What do you think?
Rate this book
DI Kelly Porter #11
Silent Bones
The discovery of a skeleton in Thirlmere Reservoir has shaken the tight-knit community of Pooley Bridge.
For DI Kelly Porter, the case quickly becomes personal when the bones are revealed to be the remains of an old classmate. Brian Miller was just seventeen when he went missing over twenty years ago.
A day later, another body is found in a caravan park, its head broken and bloody. Jason Cooper had been a friend of Brian’s, and one of the last people known to see him alive.
Kelly suspects these two crimes are linked. But if she’s right, that means there’s a ruthless killer somewhere in her community — someone who will do anything to keep the truth buried…
For DI Kelly Porter, the case quickly becomes personal when the bones are revealed to be the remains of an old classmate. Brian Miller was just seventeen when he went missing over twenty years ago.
A day later, another body is found in a caravan park, its head broken and bloody. Jason Cooper had been a friend of Brian’s, and one of the last people known to see him alive.
Kelly suspects these two crimes are linked. But if she’s right, that means there’s a ruthless killer somewhere in her community — someone who will do anything to keep the truth buried…
348 pages, Kindle Edition
First published June 27, 2023
170 people are currently reading
492 people want to read
About the author
Rachel Lynch
81 books419 followersRachel Lynch grew up in Cumbria and the lakes and fells are never far away from her. London pulled her away to teach History and marry an Army Officer, whom she followed around the globe for thirteen years.
A change of career after children led to personal training and sports therapy, but writing was always the overwhelming force driving the future. The human capacity for compassion as well as its descent into the brutal and murky world of crime are fundamental to her work.
A change of career after children led to personal training and sports therapy, but writing was always the overwhelming force driving the future. The human capacity for compassion as well as its descent into the brutal and murky world of crime are fundamental to her work.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 109 reviews
February 24, 2025
Silent Bones brings us back to Lake District and to DI Kelly Porter and her team. The case being investigated hits close to home for Porter in more ways than one.
Rachel Lynch delivers yet again a great story, paced really well, a story that links past and present seemlessly with a cast of characters that are well fleshed out.
I cannot get enough of those characters, the setting and the cases. Rachel Lynch created a highly addictive series of books and I hope there are many more to come.
Rachel Lynch delivers yet again a great story, paced really well, a story that links past and present seemlessly with a cast of characters that are well fleshed out.
I cannot get enough of those characters, the setting and the cases. Rachel Lynch created a highly addictive series of books and I hope there are many more to come.
June 13, 2023
"Each time she absorbed the impact of a murder—of seeing somebody who was once alive and vibrant, like her own family, on the mortuary slab; of seeing the pain and mess they left behind—it carved off a little piece of her."
tw: light spoilers, murder, crime, death
To be totally honest, this book intimidated me at first.
Though I can get down for a good mystery, it's not my first go-to genre when picking a new book to read. Not only that, but this is a part of an ongoing series, and I have yet to check out any of the earlier volumes. I was diving headfirst into this dark pool of a murder mystery with unfamiliar characters and preestablished information that I couldn't even hope to guess. Because of that, I was floundering a bit, lost in the words as they jumbled in my head for the first fifty pages or so. But then, it was like something snapped—suddenly, I knew I was hooked, and I was unable to put the book down until I finished it, well past two in the morning.
DI Kelly Porter was certainly a character—one that I could get behind supporting. She's a highly successful career woman who balances work and home, but not so much that readers are unable to relate to her. Even though I knew nothing about her beforehand, it was just so easy to start to root for her. I was surprised at my strong feelings towards the story once I finished the book. Similarly, the other characters were easy to remember and understand; there was not a single character that I felt disconnected to. There was just enough context to flesh out each character that appeared, whether they were a new character or one that appeared in past volumes. In Kelly's case, the parts of the novel that took a break from the case, like when she went out with her family, for example, really helped humanize Kelly in my mind. She appears as much more than just a detective, she is a mother, a friend, a childhood acquaintance turned local celebrity...
Because of this effect that Lynch's characterization has, I also found myself getting genuinely emotional when it came to the unfortunate demise of a character, though they were not of the (assumed) main cast. I also couldn't help but feel as though this was a big contribution to Kelly's breakdown that happens later in the novel. This had a big impact; it was why I chose the quote at the top of the review. It stuck out to me, and really reminded me that people who seem untouchable—celebrities, police, parents, etc.—are all human too. They all have feelings too. Kelly is a likable character because she has "weak" moments like this.
Something else that helped bring this book to life was the actual loose plot. The idea of an impromptu high school reunion, of students brought back together over the deaths of two of their peers. It's even more interesting because of their ages, and how much things have changed since their younger years. Lynch does a wonderful job painting that awkward feeling between old friends who have long since lost communication, and of making their past realistic. The descriptions of how their physical bodies have changed was a wonderful touch; it really helps separate the picture of the characters when they were in high school in comparison to modern day. It's a clear parallel, between Brian and Jason, and it is quite well done.
I do have some light criticism, but this is purely me nitpicking and also perhaps just not fully understanding stylistic choices in writing. The similar introduction that appears three or so times throughout the book, introducing new characters by name then going task by task and describing what they are doing. Is there a deeper meaning here? I understand that they were meant to be formatted the same on purpose, but I don't understand why that is. It did not do anything for me and actually just felt repetitive and unnecessary, though it was purposely repetitive to call attention to it.
My second note simply says that the "plot twists" were a bit easy to guess, which is true. Once I understood what was going on, I knew who the killer was right away. I did not guess all of the details, but it was more than enough for me to pick out the culprit. I also predicted some of the other smaller events that happened over the course of the book.
Lastly, this is once again a pure stylistic thing, but I missed some imagery in this book. Sure, the descriptions of the crime scenes and especially the forensics behind it was really helpful. Especially for someone like me, who is not familiar with such topics at all. But I truly wished there was more imagery, so that I could really paint a picture of Kelly in my mind. The descriptions of the visuals were weak and quick, too bland for me to really do much other than sketch out a basic picture in my head before moving on. It's not something that everyone enjoys; in fact many people criticize writers for being "too flowery" but I have always loved imagery, as much of it as I can get.
Honestly, if there were an option for a 0.5 star, I would have rated this a 3.5 star read rather than just three stars. It falls in between my personal criteria for rating books, something that has not really happened before. I really enjoyed this book even though it was a step outside of my comfort zone, and I am so glad that I did. DI Kelly might have singlehandedly convinced me to read more mystery and crime books!
A huge thank you to Netgalley, Canelo, and Rachel Lynch for sending me an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
tw: light spoilers, murder, crime, death
To be totally honest, this book intimidated me at first.
Though I can get down for a good mystery, it's not my first go-to genre when picking a new book to read. Not only that, but this is a part of an ongoing series, and I have yet to check out any of the earlier volumes. I was diving headfirst into this dark pool of a murder mystery with unfamiliar characters and preestablished information that I couldn't even hope to guess. Because of that, I was floundering a bit, lost in the words as they jumbled in my head for the first fifty pages or so. But then, it was like something snapped—suddenly, I knew I was hooked, and I was unable to put the book down until I finished it, well past two in the morning.
DI Kelly Porter was certainly a character—one that I could get behind supporting. She's a highly successful career woman who balances work and home, but not so much that readers are unable to relate to her. Even though I knew nothing about her beforehand, it was just so easy to start to root for her. I was surprised at my strong feelings towards the story once I finished the book. Similarly, the other characters were easy to remember and understand; there was not a single character that I felt disconnected to. There was just enough context to flesh out each character that appeared, whether they were a new character or one that appeared in past volumes. In Kelly's case, the parts of the novel that took a break from the case, like when she went out with her family, for example, really helped humanize Kelly in my mind. She appears as much more than just a detective, she is a mother, a friend, a childhood acquaintance turned local celebrity...
Because of this effect that Lynch's characterization has, I also found myself getting genuinely emotional when it came to the unfortunate demise of a character, though they were not of the (assumed) main cast. I also couldn't help but feel as though this was a big contribution to Kelly's breakdown that happens later in the novel. This had a big impact; it was why I chose the quote at the top of the review. It stuck out to me, and really reminded me that people who seem untouchable—celebrities, police, parents, etc.—are all human too. They all have feelings too. Kelly is a likable character because she has "weak" moments like this.
Something else that helped bring this book to life was the actual loose plot. The idea of an impromptu high school reunion, of students brought back together over the deaths of two of their peers. It's even more interesting because of their ages, and how much things have changed since their younger years. Lynch does a wonderful job painting that awkward feeling between old friends who have long since lost communication, and of making their past realistic. The descriptions of how their physical bodies have changed was a wonderful touch; it really helps separate the picture of the characters when they were in high school in comparison to modern day. It's a clear parallel, between Brian and Jason, and it is quite well done.
I do have some light criticism, but this is purely me nitpicking and also perhaps just not fully understanding stylistic choices in writing. The similar introduction that appears three or so times throughout the book, introducing new characters by name then going task by task and describing what they are doing. Is there a deeper meaning here? I understand that they were meant to be formatted the same on purpose, but I don't understand why that is. It did not do anything for me and actually just felt repetitive and unnecessary, though it was purposely repetitive to call attention to it.
My second note simply says that the "plot twists" were a bit easy to guess, which is true. Once I understood what was going on, I knew who the killer was right away. I did not guess all of the details, but it was more than enough for me to pick out the culprit. I also predicted some of the other smaller events that happened over the course of the book.
Lastly, this is once again a pure stylistic thing, but I missed some imagery in this book. Sure, the descriptions of the crime scenes and especially the forensics behind it was really helpful. Especially for someone like me, who is not familiar with such topics at all. But I truly wished there was more imagery, so that I could really paint a picture of Kelly in my mind. The descriptions of the visuals were weak and quick, too bland for me to really do much other than sketch out a basic picture in my head before moving on. It's not something that everyone enjoys; in fact many people criticize writers for being "too flowery" but I have always loved imagery, as much of it as I can get.
Honestly, if there were an option for a 0.5 star, I would have rated this a 3.5 star read rather than just three stars. It falls in between my personal criteria for rating books, something that has not really happened before. I really enjoyed this book even though it was a step outside of my comfort zone, and I am so glad that I did. DI Kelly might have singlehandedly convinced me to read more mystery and crime books!
A huge thank you to Netgalley, Canelo, and Rachel Lynch for sending me an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
September 20, 2023
Solids 4 / 5 stars
Following on from the events of the previous book, I understand why there’s many positive reviews and high ratings. I didn’t have a bone to pick with this one, solid plot, solid build up and great ending. Although I did find it obvious and predictable, I think it was always the reasoning behind it that- there’s always a element of surprise.
The plot follows Kelly after a body is found in the bottom of a reservoir. Initially this body didn’t pose a significant theft but after conformation through dental records reveal that the body is of a friend of Kelly who went missing 24 years ago. To top it off, another body is found at caravan park. To top it all off Kelly recognises bother bodies as part of her history before joining the police force. Kelly goes on a mission to find out who is responsible- where more information of her past is revealed which leaves Kelly dealing with the aftermath of events.
My biggest takeaway from this is the personal and professional issues Kelly Porter is trying to balance and manage. This book makes her look very human and relatable, returning back home to be thrust in a murder investigation about previous friends in GCSE and A levels. She felt relatable, real and genuine which is why I’m starting to enjoy the series more. Her problems about school, about past friends I resonated throughout the book. It Feels more real and you feel more for the characters. The plot was great, the build up is steady-overall a good read. Definitely worth investigating into the series if you have not!
Following on from the events of the previous book, I understand why there’s many positive reviews and high ratings. I didn’t have a bone to pick with this one, solid plot, solid build up and great ending. Although I did find it obvious and predictable, I think it was always the reasoning behind it that- there’s always a element of surprise.
The plot follows Kelly after a body is found in the bottom of a reservoir. Initially this body didn’t pose a significant theft but after conformation through dental records reveal that the body is of a friend of Kelly who went missing 24 years ago. To top it off, another body is found at caravan park. To top it all off Kelly recognises bother bodies as part of her history before joining the police force. Kelly goes on a mission to find out who is responsible- where more information of her past is revealed which leaves Kelly dealing with the aftermath of events.
My biggest takeaway from this is the personal and professional issues Kelly Porter is trying to balance and manage. This book makes her look very human and relatable, returning back home to be thrust in a murder investigation about previous friends in GCSE and A levels. She felt relatable, real and genuine which is why I’m starting to enjoy the series more. Her problems about school, about past friends I resonated throughout the book. It Feels more real and you feel more for the characters. The plot was great, the build up is steady-overall a good read. Definitely worth investigating into the series if you have not!
July 23, 2023
This is a great crime thriller.
With the discovery of bones in a dried out reservoir, DI Kelly Porter has her hands full trying to work out their identity.
Whilst this is taking place another body is found under a holiday home but this time they know his identity.
Once dental checks come back Kelly knows that the two men were friends as she used to go to school with them.
The owner of the holiday park also knew both men very well and Kelly as well.
There’s other people linked to the murders but Kelly and the team have trouble finding the truth, as more than one person is hiding something.
This is a gripping crime thriller with some nail biting final chapters.
Thanks to Canelo and NetGalley for the opportunity to read this book.
With the discovery of bones in a dried out reservoir, DI Kelly Porter has her hands full trying to work out their identity.
Whilst this is taking place another body is found under a holiday home but this time they know his identity.
Once dental checks come back Kelly knows that the two men were friends as she used to go to school with them.
The owner of the holiday park also knew both men very well and Kelly as well.
There’s other people linked to the murders but Kelly and the team have trouble finding the truth, as more than one person is hiding something.
This is a gripping crime thriller with some nail biting final chapters.
Thanks to Canelo and NetGalley for the opportunity to read this book.
July 25, 2023
would like to thank netgalley and the publisher for letting me read this brilliant book
it was great catching up with kelly and her work colleagues, seeing how they were getting on with lives and their jobs...
a summer drought meant that all the reservoirs were low and thats what caused the body to be discovered from its place....
bones old bones and kellys unit were called in...along with ted her dad....
these old bones were about to tell a story one that took kelly back to her school days and her memories were about to receive a nasty shock
but another murder happened which was to shock kelly even more....
oh my goodness me what a storyline i couldnt put this book down at all...the shocks kept coming for poor kelly, just shows how our memories can be tainted without us even knowing ... a painful lesson for kelly but one that will make her stronger
cant wait for the next book in this brilliant series
it was great catching up with kelly and her work colleagues, seeing how they were getting on with lives and their jobs...
a summer drought meant that all the reservoirs were low and thats what caused the body to be discovered from its place....
bones old bones and kellys unit were called in...along with ted her dad....
these old bones were about to tell a story one that took kelly back to her school days and her memories were about to receive a nasty shock
but another murder happened which was to shock kelly even more....
oh my goodness me what a storyline i couldnt put this book down at all...the shocks kept coming for poor kelly, just shows how our memories can be tainted without us even knowing ... a painful lesson for kelly but one that will make her stronger
cant wait for the next book in this brilliant series
June 16, 2023
DI Kelly Porter has lived her whole life in the Lake District, apart from a brief spell with the Met, so it isn't unusual for her to know some of those involved in her cases, but her latest investigation is taking this to a whole new level. In the middle of a spell of hot, dry weather, local water levels are getting dangerously low with nearby Thirlmere Reservoir gradually revealing some of its secrets,
When a skeleton is found and identified, memories come rushing back for Kelly as she begins looking at a cold case from her schooldays. When a second body is found with similar links, she finds herself speaking with peers she hasn't thought of in decades, and none of them is telling everything they know. Gradually, things begin to move, and for Kelly, everything becomes very personal indeed.
This is the eleventh in Rachel Lynch's excellent series and a brilliant addition. The case this time gives more insight into Kelly's past and how her classmates saw her. I found this a fascinating part of the storyline, which made me like Kelly even more. The research undertaken by the author shone brightly throughout and added another level to this first-class read, which will leave everyone desperate for book twelve.
I was able to read an advanced copy of this book thanks to NetGalley and publishers Canelo Crime, but the opinions expressed are my own. I loved this. It is excellent and easy to recommend.
When a skeleton is found and identified, memories come rushing back for Kelly as she begins looking at a cold case from her schooldays. When a second body is found with similar links, she finds herself speaking with peers she hasn't thought of in decades, and none of them is telling everything they know. Gradually, things begin to move, and for Kelly, everything becomes very personal indeed.
This is the eleventh in Rachel Lynch's excellent series and a brilliant addition. The case this time gives more insight into Kelly's past and how her classmates saw her. I found this a fascinating part of the storyline, which made me like Kelly even more. The research undertaken by the author shone brightly throughout and added another level to this first-class read, which will leave everyone desperate for book twelve.
I was able to read an advanced copy of this book thanks to NetGalley and publishers Canelo Crime, but the opinions expressed are my own. I loved this. It is excellent and easy to recommend.
August 2, 2023
Silent Bones is a gripping crime thriller that takes place in the picturesque Lake District in the UK. The story revolves around DI Kelly Porter, a determined and tenacious detective who is investigating a mysterious case involving a skeleton found at the bottom of the Thirlmere reservoir during a drought.
The novel combines elements of police procedural, murder mystery, and psychological suspense. As the investigation unfolds, secrets and long-buried truths come to light, creating a tense and atmospheric atmosphere throughout the narrative. The Lake District setting adds to the eerie and haunting ambience, creating a sense of isolation and foreboding.
The story delves into themes of betrayal, deception, and the dark secrets that can lurk beneath the surface of seemingly idyllic communities. As DI Kelly Porter digs deeper into the case, she must navigate through a web of lies and hidden motives to uncover the truth behind the skeleton's identity and the circumstances of its death.
The characters are well-developed and multi-dimensional, with complex backstories and personal struggles that add depth to the story. DI Kelly Porter is a compelling and relatable protagonist, driven by a strong sense of justice and a determination to bring closure to the victim's family.
Silent Bones offers an enthralling and atmospheric crime thriller that will keep readers on the edge of their seats until the final revelation. Rachel Lynch's skilful storytelling and attention to detail make for a compelling read that will appeal to fans of suspenseful and well-crafted mysteries.
The novel combines elements of police procedural, murder mystery, and psychological suspense. As the investigation unfolds, secrets and long-buried truths come to light, creating a tense and atmospheric atmosphere throughout the narrative. The Lake District setting adds to the eerie and haunting ambience, creating a sense of isolation and foreboding.
The story delves into themes of betrayal, deception, and the dark secrets that can lurk beneath the surface of seemingly idyllic communities. As DI Kelly Porter digs deeper into the case, she must navigate through a web of lies and hidden motives to uncover the truth behind the skeleton's identity and the circumstances of its death.
The characters are well-developed and multi-dimensional, with complex backstories and personal struggles that add depth to the story. DI Kelly Porter is a compelling and relatable protagonist, driven by a strong sense of justice and a determination to bring closure to the victim's family.
Silent Bones offers an enthralling and atmospheric crime thriller that will keep readers on the edge of their seats until the final revelation. Rachel Lynch's skilful storytelling and attention to detail make for a compelling read that will appeal to fans of suspenseful and well-crafted mysteries.
November 12, 2025
This was a quick enjoyable read, and although it was a stand alone story it is part of the Detective Kelly Porter series of books, which meant that there were some references to previous plot/story lines which I knew nothing about and at times I wished I did!
December 18, 2023
4.5 stars really another enthralling installment.
February 7, 2024
Another good read
August 1, 2023
3.5/5 stars
This book is about DI Kelly Porter and her team investigating a body being found and a subsequent body turning up, revealing hidden and dark secrets from within the community.
What worked for this book was that the first couple pages really hooked the reader. This is important because you want to be drawn into a book by the writing style and story setup. Even though this was the first book I had read in this series, it was easy to connect to storyline and characters even without reading the first set of books. Though I do plan to start from the beginning.
Although the book did have an intriguing storyline and characters especially Kelly, Kate and Ted, I found that sometimes there was bit too much description with some of the character or scene setups.
Overall, it was a good read, and I would say this book is for people who love mystery – suspense novels and those that enjoy intriguing characters.
Thank you to Netgalley and Canelo Digital Publishing for the ARC.
#SilentBones #Netgalley #rachellynch #dikellyporter #dikellyporterseries #bookreview
This book is about DI Kelly Porter and her team investigating a body being found and a subsequent body turning up, revealing hidden and dark secrets from within the community.
What worked for this book was that the first couple pages really hooked the reader. This is important because you want to be drawn into a book by the writing style and story setup. Even though this was the first book I had read in this series, it was easy to connect to storyline and characters even without reading the first set of books. Though I do plan to start from the beginning.
Although the book did have an intriguing storyline and characters especially Kelly, Kate and Ted, I found that sometimes there was bit too much description with some of the character or scene setups.
Overall, it was a good read, and I would say this book is for people who love mystery – suspense novels and those that enjoy intriguing characters.
Thank you to Netgalley and Canelo Digital Publishing for the ARC.
#SilentBones #Netgalley #rachellynch #dikellyporter #dikellyporterseries #bookreview
July 23, 2024
Absolutely amazing! Hurry, Book 12!
As was the case from Kelly Porter's introduction, the backdrop is easily envisioned, and just as entertaining, as the protagonist herself. Cumbria sounds amazing. Her entire team and family are down to earth and relatable. This is great reading. I couldn't out this one down. Lottie and Kim Stone, you're in great company with Kelly Porter. Absolutely recommend this series.
As was the case from Kelly Porter's introduction, the backdrop is easily envisioned, and just as entertaining, as the protagonist herself. Cumbria sounds amazing. Her entire team and family are down to earth and relatable. This is great reading. I couldn't out this one down. Lottie and Kim Stone, you're in great company with Kelly Porter. Absolutely recommend this series.
July 19, 2023
Thanks to Netgalley and Canelo for the ARC of this book. All views are my own.
I have read all but one of Rachel Lynch's DI Kelly Porter series; I love them. Rachel Lynch is one of my favourite crime writers, alongside LJ Ross and Angela Marsons. Her books are gritty - she pulls no punches with her source material - and her characters feel like real human beings, with everyday lives and issues of their own to deal with. Kelly Porter is the kind of detective, whereby, if something bad happened to one of my loved ones (Heaven forbid!) I'd want her on the case!
The book begins with the discovery of human remains in the dried-up edges of one of the Lake District's stunning lakes, revealed due to falling water levels as a result of a hot summer. This gives Kelly the opportunity to solve a cold case - one which soon transpires to be a lot closer to home than she could have foreseen. Of course, in true Lynch style, the body count doesn't stay too low for long and Kelly finds herself investigating the far more recent murder of an old school pal.
I don't want to say more about the story for fear of giving away too many details. However, what I will say is that the regular characters and their relationships continue to be central to the plot. I love the relationship between Kelly and Ted, and felt that Ted, quite rightly, was able to come into his own as her real father in this book. I also adored his friend who drops by to help with the analysis of the bones! I'd love to see him some more in your books, Rachel! As a mother of a child who has just sat his A Levels and is waiting for his results, I'm also rooting for Kelly's stepdaughter, and I think her choosing to go into forensic science would be a fabulous idea (rather than History!) and I can even see her as a summer intern alongside Ted! I'm going to stop trying to force my ideas on the lovely Rachel now!
As ever, the narrative is fast-paced and you will find yourself both flying towards the end and simultaneously trying to drag it out for as long as you can. Both the writing and editing are excellent, but I'm guessing this is what keeps me coming back time and again for more!
Please, if you have not read any of Rachel Lynch's books, do give the DI Kelly Porter series a look. Dark Game is the first instalment and I am sure you will be as hooked as I am!
I have read all but one of Rachel Lynch's DI Kelly Porter series; I love them. Rachel Lynch is one of my favourite crime writers, alongside LJ Ross and Angela Marsons. Her books are gritty - she pulls no punches with her source material - and her characters feel like real human beings, with everyday lives and issues of their own to deal with. Kelly Porter is the kind of detective, whereby, if something bad happened to one of my loved ones (Heaven forbid!) I'd want her on the case!
The book begins with the discovery of human remains in the dried-up edges of one of the Lake District's stunning lakes, revealed due to falling water levels as a result of a hot summer. This gives Kelly the opportunity to solve a cold case - one which soon transpires to be a lot closer to home than she could have foreseen. Of course, in true Lynch style, the body count doesn't stay too low for long and Kelly finds herself investigating the far more recent murder of an old school pal.
I don't want to say more about the story for fear of giving away too many details. However, what I will say is that the regular characters and their relationships continue to be central to the plot. I love the relationship between Kelly and Ted, and felt that Ted, quite rightly, was able to come into his own as her real father in this book. I also adored his friend who drops by to help with the analysis of the bones! I'd love to see him some more in your books, Rachel! As a mother of a child who has just sat his A Levels and is waiting for his results, I'm also rooting for Kelly's stepdaughter, and I think her choosing to go into forensic science would be a fabulous idea (rather than History!) and I can even see her as a summer intern alongside Ted! I'm going to stop trying to force my ideas on the lovely Rachel now!
As ever, the narrative is fast-paced and you will find yourself both flying towards the end and simultaneously trying to drag it out for as long as you can. Both the writing and editing are excellent, but I'm guessing this is what keeps me coming back time and again for more!
Please, if you have not read any of Rachel Lynch's books, do give the DI Kelly Porter series a look. Dark Game is the first instalment and I am sure you will be as hooked as I am!
October 12, 2024
It’s a year since the last time we visited the Lake District in the world of the D I Kelly Porter series and Kelly has moved on from the difficult situation that caused her so much pain in her personal life.
The summer has been hot and dry so much so that Lake Thirlmere, a manmade reservoir, has lost a lot of water and in doing so reveals the remains of a young man – who was he? How did he end up in Thirlmere?
When another body turns up, that of a man recently killed, Kelly cannot but feel that they are linked somehow. Especially when it takes her back to her school days and an unresolved missing person case that her father worked on.
As the investigations continue, the post mortem on the second body and the forensic evidence being gathered on the Thirlmere remains bring up a fact that confirms Kelly’s suspicions. Kelly also has to face the fact that the man she called her father for most of her life and looked up to may not the man she thought she knew.
It was good to be back in the Lakes especially as I had literally been there just a short while before reading Silent Bones and had visited a number of the places that were in the book in particular Penrith were I visited the charming Hedgehog bookshop and Pooley Bridge which included a visit to the lovely Verey Bookshop and cafe (yes, I bought books!). It makes the story feel so real and ensured my engagement and enjoyment of the book right from the opening page.
Rachel Lynch not only brings the beautiful Lakes setting into her story bringing it to life as she would a character – and she has some lovely characters that are part of her team and her family – but delivers an engaging, engrossing story with good plots that make for a really good read. Silent Bones is another terrific addition to this wonderful series and now the next instalment is calling me, it won’t be too long before I sit down to read Shared Remains which is quietly awaiting my attention.
4.5*
The summer has been hot and dry so much so that Lake Thirlmere, a manmade reservoir, has lost a lot of water and in doing so reveals the remains of a young man – who was he? How did he end up in Thirlmere?
When another body turns up, that of a man recently killed, Kelly cannot but feel that they are linked somehow. Especially when it takes her back to her school days and an unresolved missing person case that her father worked on.
As the investigations continue, the post mortem on the second body and the forensic evidence being gathered on the Thirlmere remains bring up a fact that confirms Kelly’s suspicions. Kelly also has to face the fact that the man she called her father for most of her life and looked up to may not the man she thought she knew.
It was good to be back in the Lakes especially as I had literally been there just a short while before reading Silent Bones and had visited a number of the places that were in the book in particular Penrith were I visited the charming Hedgehog bookshop and Pooley Bridge which included a visit to the lovely Verey Bookshop and cafe (yes, I bought books!). It makes the story feel so real and ensured my engagement and enjoyment of the book right from the opening page.
Rachel Lynch not only brings the beautiful Lakes setting into her story bringing it to life as she would a character – and she has some lovely characters that are part of her team and her family – but delivers an engaging, engrossing story with good plots that make for a really good read. Silent Bones is another terrific addition to this wonderful series and now the next instalment is calling me, it won’t be too long before I sit down to read Shared Remains which is quietly awaiting my attention.
4.5*
August 11, 2023
My Rating: 2.5 stars out of 5
I came into this novel having not read any of the prior ones because the premise caught my attention.
And here is what I learned.
The author tells the story in such a way that you don't need to have read any of the others in order to grasp what is happening. There was just enough background given for each of the main players that I felt I understood them and their relationships to one another (although having two female characters named Kelly and Kate working close together did get confusing more than once as I sometimes forgot just who was actually in charge).
The second thing I learned is that too much detail spoils the plot. Seriously. It was a good story, but there were just so many details about absolutely everything that I struggled to stay invested. I don't need to know step by step every thought a character has or every movement that they make. This is especially true when I had things figured out before the detectives. There were times when I found myself wanting to throw my Kindle (instead, I settled for closing it and setting it aside time and time again) because I found myself so frustrated with how things were going.
Please, authors, I beg you, if you put that much detail into your characters every thought and movement, please make them smarter?
At the end of the day, this one was not for me for the reasons listed above. However, I can see where it would appeal to others, especially people who have been reading this series longer and therefore have a better understanding of these characters.
DISCLAIMER: I received a complimentary copy of this novel from the publisher. This has not affected my review in any way. All thoughts and opinions expressed in this review are 100% my own.
I came into this novel having not read any of the prior ones because the premise caught my attention.
And here is what I learned.
The author tells the story in such a way that you don't need to have read any of the others in order to grasp what is happening. There was just enough background given for each of the main players that I felt I understood them and their relationships to one another (although having two female characters named Kelly and Kate working close together did get confusing more than once as I sometimes forgot just who was actually in charge).
The second thing I learned is that too much detail spoils the plot. Seriously. It was a good story, but there were just so many details about absolutely everything that I struggled to stay invested. I don't need to know step by step every thought a character has or every movement that they make. This is especially true when I had things figured out before the detectives. There were times when I found myself wanting to throw my Kindle (instead, I settled for closing it and setting it aside time and time again) because I found myself so frustrated with how things were going.
Please, authors, I beg you, if you put that much detail into your characters every thought and movement, please make them smarter?
At the end of the day, this one was not for me for the reasons listed above. However, I can see where it would appeal to others, especially people who have been reading this series longer and therefore have a better understanding of these characters.
DISCLAIMER: I received a complimentary copy of this novel from the publisher. This has not affected my review in any way. All thoughts and opinions expressed in this review are 100% my own.
October 18, 2023
A gripping tale that is as much about the past as the present. DI Kelly Porter returns with a new tale about a cold case that brings back haunting memories for all involved.
Kelly was a good girl in school she stayed away from the cool kids, she kept her head down and did not rub people up the wrong way yet she remained approachable and knew when the cool kids went bad.
In 1997, a young boy called Brian disappears and during a drought in the Thirlmere part of the Lake District, a body is found in a reservoir. The body is found to be that of young Brian who never came home one night.
The case spins on the discovery that some people are not letting on to know as much as they originally suggested. From the teacher, Mr. Thompson who hangs out with children at the weekend and may or may not been a drug supplier to those same pupils to Michelle the owner of a Holiday camp who took pity upon a local no-good Jason Cooper.
The discovery of a second body turns the case upside down with two murders to solve in a small town; coupled with accusations that Kelly's father, John Porter, renowned local policeman was not the salt of the earth he led people to believe.
As well as having to solve a case, Kelly also has a young family to look after and this follows familiar tropes of Canelo Crime releases from Lynch's contemporaries (MJ Lee and Marion Todd) who also have domestic routines to account for. This stable of writers make clear that law enforcement have problems at home to deal with as well as the crimes to solve - and this balance or openness of relationships certainly makes the characters more relatable and sympathetic.
At times highly enthralling and page-turning, this is my first read of a Lynch crime thriller and certainly shall not be the last.
Kelly was a good girl in school she stayed away from the cool kids, she kept her head down and did not rub people up the wrong way yet she remained approachable and knew when the cool kids went bad.
In 1997, a young boy called Brian disappears and during a drought in the Thirlmere part of the Lake District, a body is found in a reservoir. The body is found to be that of young Brian who never came home one night.
The case spins on the discovery that some people are not letting on to know as much as they originally suggested. From the teacher, Mr. Thompson who hangs out with children at the weekend and may or may not been a drug supplier to those same pupils to Michelle the owner of a Holiday camp who took pity upon a local no-good Jason Cooper.
The discovery of a second body turns the case upside down with two murders to solve in a small town; coupled with accusations that Kelly's father, John Porter, renowned local policeman was not the salt of the earth he led people to believe.
As well as having to solve a case, Kelly also has a young family to look after and this follows familiar tropes of Canelo Crime releases from Lynch's contemporaries (MJ Lee and Marion Todd) who also have domestic routines to account for. This stable of writers make clear that law enforcement have problems at home to deal with as well as the crimes to solve - and this balance or openness of relationships certainly makes the characters more relatable and sympathetic.
At times highly enthralling and page-turning, this is my first read of a Lynch crime thriller and certainly shall not be the last.
June 15, 2023
I really enjoy reading police procedural series and the DI Kelly Porter is one of my favourites. This is the eleventh book in the series by author Rachel Lynch and once again it is a very enjoyable read.
This another very good addition to this series and had me hooked from the very start. For me the characters are the strongest part of this series, so well described and developed that I feel like I know them and would love to watch a television series based on the books.
A skeleton is discovered in Thirlmere Reservoir leaving the local community shocked. Secrets and painful memories are about to be exposed. DI Kelly Porter is once again leading investigations but this time it threatens to be personal when the bones are revealed to be a former classmate. Brian Miller went missing over two decades ago and now the discovery of his remains makes it very difficult for Kelly to stay professional.
Rachel Lynch paces the story excellently as the case unfolds with the past and present meeting. When another body is discovered in a caravan park it is found to be Jason Cooper, a friend of Brian’s who was one of the last people to see him alive. This is too much of a coincidence for the two cases not to be linked.
As stated before the strength of this series are the characters who are flawed and relatable and make a very entertaining read. Kelly Porter is a great character but she is well supported by her family members. This is a very good crime series that I would recommend starting from book one to get the full package.
I would like to thank both Netgalley and Canelo books for supplying a copy of this novel in exchange for an honest review.
This another very good addition to this series and had me hooked from the very start. For me the characters are the strongest part of this series, so well described and developed that I feel like I know them and would love to watch a television series based on the books.
A skeleton is discovered in Thirlmere Reservoir leaving the local community shocked. Secrets and painful memories are about to be exposed. DI Kelly Porter is once again leading investigations but this time it threatens to be personal when the bones are revealed to be a former classmate. Brian Miller went missing over two decades ago and now the discovery of his remains makes it very difficult for Kelly to stay professional.
Rachel Lynch paces the story excellently as the case unfolds with the past and present meeting. When another body is discovered in a caravan park it is found to be Jason Cooper, a friend of Brian’s who was one of the last people to see him alive. This is too much of a coincidence for the two cases not to be linked.
As stated before the strength of this series are the characters who are flawed and relatable and make a very entertaining read. Kelly Porter is a great character but she is well supported by her family members. This is a very good crime series that I would recommend starting from book one to get the full package.
I would like to thank both Netgalley and Canelo books for supplying a copy of this novel in exchange for an honest review.
July 6, 2023
Silent Bones is the eleventh book in the DI Kelly Porter series, but you don’t need to have read the earlier books to enjoy this one. This is a solid police procedural set in the Lake District around Penrith. Kelly Porter is from the area and after a spell in London working for the Met has returned to her roots.
“Bastards doing horrible things hadn’t changed: the scenery had just got prettier.”
As water levels go down in a hot summer spell, a skeleton emerges in Thirlmere Reservoir. The skeleton is found to be Kelly Porter’s erstwhile classmate, Brian Miller, who had disappeared as a teenager, 24 years previously. A day later the body of a second classmate is found freshly killed in a local caravan park. Kelly has to decide whether to continue with the case, is it possible to stay professional when the victims and persons of interest were known to her? Investigating the murders will bring back memories of her own teenage years as a lonely girl, who studied hard but who was never part of the cool kids group.
The pacing is good and the characters are fascinating and flawed. The forensic details feel accurate down to the mortuary wax and the latest photogrammetry techniques. Kelly is continually frustrated by the lies she is told as she tries to get to the bottom of this murder mystery. I can imagine this would make for a good TV adaptation.
I would like to thank both Netgalley and Canelo books for supplying a copy of this novel, I leave this review voluntarily.
“Bastards doing horrible things hadn’t changed: the scenery had just got prettier.”
As water levels go down in a hot summer spell, a skeleton emerges in Thirlmere Reservoir. The skeleton is found to be Kelly Porter’s erstwhile classmate, Brian Miller, who had disappeared as a teenager, 24 years previously. A day later the body of a second classmate is found freshly killed in a local caravan park. Kelly has to decide whether to continue with the case, is it possible to stay professional when the victims and persons of interest were known to her? Investigating the murders will bring back memories of her own teenage years as a lonely girl, who studied hard but who was never part of the cool kids group.
The pacing is good and the characters are fascinating and flawed. The forensic details feel accurate down to the mortuary wax and the latest photogrammetry techniques. Kelly is continually frustrated by the lies she is told as she tries to get to the bottom of this murder mystery. I can imagine this would make for a good TV adaptation.
I would like to thank both Netgalley and Canelo books for supplying a copy of this novel, I leave this review voluntarily.
July 27, 2023
Increasing temperatures in the Lake District have led to a depleted Thirlmere Reservoir uncovering a skeleton at the bottom. This soon becomes personal for DI Kelly Porter when the body is revealed to be that of someone she went to school with. When this is soon followed by the violent death of another classmate, worries surface that someone has killed to prevent what happened years ago being revealed. The likelihood is that Kelly knows the killer; can she prevent more deaths?
This is now the eleventh book in the Kelly Porter series and it is still as good as ever. As in previous books, the setting is one of the main strengths, with Rachel Lynch creating a vivid image of the Lake District, helping to set the scene for some very location-specific crimes. I found it easy to picture the reservoir, the caravan park and the surrounding areas, making this a fully immersive read. In some police procedurals, it can feel like the lead detective becomes personally involved in a disproportionate amount of crime but the setting here makes it inevitable, with Kelly having to put her past behind her to remain open minded.
It was interesting to see an old adversary of Kelly’s making an appearance and witnessing how, despite them not being around, they continue to exercise their power over certain individuals. There are several spoilers here for those who have not read previous books but this could still be read as a standalone. The rest of the series is brilliant, though, so I would recommend reading them all!
Rachel Lynch has written another gripping book which, thanks to one particular event, also manages to tug on the heart strings. I’m looking forward to seeing what is next for Kelly and her team.
This is now the eleventh book in the Kelly Porter series and it is still as good as ever. As in previous books, the setting is one of the main strengths, with Rachel Lynch creating a vivid image of the Lake District, helping to set the scene for some very location-specific crimes. I found it easy to picture the reservoir, the caravan park and the surrounding areas, making this a fully immersive read. In some police procedurals, it can feel like the lead detective becomes personally involved in a disproportionate amount of crime but the setting here makes it inevitable, with Kelly having to put her past behind her to remain open minded.
It was interesting to see an old adversary of Kelly’s making an appearance and witnessing how, despite them not being around, they continue to exercise their power over certain individuals. There are several spoilers here for those who have not read previous books but this could still be read as a standalone. The rest of the series is brilliant, though, so I would recommend reading them all!
Rachel Lynch has written another gripping book which, thanks to one particular event, also manages to tug on the heart strings. I’m looking forward to seeing what is next for Kelly and her team.
June 28, 2023
Kelly Porter’s past is thrown into question when the bodies of two former classmates are found; one who has been missing for 24 hours and one who was murdered after the body was found. These discoveries cause her to question her memories of her family, teachers and classmates as she hunts down the culprits of these crimes.
To echo the other reviews here; I knew exactly who did it and why before the detective did. I found this frustrating, as I waited for Kelly to figure out what I already knew. Additionally, it is revealed in the plot summary that the first body is Brian’s and it found that it took the detectives a frustratingly long time to come to this conclusion. I am a reader who likes plot twists and surprises and this book did not have that for me. However, for someone who is looking for a light read, this quality may be what they are looking for.
This was my first time reading a Kelly Porter book and to start with #11 in the series is no doubt a daunting task. However, I found that it functioned well as a standalone book. Characters pasts and the relationships between them were explained well and concisely. It allows readers like myself to get background information while lovers of the Kelly Porter series likely won’t find it repetitive since it is quite concise.
Thank you to NetGalley and Canelo Crime for this advanced copy in exchange for my honest review.
To echo the other reviews here; I knew exactly who did it and why before the detective did. I found this frustrating, as I waited for Kelly to figure out what I already knew. Additionally, it is revealed in the plot summary that the first body is Brian’s and it found that it took the detectives a frustratingly long time to come to this conclusion. I am a reader who likes plot twists and surprises and this book did not have that for me. However, for someone who is looking for a light read, this quality may be what they are looking for.
This was my first time reading a Kelly Porter book and to start with #11 in the series is no doubt a daunting task. However, I found that it functioned well as a standalone book. Characters pasts and the relationships between them were explained well and concisely. It allows readers like myself to get background information while lovers of the Kelly Porter series likely won’t find it repetitive since it is quite concise.
Thank you to NetGalley and Canelo Crime for this advanced copy in exchange for my honest review.
June 17, 2023
Silent Bones by Rachel Lynch
Characters: 5/5
Plot: 5/5
Mystery/Thrill: 5/5
Overall: 5/5
I am so happy that we get so see DI Kelly Porter again and this book takes us to her past. A skeleton is found in the bottom of Thirlmere Reservoir in the Lake District where Kelly grew up for most of her young life. It just happens to be one of her classmates that went missing years ago named Brian Miller. DI Kelly Porter leads the investigation that gets turned even further upside down when a second body is found. That of Jason Cooper, who was the last person to see Brian Miller alive, was found deceased in a caravan park. Kelly is also dealing with a personal issue with the man she now knows is not her biological father John Porter. Sergeant Porter was a wonderful police officer in her eyes but turned out to be a very flawed father and husband. The two collide and Kelly must find her inner strength to determine who is lying and who, if anyone, is telling the truth.
The pace was perfect as were the characters. As usual Lynch has done an amazing job of bringing two different situations and show how turmoil affects the characters she has created. An amazing storyline that is very well written.
July 22 2023! Cannot wait.
Thank you to NetGalley as well as the author and publisher for giving me the opportunity to read this book in exchange for my unbiased and honest review.
Characters: 5/5
Plot: 5/5
Mystery/Thrill: 5/5
Overall: 5/5
I am so happy that we get so see DI Kelly Porter again and this book takes us to her past. A skeleton is found in the bottom of Thirlmere Reservoir in the Lake District where Kelly grew up for most of her young life. It just happens to be one of her classmates that went missing years ago named Brian Miller. DI Kelly Porter leads the investigation that gets turned even further upside down when a second body is found. That of Jason Cooper, who was the last person to see Brian Miller alive, was found deceased in a caravan park. Kelly is also dealing with a personal issue with the man she now knows is not her biological father John Porter. Sergeant Porter was a wonderful police officer in her eyes but turned out to be a very flawed father and husband. The two collide and Kelly must find her inner strength to determine who is lying and who, if anyone, is telling the truth.
The pace was perfect as were the characters. As usual Lynch has done an amazing job of bringing two different situations and show how turmoil affects the characters she has created. An amazing storyline that is very well written.
July 22 2023! Cannot wait.
Thank you to NetGalley as well as the author and publisher for giving me the opportunity to read this book in exchange for my unbiased and honest review.
December 5, 2023
So, this is the 11th novel in this series; I’m always a little worried that long series like this will become repetitive however that doesn’t seem to be the case. Each one of these novels is great and this was no exception. I really like the development of the original characters and like the introduction of some new ones. I thought the plot was interesting and had plenty of twists and turns, as any good crime thriller should have. I did guess the ‘who done it’ this time but that didn’t take away from the ending at all and I didn’t see the final twist at all! I also always love visiting the Lake District so the setting is spot on! I would 100% recommend this series to anyone who loves a good crime thriller! You do need to start from the beginning though!
Blurb
Thirlmere hides a deadly secret…
Drought hits the Lake District, uncovering a skeleton at the bottom of Thirlmere reservoir. The case quickly becomes personal for DI Kelly Porter when she discovers it’s the remains of an old classmate, missing for over twenty years.
Then a day later, another body is found in a caravan park, its head broken and bloody.
Kelly suspects these two crimes are linked. But if she’s right, that means there’s a ruthless killer somewhere in her community – someone who will do anything to keep the truth buried…
Blurb
Thirlmere hides a deadly secret…
Drought hits the Lake District, uncovering a skeleton at the bottom of Thirlmere reservoir. The case quickly becomes personal for DI Kelly Porter when she discovers it’s the remains of an old classmate, missing for over twenty years.
Then a day later, another body is found in a caravan park, its head broken and bloody.
Kelly suspects these two crimes are linked. But if she’s right, that means there’s a ruthless killer somewhere in her community – someone who will do anything to keep the truth buried…
February 27, 2024
This is the eleventh book in this brilliant series featuring Detective Kelly Porter. It makes more interesting reading as it is set in the Lake District. The Lake District is in the middle of a drought and the water levels in the lakes are really low. This leads to the discovery of a skeleton in Thirlmere Reservoir. Kelly is shocked to find after extensive examination that it is an old school friend of hers, Brian Miller, who disappeared over twenty years ago. Whilst investigating this case a body is found under a caravan in a holiday park. It was the body of Jason Cooper, another one of Kelly’s schools friends and one of the last people to see Brian alive. She realises that somehow the cases must be linked but more shocks are in store as it appears that the original police investigation into Brian’s disappearance had been very badly handled. Also Kelly was horrified to learn that her father had been leading the investigation and questions his findings. This case brings very painful memories for Kelly as she has to interview more of her school peers and realises that they know more than they are letting one. This was another brilliant read that had me totally gripped. I look forward to the next book in the series.
Thanks to Netgalley and Canelo books for giving me the opportunity to read and review this book,
Thanks to Netgalley and Canelo books for giving me the opportunity to read and review this book,
July 4, 2023
This book is the perfect crime series for any and all CSI fans!!! Silent Bones is the 11th (!!!!) instalment of DI Kelly Porter, but can be read as a stand-alone. And let me tell you, this book will suck you in from the very start.
Each character is so well thought out, I love when everything and everyone has a deep rooted connection, and what better than a small town group of roughen teens turned adults holding on to the truth for 24 years… 👀
Kelly is a very relatable character, fighting between duty and her head/heart. Each side character as mentioned was perfectly executed and I felt intertwined with them all and the storyline.
Lynch brings you right into the thick of it with pathologists and investigative detectives. The jargon of these professionals brings a new meaning to the story, it’s an addictive reading feeling like you’re right in the room with them.
I do wish the ending had a bit more of a punch but overall pretty satisfied with how everything came together! I also love when you get a taste of everything coming together before the characters do, omg you turn the pages so fast 🤣
Highly recommend this one for a great crime read/series 👮🏻🚓🚨
Thank you to @canelo, @netgalley, and the talented @rachellynch for the ARC 🤍🦴
Due to release this month, July 27!!! 📖
Each character is so well thought out, I love when everything and everyone has a deep rooted connection, and what better than a small town group of roughen teens turned adults holding on to the truth for 24 years… 👀
Kelly is a very relatable character, fighting between duty and her head/heart. Each side character as mentioned was perfectly executed and I felt intertwined with them all and the storyline.
Lynch brings you right into the thick of it with pathologists and investigative detectives. The jargon of these professionals brings a new meaning to the story, it’s an addictive reading feeling like you’re right in the room with them.
I do wish the ending had a bit more of a punch but overall pretty satisfied with how everything came together! I also love when you get a taste of everything coming together before the characters do, omg you turn the pages so fast 🤣
Highly recommend this one for a great crime read/series 👮🏻🚓🚨
Thank you to @canelo, @netgalley, and the talented @rachellynch for the ARC 🤍🦴
Due to release this month, July 27!!! 📖
July 9, 2023
Silent Bones by Rachel Lynch is the 11th book in the D.I. Kelly Porter series and has time flown.
After a spell of hot weather, D.I. Kelly Porter is investigating a skeleton rising from the depths of local Thirlmere reservoir. She is shocked to discover after the remains is identified, that they are of an old classmate that disappeared over twenty-four years ago. Who would want to kill him and why?
When another body is discovered at a local Caravan Park murdered in a similar way of that the skeleton and another old school friend of Kelly’s. She takes it personal but keeps being professional in her investigation. She needs to find out the connection between the two murders and why wait for the killer to strike again. She knows that she has a serial killer of her hands.
Thank you, Canelo, for a copy of Silent Bones. Once again, the author has a provided solid murder mystery with D.I. Kelly Porter at the helm. The quality this series never falters. This has a great storyline and I love the descriptions of the different parts of the Lake district and the author gives us great insight of the different procedures in the world of pathology. I really enjoyed this. Another 5 stars from me.
After a spell of hot weather, D.I. Kelly Porter is investigating a skeleton rising from the depths of local Thirlmere reservoir. She is shocked to discover after the remains is identified, that they are of an old classmate that disappeared over twenty-four years ago. Who would want to kill him and why?
When another body is discovered at a local Caravan Park murdered in a similar way of that the skeleton and another old school friend of Kelly’s. She takes it personal but keeps being professional in her investigation. She needs to find out the connection between the two murders and why wait for the killer to strike again. She knows that she has a serial killer of her hands.
Thank you, Canelo, for a copy of Silent Bones. Once again, the author has a provided solid murder mystery with D.I. Kelly Porter at the helm. The quality this series never falters. This has a great storyline and I love the descriptions of the different parts of the Lake district and the author gives us great insight of the different procedures in the world of pathology. I really enjoyed this. Another 5 stars from me.
June 19, 2023
As the result of a drought a body is discovered in a local reservoir and is determined to be the subject of a decades all cold case and former classmate of DI Kelly Porter. Not too long after another former classmate is found murdered. This takes Kelly back to the past revisiting old classmates and drudging up some uncomfortable memories for all.
This is the 11th installment in the DI Kelly Porter series but this was my first read of the series. I enjoyed how the author calls back to previous cases in such a way that you are intrigued to find out about them but you don’t feel like you are missing any critical information if you haven’t read them.
Pros – The prologue grabs you from the start. Strong female lead, good level of mystery and surprise around some of the victims, suspects.
Cons – Unnecessary details (clothing, cars etc.) that don’t feel like they add to story in any way. The pacing felt slow and a little predictable in some areas.
This is a solid mystery read and I will be adding more of this series to my TBR.
Thank you to NetGalley for this ARC in exchange for my honest review.
This is the 11th installment in the DI Kelly Porter series but this was my first read of the series. I enjoyed how the author calls back to previous cases in such a way that you are intrigued to find out about them but you don’t feel like you are missing any critical information if you haven’t read them.
Pros – The prologue grabs you from the start. Strong female lead, good level of mystery and surprise around some of the victims, suspects.
Cons – Unnecessary details (clothing, cars etc.) that don’t feel like they add to story in any way. The pacing felt slow and a little predictable in some areas.
This is a solid mystery read and I will be adding more of this series to my TBR.
Thank you to NetGalley for this ARC in exchange for my honest review.
June 13, 2023
A severe drought uncovers bones in Thirlmere reservoir in the Lake District.
DI Kelly Porter investigates.
Then there is a murder of Jason who was one of her classmates at school.
The skeleton is identified as Brian, former classmate as well. Kelly's father - or the man she thought was her biological father, had investigated the disappearance of Brian, and never solved it. Kelly discovers that her hero had feet of clay, and it devastated her.
Kelly and her team find that there is a link between the killings, not only the way they were killed, but the company they kept.
I loved this police procedural. I was gripped from start to finish. The clues that pull the investigators in one direction, then a better clue to another.
The team is close knit, and I like the way their personal lives are part of the story. It makes the characters more human.
I definitely want to read more by this author. Very enjoyable novel!
Thanks to Netgalley and the publishers for the opportunity to read this book in exchange for an honest review.
DI Kelly Porter investigates.
Then there is a murder of Jason who was one of her classmates at school.
The skeleton is identified as Brian, former classmate as well. Kelly's father - or the man she thought was her biological father, had investigated the disappearance of Brian, and never solved it. Kelly discovers that her hero had feet of clay, and it devastated her.
Kelly and her team find that there is a link between the killings, not only the way they were killed, but the company they kept.
I loved this police procedural. I was gripped from start to finish. The clues that pull the investigators in one direction, then a better clue to another.
The team is close knit, and I like the way their personal lives are part of the story. It makes the characters more human.
I definitely want to read more by this author. Very enjoyable novel!
Thanks to Netgalley and the publishers for the opportunity to read this book in exchange for an honest review.
June 22, 2023
I can’t believe that this is book 11 of the brilliant DI Kelly Porter series I have loved every single one of the previous books and this one is no exception it was an excellent police procedural that kept me gripped.
This latest episode of the series starts with the discovery of a skeleton in Thirlmere reservoir and when the victim is identified Kate is shocked to find he was a former classmate but then another body turns and she realises he also was a classmate things become very personal for Kate and things are about to get even worse.
I loved this book the stunning locations in the beautiful Lake District (which is not far from me) , the reoccurring characters and the superb writing by Rachel Lynch they all go together to make you feel you are a part of the story. It’s a series that never gets stale and I hope it will continue for may more books.
Many thanks to Rachel Lynch for so much enjoyment and foe a wonderful 5 star read.
My thanks also to NetGalley and Canelo for giving me the opportunity to read the ARC in exchange for my honest opinion.
This latest episode of the series starts with the discovery of a skeleton in Thirlmere reservoir and when the victim is identified Kate is shocked to find he was a former classmate but then another body turns and she realises he also was a classmate things become very personal for Kate and things are about to get even worse.
I loved this book the stunning locations in the beautiful Lake District (which is not far from me) , the reoccurring characters and the superb writing by Rachel Lynch they all go together to make you feel you are a part of the story. It’s a series that never gets stale and I hope it will continue for may more books.
Many thanks to Rachel Lynch for so much enjoyment and foe a wonderful 5 star read.
My thanks also to NetGalley and Canelo for giving me the opportunity to read the ARC in exchange for my honest opinion.
July 26, 2023
A solid police procedural with a good plot.
The discovery of a skeleton in a lake was brilliantly written, the forensic descriptions were fascinating and clearly very well researched. After a second recent murder takes place, it was so tricky to try and work out who the killer(s?) were as so many of the suspects in the first murder had since died and the history of the police failures from that time were so interesting to read about as I’m sure, happened a lot in those times.
I haven’t read the previous books in this series and so coming in at book 11 meant I didn’t have the benefit of knowing the background of Kelly, her family and her team, however the author did ensure that the essential information is given in this book and so there was no confusion. I did find I struggled to really connect with any of the characters though and perhaps this was due to coming in at a late stage?
3 ⭐️ Thanks to Netgalley, the author and the publisher for an ARC in return for an honest review.
The discovery of a skeleton in a lake was brilliantly written, the forensic descriptions were fascinating and clearly very well researched. After a second recent murder takes place, it was so tricky to try and work out who the killer(s?) were as so many of the suspects in the first murder had since died and the history of the police failures from that time were so interesting to read about as I’m sure, happened a lot in those times.
I haven’t read the previous books in this series and so coming in at book 11 meant I didn’t have the benefit of knowing the background of Kelly, her family and her team, however the author did ensure that the essential information is given in this book and so there was no confusion. I did find I struggled to really connect with any of the characters though and perhaps this was due to coming in at a late stage?
3 ⭐️ Thanks to Netgalley, the author and the publisher for an ARC in return for an honest review.
July 27, 2023
You might think by the time it gets to book 11 you know what to expect from an author but Rachel Lynch certainly proved me wrong here. An enquiry begins after discovery of a skeleton in a dried up reservoir and a few days later another body is found in a caravan park. It turns out that DI Kelly Porter knew both males when she was at school. There is so much about this enquiry that is personal to Kelly, maybe not enough to remove her from the case but definitely enough to challenge her ability to retain an emotional distance from it. On the positive side her home life seems to be in good shape again. As with the other books there is a great sense of the teamwork involved in the enquiry but this one definitely has Kelly at its core. I’m pretty sure this could be read as a standalone but probably works better as part of the series. When I finished reading this one I had to check the author’s social media for confirmation that there is another book planned. Thankfully there is.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 109 reviews