Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Why Choose Haremland #5

Their Easter Bunny

Rate this book
Three gorgeous men rescued me from my worst nightmare, but that was just the beginning.

My dad’s best friends were completely off-limits.

I wasn’t thinking straight when I let Mateo kiss my lips the night I was devastated about my ex’s betrayal.

And then he invited two of his friends to join us and make my night even better.

Mateo . . . He’s two decades older, and the kind of silver fox I didn’t know I wanted.

Ericis unpredictably ruthless but that doesn’t scare me. His protective arms allow me to sleep in peace.

And Lucasadds all the spice I need in the bedroom while craving for more.

Ending up in this position and being their Easter bunny has its consequences.

My blackmailing ex has gotten these men . . . angry.
They are shielding me from him.
But none of us know how to save my dad’s career if word gets out.

Especially now that I’m pregnant with triplets . . . with no idea who the baby daddy is.

"Their Easter Bunny" is the fifth book in the The Why Choose Haremland series, and is Mateo, Eric, Lucas and Renn's story.

192 pages, Kindle Edition

First published March 29, 2023

495 people are currently reading
223 people want to read

About the author

Ajme Williams

119 books477 followers
Ajme Williams - mother, wife, daughter, dreamer, an avid reader and a writer.
When she's not writing romance, Ajme can be seen sipping coffee, gorging on dark chocolate, exercising, or travelling with family and friends. Cooking is therapeutic for her and she drools over Italian food...and men.
What to expect from her books?
Ajme loves variety, so expect a lot of second chances, secret babies, office romances, big fat fake weddings, curvy heroines and alpha heroes. HEA? Always, baby!
If you're a fan of emotional angsty contemporary romance, then you'll enjoy Ajme Williams.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
257 (41%)
4 stars
156 (25%)
3 stars
121 (19%)
2 stars
55 (8%)
1 star
31 (5%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 57 reviews
Profile Image for Lisa Bing.
6,194 reviews69 followers
April 1, 2023
This was a fun, fast and steamy romance that takes Renn and shows her what a scumbag her hubby is when she finds him cheating on her with her BFF...a quick trip to her father's place to regroup puts her in the path of three hot men, who happen to know her father. Yep, tricky but they make it work ;) There is a ton of steam, some bad business and a fab future to carve out for strong and feisty Renn. I love that they got their HEA and some good closure for her 'ex' ;D
Profile Image for kymagirl.
6,238 reviews89 followers
April 8, 2023
Renn leaves the big city after finding her husband cheating with her best friend and returns to her small hometown to pick up the pieces of her life. A visit to a bar leads her to Mateo (H), Eric (H), and Lucas (H), her father’s best friends. Things heat up very quickly for the four, even though they’re keeping their relationship under wraps. Unfortunately, Renn’s ex isn’t done with her and her three men will have to come up with a plan to get rid of him for good. Ultra-hot and steamy age gap RH with a bit of family and friendship drama.
23 reviews2 followers
April 2, 2023
Renn found out her husband was having an affair with her best friend. This did not go over big. She leaves him and returns to her home town where she is blessed with connecting with three wonderful men. Mateo, Eric and Lucas teach her how to be worshipped.,. While they are her father’s friends, it doesnt stop the connection. Before long the foursome begins. Will her family accept her new found choices?.

I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
Profile Image for Savanna Wilkinson.
208 reviews4 followers
August 1, 2023
READ REVIEWS BEFORE THE BOOK!!

DNF… I don’t even know where to begin with this tragic story.. first off I will say I have read one other book by this author and loved it enough to give it 4 stars… but holy fu*k is this book all over the place. I was completely confused and lost by the first chapter I had to go back a few pages to make sure I didn’t miss something because I was so confused. Let’s break this down.

The FMC marries college sweetheart right after graduation, she opens a lingerie store in NYC mind you, and makes a ton of money (it was never specified how much), then goes to a spa her card gets declined the estheticians berate her and the FMC gets kicked out because of it then she finds out her husband is f**king her best friend and spent all FMC’s money on said best friend. It’s also mentioned that the “husband” has all control of the accounts even though ITS HER BUSINESS AND HES JUST AN EMPLOYEE!!

Then she somehow ends up back in her small town of what I’m assuming is Louisiana because someone in the book spoke Cajun French. My first question is why did the FMC have literally no anxiety about leaving NYC and going home? She never talked about the fear of not having money nothing…

Anyways she walks from the airport and was supposed to go home to her fathers house but somehow ends up at a bar… with no explanation. Then her dads best friend was there and recognized her then she ended up kissing him in front of EVERYONE at the bar… doesn’t that seem a lil suspicious to anyone? Like who in h*ll just decides hey! This is my dads bsf let me kiss in front of the whole town. Plus she literally leaves with him and there’s no signs of this chick’s luggage like where did it go?

Moving on, the dads bsf ends up calling his “buddies” and says he’s bringing home a girl to the apartment for them to share. But then somehow ends up at this house and walks into what I’m assuming was supposed to be a lobby and a guy said taste a drink and that the guy she got for the night..? I know this is confusing but it seriously did happen. This sounds more like a s*x club to me then an actual house… where people are supposed to live… she ends up with Lucas (one of the buddies) from the drink she choose but all of them show up to the room? And start having s*x. Like that s*x part was to be expected but what the fu*k is with the drink thing and the s*x club vibe. And where the fu*k is the luggage 😂😂.

Now let me get this straight this girl went from shy asf, couldn’t sit through a Brazilian wax (that’s why she was at the spa), and broke (with no luggage… I’m never going to get over that) but turned vicious s*x kitten with the dads bsf and 2 guys she never met before… right right cuz that makes fu*king perfect sense… NOT. This book jumped all over the place and you can see now. I am sorely disappointed with this author.

0 ⭐️ 1 🌶️
Profile Image for Kiley.
1,873 reviews45 followers
May 25, 2023
There were a lot of things going on at the same time, to the point that it was confusing at times as to who was speaking. In fact, there was one point near the end when the person who was narrating changed and even the tense of the writing switched from first to third then back to first person. There were so many grammatical errors that it was aggravating.
The book also had so many plot twists and paths that just dropped off without being finished that it was completely devoid of a clear plotline. Too many unresolved issues made for a very bad storyline.
Much of the story was written in such a way that it would cause any reader, including myself, to ask what author in their right mind interrupts a volcanically spicy hot scene with a boring monologue about counterfeit money and the "modus operandi" of the villain making it, and then reminisces how three friends met in the first place?! The book kept taking side roads with things that were totally unrelated to the story within each of the three men's memories. First, one of them reminisced about money laundering, another remembered school days when the three of them first met, and the third one remembered what happened to a client that had no bearing on the FMCs situation.
I also found an issue with the fact that the end of the Blurb mentioned her being pregnant with triplets, yet that didn't happen just before the ending. It was a bit ridiculous how convoluted the entire book was. Oh, it had the potential to be a really good book, but there were just too many issues with it that I couldn't give it more than a two-star rating.
Profile Image for Sheila Fowler.
Author 47 books544 followers
March 31, 2023
Who knew finding out your husband is having an affair with your best friend could make your life better?

Renn thought she was happily married. But was she? Her husband was never around. He never made time for her. And when she tries to take a spa day, she realizes she has no money. He spent it all (or even overdrew on her credit card). The guy is an absolute jerk. Buying another woman things on their credit cards. But when she finds her best friend and husband kissing at a local restaurant, that is it.

She goes back home to stay with her father, the Mayoral candidate. Instead of going straight there she heads to a bar to wallow in her sorrows. The man she meets there is someone she's known for a long time. Matteo. Her father's best friend. They both find each other attractive, but Matteo has a proposition of another kind for her. Come home with him and his two best friends. WOAH!

I thought the romance was a little forced between the three of them. I liked the way Ajme told the story of each man and how they turned up in this small town. But, it seemed like Renn fell in love too quickly. It was still an enjoyable book. The way the three men help her with her ex-husband. And the revelation of her pregnancy was sweet. Especially between her and her father. Sometimes you fall in love with the wrong guy or guys. But the heart wants what the heart wants!.

I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
Profile Image for Korkoi.
7,048 reviews31 followers
March 31, 2023
A Life She Didn’t Know She Wanted -
Renn was totally devastating when she discovered the two people closest to her, whom she loved had betrayed her, so returned to her home town, so she could think about her next steps. As luck would have it, she run into one of her father’s best friend’s and just wanted to lose herself in one night of unbridled passion with him. However, what she didn’t expect was Mateo’s offer of a night filled of adventure, included his two best friends, Luke and Eric.

After their night together, they all realised that one night wasn’t enough and decided to embark of a secret relationship. However, just as they settled into their relationship, Renn’s soon to be ex-husband, Tyson, returned to reek havoc on their lives. Unfortunately, she soon discovered with the help of her three lovers the chaos that Tyson had caused her life and her business. Luckily, the trio were able to get her out of her predicament, just as she received life changing news, which gave them the courage to tell her father everything about everything.

This was a truly sizzling read , that had me totally lost in their story. Each of the men brought something different out in Renn, but when they were together, it was just explosive. All I can say at this point is that, it was an amazing book and you need to buy it, as you will be blown away.

I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and I am voluntarily leaving a review.
Profile Image for Emily Pennington.
20.7k reviews361 followers
April 1, 2023
Renn and the Guys . . .

Renn’s marriage was a sham she realized as she found her husband has been spending money on someone else and draining their finances. Finding him enjoying kisses with her “best friend” in a restaurant was all she could tolerate. So she plans to move back in with her father. First stop, however, is a bar. Matteo, her dad’s best friend, is there and he invites her home with him. When two other friends, Eric and Lucas, join them, they take her mind off her troubles.

The guys are protective of her. When her cheating ex-husband Tyson finds out she was sleeping with the three guys, he started blackmailing her. Her dad was a Mayoral candidate and a scandal could ruin his career. Will her guys step in and “explain” it to her ex, especially when they have information and hard evidence on him he won’t want made public either? And when she tells her men about the triplets she is carrying, maybe it’s time to let her father in on their “secret” relationship too.

The confrontation with Tyson was just perfect. For that alone, you won’t want to miss it! He is such a despicable weasel!
Profile Image for Rebecca Grove.
3,492 reviews26 followers
April 7, 2023
Renn thought her life was perfect. She was married to her high school sweetheart and making a success in her dream business. She was a little sad that her husband seemed to be distancing himself. Then she finds out that he maxed out their credit card buying lingerie for another woman. After some investigating she tracks down her cheating husband in a motel room...with her best friend. Feeling betrayed she ends things and heads home to spend time with her father the mayor. Her first night back, she goes to a bar to unwind and runs into her father's best friend Mateo. She used to have the hots for Mateo growing up. When she sees him as a grown-up sparks fly. He is interested in her too and invites her to join him and his friends for some fun. Renn is happy to feel wanted and is ready to have a fun time so she agrees. They spend a very passionate night together. The problem is none of them want the good times to end but if her father finds out there could be problems.

I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
Profile Image for Julie Beach.
25 reviews3 followers
April 4, 2023
I wanted to like it.

The plot in this story had SO many holes and issues! The timeline was inconsistent, confusing, and unbelievable. It felt like the story elements were just thrown together without any development or progression. There were just too many details that were missing or overlooked. The story premise is good, but it didn’t unfold in a believable manner.
For example, the main female character discovers that her husband cheated on her. She then left him to go back home to her father. The next time her husband is mentioned, he is referred to as her ex-husband. When did she get a divorce?!? It certainly isn’t mentioned in the book. Important details like that are missing throughout the story.
This book has some steamy RH scenes, contains a HEA, and no cliffhangers. This story could be good if the author rewrites the story to add in the missing details and clarifying information.
Profile Image for Clara Atkinson.
1,180 reviews55 followers
October 5, 2023
From heartache to happiness

Their Easter Bunny is a dad's best friend, reverse harem FMMM, secret baby romance. It follows Renn, Mateo, Eric and Lucas.
It begins when Renn discovers her husband Tyson and best friend Veronica have betrayaled her for years. She is devastated and leaves her home in New York and heads to her childhood home in Louisiana. There she comes face to face with her father's best friends Mateo, Eric and Lucas. While they are older than her it doesn't stop their undeniable chemistry. Before long they are engaged in a foursome.

Unfortunately Tyson isn't done trying to ruin her life. Can they help her stop him before it's too late?

While I enjoyed their storyline it was mostly sex (now don't misunderstand me I like that too) but I would of liked to see more of their story to balance it out.

I received a free ARC through Booksprout an I'm voluntarily leaving my review.

4⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Profile Image for Jenny Harris.
4,397 reviews33 followers
April 10, 2023
I received this book with the understanding that I could leave a voluntary and honest review.

In this book we meet Renn, Mateo, Eric, & Lucas. When this book opens we find that Renn is on her way home after she finds out that her husband and her best friend are sleeping together. After returning home she is depressed and figures drinking is the way to go. Little did she know she would find her dad's best friend. Mateo can't believe the beautiful woman who just walked into the bar. Little did he know she would be the one person he and his best friends had been looking for. If only he didn't have to betray her dad to get his ultimate fantasy. Can they find a HEA or will the past make sure a future is impossible?

Another amazing story by this author. I would highly recommend it to anyone and everyone.
10 reviews
November 5, 2023
it’s alright

This is the only standalone I’ve read from the series, so going from first impression it was a little messy. The book was maybe 80% or more of only sex, which I skipped every single time when I realized i was almost halfway through the book and it was mostly sex. Anytime it wasn’t sex it was the characters thoughts or a little conversation and then back to really drawn out sex scenes. It was mostly annoying because the books were going by so fast without any connection to the characters because of all the sex. I’ve read other books roughly the same length as this that weren’t so long and still had high quality sex scenes. I wanted to know how they’d handle Tyson so I pushed through to the end.

I would give this 2 stars but maybe I missed something that indicated the book was mostly for a sexy read.
Profile Image for SpeedReader.
332 reviews17 followers
March 31, 2023
HOT 🔥🔥🔥

• Story/Plot: 📖📖📖 /5
• Characters: 🫂🫂🫂🫂
• Drama/Angst: 😰😰
• Steam: 🔥🔥🔥🔥
• POV: 4 perspectives
• HEA? ✔️
• Would I re-read? ✔️


This was my first rh book and it was pretty good. The story was about Renn, who discovered that her husband was cheating on her with her best friend. She moves from NYC back to Louisiana where she grew up. There she sees her fathers BFF & meets 2 of his other BFFs that she didn’t previously know and they get to all know each other VERY well.

The story was more romance than plot, but still a good read. It was super spicy, for sure. I’d give a try to one of the authors other stories.

I received a free copy of this book and am voluntarily leaving a review. The review is 100% my own & 100% genuine!
Profile Image for Lacey Stafford.
39 reviews3 followers
August 22, 2024
This was so bad. I love fast paced books, but this was crazy fast. She hasn't seen Mateo in years, has been in town 5 minutes, they exchange 2 sentences, make out, then shes in the car with him and his 2 best friends. What little plot there is, is just dumb. More than once I wondered if the author was drunk while writing this because of how many mistakes there were. Sentences repeated. Actions repeated in the next paragraph as if it didn't JUST happen. The amount they say " erect penis" is cringeworthy. I'm so disappointed because I loved " Protecting their Princess"
Also around 70% the talk went from southern charm to southern hillbilly making them sound like idiots. I love hillbillies, but you can't just change their personalities at the end of a book, or anytime really.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Raecharmed.
9,296 reviews70 followers
April 1, 2023
Renn's marriage falls apart and she doesn't know what to do. She decides to go home to her father's place but makes a stop at a bar before she gets there. She runs into Matteo her father's best friend. Matteo is stunned by Renn and asks her to come home with him and his friends. Renn goes with him and its not long before things heat up. Will this be a temporary thing between them? What will her father say about it?

This is a great story that will hook you in the first chapter. This is a well written and very entertaining story. Its a book that any book lover would enjoy.

I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
Profile Image for Christina Sneeringer.
456 reviews
April 1, 2023
Renn seems to have it all but when she discovers her husband's infidelity it sends her back to her childhood home to lick her wounds and regroup. Steamy and suspenseful, Renn finds surprising comfort in the arms of Lucas, Eric, and Matteo. This was a fun read even the Easter trope was tasteful and not overly done. The spicy scenes were of course my favorite, but the suspense arc gave this story more depth than you might expect.

I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
3,552 reviews52 followers
April 16, 2023
I thought this romance was so fun to read. Rent goes to visit her father when she finds out her hubby had cheated on her with her BFF. She meets her dad’s friends Mateo, Lucas and Eric who are instantly smitten with her. As they try to help her deal with her past, chaos happens and they need to figure out how they can have their happily ever after. I found this book steamy hot and entertaining.

I received a free advance reader copy of this book and am voluntarily leaving my fair and honest review.
Profile Image for Insomniac Reviews.
180 reviews1 follower
January 16, 2025
a lot to be desired

Rough. This was a really rough one to get through. None of it made sense, the drama led nowhere and plot lines were left just hanging in the wind. Renn “fought” so hard for her business and there was absolutely no talk of it. She didn’t do one thing. The ending was snuffed short. If I’m going to read about surprise babies I wanna READ about them. She announced it and then the book was done. I’m trying really hard to give this author a chance but I’m really disappointed so far
2,910 reviews9 followers
April 1, 2023
After catching her husband cheating with her best friend, Renn, returns home to decide what’s next. She meets one of her father’s best friends who in turn introduces her to his friends and a very steamy and forbidden romance begins. Her ex comes to town to stir up trouble, she gets a surprise and now she has to explain everything to her father.
Extra steamy and a great HEA.

I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
2,603 reviews15 followers
April 1, 2023
So this is so much a book I wanted to read. Feeling betrayed when her husband used all her money and she finds him one a date with her bff she now finds herself going home. She doesn't head home right away but visits the local bar finding a friend from her Dad. He makes an offer and what does she have to loose? So this romance was what I needed to read and I am happy I did. Can't wait to read more by this author.
Profile Image for JoAnne.
3,153 reviews32 followers
April 1, 2023
This wasn't one of my favorite books since I found it hard to connect to the characters. There wasn't the development to the story that we usually see and the characters had no depth to them. I didn't like the bunny storyline at all. Lots of steam but not much else but there was definitely the possibility to be more. I thought the story ended abruptly.

I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
Profile Image for J.
4,068 reviews21 followers
April 2, 2023
This was a fast paced, steamy romance read. Our female lead is Renn who discovers her hubby is a piece of poo and cheating on her with her BFF. She meets her fathers friend at a bar and is propositioned to come home with him and his two besties. I liked the characters and the stories from them but I thought that the relationship aspect was a bit rushed but I loved the guys protectiveness.

I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
Profile Image for Cheryl A.
624 reviews2 followers
April 3, 2023
This was a steamy read and good read. Renn has a good life in NYC with a thriving business, husband, and a beautiful apartment. She finds out her husband is cheating with her best friend. She runs home to her hometown in Louisiana to run into his dad’s best friend Mateo. He introduces her to his 2 best friends Lucas and Eric who are also best friends of her Dad. She finds excitement and joy with them. And finally opens herself up to being a much stronger woman.
1,374 reviews11 followers
April 5, 2023
This is a reverse harem, dad's friend romance story.

Renn finds her husband cheating on her with her best friend. She goes to her father's to take a break and meets 3 hot men, who happen to be her father's friends. Her life suddenly takes a turn, who would have though finding her husband cheating could make her life so much better.

I enjoyed reading this book and would recommend it.

I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
10.8k reviews125 followers
April 5, 2023
I've read several books written by Ajme Williams; she is becoming one of my favorite authors. I can’t wait to read more of her books.

This is part of the Why Choose Haremland Series; it is a stand-alone book. The story is about Renn, Eric, Lucas, & Mateo; they are her dad’s best friends and she ends up with them after catching her ex-husband cheating on her with her best friend.

I received a free copy of this book via booksprout and I’m voluntarily leaving a review.
6,136 reviews17 followers
April 8, 2023
This is a good reverse harem read. It is about Renn, Lucas, Eric and Matteo. The story is a dad best friend with some excitement along the way. Renn has just discovered her husband with her best friend along with some other shady stuff her husband has been up to. She decides to go to her dads but meets the unexpected on the way. This is a steamy and sexy story with a touch of blackmail and steamy bits. I enjoyed the story and like the characters.
1,160 reviews1 follower
April 14, 2023
Their Easter Bunny

Renn is back home. A failed marriage and betrayal of a best friend that is what she faces. She ends up meeting one of her father's friend at a bar. She goes with him and meets his two friends. What a night it was. She is happy and her men adore her. Ex husband enters and tries to blackmail her. They have their own plans. All seems to go well but something else pops up. How will it all end? Loved the book.
Profile Image for Debbie Benson.
9,642 reviews34 followers
March 31, 2023
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review. Renn leaves her cheating husband and returns home where she starts a hot and loving relationship with Mateo, Eric and Lucas. When her ex comes crawling to get more money from her, they take care of him. I think they should have done more to the ex but their family was more important.
Profile Image for Nicole Potter.
1,567 reviews16 followers
March 31, 2023
5 stars of pure awesomeness by Ajme Williams

I am never disappointed when I pick up an Ajme Williams book + who doesn't love a reverse harem novel? Renn, Mateo, Eric & Lucas's story will have you hooked from the start. Will her deadbeat ex destroy it all?.

I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 57 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.