That was a generally sweet book.
Setting: The prologue was set in 1947, presumably in Lincoln, Nebraska, although it was never stated. The book proper began in New York City, sometime in the 1870's. The exact date is sketchy, but there were enough details--for example, the Children's Aid Society and its founder--for me to narrow it down. The story ended in June of 1887, and the epilogue, which basically described the rest of the characters' lives in short paragraphs, mentioned an event in 1890, and also World War I. Doing mental calculations and such, I was somewhat suspicious of the timing of all of it, but I decided none of it was impossible. Most of the location was set in Lincoln, Nebraska, although there was a brief spell in Philadelphia--which wasn't developed very well at all. The Nebraskan setting, however, was established well. The emerging city in the West, the heat in Summer, the neighboring city of Omaha, the still-primitive circumstances many of the residents faced, the contemporaneous role of women, and more contributed to a believable story.
Characters: Sarah Biddle was thirteen at the beginning of the book, and she developed well throughout the story. She was the sweetest girl, and I'm glad the author did not shy away from the salvation issue, even though Sarah was an angel in many people's eyes. Sarah had her weaknesses, but generally she was a sweet, good-natured girl, which created a nicely balanced character.
Tom was a good character as well, and I really liked the development of his relationship with Sarah. David Braddock was one of my favorite characters, and though it's easy to question historical accuracy with characters like him, it's also easy for characters like him to be the best kinds. His mother was also very good. Dr. Gilbert was also a fine character, but for some reason he rubbed me the wrong way. Somehow I got the impression he wasn't a Christian, even though it was stated that he was. So all related dislike of the book on my part wasn't really fair. Dr. Maude Allbright was an interesting character; she was written very believably (one of the characters I researched, thinking she must have been a real person), and she really couldn't be placed in a "good" or "bad" character category.
There were a few other characters, such as the Kemps, Aunt Jesse and Augusta Hathaway, LisBeth, Nellie Spomer, and George McCann. They were all written fairly well, (with the possible exception of Nellie, whose character arc I thought was really rushed) but no one stood out spectacularly.
Plot: There were certainly major conflicts and problems in this book, but the story-to-story jumps between chapters gave the book a mellow feel. The patchwork theme contributed to that feel, as if the separate stories of Sarah's life were connected by the fabric of the crazy quilt. Don't get me wrong, there were plenty of stronger plot connections; but the structure followed a pattern of day-to-day life (which I like).
Faith content: A major part of the plot, which was nice, considering the life-story pattern the book followed. The Christian behavior seemed a bit too perfect in a couple of the characters, but that was fine as their role--since that was basically their role. The faith journey of Sarah herself I thought was done well. In fact, many of the minor characters had good Christian hearts, and I hope the employees for the Children's Aid Society were historically accurate. Accurate or not, though, it was heartwarming to read about people who care for children.
Recommended for readers who enjoy gentle books, but not without its heartache. This would be a good choice for a young adult just getting started in reading romance.