Indie Author Brawl on the Books of Horror Facebook group is so fun. If you aren’t there yet, you should be! Lots of great titles that are getting more exposure due to this awesome event.
“House of Smarba” took a lot of calculated risks, and some of these paid off. Malachi being a freaking terrifying little “omen” type kid is a big one of them. Possession is always so interesting, and it’s definitely one of the most genuinely scary routes a horror novel can take. From the jump, when Debbie and Nathan’s son, Martin, starts dreaming of old toys and a mysterious companion, we get the feeling that something is just not right. Though at this point, it isn’t yet made clear to us as an audience how warped matters are about to become.
I loved the concept of old Sears toy catalogs being a beacon of forthcoming horror. However, I did not buy the way Debbie was acting. At all. I found the scene up at the school after Martin injures another boy to be kind of prissy. To each their own, but this wasn’t exactly a good herald of his incoming condition. My parents used to constantly talk to me about self defense and what it means to stand up for yourself. In retrospect, yeah, violence isn’t the answer, but I found Debbie’s reaction to the whole incident to be so inauthentic and cheesy. I also found her reaction to Martin’s mention of a Sears catalog to be a bit over the top at first. If it were my kid, I probably just would’ve assumed he’d googled it.
I can suspend disbelief pretty well for any story, though. This is fiction, and even in my waking life, I’m no stranger to the wacky and the supernatural. It’s just that a lot of these reactions seemed kind of cliche, rehearsed, and overused. A couple of aspects of this book were, as much as I hate to say that.
But it’s not without its strengths.
I thought the ending really tied matters together fairly well. When you find out the truth about Malachi, and the new family home’s ghastly origins, it does work quite well in filling in the story’s former gaps. Even though Nathan and Debbie made some parenting decisions I may not agree with, it’s plain to see they care a great deal about their son and their late daughter, Bella. I couldn’t dislike them, and I found myself rooting for the whole family. I also believe the use of vintage toys was a great creative device, and one that could certainly set this book apart from other possession stories of this caliber.
Fantastic use of the “man behind the madness” too. I wasn’t sure what I was expecting him to be like, but it certainly wasn’t THAT. I’m so happy we weren’t just dealing with the same old monster all over again.
So, it was a tough one to score. It had a lot of repetition and themes I found tiring, but its creative energy cannot and should not be easily dismissed. If you enjoy a good possession story, it’s safe to say you would be wasting no time in picking this one up. What it lacked for me in cohesiveness it sort of accounted for in certain aspects, one of them being originality. Classic possession with an interesting twist.