As Above by Julie Mannino: Dark Adult MM Erotica. Demons and Angels. BDSM. Slave/master. Single Third Person POV.
If you like Dark MM demon/Angel erotica fantasy with explicit kinky BDSM, master/slave relationships, a sex-based magic system, political and war intrigue such as power plays, and a likeable protagonist paired with a morally grey cast and society, you will like this.
To be clear, for me, it's four stars, because I don't like dark fantasy, but this was so amazingly well-written that for anyone who's used to this genre, this will be a 4 to 5 stars for you.
The story follows Riley a human deviant who is kidnapped by the demons and is sold as a sex slave by a trader to his lord, but instead of thanking the trader who was a bad person, this Demon lord decides to order them raped and killed to create magic that he can then feed on. See Demons feed on magic and magic in this world is created by sexual activities and torture. However, Riley isn't as worried, because when he looks into the eyes of this demon lord, he recognises him. Eren was his "imaginary" childhood friend who went missing, but Eren quickly denies knowing him and Riley doesn't know why he doesn't remember him. But just because he knows him, doesn't mean he's willing to bend over and thus ensues the power play between them and the gradual trust and boundaries each of them set with each other.
First up, if you are at all sensitive to rape, this might not be the one for you. There are two almost rape scenes, and raping sex slaves and criminals is a common part of demon society and mentioned a lot. When the main character who asked why it wasn't banned, our morally grey love interest said it would be like banning religion. The society in which this takes place is messed up. There is no other way to put it, but everything immoral is addressed by the main characters and given the world building it makes sense why this society has evolved like it has. It is not thrown in there for shock value, some cheap story device, or without purpose.
The society is based around a magic system where sexual energies and torture create magic that angels and demons can feed off of. Each type of activity creates a certain amount of magic and each has a different flavour. No matter what it or how evil it is, none of the tastes are unpleasant tasting. Consequently, you have people growing up in a world that encourages them to harm others to get magic and rise in the ranks. It's very plausible and easy to understand why the society is morally bankrupt. However, they have some standards. They don't believe in enslaving their own (just humans who like deviant practices), they are heavily against demon on demon rape, female demons are respected and cherished a lot because there aren't many of them, demon children are cherished and protected as well, and the souls they torture for magic are all dead humans who're repeat rapists or destined for true Hell anyway. Also, evil behavour seen in on-page is not excused or justified by the main character, Riley (and Eren at times) are firmly against many aspects of demon and angel society. So while they have standards, but you can see why this is Dark fantasy.
I don't want to spoil, but the first 1/4 of the story, Eren and Riley is very rocky and abusive, but Eren grows kinder after choosing not rape Riley. Having read the second book I'll tell you there is a genuine reason why he treats people badly, but I'm not telling you.
What I liked about this though was it doesn't generalise, and every character is different. I've read books where the society consist of individuals that all share the same beliefs and preferences (i.e. everyone is LGBTQ+ and no one is straight), and I think I went into this with assumptions. Usually with erotic romance, every character liked or wants sex. That is not the case with this book. Not every demon likes sex. There are what's called Nosexuals who don't want to have sex and generally speaking those belief are respected in Demon Society. I really like this because not many romance books address that there are people who don't like sex, and it's good to see representation. Overall, every character the protagonist interacts with or over hears feels like a unique person. It's a realistic diversity of habits, preferences and opinions.
Here is a list of things I liked:
- The magic system. It was vivid, easy to understand, and original.
- There were funny conversations with secondary characters that provided comic relief throughout
- It had unexpected twists and turns. Some were fun and exciting, others with tense and stressful and then a few were plot twists.
- The complex and diverse, though dark, culture of demons was also well-thought out
- the war and political intrigue through
- and the unpredictability of the plot.
I wanted to read some fantasy sex scenes so I was looking at erotica goodreads lists where most books were 2 to 3 stars and out of the line stood out this 4.2 star one and I decided why not. I gave it a go, and its one of the most interesting books I've read. I'm very impressed with Julie Mannino's writing. I think this will appeal to the right audience given the triggers present.
In the end, I came for the sex scenes, but stayed for the story.
How much I liked it? 4-5 stars
Ideas - World building: 5 Stars
Ideas - Plot: 5 Stars
Character Depth: 5 Stars
Character interactions: Extensive
Animal Characterisation: Standard
Non-human body language: 4 Stars
Warnings: Explicit consensual sex scenes. Torture. Graphic Violence. Sexual Assault. Themes of Rape. Slavery. BDSM.
Execution (Proofreading): 4.9 Stars