I really wish Goodreads would let you use half stars for ratings, as it is a rating closer to 3.5 stars, but not as low to guarantee a 3 star rating.
Anyways, this is an interesting book as it marks a transitory period in DD's history: marking the very end of Ann Nocenti's run on the character and the very beginning of D.G. Chichester's, with both being pretty evenly split across the contents of the book.
Kicking off with the end of Nocenti's run: it’s close to perfect, but I honestly can’t tell if she was running out of steam to tell stories with old Hornhead or if she had some kind of behind the scenes editorial mandate breathing down her neck; either way I like her final arc here but I do feel it a bit rushed and incomplete. Smaller characters and their plot lines, biggest example I can think of are the judge and his son, appear and then just vanish without much of a satisfying resolution to their problems; even Matt's new love interest just… vanishes never to be heard from again. Part of it is probably the switchover to Chichester in Issue #292 immediately after Nocenti wraps ups everything in Issue #291. That being said though, the story is still fun and continues to explore Nocenti's central thesis about the need for Matt Murdock's dual identity in a morally gray and politically complex world in very fun an entertaining ways, especially with how she uses Bullseye.
After she wraps everything up comes the annual, which is fine as far as annuals go, not much to say about the story outside of "it certainly exists and is part of Marvel's multitude of mostly pointless Annual crossovers from the 90s"
And then after that comes in D.G. Chichester as the main ongoing writer of the book and is he able to live up to Nocenti? No, but I also feel that a lot of people give him unnecessary crap over the fact he had the impossible task of following up such a monumental run AND tell a story worthy of a 300th milestone issue.
The stories in between the end of Nocenti's run in #291 and the beginning of Last Rites in #297 are mostly fine, they’re not absolute masterpieces of storytelling, nor are they horrible or unreadable in any sense. They’re just fine stories that do have a larger narrative across them, even if that larger narrative is kind of lame and poorly defined. While Nocenti felt like she was rushing to end things at certain points, Chichester feels like he’s rushing to get things back up to status quo again.
Now, Last Rites itself is an interesting beast to dissect, mainly because it’s one of only two major stories that Chichester's run is remembered by (with the second one being Fall From Grace) and I actually really enjoy it. It’s not perfect by any means, I have a lot of issues with it’s plot conveniences and characterization of certain characters (*cough* Typhoid Mary *cough*) especially, but as a big milestone celebration of 300 issues? I’ve seen worse milestone celebrations (Avengers #200 for instance, not necessarily a high bar to clear I know, but still) and it’s pretty good by those standards. Now, as a worthy follow up to Born Again? Literally one of the most beloved, important and impactful Daredevil storylines of all time? Debatable.
The story acts as a mirror of the previously mentioned Born Again, whereas BA was about Matt's rebirth through the stripping of everything that made up his Status Quo at the time; Last Rites is the same idea but about the same thing happening to Kingpin and the idea of ultimate retribution for Matt being thrown in there as well, and it’s not horribly executed but it’s also not perfect. My biggest issue comes from the fact that it feels more like Matt taking advantage of Kingpin not really looking into who he was dealing with (A very out of character thing for ol' Willie) and Matt just more spreading the word of that, I get where it’s coming from, more of an indirect and smart approach rather than just DD busting into Kingpin's office and breaking every teeth in his mouth, but it also feels like it’s just a coincidence that happened because the plot demanded it rather than it being a deliberate play on Matt's end.
It feels as if the way the story plays out after the first chapter is more just a happy accident that just so happened to align with what Matt started doing after getting rid of Typhoid Mary. Speaking of her, I don’t like the way Chichester handles her, I get that she was Nocenti's character but man did Chichester drop the ball on her, the way she gets defeated is so dumb and out of character for her, I really didn’t like that at all.
I think my last complaint about Chichester's writing in general (not just in Last Rites) is his overly verbose Neo-Noir narration; I get it man, we all love Frank Miller's run, but this is really edging on annoying. Every panel is overly stuffed with narration caption that give out overly written text that describes a lot of unnecessary and mundane details, stuff that would be fine in, say, a pulp detective magazine where there are no pictures, but the captions obscure the art so much that it feels as if all that detail could just be inferred through the artwork itself without so much verbosity, let the panels speak for themselves man. It is a very bad case of "I wanna be Frank Miller" which isn’t necessarily bad, but it is a bit annoying.
But overall I still enjoyed Chichester's stories so far, sure it’s a drop in quality from Nocenti's insane antics and politically aware, openly critical stories, but it makes a nice change of pace and, if anything, it’s nice to see Kingpin get his comeuppance.
The art in general is super solid, Lee Weeks is the artist for most of the book and he does an amazing job, even when Chichester's narration captions just completely cover his beautiful art. Mark Bagley also shows up as a fill-in artist at the very beginning of the book with Issue #283 and you can never go wrong with that man’s art.
Overall a still solid experience, with issues yes, but honestly a lot better than I expected, especially given how I have heard people talk about Chichester's run.