‘A delightful odyssey through the history, nostalgia, fascination and British love of cake. Quirky, charming, and fun.’ PRUE LEITHThe British take cakes seriously. We hold strong opinions about how to bake a brownie with the perfect squidge, the correct proportions of icing to sponge, and whether it’s jam or cream first on our scones. Now – thanks to the success of a certain TV baking show – our flirtation with flour, fruit and frosting has become a full-blown love affair.
But how did the humble cake evolve from a simple combination of starch and fat to the show-stopping bakes of today, taking pride of place at every meaningful life celebration? Travelling the country from Dundee to the Isle of Wight, writer Andrew Baker (by name, not occupation) serves up the story of our national obsession with cake, one slice at a time.
On this greediest of quests, Andrew seeks to discover the ‘True Slice’ of each iconic cake. This enviable task sees him eat sponge sandwiched with jam and cream at Queen Victoria’s holiday home Osborne House, discover the illustrious yet scandal-filled history of the Battenberg’s saccharine squares and learn how a caterpillar enrobed in chocolate became a party-starting birthday centerpiece.
From King Alfred’s oatcakes to The River Café’s revered Chocolate Nemesis, this is the crumb-spattered, buttercream-smeared story of the cakes that have claimed a place on British tables – and in our hearts.
This book has infuriated me, but I need to clarify exactly why: Firstly, this is a 5/5 star idea. Secondly, Andrew Baker is not a bad writer; on the contrary, he is funny and personable, and has the right temperament to write non-fiction books like this where it feels like a fun romp with a friend more than anything. The thing that has made me really detest this book is that it is so, so poorly researched.
There is not a single thing that couldn't be learned from this book from the most cursory of Wikipedia page reading. Time and time again Baker (well named, admittedly) goes to a place without researching ahead of time where he can buy the local cake and ends up having to get it from a supermarket (I am not joking, ALDI is well advertised in this book). When he does find bakeries that still produce these old local baked delicacies, he doesn't interview the business owners or the bakers about why they still make it today or what it means to them etc. They don't get a look in. The only business owners he does speak to are chocolate shop owners, some of whom do produce baked chocolate goods, but I learned this is only because these were business connections he made from his last book about the British Chocolate scene. There is no attempt to connect with bakers or bakery businesses in this book. After his disastrous trip to Eccles where he ended up in the aforementioned ALDI I googled 'Eccles Cake Manchester' and found a family-owned business there that proudly still makes them as their focal selling point. That is exactly the type of thing this book should have been about, not eating a Waitrose Christmas Cake in Winter Wonderland at Hyde Park.
Lastly, Baker is not a food writer. He does the Weekend section of the Telegraph and previously did Sports and Travel writing. Consequently, he has no sense of what someone interested in food actually wants to know about, and his descriptions of the food are usually quite rudimentary.
This book is a fun read, sure. He is witty, and if you want to read an easy non-fiction then you definitely might enjoy this. If you want to actually learn anything about traditional British cakes like their history or why and where they are still made, save yourself £16.99 and read the Wikipedia page.
Edit: I added another half star because the final chapter on honey cake was good and finally, thankfully, educational
Do you remember the early Bake Off episodes where, to fill time, Mel and/or Sue would be sent off to some far-flung corner of Europe to talk about a bake specific to that place? Well, here it is in book form. Though focused specifically on Britain and, with a shaky start into Saxon cakes, 'Cake' gets into the swing of things at the Victoria Sandwich and keeps moving on up - even sparing a moment to chat about Colin v Cuthbert, the biggest legal thrill our nation had experienced until Vardy v Rooney. It's all rather twee and British, but it's good fun. Plus, it'll make you want a slice of cake, which is hardly a bad thing.