Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Ghost Ships of the Great Lakes

Rate this book
This is the awesome story of the missing "ghost ships" of the Great Lakes, ships that disappeared, often in complete mystery, and were never seen again. The chronicle is a varied one: sometimes the cause was a titanic storm with huge seas and terrifying winds; or it was blinding snow that destroyed all sense of direction and massive ice that by its weight bore the ship beneath the surface; often it was mechanical failure or disregard of safety for the sake of gain. In researching this book, the author scanned thousands of old newspaper and shipping journals, read hundreds of letters from relatives of lost skippers and their crews, shipping company reports and files. The accumulated data reveal many crucial facts never before known, to document the chapters of this thrilling book.

Foreword
The luck of Mr. Murphy
The Flying Dutchman of Lake Superior
Hard times for the Benjamin Noble
Eight bells for the Clifton
Soft and brown ... with a touch of green ..
A matter of professional pride
... With the best of intentions
A very determined man
Where is the Kamloops ...?
Knives in the lifeboat!
The prophetic passing of Captain Napier
Don't change her name ...!
That damnable nuisance, Mrs. Doupe
... And then there were two
A family affair
"Telegram for Captain Stines"
Our Son ... and E.S.P

294 pages, Paperback

First published January 1, 1968

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Dwight Boyer

15 books2 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
15 (16%)
4 stars
43 (46%)
3 stars
32 (34%)
2 stars
1 (1%)
1 star
1 (1%)
Displaying 1 - 13 of 13 reviews
Profile Image for Denise Stacks.
3 reviews2 followers
July 1, 2014
Ghost Ships of the Great Lakes was an interesting book. Boyer explains in his foreword that this book is about ships that have been lost in the Great Lakes, but the reason for their foundering was not known. He calls them "Ghost Ships." So, if someone came upon this book expecting paranormal stories they would be disappointed. Although, Boyer begins the book talking about paranormal activity relating to Great Lakes ships. Perhaps he too was trying to make the book more appealing, especially given the title. Other than this discrepancy and the hokey introductions and conclusions, the book was interesting. Boyer researched each of the seventeen ships that he chronicled with tremendous detail. The photos included are helpful in getting an idea of what kind of ships he is talking about. It really made me want to know more about what happened. I actually looked up one of the ships to see if any more information had been discovered since the 1960s.
Profile Image for Mary.
393 reviews8 followers
January 30, 2010
After reading this book I'm anxious to share a couple of beers with an old mariner and learn tales of the ghosts that lie beneath the waters of Death's Door. Boyer takes a kind of CSI-approach to stories of ships that were seen as they left harbor but never returned. He researched the crew, sizes, cargo, weather conditions, and eye witness reports to piece together what might have happened to cause their disappearance. Boyer writes: "A peculiar breed of men are drawn to the seafarer's life, but beyond this common affinity for ships and the lonely life, they are probably very much like a cross section of any group of men drawn to a particular calling. They embrace the full spectrum of mortal man and his infinite psychological dissimilarities--his strengths, frailties, ambitions, loves, fears, hates, and the individual idiosyncrasies that are sometimes his delight, often his burden." Complete with historical pictures and etchings, this book is one that gives landlubbers a window into the stories below the waters, forever frozen in time.
Profile Image for Madeline.
866 reviews48k followers
April 8, 2025
It's hard to explain to people who have never seen them in person that the Great Lakes are not just lakes. They are, technically speaking, inland seas and are only classified as lakes because they have fresh water, and they're bigger than some European countries.

They will also fuck you up, as anyone who has heard The Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald can attest, and the bottom of every one of the five Great Lakes is a literal graveyard of shipwrecks. Dwight Boyer's book takes us through just a handful of them (most having sunk between the late 1800's and the 1930's, when it became mandatory for all shipping vessels to have radio equipment on board).

Fair warning for anyone intrigued by the title: no, this is not an anthology of ship-related ghost stories of the Great Lakes area, nor is it a chronicle of eyewitness accounts of supernatural sightings. This is a very straightforward history of famous shipwrecks, giving us the principle characters involved, the circumstances that led to the sinkings, and the aftermath. It gets pretty repetitive pretty quickly, because almost all of the stories can be boiled down to, "The ship left the port during bad weather conditions, it never showed up at the dock when it was supposed to, and we have no idea where it sank." And although Boyer will occasionally mention that residents will report hearing a distress horn years after the sinking, or see strange lights, this is definitely not a book of ghost stories. If anything, this is a fun guide to all the little islands that are scattered around the Great Lakes, most of which have turned into cute tourist towns.

But I have to admit that even though this wasn't what I was expecting, I couldn't help being totally charmed by this book, because the writing is fun and engaging, and you just don't get history books written like this anymore:

From the chapter titled Don't Change Her Name...!:

"In 1924 she appeared to be just what the Dunbar & Sullivan Dredging Company of Detroit was looking for in the way of another craft to tow and service their rather considerable fleet of dipper, hydraulic, and clamshell boats and associated gear. They bought her and immediately changed her name to Sachem, a title signifying the mightiest of Indian chiefs. Someone with a delightful sense of humor, probably an Irishman, is responsible for naming the assorted craft belonging to the Dunbar & Sullivan organization. They have some conventional names, too, but imagine tugs named Sachem, Shaughraun, Shaun Rhue, Spalpeen, Paddy Miles, and Nanny Goat. Fancy such names for dredges, big ones, too, as Omadhoun, Old Hickory, Tipperary Boy, Pocantico, Handy Andy, and a drill boat named Earthquake. Glorious!"
1 review3 followers
March 23, 2018
The book, Ghost Ships of the Great Lakes by Dwight Boyer is a very enjoyable read for people fascinated with the shipping industry of the Great Lakes in the 1860 - 1940 era. This book is also a good read for people who are interested in the Shipwrecks on the Great Lakes. This book is about 17 ships that went down on the Great Lakes. Some stories are narratives about the ship and the crew in their final moments, some are amazing rescues and mysteries that happened at sea. I personally liked the book, it definitely was not my favorite but it was ok. The book seemed to me to be drawn out, I selected the book because I wanted to learn about the shipwrecks. But this book has the days before the shipwreck, and the days after the shipwreck, and some stories includes details and documents about the court cases involved with the sinking of the ships. For this reason I give it a 7 out of 10. This book would be of the interest of people that want to learn about these shipwrecks and are interested in the old ways of Great Lakes shipping. I recommend this book to you for three main reasons.
One, this entire book is about these shipwrecks, it’s the main purpose of the book. All of the ships eventually sink, even if there is quite a bit of content in between the sinkings.
Two, this book told me a lot about the shipping industry of the Great Lakes, I didn’t know too much about it before I read this book. It has segments of different shipping seasons as well, the grain, timber, ore and fruit seasons. It has stories set in each of these settings. It doesn’t give you a specific everyday life account about a specific person on a ship, but views this topic as a whole, like the atmosphere of a ship during the different shipping seasons.
Finally, this book does have some specific dates and winters that are now known as “horrible shipping seasons’’. If you want to learn about how disastrous a specific season was chances are there is a ship in this book that sunk during that shipping season.
Profile Image for Alan Carlson.
289 reviews5 followers
January 30, 2024
Seventeen chapters, each with the mysterious loss of a merchant ship plying its trade on the Great Lakes when the storms come early. Mysterious, except for Chapter 7, recounting the loss of the SS Wisconsin, one of the few ships in the book with wireless (radio). When the SS Wisconsin got into trouble on its late October 1929 run from Chicago and Milwaukee and foundered off Kenosha, its young radio operator, Kenneth Carlson, stayed at his post to call for help, until the last moment when the electrical generator flooded and power was lost. Many souls were saved by the US Coast Guard and others, alerted by Carlson's signals.

Kenneth Carlson was my great-uncle, 20 years old in 1929, and I heard some of this story from him while I was a small boy. Ken's nephews - my Uncle Leon and my dad (Dale), both joined the US Merchant Marine in WW2 - as radio operators.

I find it ... intriguing ... how few ships were equiped with wireless, for decades after the first SOS was sent in 1909 and even after the 1912 Amendments to the Wireless Ship Act of 1910, requiring radio equipment and two operators on ships sailing the Great Lakes - if they had at least 50 passengers and crew, and sailed between ports at least 200 miles apart. Company directors (who did not sail on their radio-deprived ships) saved a few pennies; thousands of dollars were lost when ships did not get notice of sudden storms, nor did the self-same directors appear to spare expense in hiring tugs and chartering aircraft to look for their overdue - and lost - ships.
455 reviews
May 16, 2017
This is a compilation of many (actually too many) mishaps involving ships on the great lakes over the last roughly 150 years.
While somewhat interesting, the book became a bit redundant as it recounted episode after episode of gales and ship disasters.

The general takeaway (which was interesting to me) was:

There was (and still is?)a massive amount of commercial shipping on the great lakes. All types and sizes of ships were loaded with everything from automobiles to grain, wheat, corn, railroad track, iron ore, coal and more. The lakes are famous for gales (especially in November apparently) with dreadfully high seas, punishing winds, rain, and sometimes ice. Literally hundreds of ships have gone down in the lakes, many with all hands, although there have been some rescues. The reasons seem to include (in addition to the weather), lack of communication (it was only in the late 1920s that most had wireless), overloading, lack, of experienced seamen, captains who took chances, collisions in fog and urgency of delivery expressed by owners of the ships.

Although the author does describe individuals involved in various disasters and a bit of the rationale for young men to go to sea, it still seemed repetitious and I did not finish the book, although I did read about 3/4 of it.

I think it would be more interesting to anyone who lives near the lakes and/or has had family history with Great Lakes shipping. I did learn quite a bit, though!
Profile Image for Reese.
2 reviews
March 2, 2020
Dwight Boyer has created a great fiction book titled, Ghost Ships of the Great Lakes. This book is about ships that have sailed the Great lakes, but they've crashed. Dwight Boyer gives us pictures of some of the boats and tells us about each wreck. He talks about seventeen ships that have sunk in the Great Lakes.
In each Chapter, Dwight Howard, tell us about a ship. It talks about things like their crew, age of the ship, how the ship sunk, what the ship was carrying, where the wreck was found ( if it was), ect. It gives a short story to the ships that have sunk in the Great Lakes. The book describes the ships in great detail. Some ships in this book are the; Flying Dutchman, Benjamin Noble, Clifton, Kamloops, ect.
I would recommend this book to someone who likes ships or history, like a history teacher. I like the book, because It was enjoyable to learn about old timey ships and picture what they looked like. I did not like how misleading the cover and title were. Because the title “Ghost Ship of the Great Lakes” made me think it was a book about paranormal activities. This is still a good book about ships.
Profile Image for Nick S.
27 reviews
May 28, 2018
It was a very interesting book, although the premise of “ghost ships” means not all the details known about some of the sinkings. Some of the wrecks have been found since the book was written however, so additional information can be looked up online. Also, there is an odd overuse of exclamation points at times! Overall it was a great book though; I enjoyed it.
Profile Image for Ray.
169 reviews
July 13, 2020
Boyer doesn't get caught up int he floral writing of his era as much as you'd expect, and his knowledge of Great Lakes shipping (and shipwreck) history come through.

The interesting part about reading a 50-year-old history book is that there's been a lot of updates and some of these "ghost ships" (which just means they disappeared without a trace, not that there's actual ghost stories) have since been solved recently by scuba divers with side-scan sonar. That was an amusing follow-up as I read each chapter, and I noticed that most wrecks, if they had a Wikipedia entry, noted this book as a source.

Good stuff - now excuse me as I go hunt for the Marquette & Bessemer #2.
Profile Image for Jason.
Author 114 books3 followers
March 16, 2015
This is a solid collection of short pieces by Boyer about ships that sailed from Great Lakes ports and never returned, mostly pre-World War II. It serves as a reminder of how fierce the lakes can be in the winter and how little control we can have over our surroundings.
Profile Image for Tana Wold.
19 reviews1 follower
October 22, 2012
I love this kind of history. Shipwrecks in the Great Lakes have intrigued me since my first visit as a child to Lake Superior. Such mystery and intrigue of what happened to some of these ships.
Profile Image for Donna.
166 reviews
October 16, 2015
Just amazing when you read about all the ships that have been lost in the Great Lakes.
Displaying 1 - 13 of 13 reviews