No other modern British military campaign evokes as much emotion as the difficult and exceptionally lengthy operational deployment to Northern Ireland. Aaron Edward's new volume on the so-called 'Troubles' considers the strategic, operational and tactical level aspects of the British Army's longest ever campaign: the 38-year Military Aid to the Civil Power deployment in Northern Ireland, which was provided to support the local authorities restore law and order in the midst of sustained republican and loyalist violence. Codenamed 'Operation Banner' the Army's role went through a number of phases, moving from a peacekeeping stance in 1969-71, to a counter-insurgency position in 1971-77, finally ending in 2007, thirty years after the decision to scale back its activities in favour of giving the Royal Ulster Constabulary (and from 2000 the Police Service of Northern Ireland) primacy in counter-terrorist operations. An essential volume for anyone looking for insight into this historic conflict.
My several books include the critically acclaimed Mad Mitch’s Tribal Law: Aden and the End of Empire (Transworld Books, 2014; paperback 2015) and UVF: Behind the Mask (Merrion Press, 2017).
I have taught in the Faculty for the Study of Leadership, Security and Warfare at the Royal Military Academy Sandhurst since 2008, traveling the world to instruct on global security challenges, including terrorism, war and peace.
In my spare time beyond reading, writing and teaching I love walking, trekking and running.
A good book, providing a good oversight into the Northern Ireland Troubles, including the background to it, the different sects and forces involved, and the broader political, both nationally and internationally, elements.
I liked the timeline at the start and I think it tried its best to make sense of all of the different players on the scene. The images and visuals were helpful in breaking up alot of the text, but did it give it a bit of a textbook feel ( which I think it literally potentially is, so I can't hold this against it lol)
A fault of my own in that I didn't realise this focused so heavily on the 'military/ operational' aspect of the conflict, which I'm less personally interested in and so thus was harder for me to keep track of all the different groups / dynamics. But I actually think it was good to read something I wouldn't naturally gravitate too in this way, as it gave me a more practical and factual understanding of the conflict, rather than more political or ethnic - identity driven analysis.
I mean it's obviously outdated in bits due to it being published in 2011, particularly in its reference to Afghanistan and Iraq. But that doesn't take away from the substance of its analysis of the events that happened in Northern Ireland itself, most of which I believe is still the most current thinking.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
A very good overview of the Troubles in Northern Ireland, Operation Banner and the signing of the Good Friday agreement.
Whilst being short on space the author manages to convey some of the actions of all groups involved during the long period of the Troubles. There is definitely a concentration of the security forces (as opposed to the civilian casualties) but the author doesn't shy away from this area either and makes it clear that attacks on non-combatants occured throughout the period.
There is a stark reminder that the Peace Process did not make miracle workers out of the participants, or that this peace can be replicated elsewhere in the world where there are similar conflicts between groups on religious or historical grounds; but it does explain some of the reasons that NI got to the Good Friday Agreement and the end of hostilities.
A very good book, and of particular interest to me. I am British / Irish and when visiting Irish relatives during this period, my father could not join us. It was a stark introduction to a world that isn't always as safe as it should be.
An excellent short primer for anyone heading to Ulster to learn about the troubles or if you just want to understand the subject better - it’s very recent but already myths abound - this book is not that - it’s v true to the core details of its subject. Also packed with maps and pictures.
Great essentials histories about the Troubles in Northern Ireland. Edwards does a fantastic job giving history buffs factual information about this particular time in history .
Coming in with little to no knowledge of the history of Northern Ireland, this short accompaniment is a thorough starting point for one to understand the basic background that led to the quarter-century long conflict, the horror that entails it, and how the Protestants and Catholics reached an uneasy and fragile peace. It would be best, though, for one to expand their scholarly understanding through other means, were they to further understand Northern Ireland at hand. The author constantly referred "The Trouble with Guns" by journalist Malachi O'Doherty in this work, so perhaps that is a place to start. In light of the renewed sectarian conflict in the wake of Brexit and the death of journalist Lyra McKee, this work should come to the limelight once more, lest we repeated the mistakes of the past again.