I'm going to start this review by pointing out that I eat only plant based foods.
Why do I feel like this is relevant to share? Well, because, frankly, the book is kinda crap and it might otherwise be easy to write off my review as another meat-head coming down on vegan books. I'm giving it 1.5 stars rounded up - but it only clears the "not completely useless" criteria by the skin of its teeth. Mostly it felt like a complete waste of my time.
"The Plant-Based Athlete" aims to provide the reader with the peace of mind that it's ok to be an athlete without consuming animal products. The authors set out to both inspire the reader with examples of plant-based athletes and provide a road map of sorts - a guide - of how to approach nutrition for optimal performance. I guess they kind of do that, but there are far better resources out there for this. The most useful bits are the suggestions of how to pair foods to create a full and well-rounded meal - but seriously, this could have been achieved in 20-25 pages or so.
The rest is just, well, bad:
- Most egregiously, it regurgitates some falsehood statements and statistics from studies that have been both disproven and withdrawn. Moreover,
- It's ridiculously over-reliant on anecdotal and self-reported individual testimonies.
- It doesn't discuss or recognize any nuance or divergent studies/information.
- In short, it tries to convert without providing sufficient evidence.
- Yet, it doesn't know its audience.
- And uses arguments that only work if one is already converted and uncritical.
- Add to that ad nauseam "testimonials" from athletes, and I've had just about enough.
In terms of what the book argues...
- The argument that eating plant based is compatible with being an athlete, it is so well-established that this book is entirely superfluous, and,
- The argument that eating plant based is better for your performance, well, that one isn't quite as clear cut. Although, you wouldn't know it from reading this book.
However, it should throw up a pretty big red flag when the argumentation too often falls back on testimonials and "the proof is in the pudding" arguments. If one argues that plant based diets are best because there are plant based athletes at the very top of athletic performance, well, there are plenty of meat-eating athletes at the very top too...
In summary, this is not something I would recommend to anyone.