This book popped up in my local library's catalogue when I was doing a search on either Nasser or Sadat. I have been reading on the history of the modern state of Israel, which of course includes four wars with Egypt. So my main impetus for reading this book was to add to my knowledge of 20th century Egypt, in particular the conflict between Egypt and Israel. But I also have had interest in other periods of Egyptian history. For example, when I read the novel River God, by Wilbur Smith, set around the time of the Hyksos invasion, it whetted my interest in ancient Egyptian history.
My interest in all things biblical also intersects with Egyptian history somewhat. In the chapter "Nubians, Greeks, and Romans," Tignor, somewhat credulously, passes along as historical the tales of Moses's exodus from Egypt and the translation of the Greek Septuagint from the Hebrew in the 2nd century BC. There is also a short chapter on Christianity in Egypt in which I learned about the existence of two forms of monasticism: Eremetic, represented by Antony; and Cenobitic, represented by Pachomius. I had heard of these individuals before and these types of monasticism, probably in a class I took on early Christianity back in the '70s. I have since forgotten all the details, of course. This chapter on Egyptian Christianity had just a couple paragraphs on Christian Gnosticism in Egypt, which made me sad, because that is a major interest of mine.
Of course the lion's share of this book is about Islam and its influence on Egypt. Just two chapters cover the entire period from 969 AD to 1798. I found these chapters the most difficult, probably because I’m not that familiar with this period of Islamic history and I’m more interested in the biblical and early Christian eras.
The chapters covering Napoleon to 1952 were more interesting for me. I knew about Napoleon’s relationship to Egypt but didn’t know many details. I didn’t know anything about Lord Cromer.
The chapter about Nasser and Sadat was the one I was most interested in. In many ways it confirmed what I already knew. It was nice to get a fresh perspective. Tignor sees many of Nasser's military judgements as mistaken, which is a different point of view than from their rather hagiographical viewpoint of Saïd K. Aburish, whose biography of Nasser I read earlier this year.
The chapter on Mubarak was in some ways a disappointment. Perhaps this is because compared to the Nasser/Sadat period which saw a lot of action, the Mubarak years were more quiet. It seemed to me that Tignor focused more on the cultural aspects of Egypt in the 21st century than on Mubarak's policies and accomplishments.
This supposedly short history still managed to run 320 pages of text, not counting notes etc. No doubt this is because tackling the entire history of Egypt which spans millennia is a massive undertaking. Tignor is a fine writer though, and I will probably be scoping out his other books.