In February of 1820 a group of men meet in secret in rooms on Cato Street. Adam Harkness and the Bow Street Runners watch and wait. Are the men conspiring to commit treason or just disgruntled and venting? Their numbers are few and they don't seem much of a threat. Can Adam convince the King and the Privy Council to leave the men alone? By April 11 men are imprisoned in the Tower of London for treason. Rosalind and Alice are on their way to tea with Adam when they discover their maid, Amelia, calling for help for her friend who has collapsed. Adam fears the young gentlewoman has been poisoned and Rosalind insists on keeping the girl at her home until it's safe. Cate Leavitton has run away from home but won't reveal the truth about herself or what happened to drive her away. She was once close with Amelia and Amelia still has feelings for Cate. What about Alice? Francesca Finch and her man, Jack Beauchamp are looking for Cate for their open purposes. When Rosalind calls on Cate's family to get some information, she discovers Cate's elderly aunt, Marianna, is unwell and suspects the same poison that affected Cate is now killing Marianna. Could it be someone in the house wants both women dead? Rosalind won't allow that to happen. With the help of Nurse Hepplewhite, she is determined to keep Marianna safe. Marianna wants to know where her niece is and who is trying to kill her. She will allow Rosalind to investigate on her behalf. Adam, too, has a potential new client, on behalf of the radicals he must find the informant, Edwards, and discover whether someone paid him to fan the flames on the fatal day on Cato Street. Was it someone from the government? When Adam discovers ties between his investigation and Rosalind's, he's very worried and insists on protecting the ladies. Rosalind is unsure of where their future leads but knows she loves and trusts Adam with all her heart. Can she give up her independence and freedom for marriage and the consequences of childbirth?
This is one crazy complicated story. It's unnecessarily complicated and more of a search for information than a murder mystery. It took too long for the plots to collide and become one central mystery. There is a murder 2/3 of the way into the story but we know who did it right away. Then there's a second murder almost at the end and I did not guess who did that one. I knew of the Cato Street conspiracy and found Adam's part in it way too much. I also did not enjoy the same sex love triangle - NOT because it's three women but because it's inappropriate for an employer to have a relationship with a servant! MEN did it all the time and it wasn't consensual. Sure this is love and when you're different you take love where you can, but it's also a novel and the author should have thought harder how to make her story more diverse without making it about a power imbalance. Even Rosalind's romance is starting to annoy me. I absolutely understand her concerns and would have the same ones but it ruins the otherwise sweet romance. The writing style seems a lot more modern than the earlier books. I detested the modern anachronistic language used in this novel and please don't describe people by their race. Be creative not lazy. Something more like "A man whose skin was scarcely lighter than the shadows." This series started off strong but has been disappointing for the last two books. This one either concludes the series or sets it off in yet another new direction. Pick one and stick to it.
I like Rosalind for the most part but she really fails in this investigation. She doesn't know what she's dealing with and she's meddling with an extraordinarily dysfunctional family. Rosalind is normally level-headed but here she starts supposing a lot of things based on little to no information. I had an inkling of who the poisoner was just before Rosalind figured it out. Something didn't seem quite right to me. Rosalind should have been more suspicious. I also didn't like how Rosalind was so trusting. Why on earth didn't she check references herself to begin with or do some asking around? Rosalind's obsession with gentility is starting to grate on my nerves. Does she love Adam and want to be with him or not? She should learn some practical life skills and worry less about what the ladies of the ton might think. I'm sure her true friends would stand by her.
I liked Alice much more in this novel, love drama aside. Alice wrings her hands a lot before she finally decides to become proactive but when she becomes proactive, she's really present and takes charge. I liked that scene but it illustrated WHY employees should not be involved with their servants. Alice's romantic drama was a little easier to understand than Rosalind's. Her heart is hurting with the introduction of a woman from Amelia's past. Knowing Amelia has a past hurts Alice. Alice does not have a past and Amelia is her first love. Alice naively believed what they have is special and unique. That may not be the case. Amelia is a sweet girl. She's conflicted because she loved Cate and part of her still does. Part of her wants to run away with Cate and part of her wants to stay with Alice. Again, why servants and employers should not be in relationships. The upper class characters including Alice show a shocking lack of understanding and empathy for the working poor. I understand Amelia and her motivations yet what she did was not the right solution and I was shocked at the conclusion to her problems. It is an unrealistic and too tidy resolution to the qualms of a cross-class romance.
Dear Adam is such a noble man. I understand him and fight along side him. I want a more just, fair world too but he isn't in a position yet to do that. He has to answer to Townsend and others in order to do his job. He doesn't understand why Townsend doesn't see the world in black and white the way Adam does. To Adam there's right and there's wrong. Townsend answers to the King and sure Townsend is annoying, a toady, a social climber and doesn't understand Adam, he's actually a good boss. He tries to help Adam subtly without coming out and saying "We represent the King. We do what he and the government tell us. That doesn't mean we have to personally agree with it but we have to follow orders." Actually he should have come right out and said that and "We're not paying you to think in this case." Adam is smart, hard working, kind and empathetic but he has a lot to learn about dealing with the ruling class and an elderly, ill King who everyone knows is temperamental. Yes the King switched sides and was previously more liberal but if you're a government servant you have to toe the line. So, Adam has a moral dilemma. Can he afford to live and still live with himself if he stays with Bow Street? If the answer is no, what will he do and what will that mean for his future with Rosalind? By all means, put off leaving until brothers are grown and Rosalind is past child bearing years. That will solve all their problems.
Sebastian Foulks gets in on the investigations this time. He's charming and witty. He's sweetly protective of Rosalind, as someone should be, considering she doesn't have a brother and her father is now dead. Charlotte could probably assess Adam quickly and grill him but it's nice to know Rosalind has a platonic/brotherly male protector. Sebastian's character growth is good. He's gone from satirical and cynical to having more family feeling. I think he understands and sympathizes with his younger brother who may be queer like Sebastian or may just be different in another way. Their father sounds like a nightmare.
The Leavittons are also a nightmare of a family. Cate is a sneaky liar who is not very forthcoming about anything. How can Rosalind help her when she doesn't trust Rosalind? Amelia trusts Rosalind and that should be good enough for Cate. I don't believe Cate loves Amelia. Cate loves the power she has over Amelia and the illicit nature of their relationship. She can thumb her nose at her brother and avoid marriage. What she does to Amelia, inviting danger into the household, lying, omitting information and planning to run away is not kind. I don't like Cate very much. I understand and empathize with her desire to escape and be free of expectations but the way she goes about it is not right. Cate is somehow mixed up with this Fran Finch who is not on the up and up. I suspect it may have been Fran who poisoned Cate in the first place. That's only one line of inquiry though.
Cate's aunt, Marianna, is awesome. She was a bad girl in her day. She drank, drove, and ran with the men. She's also highly intelligent, an amazing business woman and I admire her very much. What I don't like about her is her caustic nature and her inability to forgive anyone who goes against her wishes. She's fair enough to Rosalind and her crankiness isn't anything Rosalind can't handle. She seems to like Nurse Hepplewhite well enough. Nurse Hepplewhite is sensible and practical and trusts Rosalind so maybe that's good enough for Marianna. Marianna took Cate under her wing and made the young woman strong but not strong enough to overcome her pampered upbringing.
The family patriarch, Marcus, was raised by an abusive father who's word was law. It's no wonder he's the same. To Marcus, reputation is everything and he guards his more carefully than Rosalind. He doesn't trust Rosalind and doesn't want the family's dirty secrets to get out. He also fears she'll lead his wife astray. Marcus is also jealous and mistrustful of everyone. He's horrible to his mother and his wife, resents his uncle's second wife for inheriting a fortune and not handing it over to him and even resents his aunt's heir. Beatrice, the family matriarch wore out after birthing 7 children. Yeesh. It's no wonder she's timid and was never up to running the household. I bet her horrid husband kept her pregnant all the time as a means of control and yet had the nerve to bully her when she wasn't strong enough to take charge of running the household. She's still weak, timid, weepy and she's also obsessed with her daughter. I don't blame her for doting on Cate when Cate was younger but Cate is an adult woman now and needs to live her own life.
Marcus's wife, Wilhelmina, is not timid like her mother-in-law. She's astute enough to know what to say around her husband and what not to say. She wants to talk to Rosalind and is the only one who may be forthcoming with information but if Marcus says no then she accepts that. This marriage is clearly an unhappy one and emotionally abusive. Wilhelmina seems to be holding her own right now but I don't think they've been married long. It's a very sad situation. Marcus's brother, Everett, comes across as the affable peacemaker but I think he's a mischief maker. He doesn't have a profession and doesn't seem to be in any hurry to get one. Is he waiting for Marianna to die? They already know what's in her will and none of them are getting anything more from her so that doesn't seem logical. Everett interferes a lot in a well-meaning way but there's something not trustworthy about him or any of them really. Mr. Harold Davenport is Marianna's protégée, her heir and right-hand man. He's supposedly engaged to Cate but he doesn't seem overly anxious to find her or worried she might be in danger. He claims he's not like other men and appreciates Cate's independent, spirited nature. Riiighhtt... I want to believe him but only Adam is that pure of heart!
This Jack Beauchamp person is bad news. He claims to be a thief taker and associated with Bow Street but he's just a thief himself. He's an opportunist and often sides with the thieves. He lives by his wits and is a thorn in Adam's side. I think Jack is a little bit more street smart than Adam and is a charming rogue type that people like him. Jack is devious and dangerous though. He's playing both sides here and that can not turn out well for anyone. His lady friend? Fran, is not as clever or shrewd. She's an impoverished woman angry at the way the world treats people like her and not above doing something illegal to improve her situation. She's a nasty piece of work but relies a lot on Jack to support her when he isn't really able to rise to the occasion.
Adam's mother is great. She knows her son better than he knows himself and she's more aware of the political side of Bow Street than he is. Her pep talk is cute and shows their relationship is a good one. His friends Goutier and Tauton are good guys who will help him out if they can. Goutier is funny and charming and Tauton seems like he's lazy but he's actually observant, intelligent and quick. Sir David, the coroner is another friend for Adam to turn to if he decides to stop torturing himself. Sir David respects Rosalind and her investigations and accepts her help on occasion. But Adam insists on not confiding in anyone and trying to be noble and do his job at the same time. I hope the solution works out.