What do you think?
Rate this book
William Monk #2
A Dangerous Mourning
Alternate cover edition for ISBN 0804110379 (9780804110372)
From the beloved creator of Inspector Pitt and his wife, the second in the Victorian mystery series started by The Face of a Stranger. No breath of scandal had ever touched the aristocratic Moidore family--until Sir Basil's daughter was stabbed to death. "A richly textured, masterfully plotted, thoroughly enjoyable story".--Kirkus Reviews.
From the beloved creator of Inspector Pitt and his wife, the second in the Victorian mystery series started by The Face of a Stranger. No breath of scandal had ever touched the aristocratic Moidore family--until Sir Basil's daughter was stabbed to death. "A richly textured, masterfully plotted, thoroughly enjoyable story".--Kirkus Reviews.
344 pages, Paperback
First published January 1, 1991
669 people are currently reading
2032 people want to read
About the author
Anne Perry
362 books3,377 followersAnne Perry, born Juliet Hulme in England, lived in Scotland most of her life after serving five years in prison for murder (in New Zealand). A beloved mystery authoress, she is best known for her Thomas Pitt and William Monk series.
Her first novel, "The Cater Street Hangman", was published in 1979. Her works extend to several categories of genre fiction, including historical mysteries. Many of them feature recurring characters, most importantly Thomas Pitt and amnesiac private investigator William Monk, who first appeared in 1990, "The Face Of A Stranger".
Her story "Heroes," from the 1999 anthology Murder And Obsession, won the 2001 Edgar Award For Best Short Story. She was included as an entry in Ben Peek's Twenty-Six Lies / One Truth, a novel exploring the nature of truth in literature.
Series contributed to:
. Crime Through Time
. Perfectly Criminal
. Malice Domestic
. The World's Finest Mystery And Crime Stories
. Transgressions
. The Year's Finest Crime And Mystery Stories
Her first novel, "The Cater Street Hangman", was published in 1979. Her works extend to several categories of genre fiction, including historical mysteries. Many of them feature recurring characters, most importantly Thomas Pitt and amnesiac private investigator William Monk, who first appeared in 1990, "The Face Of A Stranger".
Her story "Heroes," from the 1999 anthology Murder And Obsession, won the 2001 Edgar Award For Best Short Story. She was included as an entry in Ben Peek's Twenty-Six Lies / One Truth, a novel exploring the nature of truth in literature.
Series contributed to:
. Crime Through Time
. Perfectly Criminal
. Malice Domestic
. The World's Finest Mystery And Crime Stories
. Transgressions
. The Year's Finest Crime And Mystery Stories
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 554 reviews
August 28, 2018
4.5 stars. Another excellent story in this, my newly discovered hf series. This one had me completely stumped right until the end. I also like the way that in the books I’ve so far read in the series they end quite abruptly! Next!
April 27, 2012
I was so impressed by the first Inspector Monk book that I dashed to the library to get the next two in the series, of which this is #2. I have to admit I did not find it quite so entertaining as the first, but the promise is still there. The anticipated blossoming romance between William Monk and Hester Latterly does not seem to be going too well (they still don’t like each other), and Monk’s performance here as a detective seems less than stellar (at the end of the novel, Monk is standing outside the house, fired and disgraced, while Sergeant Evan does the arresting), but I shall definitely continue with the series.
The real interest in this novel is the depiction of the interrelationships between the upper and lower classes of Victorian society, in this case largely confined to a single family household: a couple, their three children and the latter’s marriage partners (one already deceased), the brother of the wife and the sister of the husband, and two grandchildren … and the servants: the cook, the butler, the housekeeper, two ladies’ maids, the scullery maid, the kitchen maid, the upstairs maid, the between-stairs maid, two laundrymaids, the parlormaid, the bootboy, the groom, and the footman (and there might have been two each of the last two). All of these had names, of course, and I found it difficult to keep; them all straight in my head (particularly because sometimes they were identified by first name and sometimes by title/surname) … all mixed up with the overflow of characters from the preceding book, from Hester’s friend & mentor, Lady Callandra Daviot; Monk’s superior, the disagreeable Runcorn; Sergeant Evans; and the lawyer, Oliver Rathbone, not to mention Dr. Pomeroy, Hester’s new superior, plus a couple minor characters brought in for a page or two. In case you lost count, that is 34 or more different characters, which is a bit more than I can keep straight in my head!
The chilling differences between high society and the lower classes (which to the members of high society meant everyone who was not) is striking. I am aware at all times that I am reading this as a 21st-century citizen of the United States with 20th-century beliefs and attitudes, whereas it is written by a Scottish woman who may find the social classes more familiar but is describing the society and culture that lived more than a century previously, but it is an education, nevertheless. It is sometimes confusing but always interesting--and once again I find myself glad I did not live in that time. It is clear that Ms. Perry has done a lot of research into contemporary language, devices, and warfare activities, and I have to presume that the depiction is largely accurate and true-to-life … and I would rather live here and now.
The real interest in this novel is the depiction of the interrelationships between the upper and lower classes of Victorian society, in this case largely confined to a single family household: a couple, their three children and the latter’s marriage partners (one already deceased), the brother of the wife and the sister of the husband, and two grandchildren … and the servants: the cook, the butler, the housekeeper, two ladies’ maids, the scullery maid, the kitchen maid, the upstairs maid, the between-stairs maid, two laundrymaids, the parlormaid, the bootboy, the groom, and the footman (and there might have been two each of the last two). All of these had names, of course, and I found it difficult to keep; them all straight in my head (particularly because sometimes they were identified by first name and sometimes by title/surname) … all mixed up with the overflow of characters from the preceding book, from Hester’s friend & mentor, Lady Callandra Daviot; Monk’s superior, the disagreeable Runcorn; Sergeant Evans; and the lawyer, Oliver Rathbone, not to mention Dr. Pomeroy, Hester’s new superior, plus a couple minor characters brought in for a page or two. In case you lost count, that is 34 or more different characters, which is a bit more than I can keep straight in my head!
The chilling differences between high society and the lower classes (which to the members of high society meant everyone who was not) is striking. I am aware at all times that I am reading this as a 21st-century citizen of the United States with 20th-century beliefs and attitudes, whereas it is written by a Scottish woman who may find the social classes more familiar but is describing the society and culture that lived more than a century previously, but it is an education, nevertheless. It is sometimes confusing but always interesting--and once again I find myself glad I did not live in that time. It is clear that Ms. Perry has done a lot of research into contemporary language, devices, and warfare activities, and I have to presume that the depiction is largely accurate and true-to-life … and I would rather live here and now.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
May 13, 2015
Description: From the beloved creator of Inspector Pitt and his wife, the second in the Victorian mystery series started by The Face of a Stranger. No breath of scandal had ever touched the aristocratic Moidore family--until Sir Basil's daughter was stabbed to death. "A richly textured, masterfully plotted, thoroughly enjoyable story".
Walkies!
This is the mediocre murder mystery of Ms Moirdore (Mordor) - in her very own boudoir, at that! Enjoyable enough as I tramped through newly sprouted spring green birches. Perry writes in a slow style that couches repetitious information which seems baggy in today's crime fiction world.
3* The Face of a Stranger (William Monk, #1)
3* A Dangerous Mourning (William Monk, #2)
2* A Sudden, Fearful Death (William Monk, #4)
TR Silence in Hanover Close (Charlotte & Thomas Pitt, #9)
3* The Shifting Tide (William Monk, #14)
4* Dark Assassin (William Monk, #15)
4* Execution Dock (William Monk, #16)
3* Paragon Walk (Charlotte & Thomas Pitt, #3)
TR Resurrection Row (Charlotte & Thomas Pitt, #4)
3* Death in the Devil's Acre (Charlotte & Thomas Pitt, #7)
TR Bethlehem Road (Charlotte & Thomas Pitt, #10)
TR Highgate Rise (Charlotte & Thomas Pitt, #11)
3* A Christmas Guest (Christmas Stories, #3)
3* A Christmas Beginning (Christmas Stories, #5)
2* The Sheen on the Silk
Walkies! This is the mediocre murder mystery of Ms Moirdore (Mordor) - in her very own boudoir, at that! Enjoyable enough as I tramped through newly sprouted spring green birches. Perry writes in a slow style that couches repetitious information which seems baggy in today's crime fiction world.3* The Face of a Stranger (William Monk, #1)
3* A Dangerous Mourning (William Monk, #2)
2* A Sudden, Fearful Death (William Monk, #4)
TR Silence in Hanover Close (Charlotte & Thomas Pitt, #9)
3* The Shifting Tide (William Monk, #14)
4* Dark Assassin (William Monk, #15)
4* Execution Dock (William Monk, #16)
3* Paragon Walk (Charlotte & Thomas Pitt, #3)
TR Resurrection Row (Charlotte & Thomas Pitt, #4)
3* Death in the Devil's Acre (Charlotte & Thomas Pitt, #7)
TR Bethlehem Road (Charlotte & Thomas Pitt, #10)
TR Highgate Rise (Charlotte & Thomas Pitt, #11)
3* A Christmas Guest (Christmas Stories, #3)
3* A Christmas Beginning (Christmas Stories, #5)
2* The Sheen on the Silk
November 16, 2021
3.5/5
The second William Monk mystery was equally good as the first but the involvement of Monk was a little bit reduced in this one and I like his personality at least the one he has after waking up with amnesia!
The involvement though of Hester Latterly because of her position was the more highlighted in this installment!
She and Monk in this installment find themselves in difficult circumstances and help each other and it was nice to see their dynamic in another light!
There were recurring characters such as Evan and Callandra Daviot who is my favourite! Also as ever annoying with his presence was Runcorn Monk's boss who is my least favourite character!
Interesting addition was that of Oliver Rathbone whom I also liked!
The mystery is focused around the Moidore family and their staff since the crime committed could only have happened from someone inside the house and as every family it has its secrets and minor or more grave crimes committed by members of the family and its staff!
Reading about the means of that era in investigating a crime and how easily some policemen were intimidated by powerful citizens I realized how difficult it is to bring the criminal to justice!
Once again Anne Perry does an amazingly good job at describing the atmosphere and circumstances of that era!
By the end I had a bittersweet feeling but I was astonished by the twist in the end!
The second William Monk mystery was equally good as the first but the involvement of Monk was a little bit reduced in this one and I like his personality at least the one he has after waking up with amnesia!
The involvement though of Hester Latterly because of her position was the more highlighted in this installment!
She and Monk in this installment find themselves in difficult circumstances and help each other and it was nice to see their dynamic in another light!
There were recurring characters such as Evan and Callandra Daviot who is my favourite! Also as ever annoying with his presence was Runcorn Monk's boss who is my least favourite character!
Interesting addition was that of Oliver Rathbone whom I also liked!
The mystery is focused around the Moidore family and their staff since the crime committed could only have happened from someone inside the house and as every family it has its secrets and minor or more grave crimes committed by members of the family and its staff!
Reading about the means of that era in investigating a crime and how easily some policemen were intimidated by powerful citizens I realized how difficult it is to bring the criminal to justice!
Once again Anne Perry does an amazingly good job at describing the atmosphere and circumstances of that era!
By the end I had a bittersweet feeling but I was astonished by the twist in the end!
December 15, 2021
I'm normally not a Victorian mystery fan, but this book (series?) is so well done. Monk and Hester and even Lawyer Oliver Rathbone are characterized perfectly. I got more than half way through and figured out the murderer had to be one certain person, only to have the rug pulled out from underneath my solution!
September 12, 2011
The first novel in this series seemed to hold some promise in putting an end to my quest to find another series to love, but after having read the second book I can honestly say this series isn't for me. I'm STILL searching...
The premise of William Monk having amnesia was a good story line and really added a lot of interest to the first novel. While I expected it to carry over into this second novel, I didn't expect so much repetition of it. Four months are supposed to have passed in time since the ending of the last story. I expected Monk to have done some investigating of his own life in order to discover who he is, especially because he would need to work the connections he had with any informants as well as navigate his hostile workplace. The idea that he wouldn't have learned more about himself in that period of time just isn't realistic.
I thought the story itself was far too similar to the first mystery in the series, so much so that it felt like a rehash of the same mystery, there were just too many similar ingredients. The entire story was tedious, repetitious and pedantic. There were far too many times where information was repeated without reason, the repetition only served to stall the momentum of the story.
Monk was unrealistically maudlen and the dialogue was often melodramatic and unrealistic. I found it hard to believe that Sergeant John Evan would be unfamiliar with the duties of a footman as he claims to be at one point in the story.
There are far too many unrealistic questions asked which only to offer the author the opportunity to educate the reader on the mores of Victorian life. When you choose to narrate a novel in the third person you have every opportunity to educate the reader without the need to insert unrealistic diologue in order to do so. And the education of the reader on the Victorian period was tiring.
The things that pulled me into the story in the first novel were not developed at all in the second novel. It's as if the author just repeated the same storyline without showing any growth or evolution to the characters. Most disappointing was the relationship between Monk and Evan which was virtually nonexistent in this novel.
Sadly I'm still looking for a good series to read...
The premise of William Monk having amnesia was a good story line and really added a lot of interest to the first novel. While I expected it to carry over into this second novel, I didn't expect so much repetition of it. Four months are supposed to have passed in time since the ending of the last story. I expected Monk to have done some investigating of his own life in order to discover who he is, especially because he would need to work the connections he had with any informants as well as navigate his hostile workplace. The idea that he wouldn't have learned more about himself in that period of time just isn't realistic.
I thought the story itself was far too similar to the first mystery in the series, so much so that it felt like a rehash of the same mystery, there were just too many similar ingredients. The entire story was tedious, repetitious and pedantic. There were far too many times where information was repeated without reason, the repetition only served to stall the momentum of the story.
Monk was unrealistically maudlen and the dialogue was often melodramatic and unrealistic. I found it hard to believe that Sergeant John Evan would be unfamiliar with the duties of a footman as he claims to be at one point in the story.
There are far too many unrealistic questions asked which only to offer the author the opportunity to educate the reader on the mores of Victorian life. When you choose to narrate a novel in the third person you have every opportunity to educate the reader without the need to insert unrealistic diologue in order to do so. And the education of the reader on the Victorian period was tiring.
The things that pulled me into the story in the first novel were not developed at all in the second novel. It's as if the author just repeated the same storyline without showing any growth or evolution to the characters. Most disappointing was the relationship between Monk and Evan which was virtually nonexistent in this novel.
Sadly I'm still looking for a good series to read...
May 28, 2018
Review written May 28, 2018
3.7 Stars - Enjoying old styled whodunnit mystery
Book #2
Maybe not as interesting and intriguing as the first part about Police inspector William Monk and the nurse Hester Latterly but whiteout doubt enjoying enough.
Monk is still lacking 95% of his memory and he is struggling hard with whom he is, both now and wath kind of person he was known to be earlier, then before the accident. His boss is still a unbelievable dumb jerk and it’s actually kind of nice to sincerely dislike that stupid man. The female character Hester Is the style of a brave and modern women heroine past then I truly like in books.
Yes, I will continue. Looking forward to start the next book (#3 - Defend and Betray) in this “never ending” William Monk serial (24 books 📚).
I listened to the 14:48 hours audiobook very very well narrated by Davina Porter.
I LIKE - Monk...
3.7 Stars - Enjoying old styled whodunnit mystery
Book #2
Maybe not as interesting and intriguing as the first part about Police inspector William Monk and the nurse Hester Latterly but whiteout doubt enjoying enough.
Monk is still lacking 95% of his memory and he is struggling hard with whom he is, both now and wath kind of person he was known to be earlier, then before the accident. His boss is still a unbelievable dumb jerk and it’s actually kind of nice to sincerely dislike that stupid man. The female character Hester Is the style of a brave and modern women heroine past then I truly like in books.
Yes, I will continue. Looking forward to start the next book (#3 - Defend and Betray) in this “never ending” William Monk serial (24 books 📚).
I listened to the 14:48 hours audiobook very very well narrated by Davina Porter.
I LIKE - Monk...
April 18, 2016
Overall a good book, but I didn't find it as interesting as the first. I feel like mysteries can depend on interesting investigators, an interesting crime, or a blend of both. In this case, both the mystery and Monk's development beyond confused amnesiac detective left a lot to be desired. Now, to be fair, confused amnesiac detective is a pretty awesome premise, but the author didn't cover much new ground for Monk personally in this book compared to the previous. His professional developments were interesting enough, but Perry mostly seemed to use this book to set up future novels, so it felt pretty flat emotionally. To be fair, Hester Latterly and a mostly new character, Oliver Rathbone, are both interesting, sympathetic characters, and I'm excited to see more of them. The mystery itself and its conclusion were disappointing. Personally I thought the resolution - or at least, the main antagonists - were fairly obvious.
As a very nitpicky sidebar, all of the characters are very definite about the fact that women won't be able to be doctors, never, ever, oh no, poor Hester. I would have liked at least a throwaway line about Elizabeth Blackwell and some hope for the future. EB graduated from medical school in the US in 1849 then studied in Paris in 1852 or thereabouts. She worked in England in the late 1850s and was a recognized physician there. Either way, 4-7 years before our characters come into contact with each other she had medical training and was recognized in the States and in Europe. Now, I'm not saying this would have significantly altered Hester's career path, but you'd think it would at least have come up in conversation.
As a very nitpicky sidebar, all of the characters are very definite about the fact that women won't be able to be doctors, never, ever, oh no, poor Hester. I would have liked at least a throwaway line about Elizabeth Blackwell and some hope for the future. EB graduated from medical school in the US in 1849 then studied in Paris in 1852 or thereabouts. She worked in England in the late 1850s and was a recognized physician there. Either way, 4-7 years before our characters come into contact with each other she had medical training and was recognized in the States and in Europe. Now, I'm not saying this would have significantly altered Hester's career path, but you'd think it would at least have come up in conversation.
October 12, 2018
This is book 2 in the William Monk detective series. I greatly enjoyed it. With the Victorian setting it reminds me of playing Clue as a child which was a game I loved!
At times there was a bit too much unnecessary dialogue which slows the pace of the story. So, I skimmed through those parts just to speed it up. That's my only complaint. Otherwise the author had me fooled on who did it! I was right on one of the culprits but I had thought my culprit was the murderer and he actually wasn't.....
I like Monk as a character and I'm interested in his life. I also like Hester more now. She kind of annoyed me in book 1. She was more real or admirable in this book.
I will be carrying on with book 3 and see what other adventures are to be had....
At times there was a bit too much unnecessary dialogue which slows the pace of the story. So, I skimmed through those parts just to speed it up. That's my only complaint. Otherwise the author had me fooled on who did it! I was right on one of the culprits but I had thought my culprit was the murderer and he actually wasn't.....
I like Monk as a character and I'm interested in his life. I also like Hester more now. She kind of annoyed me in book 1. She was more real or admirable in this book.
I will be carrying on with book 3 and see what other adventures are to be had....
January 3, 2013
This is the second book in the William Monk series by Anne Perry. There is a pattern to her books that I find intriguing, yet comforting. (I did not start with the first book; I read several later books in the series by Perry when I first discovered her. Then I decided to figure out where the beginning of the series was. It has cleared up so many questions for me!) They all seem to be about 12 to 13 chapters long; the beginning is usually about Monk and nurse Hester Latterly working on a new case (Monk is first with the police department in London, but then quits to become a private investigator after quarreling with his vitriolic boss, Runcorn); as the case develops, it becomes entangled with a case that Oliver Rathbone (barrister extraordinaire and friend to both Hester and Monk)is involoved in. When we are certain that Rathbone will lose his case, Monk and Hester dig up some information that saves the day. Meanwhile, though, we are treated to the foggy, atmospheric climate of London--primarily along the Thames River--during the 19th century. Perry includes references to America and the Civil War, along with references to the recently-fought Crimean War, in which Hester served as a nurse alongside Florence Nightengale. And like the first book, Monk is struggling to find out about his past and what kind of man he was before his terrible accident.
April 30, 2023
Libro corposo in cui l'autrice fa un'approfondita descrizione della società vittoriana dei quartieri alti, soffermandosi anche su ambienti, arredamento, abbigliamento e rallentando forse un po' il ritmo del racconto e della trama 'gialla'. Ma non si può non rimanere affascinati da tutto ciò e da come il delitto si inserisce perfettamente, alla fine, nella mentalità dei personaggi descritti.
Solo alla fine si scoprirà quale è stato però il vero delitto commesso!!!
RILETTURA APRILE 2023
Ho ricominciato a leggere la serie di Monk proprio poco prima che l'autrice venisse a mancare. Ora che ho una conoscenza approfondita delle sue opere, apprezzo ancor più il gusto del dettaglio, la precisione delle descrizioni e quel modo tutto suo di sorprendere il lettore alle ultimissime pagine.
Solo alla fine si scoprirà quale è stato però il vero delitto commesso!!!
RILETTURA APRILE 2023
Ho ricominciato a leggere la serie di Monk proprio poco prima che l'autrice venisse a mancare. Ora che ho una conoscenza approfondita delle sue opere, apprezzo ancor più il gusto del dettaglio, la precisione delle descrizioni e quel modo tutto suo di sorprendere il lettore alle ultimissime pagine.
February 7, 2019
With a book by Anne Perry, you not only get a good mystery, but you learn about cultural mores, what life is like in Victorian London, court procedures and even some information of what is eaten. This is the second of the series with Policeman, William Monk, who has lost most of his memory due to an accident. There are some changes in his life during this book, and I look forward to his further sleuthing.
May 28, 2017
I love how the two main characters pretend to despise each other, but secretly really like each other.
Also, the plot was great, yet also shows a different side to the 1850's.
Also, the plot was great, yet also shows a different side to the 1850's.
June 8, 2011
http://yearningtoread.blogspot.com/
The case is dangerous: the murder of a young woman of society, stabbed to death in her own room and a few trinkets stolen. Inspector William Monk takes on the case, still lacking 95% of his memory but determined to keep this loss a secret and prove himself worthy. It seems a simple endeavor, but the case becomes more and more complicated with time. Monk is able to prove that the murderer attacked from within the house, a feat that could only be accomplished by someone living in the house. It being practically a crime itself to accuse a member of high society of being a criminal, Monk's reputation is on the line. Was the murderer a servant, like society says it should be? Or was he a family member, harboring a dark secret? And Monk has his own problems to attend to, more personal and deeper than anything he's ever experienced - or so they tell him. Who is he? Why does he have the reputation he has? Who will he become without his memory? With these questions never ceasing, and the murder case honing in on him, Monk must face problems and consequences he never foresaw.
___________________________________
My thoughts -
I normally don't read mysteries. They intrigue me, but I'm not motivated to read them like I am a good fantasy/dystopian book. That is, I'm not motivated to read mysteries other than the William Monk mysteries, which are some of the greatest books around. I could rave for hours about the genius of these books. They provide incredible, life-like characters, situations that are out of the ordinary but not hard to believe, insight into the Victorian era in England like only a Victorian novelist could give, and phenomenal mysteries that have you guessing until the very end. Literally, the last few pages.
Have I caught your attention yet?
If I haven't, keep reading and I hope by the time you finish reading this review you'll have made up your mind to start reading this incredible series.
Character notes -
The characters in Anne Perry's novels seem, to me, as real as any one I can see or hear or interact with. They are full to the brim with wonderful liveliness and incredible depth, human desires, strengths, and weaknesses. This is hard to come by these days in a near perfect way - but Anne Perry has nailed it and I can't tell you how much it inspires me.
Monk is one of those "tragically wonderful" characters who I love and adore. I can't get enough of him. Whatever he does is interesting, whether its solving a crime or discovering things about his past. I admire him and love his journey as he discovers how proud he was in the past and is humbled. He and Hester are the perfect duo for these books...how I love their arguments!
Runcorn and Evan are great characters as well. The Lord Basil and his wife Beatrice, their son and daughters, their brothers and sisters, their servants - all of them had me captivated. There is a sense of human desperation in these stories that is very real and easy to relate to. Everyone, tried and exhausted and frustrated, trying to make sense of it all, no one trusting, everyone confused - it is stunning to read and makes for an intensity that builds and builds and builds and finally bursts. Wonderfully done, Perry!
Hester has a greater part in this story than the last (actually, half of the book is from her perspective). I feel like I should say this in case anyone is expecting just Monk's perspective and is possibly frustrated (as I was at first). But Hester is a fun character and brings a lot to the story, so if you go into it expecting that, you'll love it from the first!
Story notes -
While character development and interaction is a major focus (and one of the main ways the author uses to solve the mystery), Anne Perry uses incredible details and events to set up the story, create a conflict, and solve the crime. A few scenes had me cringing (or freaking out, haha!) because it was so intense and I had no idea what was going to happen and I didn't want one thing to happen... Or I was just plain stumped.
This book, just like its predecessor, was not a "fast" read for me. For me, it was intense, yes, and very interesting and satisfying and incredible, but it's one of those books I feel like I have to read slower to get all the details... The details are meant to be soaked in. Let's say you ate a really sweet strawberry really fast and didn't let the taste linger on your tongue...how sad! You wouldn't get the full potential of that wonderfully tasting strawberry! It's the same with these books. If you don't savor them, you might miss out on some incredible details that make the story all the more fantasic. That is what I love about these books. They make me slow down and focus on the little things; they make me forget about the next book I have to read and just enjoy; they make me appreciate slow-building intensity.
One word to sum it up (final thoughts) -
Stunning. This is some of the best prose out there, a lovely combination of mystery and historical fiction, of detail and story and character. And it's all tied up perfectly at the end, leaving you surprised at the turn the story took in just the last ten pages, and totally in love with good literature, Victorian England, and William Monk. Is there anything not to love? Need I say more?
For the parents: These are not children's books; whether or not they are young adult books is everyone's personal opinion. There is nothing sexual, and there is little bad language. However, the subject matter and the violence and possible psychotic killer can be very intense for certain readers. One character is stabbed mercilessly and left for dead (details not shown, but the inferred could be enough to make a more sensitive reader uncomfortable to the point of dislike); there are a few references to rape and how to rape a Lord's daughter is a crime, but to rape the same Lord's servant is pardonable. Over all a profound book and recommended to every adult, and most older teens out there!
The case is dangerous: the murder of a young woman of society, stabbed to death in her own room and a few trinkets stolen. Inspector William Monk takes on the case, still lacking 95% of his memory but determined to keep this loss a secret and prove himself worthy. It seems a simple endeavor, but the case becomes more and more complicated with time. Monk is able to prove that the murderer attacked from within the house, a feat that could only be accomplished by someone living in the house. It being practically a crime itself to accuse a member of high society of being a criminal, Monk's reputation is on the line. Was the murderer a servant, like society says it should be? Or was he a family member, harboring a dark secret? And Monk has his own problems to attend to, more personal and deeper than anything he's ever experienced - or so they tell him. Who is he? Why does he have the reputation he has? Who will he become without his memory? With these questions never ceasing, and the murder case honing in on him, Monk must face problems and consequences he never foresaw.
___________________________________
My thoughts -
I normally don't read mysteries. They intrigue me, but I'm not motivated to read them like I am a good fantasy/dystopian book. That is, I'm not motivated to read mysteries other than the William Monk mysteries, which are some of the greatest books around. I could rave for hours about the genius of these books. They provide incredible, life-like characters, situations that are out of the ordinary but not hard to believe, insight into the Victorian era in England like only a Victorian novelist could give, and phenomenal mysteries that have you guessing until the very end. Literally, the last few pages.
Have I caught your attention yet?
If I haven't, keep reading and I hope by the time you finish reading this review you'll have made up your mind to start reading this incredible series.
Character notes -
The characters in Anne Perry's novels seem, to me, as real as any one I can see or hear or interact with. They are full to the brim with wonderful liveliness and incredible depth, human desires, strengths, and weaknesses. This is hard to come by these days in a near perfect way - but Anne Perry has nailed it and I can't tell you how much it inspires me.
Monk is one of those "tragically wonderful" characters who I love and adore. I can't get enough of him. Whatever he does is interesting, whether its solving a crime or discovering things about his past. I admire him and love his journey as he discovers how proud he was in the past and is humbled. He and Hester are the perfect duo for these books...how I love their arguments!
Runcorn and Evan are great characters as well. The Lord Basil and his wife Beatrice, their son and daughters, their brothers and sisters, their servants - all of them had me captivated. There is a sense of human desperation in these stories that is very real and easy to relate to. Everyone, tried and exhausted and frustrated, trying to make sense of it all, no one trusting, everyone confused - it is stunning to read and makes for an intensity that builds and builds and builds and finally bursts. Wonderfully done, Perry!
Hester has a greater part in this story than the last (actually, half of the book is from her perspective). I feel like I should say this in case anyone is expecting just Monk's perspective and is possibly frustrated (as I was at first). But Hester is a fun character and brings a lot to the story, so if you go into it expecting that, you'll love it from the first!
Story notes -
While character development and interaction is a major focus (and one of the main ways the author uses to solve the mystery), Anne Perry uses incredible details and events to set up the story, create a conflict, and solve the crime. A few scenes had me cringing (or freaking out, haha!) because it was so intense and I had no idea what was going to happen and I didn't want one thing to happen... Or I was just plain stumped.
This book, just like its predecessor, was not a "fast" read for me. For me, it was intense, yes, and very interesting and satisfying and incredible, but it's one of those books I feel like I have to read slower to get all the details... The details are meant to be soaked in. Let's say you ate a really sweet strawberry really fast and didn't let the taste linger on your tongue...how sad! You wouldn't get the full potential of that wonderfully tasting strawberry! It's the same with these books. If you don't savor them, you might miss out on some incredible details that make the story all the more fantasic. That is what I love about these books. They make me slow down and focus on the little things; they make me forget about the next book I have to read and just enjoy; they make me appreciate slow-building intensity.
One word to sum it up (final thoughts) -
Stunning. This is some of the best prose out there, a lovely combination of mystery and historical fiction, of detail and story and character. And it's all tied up perfectly at the end, leaving you surprised at the turn the story took in just the last ten pages, and totally in love with good literature, Victorian England, and William Monk. Is there anything not to love? Need I say more?
For the parents: These are not children's books; whether or not they are young adult books is everyone's personal opinion. There is nothing sexual, and there is little bad language. However, the subject matter and the violence and possible psychotic killer can be very intense for certain readers. One character is stabbed mercilessly and left for dead (details not shown, but the inferred could be enough to make a more sensitive reader uncomfortable to the point of dislike); there are a few references to rape and how to rape a Lord's daughter is a crime, but to rape the same Lord's servant is pardonable. Over all a profound book and recommended to every adult, and most older teens out there!
September 15, 2024
Another good one in this series. I intend to continue with this series because I really like Monk and Hester. The storyline is good, even if some of it is too convenient - it makes for good listening/reading.
September 24, 2021
Anne Perry no defrauda. Monk, tampoco. En este libro el giro final me ha pillado desprevenida y eso me gusta.
April 25, 2012
Once again Perry has pulled me into her world. She gave puzzle pieces, clues, to solve the unknown picture. I thoroughly enjoyed how she left me hanging at the end of The Face of A Stranger, the first book in the Monk series. I had to know what was going to happen to Inspector Monk so I followed him to A Dangerous Mourning. Only now, she has me even more fascinated with Hester to boot!
I am very drawn to the main characters Monk and Hester. They have such admirable qualities. They are witty and do not hesitate to share their opinions. They always seem to handle situations wonderfully. Never sacrificing themselves for someone else. Always aware of their thoughts and how to best handle the people and the circumstances they are in. Receptive to others personality and emotions as they speak to them. Characteristics that many would be fascinated with.
I enjoy how Perry speaks of customs and social norms. Especially those pertaining to women. How women were meant to be gentle, fragile beings sitting pretty doing needle work. I wonder if there were a great many more women in that era that were like Hester, wanting more from life, wanting to make a difference.
I am curious about how she unfolded the story, laying out her clues. I deciphered early on that there was something in the story that had to do with Octavia's husbands dying in the war. The night of her death she told her Uncle, Septimus, that he would understand better than anyone else. The only major quality that was shared about Septimus was that he had been unable to spend his life with the woman he loved. So I was left wondering when Monk would investigate Octavia's husbands passing. Yet, I suppose a man dying in the war was nothing much to investigate. Even more so, what could she possibly have in common with her Uncle. Who would think to tie these two concepts in real life when there is so much else going on around them. I guess it may have been a dead end, no pun intended. Yet, I felt very pleased, watch me as I stroke my ego, that I had suspicions about this part of the story and was glad to see that it played out in the end.
I was also keen on the characters behaviours and declared who the murderers were before there was any proof. I knew who was responsible but had no idea why. I feel proud that I deciphered Perry's code ... well part of it.
Closing the book and laying it on my night stand I layed my head down on my pillow, for it was five o'clock in the morning, to think about the story. As the day crept on I noticed a new light inside me. An energy floating around. I was in a high all day. I am still feeling the side affects a day later. It inspired me to write, shook my muse awake as she has been sleeping for a few weeks, maybe months. I am not sure when I last saw her actually. It opened up a door for me and I believe it is because I saw my interests as well as messages, quotes, that spoke to me. It woke me up and revitalized me and I hope to hang onto this feeling as long as I can.
Her ability to wrap the reader into the lives of the characters as well as bring you into their perspective is most rewarding for any writer. For the characters are strong believers for every person to be themselves and pursue their interests yet recognize socially that is not acceptable in many cases. It is like a self-help book that snuck onto your book shelf. To see the characters determined to pursue their passions, to know their strengths and not let anyone, not even social pressures detour them from their path is most amazing. These characters could be real people out there.
Due to my desire to follow Monk and Hester I will be picking up the next book, Defend and Betray, in the very near future to stalk them on their next adventure.
I am very drawn to the main characters Monk and Hester. They have such admirable qualities. They are witty and do not hesitate to share their opinions. They always seem to handle situations wonderfully. Never sacrificing themselves for someone else. Always aware of their thoughts and how to best handle the people and the circumstances they are in. Receptive to others personality and emotions as they speak to them. Characteristics that many would be fascinated with.
I enjoy how Perry speaks of customs and social norms. Especially those pertaining to women. How women were meant to be gentle, fragile beings sitting pretty doing needle work. I wonder if there were a great many more women in that era that were like Hester, wanting more from life, wanting to make a difference.
I am curious about how she unfolded the story, laying out her clues. I deciphered early on that there was something in the story that had to do with Octavia's husbands dying in the war. The night of her death she told her Uncle, Septimus, that he would understand better than anyone else. The only major quality that was shared about Septimus was that he had been unable to spend his life with the woman he loved. So I was left wondering when Monk would investigate Octavia's husbands passing. Yet, I suppose a man dying in the war was nothing much to investigate. Even more so, what could she possibly have in common with her Uncle. Who would think to tie these two concepts in real life when there is so much else going on around them. I guess it may have been a dead end, no pun intended. Yet, I felt very pleased, watch me as I stroke my ego, that I had suspicions about this part of the story and was glad to see that it played out in the end.
I was also keen on the characters behaviours and declared who the murderers were before there was any proof. I knew who was responsible but had no idea why. I feel proud that I deciphered Perry's code ... well part of it.
Closing the book and laying it on my night stand I layed my head down on my pillow, for it was five o'clock in the morning, to think about the story. As the day crept on I noticed a new light inside me. An energy floating around. I was in a high all day. I am still feeling the side affects a day later. It inspired me to write, shook my muse awake as she has been sleeping for a few weeks, maybe months. I am not sure when I last saw her actually. It opened up a door for me and I believe it is because I saw my interests as well as messages, quotes, that spoke to me. It woke me up and revitalized me and I hope to hang onto this feeling as long as I can.
Her ability to wrap the reader into the lives of the characters as well as bring you into their perspective is most rewarding for any writer. For the characters are strong believers for every person to be themselves and pursue their interests yet recognize socially that is not acceptable in many cases. It is like a self-help book that snuck onto your book shelf. To see the characters determined to pursue their passions, to know their strengths and not let anyone, not even social pressures detour them from their path is most amazing. These characters could be real people out there.
Due to my desire to follow Monk and Hester I will be picking up the next book, Defend and Betray, in the very near future to stalk them on their next adventure.
April 17, 2009
There is something to be said about a character that starts a story not remembering who he is and without and family and close friends to help him. That is exactly what Anne Perry did in the first book of this series and that is what really attracted my attention to the books. In this second book the Inspector Monk is still unable to remember his past but has he moves through London he finds glimpses of familiar things and an image of him that seems very different from who he is now. (Would a kind soul me know if he ever remember and in which book?)
In this story Monk is called to investigate the murder of a young lady, Octavia Haslett, the daughter of Sir Basil Moidore has been stabbed to death in her own bedroom during the night. From the beginning, it is clear that Sir Basil and most of his family is mostly concerned with hushing the scandal and finding a guilty party as soon as possible. Even after it seems it is one of them who must have done it, the family still believing it must be one of the servants.
When Monk finds himself unable to find evidence pointing to someone he asks for the help of Hester Latterly, one of Miss Nightingale's nurses who was also a character in the previous book. I really like Heather! She is dedicated to her job, honest and has a hard time controlling her temper when she perceives an injustice. Despite her efforts while nursing Lady Beatrice, Octavia's mother, Heather is unable to find the culprit and when a bloody knife is found in one of the footmen's room the case seems closed to all but Monk and Heather. Refusing to arrest the footman leads to Monk being fired from the police force but Heather doesn't give up and manages to interest Oliver Rathbone, a lawyer and a very interesting character that I hope to see in future books, in the case.
I just love Perry's view of the Victorian world and there was lots of information about it in the book. In this particular story, I very much enjoyed her portrayal of the higher and lower classes. The differences in behaviours, beliefs and social status. Much of the book is set in the Moidores house and the atmosphere is oppressing, intriguing and full of suspense. I couldn't wait to get to the end of the story and find out who had done it and I must say that the final twist surprised me. I loved how they followed all the clues to reach the right conclusion about what really had happened and who was responsible. And now I can’t wait for the next book.
Grade: 5/5
In this story Monk is called to investigate the murder of a young lady, Octavia Haslett, the daughter of Sir Basil Moidore has been stabbed to death in her own bedroom during the night. From the beginning, it is clear that Sir Basil and most of his family is mostly concerned with hushing the scandal and finding a guilty party as soon as possible. Even after it seems it is one of them who must have done it, the family still believing it must be one of the servants.
When Monk finds himself unable to find evidence pointing to someone he asks for the help of Hester Latterly, one of Miss Nightingale's nurses who was also a character in the previous book. I really like Heather! She is dedicated to her job, honest and has a hard time controlling her temper when she perceives an injustice. Despite her efforts while nursing Lady Beatrice, Octavia's mother, Heather is unable to find the culprit and when a bloody knife is found in one of the footmen's room the case seems closed to all but Monk and Heather. Refusing to arrest the footman leads to Monk being fired from the police force but Heather doesn't give up and manages to interest Oliver Rathbone, a lawyer and a very interesting character that I hope to see in future books, in the case.
I just love Perry's view of the Victorian world and there was lots of information about it in the book. In this particular story, I very much enjoyed her portrayal of the higher and lower classes. The differences in behaviours, beliefs and social status. Much of the book is set in the Moidores house and the atmosphere is oppressing, intriguing and full of suspense. I couldn't wait to get to the end of the story and find out who had done it and I must say that the final twist surprised me. I loved how they followed all the clues to reach the right conclusion about what really had happened and who was responsible. And now I can’t wait for the next book.
Grade: 5/5
September 20, 2011
A fairly interesting, very involved murder set in an upper-class Victorian home where nearly everyone, from servants to Sir Basil himself are lying. Several characters return from the previous book, and a large loose end is tied up as well. I was hooked all the way through, and intend to keep reading more of this series.
To read the longer review, please go here:
http://www.epinions.com/review/A_Dang...
To read the longer review, please go here:
http://www.epinions.com/review/A_Dang...
August 8, 2016
Okay - I did not see that ending coming. I like books that surprise me.
This is a very enjoyable mystery. Perry's characters are interesting and complicated. Monk and Hester are quirky and intelligent and I enjoy their company. This is the second in the William Monk series and I will be reading more.
This is a very enjoyable mystery. Perry's characters are interesting and complicated. Monk and Hester are quirky and intelligent and I enjoy their company. This is the second in the William Monk series and I will be reading more.
March 12, 2025
The murder of a war widow, daughter of a wealthy and powerful family, brings Monk and Hester together again, and set them both on new career paths. This book also introduces Oliver Rathbone, a charming and wealthy lawyer who will become a lead character in the books to follow.
January 20, 2019
Round up to 3.5 stars. What an ending!!!
July 30, 2022
Thoroughly enjoyed this second installment in the William Monk series. Looking forward to the next one.
January 7, 2021
Getting to know William Monk as he gets to know himself seems to be a real treat. Monk, along with Sergeant Evan and Hester Latterly, both of whom I liked from the previous book, The Face of a Stranger, come together nicely by Perry's finessing to solve the crime and subsequent mystery in A Dangerous Mourning. Letting go of the constant reminders of Monk's amnesia-addled mind happens early on, and Perry tapers it off into just sporadic mentions that are really very reasonable — especially compared with the persistent nudging from the first installment.
Perry has a wonderful way of melding the formal voice for Victorian England with her own contemporary audience — it's smooth and she knows her characters and her settings well. The harsh line of class distinction is a feature in A Dangerous Mourning as is a more blunt view of a married woman's place — not just the viewpoint of a single, unmarried or widowed woman as we saw in the previous book. I love the interwoven feminist threads that are strong and sturdy through not only the character of Hester Latterly, but many other women Perry has interspersed — either through their personal opinions or through our modern lens and their resigned positions.
Personally I think I would have liked to have had a little more of Monk doing some actual detecting here, but the circumstances of the case required more of Hester Latterly's skills and I was quite happy to have her enter Monk's professional radar so early on in the series. I was suspicious it would take longer, but glad to see Perry wasted no unnecessary time getting Latterly involved on a more equal footing — if not to Monk's level, at least to Sergeant Evan's.
Audiobook, as narrated by Davina Porter: While I continue to love Porter's voice and fantastic performance — she strikes all the right notes here too — I find that perhaps this series isn't quite suited in audiobook for me. (Or maybe it's my mindset right now. Who can tell?) But some of the names, especially for the upperclass citizens Perry has used thus far (Callandra, Fenella, Octavia, Araminta), can get a little confusing just heard in my ear and not seen with my eyes. That being said, I would not hesitate to listen to another audiobook narrated by the great Davina Porter.
Perry has a wonderful way of melding the formal voice for Victorian England with her own contemporary audience — it's smooth and she knows her characters and her settings well. The harsh line of class distinction is a feature in A Dangerous Mourning as is a more blunt view of a married woman's place — not just the viewpoint of a single, unmarried or widowed woman as we saw in the previous book. I love the interwoven feminist threads that are strong and sturdy through not only the character of Hester Latterly, but many other women Perry has interspersed — either through their personal opinions or through our modern lens and their resigned positions.
Personally I think I would have liked to have had a little more of Monk doing some actual detecting here, but the circumstances of the case required more of Hester Latterly's skills and I was quite happy to have her enter Monk's professional radar so early on in the series. I was suspicious it would take longer, but glad to see Perry wasted no unnecessary time getting Latterly involved on a more equal footing — if not to Monk's level, at least to Sergeant Evan's.
Audiobook, as narrated by Davina Porter: While I continue to love Porter's voice and fantastic performance — she strikes all the right notes here too — I find that perhaps this series isn't quite suited in audiobook for me. (Or maybe it's my mindset right now. Who can tell?) But some of the names, especially for the upperclass citizens Perry has used thus far (Callandra, Fenella, Octavia, Araminta), can get a little confusing just heard in my ear and not seen with my eyes. That being said, I would not hesitate to listen to another audiobook narrated by the great Davina Porter.
dnf
August 22, 2018DNF at 58%. The narrator is very good but she can’t save this slow moving and boring story. I read the spoilers and would not have been happy with that ending.
September 29, 2019
Mucho mejor que la primera, más dinámica y atractiva como lectura, aunque la narración es igual de buena. Excelente ambientación.
El misterio es igenioso y poco previsible, los personajes de Monk y Hester evolucionan en este segundo libro y son más creíbles y cercanos para el lector.
Muy recomendable para los lectores de novela de suspense con toques históricos.
El misterio es igenioso y poco previsible, los personajes de Monk y Hester evolucionan en este segundo libro y son más creíbles y cercanos para el lector.
Muy recomendable para los lectores de novela de suspense con toques históricos.
April 17, 2024
Anne Perry's sensitively wrought portrayals of families and individuals in turmoil are always bittersweet at best, but I think this might be the most tragic story I've read in either the William Monk or Charlotte and Thomas Pitt series. As the plot progressed, with some of the most vividly rendered characters I've ever met in a mystery novel - both the downstairs and upstairs crews - the threads of selfishness, pride, and unresolved grudges wove an ever-clearer tapestry of the miserable Moidore family. I even felt some understanding, if not sympathy, for the original architect of the tragedy . The insight into human psychology, including those dreadful snowball effects of sins stacking atop sins, was absolutely on point. For me, Septimus and Fenella were the most captivating, though for the former it was positive and the latter... decidedly not.
I also loved the continuing characterization of Monk and Hester. Amnesia is nearly always used as a cheap device to increase suspense, but here, Monk is in the fascinating and uneasy situation where he can pass judgement on himself from an unprecedented objective standard. What insights might we all gain if we were gifted with such distance from ourselves? I can't wait to see how his character arc develops. Hester's strong-willed feminism (the real feminism that embraces equality, not superiority) is also so inspiring, allowing strong commentary and advocacy for historical and current social issues without it seeming preachy.
I was very glad that the plot of the first book remained important here, rather than being swept under the rug! For those wondering, do not read this book before The Face of a Stranger - spoilers galore. Rathbone is a highly intriguing new character, making me curious about the further adventures of this Victorian league of justice-seekers.
Although I didn't guess the culprit this time, I wasn't the biggest fan of how their identity was a bit arbitrary - I think it was equally likely to have been a few people. The conclusion was a bit rushed, despite the rest of the book being quite slow-paced, with one reaction making me wonder why it took so long for the truth to come out. And though Callandra Daviot's presence certainly makes the situations more pleasant, her indulgence and endless wealth are so convenient as to make the story somewhat fantastical.
Overall, another wonderful exploration of human nature by Anne Perry! Every time I finish one of her books, I'm eager to read more.
I also loved the continuing characterization of Monk and Hester. Amnesia is nearly always used as a cheap device to increase suspense, but here, Monk is in the fascinating and uneasy situation where he can pass judgement on himself from an unprecedented objective standard. What insights might we all gain if we were gifted with such distance from ourselves? I can't wait to see how his character arc develops. Hester's strong-willed feminism (the real feminism that embraces equality, not superiority) is also so inspiring, allowing strong commentary and advocacy for historical and current social issues without it seeming preachy.
I was very glad that the plot of the first book remained important here, rather than being swept under the rug! For those wondering, do not read this book before The Face of a Stranger - spoilers galore. Rathbone is a highly intriguing new character, making me curious about the further adventures of this Victorian league of justice-seekers.
Although I didn't guess the culprit this time, I wasn't the biggest fan of how their identity was a bit arbitrary - I think it was equally likely to have been a few people. The conclusion was a bit rushed, despite the rest of the book being quite slow-paced, with one reaction making me wonder why it took so long for the truth to come out. And though Callandra Daviot's presence certainly makes the situations more pleasant, her indulgence and endless wealth are so convenient as to make the story somewhat fantastical.
Overall, another wonderful exploration of human nature by Anne Perry! Every time I finish one of her books, I'm eager to read more.
May 21, 2010
How is it that I want to clap my hands in glee after finishing one of Perry's books?! I love a lot of books, but something about the way she wraps up her plot or whatever, I can't quite figure it out, something about it brings this odd reaction out in me.
I thought I had the plot figured out the whole way through and was a little disappointed in the back of my mind (if I, of all dumb gullible people, can figure out the plot before the book ends, then that severely insults the intelligence of the author.) Ha ha. I was wrong about the plot, which proved a relief and a delight (I love it when authors prove how much better they are at their craft than I could ever dream of being.)
I'm a fan of books set in the Victorian era. My husband 'enjoyed' a grueling college course on Jane Austen and our eyes were opened to the reality vs. the hollywoodness of the culture we have created around Jane Austen's works and the Victorian Era. Perry sticks to reality and I am so glad. An example: the inspector/policeman is on an equal social standing with a laundry maid, pretty much. It's good Perry doesn't set him up as some CSI heartthrob or something ridiculous. This makes everything else with her writing more trustworthy.
The thought occurred to me: I don't think I could read Perry's books if they were set in modern times. I don't have interest in reading about current-day murders and class differences in a fiction setting. Perry's setting her tales in a time and place so distant from me helps the harsh realities she uncovers to be very much more palatable and approachable for me. She then leaves it the the reader to draw the parallels and correlate the lessons learned with our modern-day situations. Smart, Perry.
Once again, I loved Lady Callandra, Ms. Latterly, Evan, and of COURSE Inspector Monk. The twists and peeks at his evolving character that his returning memory provide are a fun addition to an already great storyline. I'm ready for the next in the series!
I'd love to read a bit more about the wars referred to (the Crimean, the charge of the Light Brigade, the battles at Balaclava...) If anyone knows of great material on any of those, I'm game...
I thought I had the plot figured out the whole way through and was a little disappointed in the back of my mind (if I, of all dumb gullible people, can figure out the plot before the book ends, then that severely insults the intelligence of the author.) Ha ha. I was wrong about the plot, which proved a relief and a delight (I love it when authors prove how much better they are at their craft than I could ever dream of being.)
I'm a fan of books set in the Victorian era. My husband 'enjoyed' a grueling college course on Jane Austen and our eyes were opened to the reality vs. the hollywoodness of the culture we have created around Jane Austen's works and the Victorian Era. Perry sticks to reality and I am so glad. An example: the inspector/policeman is on an equal social standing with a laundry maid, pretty much. It's good Perry doesn't set him up as some CSI heartthrob or something ridiculous. This makes everything else with her writing more trustworthy.
The thought occurred to me: I don't think I could read Perry's books if they were set in modern times. I don't have interest in reading about current-day murders and class differences in a fiction setting. Perry's setting her tales in a time and place so distant from me helps the harsh realities she uncovers to be very much more palatable and approachable for me. She then leaves it the the reader to draw the parallels and correlate the lessons learned with our modern-day situations. Smart, Perry.
Once again, I loved Lady Callandra, Ms. Latterly, Evan, and of COURSE Inspector Monk. The twists and peeks at his evolving character that his returning memory provide are a fun addition to an already great storyline. I'm ready for the next in the series!
I'd love to read a bit more about the wars referred to (the Crimean, the charge of the Light Brigade, the battles at Balaclava...) If anyone knows of great material on any of those, I'm game...
December 11, 2011
I liked this second book even more than the first. The writing is good, if still a bit repetitive, and still hitting the themes of sexism and classism pretty hard. I'm enjoying the Victorian London setting.
I like the setup for this series. Monk is a driven, abrasive police detective, suffering from amnesia and trying to discover what kind of man he used to be. Hester was a nurse in the Crimean War, and is disgruntled to find that her talents and experience are unappreciated back in London. They have a charming, wealthy lawyer friend who's willing to take on difficult cases, and an aristocratic sponsor willing to give advice, spend money, and use her influence on their behalf. It's an interesting team, and I look forward to reading more about them.
I like the setup for this series. Monk is a driven, abrasive police detective, suffering from amnesia and trying to discover what kind of man he used to be. Hester was a nurse in the Crimean War, and is disgruntled to find that her talents and experience are unappreciated back in London. They have a charming, wealthy lawyer friend who's willing to take on difficult cases, and an aristocratic sponsor willing to give advice, spend money, and use her influence on their behalf. It's an interesting team, and I look forward to reading more about them.
November 2, 2017
This series is SO good - how have I missed this all these years. I would almost say this is not so much the second in the series as a bit of a sequel to the first book. If you didn't read the first book first, you will find out 'whodunit' pretty early on in the second, which kind of surprised me. But unlike other series writers, I get the feeling Ms. Perry doesn't necessarily want each book to be a standalone.
Hester and Monk continue to become the most interesting characters. And I'm really very glad I didn't live in Victorian times. Ms. Perry paints a rather dreary picture of what it was like for the poor, uneducated and female. Heaven help you if you were all three.
Looking forward to book three!
Hester and Monk continue to become the most interesting characters. And I'm really very glad I didn't live in Victorian times. Ms. Perry paints a rather dreary picture of what it was like for the poor, uneducated and female. Heaven help you if you were all three.
Looking forward to book three!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 554 reviews