“Rushton's work is generous, thoughtful, and honest, taking care neither to romanticize nor to disparage the choice to become a parent.” —Jenny Hamilton, Booklist (starred review)
A bold feminist investigation into the mother of all questions; whether or not to become a parent in these turbulent times.
Should we become parents?
This timeless question forces us to reckon with who we are and what we love and fear most in ourselves, in our relationships, and in the world as it is now and as it will be.
When Gina Rushton admitted she had little time left to make the decision for herself, the magnitude of the choice overwhelmed her. Her search for her own “yes” or “no” only uncovered more questions to be answered. How do we clearly consider creating a new life on a planet facing catastrophic climate change? How do we reassess the gender roles we have been assigned at birth and by society? How do we balance ascending careers with declining fertility? How do we know if we’ve found the right co-parent, or if we want to go it alone, or if we don’t want to do it at all?
To seek clarity on these questions, Rushton spoke to doctors, sociologists, economists, and ethicists, as well as parents and childless people of all ages and from around the world. Here, she explores and presents policies, data, and case studies from people who have made this decision—one way or the other—and shows how the process can be revelatory in discovering who we are as individuals.
Drawing on the depth of knowledge afforded by her body of work as an award-winning journalist on the abortion beat, Rushton wrote the book that she needed, and we all need, to stop a panicked internal monologue and start a genuine dialogue about what we want from our lives and why.
"I can’t find a template for an ambivalent woman."
I enjoyed this well-organised and well-articulated examination of what it means to be a modern mother and parent. Rushton uses each chapter to consider different factors in what is a life changing choice for anyone, whether that choice is to have a child or not. Being around the author’s age and thinking about these things myself, this book stands out to me among others about this subject because it is topical and takes into account the aftermath of the pandemic and the present state of the climate crisis, is rich and well-written, and most importantly for me, I identified with the feeling of ambivalence and wondering why career or children are often presented as the only two potential life paths that shape who we become.
I received an ARC of this novel through NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
Fucking loved that one. So nuanced, so well-researched. Incredible work of journalism. Moving. Informative. Definitely provided me with some answers on (un)decisions around parenthood. Highly recommend.
This book was released about a week ago. The intro started off super strong with the author voicing a lot of the concerns and internal debates I've been having in the last few years about parenthood, the future, the present, climate, gender, and life generally. A couple great quotes from the intro:
“I am a member of a generation that often feels impotent in the face of endless uncertainty. The question of children thrusts us into a time beyond now, demanding we come up with more than whatever gets us through the present, while the only assurance we’ve had about what lies ahead is that it will be worse.”
“The childfree women I know have already tasted motherhood. We have given unconditional love, care, domestic and emotional work to those around us, including partners, for our entire adult lives.”
The first chapter focused on abortion, and it didn’t really teach me anything I didn’t already know - I feel like I’m pretty well-versed on the topic, but not exceptionally so. The second chapter was about reproductive justice, which again, I am not a special expert in though do have a general interest in, and I was also already pretty familiar with the majority of the info that was covered here (though I appreciated the main point, which is that the assumption that all women are pressured into having children is a very white perspective in the face of the historical reality of forced sterilization and medical racism). I guess in order to be comprehensive/contextual, these chapters were important, but I could have done without them since they didn't do much that was new (to me).
The third chapter is about work, the thesis essentially being that loving your work may seem like a potential path for fulfillment, but this is often a false promise. This chapter echoed some of the main points discussed in Arlie Hochschild's The Managed Heart (1979) and in Sarah Jaffe's more recent Work Won't Love You Back (2021), e.g., that "doing what you love", monetizing your hobbies, "we're a family" company culture, etc., are pretty much always a neoliberal scam. I liked that the author, as an Australian, was able to point out that a lot of these problems are extra prominent in American work culture and not something that the rest of the world necessarily thinks is normal, and she connects this observation to the fact that American workplaces are also the providers of things that should ideally be independent of work - from free bagels and fitness centers to more fundamental needs like healthcare - making us extra incentived to equate our company with our family, our jobs with our passions, our work with our life. The chapter ends with the question: why does it still feel radical to admit that I might want a life that is centered around neither children nor a career?
Chapter 4, which covers emotional labor and the fact that many women in relationships with men are wary of motherhood because they are already de facto mothers to their male partners, was insightful. Chapter 5 was, of course, about climate change. Some takeaways were: if you have kids, they will NOT have the same life you had; the world WILL be more dangerous; one must grapple with the question of whether having children is an act of hope or of human sacrifice.
Chapter 6 was about fertility, a topic I haven’t honestly thought much about - and indeed, this was kind of the point of the chapter, that (in)fertility and miscarriage are still relatively taboo topics. There was some interesting discussion about race, queerness, and colonialism, and how the state and corporations gatekeep fertility options in harmful ways. It also touched briefly on some of the unethical aspects of the adoption system (though she could’ve spent more time on this topic IMO - I have friends considering private adoption and the system is really problematic and complicated). What I took away most from this chapter is that it just really sucks that women don’t have time to decide. At 28, I think I don’t want children, but what if, in twenty years, I do? A man can make that choice; I can’t.
The final chapter, called Inheritance, discusses the anxiety we as Millennials in particular have about reproducing the traumas that we inherited - or, alternatively, the desire to correct the mistakes in our own upbringing by doing it better than our parents did. This chapter asks a philosophical question that I have been grappling with lately - is everything, in fact, the parents’ fault? In the conclusion, she reflects on the nature of decision-making itself, on responsibility and control, on hope and despair.
Overall, I’m glad I read this, since I’ll read pretty much anything about questioning motherhood as a life choice in the era of climate change. But, I wouldn’t say I got a ton out of it that I hadn’t already read or thought about. Also, wouldn’t recommend the audiobook - the narrator mispronounced a lot of words and put odd emphasis on parts of sentences that made certain parts a little confusing.
“I want to consider a life in which my identity is not contingent on the labor my body produces in reproduction or production”
should i become a parent? it's a question I've asked myself much more than I thought I would at the age of 24 (almost 25). I find myself thinking about it, weighing up the pros and cons, even though I don't see myself having children at all for at least ten years, or at all. Like many people, I think, I find it hard to project myself into this world.
Gina Rushton explores the question of parenthood through the prism of reproductive rights, reproductive justice, work, emotional labor, climate change, fertility and inheritance, and brings many perspectives that I hadn't even thought of. She raises a number of points that are not intended to provide a clear, universal answer to the question of parenthood, but more to bring material to the individual conflicted debate we might all be having.
I was particularly struck by the part about the climate. for me, it would be the main factor in deciding whether or not to have children one day.
I found the chapter on abortion rights instructive, well-researched and essential. As a journalist on reproductive rights, she brings a lot of examples that made me realize how privileged I am to even think about the question of parenthood, and to have the choice/right to abort if I wish. Making the choice of parenthood is also and above having the choice to have an abortion, or not, and being able to do so in my own country.
Rushton explores all aspects of parenthood, and it's reassuring to have a testimonial that proves I'm not the only one asking myself all these questions. too many questions hanging in the air, too many factors to take into account, choosing whether or not to have children makes your head spin. This book is a first step towards answering these questions; it's a key to understanding, an observation, but by no means a binary answer to the question of parenthood. It's up to each of us to find our own way through the heap of questions, doubts and fears.
Very nuanced, well written analysis of the myriads of factors that go into thinking about motherhood, from reproductive justice or climate change to inheritance to bare minimum partners to capitalistic feminism. I have had every single thought articulated in this book, and though I am not any closer to knowing what path I would choose, I am now at least comforted by the fact that a lot of people with uteri feel the way I do about modern motherhood.
Really glad I stuck this one out. Front is quite heavy with Australia centric reproductive law, but the chapters after are exactly what I was looking for. A heartfelt, emotional, and open-handed deep dive into all the questions we ask ourselves before having kids.
I found this resonated with me so much. It looks into the dilemma of whether we should have children with the current state of the world, looking into: reproductive rights and justice, work, emotional labour, the climate crisis, fertility and inheritance.
“No one these days can consider having children without confronting the unavoidable cost of raising them.”
“Growing a family during a time when houses in our city cost six times the average salary, not more than fifteen as they do now.”
It raised so many great points, basing most of the data from Australia but also pulling in some from the UK and the US. I still found it wholly relevant and it reassured me that I’m not the only one having these doubts.
This is a collection of facts and testimonies about alllllll of the struggles & considerations (social, medical, physical, philosophical, economic, intellectual, environmental etc etc) women have to go through whether they procreate or not. Its less of a guide book on how to decide whether you will choose parenthood or not so you are less left with an answer but instead you gain insight on peoples personal experience with the decision process, the wanted or unwanted, the terminated or to term pregnancies and all that comes after it, impacting every aspect of your life.
Suggest this read to your local man, and also woman bc honestly taught me a boat load too.
Stunning and heartbreaking book - picked this up because my parenthood morality problems are mostly climate based (and there is a whole chapter on this) but there’s also so much more. Fertility, abortion, emotional labor and careering, things you need to think about even before having the idea to conceive. So well written and it had to have taken a lot of heart and hard work to put all of these stories of different people together
Wow. I knew I would never get an “answer” regarding one of the biggest questions I have asked myself in the last couple of years, but this book was a journey I needed to take. There are anecdotes, statistics, references that confirm all my worst fears. And yet - you come out of the end with a sense of serenity and hope.
I picked up this book when my husband and I were exploring a new bookstore on a trip to Indianapolis. Over the past year, we’ve really been exploring the question of kids—not necessarily because either of us doesn’t want them, but more because of the curveballs life has thrown (thx cancer) and what it means for family planning. So stumbling on this book felt well timed to examine other factors about becoming a parent in today’s world.
It’s very clear the author wrote this book as a way to explore whether or not she wants to take on motherhood. She’s honest about her positionality and so the book centers around topics most relevant to her—focused mostly on US/UK/AUS, what it means to be a millennial parent, etc—so it shouldn’t be approached as a comprehensive look across various types of people approaching motherhood, though through her interviews she did include some other perspectives (for example, queer experiences of family planning).
Anyway, as for my take, I’d say it was interesting and there were a few points that I’ll take away, but overall I felt like the topics she explored were topics I’ve already approached. That’s not the author’s fault but I think indicates that if you’re just starting to consider motherhood, this book might be better timed at the beginning of that journey rather than after you’ve been in it for a while.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
"I want to consider a life in which my identity is not contingent on the labor my body produces in reproduction or production.”
I have been grappling with the concept of motherhood and parenthood for years. I have had my struggles and fear with fertility but at the end of the day, I still had a choice. However, today that choice was decided for me by the American people. I woke up (didn’t sleep) to finish this book to distract myself from the horror that was this election. I am truly unbelievably heartbroken.
I enjoyed the interview/research aspect of this book. Though there were certainly great points of view from many experts, the entire book felt more like an inconclusive memoir. I would recommend this book to anyone who is unsure if they want kids, not for a sure answer but for the space to reflect on their own feelings. Overall I wished there was more research and less personal anecdotes but I still found value in exploring the question.
Surprised myself with this one! I don’t usually reach for books like this but the way so many people’s stories are woven into the themes/issues facing mothers was so thoughtful and enlightening. The question of whether or not to have children is so complicated and the depth and grace in how this question is explored is wonderful.
Also - managed not to get bored! I really couldn’t wait to read this as the end of the day.
I was pleasantly surprised by how nuanced this book was despite being only 200 pages. It’s unapologetically feminist while also directing readers to be mindful of those who can feel othered by “catchphrase” feminism: for example, families who sincerely want children and are struggling to conceive, and people of color who have traditionally been targets of now-respected family planning organizations that had eugenics influencing their origins. I also thought the chapter on emotional labor was very strong. It was a really thought-provoking book, even to someone who like me who will never personally be involved in the kinds of decisions and conversations the author talks about.
I went into this book looking for answers, similar to why the author began her research into the decision to be a parent in the first place. This book has shown me that there is no solid answer. The writing is beautiful, and it opened my eyes to the fact that procreating is not morally right or wrong. Thank you to the author for writing this!!
I thought this was a really beautiful book, though a lot more personal to the author's experience than expected, which I didn't mind. I really resonated with the overall thesis of the book which is that you can't moralize the choice whether or not to have children in an unjust world. We all move through society differently, and what looks like privilege to one group can look like oppression to another. Rather, we should aspire to a world where the decision to have children or not is one that can be made confidently and voluntarily rather than being pushed by outside pressures. It's not a book to read if you're looking to be told an answer, but rather a deep dive into topics to consider and see what resonates with you the most.
I'll also admit that I teared up a bit at the book's conclusion with the author learning to reconcile with her mother. As someone who lost their mother soemwhat recently (and pregnant at the time of reading the book), it hit really hard. I think the personal nature of the book reflects that parenthood should be treated as a unique and personal choice where there is no one-size-fits-all answer. But also, that we often have to do a lot of emotional work to uncover which desires are true to your own values and which ones are shaped by trauma.
Overall, it's not necessarily a book I'd recommend to everyone, but it was one that came at a perfect time in my life.
i think this book is a solid 3.75 stars. it really helps to paint a more complete picture about the current state of the world and the complex factors surrounding bringing a new life into it, but doesn’t come close to answering the question, which isn’t what i was expecting anyway. it just helps to make the question more clear, or rather, helps me ask the right questions around the debate of motherhood.
for some reason, i think what also helps is that the author herself has decided to remain child-free after writing this book, which lets me know that this book isn’t a justification to go and have a child anyway because “all humans can do is hope for a better future”. the decision to not be a parent is an act of love as well.
I'll admit that I almost DNFed this book. For a journalist, Rushton ignores the K.I.S.S. principle when it comes to sentence construction. Comma splices, dangling modifiers, and sentences held by fraught conjunctions abound. Some examples:
"Sally talks about the idea of the life she wants to lead and she looks momentarily dazed before she says softly,"
"In love, we find who we are, in devotion we express it."
"As a child I thought she was a woman who chose architecture over children but I see now she chose many things instead."
These instances were constant and distracting; The Parenthood Dilemma needed a much, much better line editor. With that being said, however, the actual content of the book gets stronger as the chapters go on.
Rushton interrogates parenthood as more than just a personal choice, but also as a political right not everyone has equal access to. Readers who are invested in feminist ideology will be familiar with a lot of its talking points, but The Parenthood Dilemma is deeply researched and thoughtfully constructed. I appreciated how Rushton highlighted issues faced by Indigenous people when it comes to parental separation and forced sterilization; the clarity with which she links climate change and the ethical debate of bringing new life into the world; and criticism of how neoliberal feminism has sold the myth of finding true meaning in the workplace.
For a book about parenthood, I found discussions regarding adoption to not be present entirely. The chapter on fertility, in general, felt incomplete. There was no interrogation of the ethics of one of the pathways to parenthood Rushton's subjects discuss: surrogacy. Given the ethical and legal implications of the industry, I was a bit disappointed to see that it was only presented at face value.
Clear-eyed but not cynical, political without being preachy, The Parenthood Dilemma will be a valuable read for anyone anxious—but yearning—for parenthood.
This was well-organized and works through some really important topics like climate change, genes and traumas, and what you may feel your purpose in life is (work, parenthood, discovering yourself, a combination of these things), in order to make some decisions about being a parent.
These are all things I have thought about independently, but it was nice to see someone else having similar thoughts and experiences. The author does a great job of providing both perspectives. At no point did I feel a particular side was being pushed. I liked this.. but I was also frantically reading through the book for a solid answer on what to do. This book will not give you an answer, but it will provide research, musings, and personal accounts to help you think things through.
I did feel that at times the book would ramble off topic slightly, and the final chapter went on a bit too long. However, I know this might be a personal opinion because I was waiting for a clear sentence saying "[do/don't] have a child" and that never happens (as I knew it wouldn't.. but I secretly hoped).
If anything, this book gave me some great talking points to use should I decide to be child-free, while having some serious respect for people who become parents. It also reminded me that should I become a parent, I do not have to fall into the traditional mother role. I can parent how I want, I can have a partnership that supports my needs, and I can do what feels right for me.
After a breakup reshaped the future I'd long imagined (and even more so as I entered my thirties and started to feel the weight of time and expectation press in), I realized I'd never truly interrogated whether I wanted children, how essential a balanced partnership would be to that life, or wrestled with the ethical dilemma of bringing new life into a world that feels increasingly precarious. For a long time, I had simply just assumed I would.
Enter this very special book, which came to me right when I needed it most. In The Parenthood Dilemma, Rushton moves beyond personal ambivalence to examine the structural forces shaping this choice: climate anxiety, financial strain, gendered labor, reproductive health, and the stories we inherit from our own parents. She refuses any easy framing of this as a purely private choice and instead asks what it means to choose parenthood when you cannot fully know the future you are choosing -- for yourself, or for the person who doesn't yet exist.
This book will not tell you what to do (there are no easy answers here), but I can bet that you will finish it feeling far less alone, and far more informed about what's at stake.
Gotta say I'm surprised by some of the negative reviews of this book. Not because there's no room for criticism, but because I feel like it's pretty apparent the book isn't here to answer a question or to tell you what to do. It's a place for a mixture of research and journalism and personal thought processes and biases. I really appreciated how the author jumped from scientific studies (complete with acknowledgements of how some studies' findings may have been called into question) into much more personal, almost poetic sections. Also really appreciated a reproductive justice discussion that isn't centered on the US system. Serves as a great reminder that even every fully modernized country has nuanced fuckery when it comes to women's bodies.
This really made me think about a lot of different off-shoot topics surrounding parenthood and our current culture, and I think that's what it set out to do.
As a marriage therapist I can say this book is a appalling and promotes an untrue/unfounded narrative that is both toxic and unhelpful in its goal of helping people find answers with the difficult question of ‘should I have kids’. It’s funny (and disturbing) that the author talks about how religion is unhelpful and has its issues but has zero problem touting a pseudo religious cult-like narrative of “the big bad invisible patriarchy” as the problem. I’m glad I was able to return the book so I don’t support this toxicity, and glad to know what book to reccomend avoiding for married couples seeking unbiased help with this issue.
This book is fabulous, well-researched and written, humorous, engaging, moving. I found the book relatable as a millennial woman who has grappled with these questions and topics, and validating in seeing my concerns written on page in another’s voice.
The audiobook was lovely and engaging as well. The book mostly interviewed folks in hetero relationships, with a sprinkling of consideration to folks in queer relationships. More could have been said in this regard.
Recommend. For those considering having children, who are thoughtful about the idea to or to not have children, or those who want a lens into a millennial’s confrontation to the question of having children.
Has a lot of great research covering almost too many subjects. But the author overuses dramatic metaphors and uses her personal response as the main summary of multiple threads of thought. There's a lot of thoughts but not much overarching wisdom for readers who are genuinely trying to answer the question for themselves. She herself admits at the end that the decision to have a child or not is not one that can be determined by facts and logic.
A gorgeously written book that's part memoir, part culture study, part social history. This book was elevated beyond its peers due to the quality of the writing, particularly the metaphors and thoughtful, careful word choice. As someone who reads sociological books primarily from a US perspective, I also found the Australian perspective particularly interesting and I was able to learn a lot from this book. This book will stay with me for a long time. 5 stars.