I’d read several of the Phase 1 High Republic books as they were published, and I didn’t enjoy them. After really loving The Acolyte, I decided to try the Phase 2 books. This first one, Quest for the Hidden City, is not the worst Star Wars book I’ve read, but that doesn’t mean it’s an amazing book. Like a number of other Star Wars stories recently, it begins to introduce elements of (lite) horror, with one species undergoing a rather horrifying, if entirely nonsensical, transformation. There was the possibility of making this into more of an Alien kind of story, but the author didn’t take it that far.
Because the story is almost entirely planet-bound, it feels overall much more like Trek than Wars. (Also, we’re told a number of times that the pathfinder Jedi are “seeking out new life and new civilizations”—not in exactly those words, but pretty close.) The heavy-handed environmental themes would be very appropriate in a Third Doctor story (in fact, a lot of this story reminded me of “The Green Death”).
The novel introduces a few elements that I find intriguing:
• I love the idea of the pathfinder Jedi. This is closer to what I’d imagine the Jedi to be when there were just the original three movies. I pictured Jedi as wandering ronin-type characters, not as a unified community with a central hub on Coruscant. In hindsight, I guess I was more interested in the lone knight on a quest than in the political intrigues at the Round Table. The prequel trilogy was very Round Table–ish, and I didn’t care for the story very much. In this novel, we see the Jedi traveling the galaxy with small teams, exploring unreached places and trying to do good wherever they go. Bringing this together with The Acolyte makes a very interesting story arc—that the Jedi originally serve the colonizing force of the galaxy (the Republic), and by the time of The Acolyte, they’ve become the police force of the galaxy. With all that background in mind, the events of the prequel trilogy, especially the way Palpatine successfully deceives the Jedi, take on deeper and more intriguing resonance.
• Nitani’s synesthetic perception of the Force is a great addition. Taking only the movies and TV series, we really have little idea what it means to sense things through the Force. This book pulls back the curtain just a bit to show how one padawan understands the Force and uses it as a guide for movement and action.
• Though we’re not yet far enough back in the timeline to see a Star Wars without droid assistance, this book presents droids as simpler “tools” rather than as essentially sentient beings. The droids do what they’re made for, and they communicate, but none of the droids here speaks, aside from electronic warbles. There is indication of emotional response and even humor, but these still seem to be a lower level of droid than in later eras of Star Wars. I would still like to see an era that has no droid assistance whatsoever. (This is another aspect of The Acolyte that I enjoyed—very little interaction with droids, and few droids that manifest human-like personalities. I like that astromechs are mentioned but never shown, so we don’t know if at that point in the timeline they were anything like R2-D2.)
A problem I’ve had throughout the High Republic stories is that I couldn’t care less about any of the basically interchangeable Jedi the stories introduce. I don’t know what it would take to make a distinct, interesting Jedi, but in this book I really don’t care about any of them. One of them is distinguishable by her use of a shield (which seems to me like an odd accessory for a Jedi), but the others could switch places in just about any part of the story and it wouldn’t make any difference. It may be that the way Lucas envisioned the Jedi is simply a dead end for character development. How can you make an attachment-less, emotionally balanced character different from all the others? The Acolyte solves that problem by showing the different ways each member of Jedi team responds to a tragedy they caused (vow of silence; solitary exile; frontier life; and living with unaddressed remorse in the Jedi temple).
I didn’t want to give up any of my real reading time for this book, so I listened to the audiobook during my daily commutes. Though the music and sound effects included in the audiobook are a good addition, the reader didn’t succeed for me. The voices she used for the younger characters all sound like kids on a 1950s sitcom. And in general, I felt like she was holding back. A good audiobook reader feels like they’re reaching out and connecting with the listener; it’s a compelling performance. A lesser reader feels like they’re sitting by themselves, reading into a microphone. The reader for this book definitely seemed like she was on her own with a microphone.
Quest for the Hidden City wasn’t the worst High Republic book I’ve read, and it includes enough interesting elements that I’m curious to see more of Phase 2.