrative. I would've also liked a few more moments that showed the hints of Lloyd's predicament. Content mentions should include physical and verbal abuse, mentioned rape, mental illness, suicide, child neglect, animal cruelty and alcoholism to name a few.
Noted as perfect for fans of Margaret Atwood’s Alias Grace, I'd also like to add Hour of the Witch! Huge thank you to the author for considering me as a reviewer for her book baby. I cannot wait to see what she tackles next! If you enjoy any of the genres I listed, GET THIS BOOK! True rating 4.5/5.
January 13, 2026
BOOK: THE VEIL OF DOUBT
AUTHOR: SHARON VIRTS
PUB DATE: OCTOBER 2023
⚖️⚖️
REVIEW
Thanks to Netgalley and the Publisher for this ARC. I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
⚖️⚖️
I'm always a fan of Legal Thrillers and good Lawyers, so it's not surprising I requested it. I liked it, it was very, very good. The Author did a good job in showing the story, I can see the research she did while writing the book. Let me just say I know more about arsenic and bismuth.
⚖️⚖️
Powell, our MMC, was an amazing lawyer. If I'm ever in a bind, I won't hesitate to hire. He's diligent, smart, a lover of justice, and always willing to fight for his clients in the right way. I liked him, his brother Matt and his friend, JW. I also liked that I got insights into his personal life
⚖️⚖️
Now, the legal case the book was based on. I loved reading the arguments between the lawyers. It felt like I was in court with them. I loved everything about the court case, but I don't really like the ending of the book.
⚖️⚖️
I empathized with the suspect, Emily Lloyd. She's had a lot of bad experiences, and losing all members of her family twice, it was really heartbreaking. But, I still suspected her throughout the book until I found out who the real perp was. I promise you'd never think of it, I didn't!
⚖️⚖️
I liked this book, i'd have given it 5 stars if not for the ending. Y'all know I love a perfect ending without any ambiguity. This book had an ambiguous ending, and I felt justice was not served. But, it's still worth a read(definitely! )
AUTHOR: SHARON VIRTS
PUB DATE: OCTOBER 2023
⚖️⚖️
REVIEW
Thanks to Netgalley and the Publisher for this ARC. I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
⚖️⚖️
I'm always a fan of Legal Thrillers and good Lawyers, so it's not surprising I requested it. I liked it, it was very, very good. The Author did a good job in showing the story, I can see the research she did while writing the book. Let me just say I know more about arsenic and bismuth.
⚖️⚖️
Powell, our MMC, was an amazing lawyer. If I'm ever in a bind, I won't hesitate to hire. He's diligent, smart, a lover of justice, and always willing to fight for his clients in the right way. I liked him, his brother Matt and his friend, JW. I also liked that I got insights into his personal life
⚖️⚖️
Now, the legal case the book was based on. I loved reading the arguments between the lawyers. It felt like I was in court with them. I loved everything about the court case, but I don't really like the ending of the book.
⚖️⚖️
I empathized with the suspect, Emily Lloyd. She's had a lot of bad experiences, and losing all members of her family twice, it was really heartbreaking. But, I still suspected her throughout the book until I found out who the real perp was. I promise you'd never think of it, I didn't!
⚖️⚖️
I liked this book, i'd have given it 5 stars if not for the ending. Y'all know I love a perfect ending without any ambiguity. This book had an ambiguous ending, and I felt justice was not served. But, it's still worth a read(definitely! )
May 12, 2023
Veil of Doubt - Sharon Virts
Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for providing this eARC.
This novel tells the story of a woman, Emily, whose 3 children (as well as her spouse) all die under mysterious circumstances. After her FOURTH child, a daughter, dies, Emily is arrested and put on trial for her murder.
Imagine the pain, humiliation, and stress of being on trial for murder in a typical scenario... Now think of how that would be multiplied if the murder you were on t trial for was that of one of your children, when you have already lost so much...
A fascinating story told by a talented author, Veil of Doubt will grab your attention, and hold it, until those responsible for determining Emily:s fate have cast their votes for her guilt or her innocence and the verdict is finally in.
I'How many deaths of immediate family members have to occur before make one seems guilty, rather than merely tortorously unlucky?
Did Emily murder her child, and IF she did, then WHY did she commit these heinous crimes?
Read this book find out the answers to all of the questions!
Until next time...
Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for providing this eARC.
This novel tells the story of a woman, Emily, whose 3 children (as well as her spouse) all die under mysterious circumstances. After her FOURTH child, a daughter, dies, Emily is arrested and put on trial for her murder.
Imagine the pain, humiliation, and stress of being on trial for murder in a typical scenario... Now think of how that would be multiplied if the murder you were on t trial for was that of one of your children, when you have already lost so much...
A fascinating story told by a talented author, Veil of Doubt will grab your attention, and hold it, until those responsible for determining Emily:s fate have cast their votes for her guilt or her innocence and the verdict is finally in.
I'How many deaths of immediate family members have to occur before make one seems guilty, rather than merely tortorously unlucky?
Did Emily murder her child, and IF she did, then WHY did she commit these heinous crimes?
Read this book find out the answers to all of the questions!
Until next time...
July 2, 2023
The book is so engrossing and mysterious. The prologue is heart-aching and the beginning of the book feels like a lot of things are happening. The book is filled with horror and grief. Mysterious deaths of family members and then accusation of poisoning a child was made. Could a mother kill her own child? While this story of Emily Lloyd and Powell Harrison’s defense of her are based on true events.
The case of poisoning follows the legal and medical procedurals to figure out the mystery. But it is twisted and complex. In the web of deceit, hidden truth and mystery, it seems that the characters have a mysterious demeanour. Some truths are so horrible that they fill one’s life with horror and grief turning the life upside down. The book has shared the odyssey of a young widow and a mother who lost her child. But the family history seems to be convincing enough. Though truth needs to be found.
The author has done an excellent job showing psychological, crime, legal and medical aspects.
Thank you Netgalley, Author and Publisher
The case of poisoning follows the legal and medical procedurals to figure out the mystery. But it is twisted and complex. In the web of deceit, hidden truth and mystery, it seems that the characters have a mysterious demeanour. Some truths are so horrible that they fill one’s life with horror and grief turning the life upside down. The book has shared the odyssey of a young widow and a mother who lost her child. But the family history seems to be convincing enough. Though truth needs to be found.
The author has done an excellent job showing psychological, crime, legal and medical aspects.
Thank you Netgalley, Author and Publisher
February 25, 2024
V good. For lovers of historical fiction, legal dramas, twists & turns this is for you...and it's based on an actual murder trial.
May 19, 2025
I would bump it up to 3.5
September 12, 2023
This is one of my favorite books I’ve read so far this year. It’s a historical legal thriller based on a real Virginia court case. It’s got medical procedures and mental health diagnosis 1870s style.
The book also gives insight into the impact of the Civil War on individuals who fought and lived through it.
The characters in this book are expertly written with a true depth. The trial of a woman accused of poisoning her child is fascinating. The small town gossip, rivalries, and alliances all add to the atmosphere of the read.
It’s a mix of a John Grisham novel that meets a Robin Cook book with a touch of NORTH AND SOUTH!
The book also gives insight into the impact of the Civil War on individuals who fought and lived through it.
The characters in this book are expertly written with a true depth. The trial of a woman accused of poisoning her child is fascinating. The small town gossip, rivalries, and alliances all add to the atmosphere of the read.
It’s a mix of a John Grisham novel that meets a Robin Cook book with a touch of NORTH AND SOUTH!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 171 reviews