Her love was as wild and untameable as the frontier itself. Her brave heart is torn between two worlds. Ever since blonde Cassie Stevens was captured by the Indians at the age of four she has loved her Iroquois family, and at fifteen she can shoot and ride as well as any warrior. Then her world is destroyed when passion drives her from the only home she knows. Where does Cassie truly belong? In the arms of the handsome and adventurous fur trapper Joshua, or in the town where she was born, with Ben who mistrusts her Indian spirit?
I first found this book in one of the St. Louis libraries when I was 8 or 9. Years later I still remembered the title and loving the story. I found it again at David Kidd booksellers in Nashville when I was 12 and have read it many times since. I'm in my early 30's now and re-enjoyed it just this summer. I certainly find it a bit more trite than I did as a teen, but still love and enjoy it.
This entire series is fun light reading. When I started buying into the series as a pre-teen and early teen, my mom read them all as well. Then she recommended them to my girlfriends' moms and a whole group of ladies young and middle-aged was hooked on these stories. They are all historically based romance fictions, set in different historical times and eras of American history with young women torn between two love interests. I actually learned a fair bit of American history through these books that I didn't get exposed to in school or other reading later on.
(See my review of Amanda for my general review of the series.)
Either Cassie is one of Vivian Schurfranz's better entries in the Sunfire series, or I've just gotten used to Schurfranz. (Perish the thought!) I read this one as a kid, but other than the raised-by-Indians thing, I didn't remember a thing about it, nor my opinion of it, so this is essentially a first time read.
Cassandra Stevens was kidnapped by Indians in a raid at age four and has grown up in the Iroquois village of Mecotan. Aside from her name and her hometown, Cassie remembers very little of her previous life, and considers herself Iroquois. "Snowflower" has slowly carved out a place in the tribe, even earning an eagle feather for her courage, and is engaged to the warrior Silverblade.
Cassie's rooting around in the woods one fine 1756-ish day when she runs into fur-trapper Joshua Benton. The two are soon smitten and meeting every day. Joshua wants Cassie to return to the white world with him, and when she refuses, he promises to return in a few months with news of her parents.
In that short time, Cassie's adoptive mother, White Cloud, dies, Silverblade rejects her after Cassie tells him about Joshua, and the tribe's new chief just happens to be the fiance of the haughty Little Wolf, who hates Cassie. It's enough of a teen angst burst to make Cassie decide to run off with Joshua and try life with the white folks.
Although Cassie's parents welcome her back, she doesn't even come close to fitting in. And she's pretty heartsick over Joshua's perceived rejection. (He's convinced that being a fur trapper's wife must be the crappiest, and he's determined not to put any woman through that.) So she accepts the attention of village blacksmith Ben Newall, whose parents were killed by the Iroquois. So he hates Indians. And Cassie was raised by... you see where this is going.
And then one evening, Cassie overhears some shady types discussing plans to attack Mecotan. Whatever will she do?
I enjoyed this one more than Schurfranz's usual fare, mostly because it actually had a pretty interesting plot. Cassie's loyalties appeared very divided, but when her childhood home is threatened, she doesn't even hesitate to try and help them. And she lands herself in a heap of trouble. Schurfranz did a nice, if occasionally overstated, job of showing the white settlers' prejudice towards the Indians. And as usual, the research is well done, and is well-integrated into the narrative about fifty percent of the time.
My issues with this novel are the usual that I have with this author. Some of the historical exposition is *extremely* clunky, including informative bits that are placed into the mouth of a character, yet stated in textbook format. Very tiresome. And we very nearly made it through a Schurfranz without a personal encounter with a historical celebrity- and then Ben Franklin shows up in Cassie's parents' inn. For a few pages. For no reason at all except to point out that Schurfranz learned who the important people of 1756 were. I have the same problem with a couple of myths that were inserted into the narrative: hey, this reminds Character A of Story B! And then they have to internally monologue the entire story, including the parts that have nothing to do with the present situation! It's like the author can't stand not to include the tiniest scrap of anything she learned during her research!
The romantic plot isn't too bad. It's obvious that Ben's interest in Cassie is merely superficial, since he can't abide anything she stands for and even angrily scolds her for acting too "Indian." (And what the heck was the purpose of Ben's brother Jimmy? This spunky little tyke showed up every once in a while to be barfingly precious-like and then run away screaming "Yippie!" while throwing his hands in the air! Yes, he thinks Cassie's cool! Which *makes* Cassie cool, right? Urgh.)
Joshua is an almost too-perfect match for Cassie, but it's a relief that someone who appreciates her wilder side is there to spirit her away to happiness. Because otherwise, the kid wouldn't really have it. The only problem I have with the romance plot is that our intrepid author has a really annoying habit of continually placing flowery praise for the heroine in our heroes' mouths. I grew tired of hearing that Cassie's cheeks were like roses and her eyes were like larkspurs and her hair was like hay, but really *nice* hay, and on and on and barf.
Verdict: The Schurfranziness subtracts two stars, simply because it is what it is. But this book is otherwise pretty entertaining.
Remember those book flyers you'd get in elementary school? The ones you'd take home and give to your parents with half the books circled and beg them to buy them for you? Well, apparently my mom thought that Stephen King and Dean Koontz weren't appropriate reading material for a young girl, because she bought me some YA romance books out of some of those flyers. When I saw a couple of those books from my childhood on the shelf at the local used book store, nostalgia got the better of me and I picked a couple of them up.
I read this book back in the late 80's, when as a teen, I bought a paperback copy at a garage sale! It was my first Western romance book. I have never forgotten it. Decades later, I have begun reading a recently published Historical Christian fiction, Gold in Fire, by Misty Woods. Although different locations, Indian tribes, and characters, I was reminded of Cassie. Some similarities, I'm sure, have yet to be revealed. It was so long ago, that I don't recall reading any facts versus fiction by Cassie's author. However, I would definitely recommend this book.
*Rereading my way through the Sunfire series, in publication order*
A typical Vivian Schurfranz Sunfire, with thinly drawn characters and an equally thin plot.
Cassie is beautiful, talented, and unnecessarily clever (despite being taken at age four, she speaks and reads English beautifully). She can't be all that clever, as sees nothing alarming in running off with Joshua, a teenage fur trapper she's only spent a handful of hours with (Even though the Iroquois have been kind to her, she's been proposed to a warrior who, at twenty-five, is OLD.), though perhaps it's because Joshua does things like compare her eyes to stormy skies, which is not the sort of thing real teenage boys say. Returned to her birth parents, Cassie adjusts to life in a white village in about ten minutes, though Schurfranz tries to convince us that the transition is rough by having Cassie periodically complain about her buckled shoes. Joshua then disappears, only to return every so often for an hour or two, and we're stuck with Ben, the handsome blacksmith with zero sense of humor and even less a sense of How to Say Nice Things. Apart from telling Cassie how pretty she is (We are reminded of her flowing golden locks every other page, whether it's an opportune time or not.), the only other things he offers are criticisms as to her "Indian ways". He's really pretty much an asshole, unless he's talking about her hair. Will Cassie choose the ripped blacksmith with the anger problem? Or will she choose the trapper with "black ringlets" and pretty prose?
CASSIE isn't one that I read back in the day, but was a favorite of friends who had read it. I had high hopes, but they weren't held up. I wish we'd spent more time with the Iroquois and that Cassie would have had more trouble adjusting to village life. It had potential, but wasn't carried through.
Cassie is a super-speshul snowflake. Oops, I mean Snowflower.
"I know all of the Iroquois tribes. Hey, let me list them for you!"
Why, yes, I totally believe that a teenage fur trapper would compare the heroine's eyes to a stormy sky and otherwise speak like a romance novelist. *sigh*
Aaaaand here's instalove: "I've known you for all of two hours, but of course I'll consider making a multi-day journey with you through desolate terrain." All this, and I've only made it to page 24 so far.
Hmmm...last I checked mares were FEMALE horses.
Wait, what? You know what "latitude" means, but not "inn?"
Instalove: take two.
Apparently, *every* teenage boy in pre-Revolutionary America spouts romance novel drivel. Poor Cassie, she's actually not a bad character, but when every single male character (except her dad, thank god) breaks into poetry about her eyes, hair, cheeks, etc. I get a little stabby.
Hey, here's Ben Franklin. Oops...bye Ben!
That was the most inept rescue attempt ever. If Cassie is supposed to be so in tune with her forest home how in the hell does she fall into a wolf trap (of course, she knows exactly how it's constructed and easily escapes it).
Aww...even the bitchy girl luuurves Cassie now.
This wasn't a bad story, it just got bogged down in Schurfranz craziness. I already liked Cassie, you don't need to beat me over the head with how speshul she is and how very much every luuurves her.
A special shout out for the cover: both love interests look EXACTLY THE SAME.
Read this many years ago when I was in middle school...always loved these straightforward YA romance novels. Girl must choose between (usually) 2 men set against a historical backdrop. Of course, the girl ALWAYS chooses the not so rich but rich in heart guy vs the original option. I think between these and Ann Rinaldi, this is what got me into historical romance and romance novels in general! ^_^
I think I was probably 9 or so when I first read this book? I haven't read it in over a decade or so, but I still have a lot of fondness for what is, arguably, the first "Romance" I ever read. It's pretty terrible though, in pretty much all ways- racist, sexist, grossly historically inaccurate, bad prose, etc etc.
This was my favorite Sunfire historical romance in 6th grade. (Maybe 5th?) For years thereafter, I was certain I would name my first girl child Cassandra. However, I went on to read the Greek playwrights, and the name did not long remain on the list.
What a throwback. So the "Sunfire" series is a YA Romance series published in the 80s. I was in 8th grade when I first came across these series at my middle school's library, and at the time it was a perfect fit. I had moved beyond Little House on the Prairie, Dear America, etc, and was interested in a historical fiction series geared more towards tween/teen readers. I read through maybe a dozen or so of these books, whichever ones I could find at my school library, public library, and thrift stores here and there. Each book in the series is based on the premise of some 15-16 year old girl choosing between two suitors, in the midst of some monumental historical moment. You actually do learn about history, too, as I remember the only reason I got this one question correct on my AP History exam in high school, was because I remembered what I had read in one of these books. No lie.
I haven't come across any Sunfire Romance books in the past 15 or so years (they're incredibly hard to find), but was able to stumble across Cassie in a local used bookstore this weekend! Grabbed it for $4.30 and was ready for a nostalgic walk through memory lane.
"Cassie" is set in the Hudson River/Albany area, in 1755-1756. We are introduced to Cassie, a blonde-haired, blue-eyed white girl who was raised by the Mohawk Iroquois, after being kidnapped at age 4 during an Indian raid on some nearby colony. She eventually finds her birth parents and tries to acclimate to "white society", and captures the attention of Joshua, an 18 year old fur trapper, and Ben, an 18 year old smith in her hometown.
This is honestly likely the most problematic, un-PC book of the 32-book series, as we are forced to learn about the Iroquois and their history, through the eyes of a white girl. WHY Sunfire didn't think it would be better to have the main heroine of the book be an actual Native American, I'm not sure. But here we are. The book is sprinkled with info on fur trapping (beavers, mainly), French and English presence in the what-is-now Northeast US, French-American-English-Native American relations, some military talk, and general daily colonial life (making lye soap, songs, literature, etc). Benjamin Franklin even makes an appearance.
SPOILER ALERT It is clearly obvious who she will end up choosing, I mean even the description on the back of the book makes this a non-choice: "Where does Cassie truly belong? In the arms of the handsome and adventurous fur trapper Joshua, or in the town where she was born, with Ben who mistrusts her Indian spirit?" Like Ben the entire time belittles Cassie and forbids her of speaking about her upbringing with the Mohawks. Whereas Joshua likes her for who she is. I mean, come on.
Overall the book was alright. I'm sure I loved it as a 13 year old girl, but reading it as a 31 year old, it was just okay. Insta-love, a general unease about reading unpolitically-correct material, a heroine who seems a bit uber-dramatic at times (going from "I'm so in love" to bursting into tears and believing the world is ending, all in the span of a page or two)....but this is YA Romance from the 80s so what can you expect.
I'll still keep an eye out for others in the series, whenever I'm at a thrift store or yard sale. They're not amazing enough books to spend $20 on eBay for them, but they make for a fun $4 read.
Nostalgia Book- This book comes from a series called Sunfire. I loved these books as a girl as they put the girls in historical periods and gave her two men to choose from to love. The books are written by about seven different authors and Schurfranz is my least favorite. I am not entirely sure how much I liked Cassie as a girl but now, I can hardly stand it. The topic of a white girl being raised by Native Americans is too weighty and I do not like how her family and the one man in her life keep trying to change her. And Schurfranz's heroines are too willing to just fall into the arms of the first man they meet. There is no great resolution at the end except that she gets to be with the man she loves and who accepts her.
This book made me want to stab myself in the ear. It's racist, illogical, and everyone in the whole book is either an idiot or doing a great impression of one. It's not even enjoyable to read as a romance! There's a baffling encounter with a bear! Why is any of this happening? I want to use this book to light my barbecue.
A book I remember from my childhood. Not nearly as good as I remember it being but hey it's been years. I really did enjoy these books in my preteen years.
I read this book when I was a pre-teen but wanted to review it bc let me tell you I was OBSESSED! It was my favorite book for years. As someone that age I connected with Cassie's wild curiosity and free spirit. I imagined if I lived back in those times I would want to be just like her. I highly suggest this book, regardless of your age-you won't regret it!
I originally read this series back in the 80s, checking them out from my elementary school library. Having re-read them as an adult I think they stand the test of time and are still relevant as far as historical fiction is concerned.
For the most part the story is pretty good; similar to the Dear America diary Standing in the Light. It explores the culture shock of returning to one’s hometown after several years in a different environment. One love interest is clearly not compatible with Cassie.