I received an uncorrected audiobook ARC of “Birder, She Wrote” from NetGalley and Macmillan Audio/Minotaur Books in exchange for an honest review.
With opening music reminiscent of a BritBox murder special, the author, Donna Andrews, really knows how to put a story together. Andrews is obviously knowledgeable about country life. Her references to the NIMBY’s ( Not In My Backyard!) who come from the city with a yearning for country life is spot on. I live in the country and not a year goes by when a city person shows up. But while the city folk come to “escape” from the city, they turn around and do everything in their power to turn the country into the city.
As a country girl myself, I love how the author talked about the numerous wild and domestic plants, along with the domestic and wild birds, including chickens. Like the MC, my mom also has a Welsummer hen (among many other). And the fact that Andrews included an abandoned African American cemetery in the book shot arrows of joy into my heart. My doctoral dissertation focused entirely on old African American cemeteries. In fact, I have waded through more brush than a raccoon looking for old cemeteries. The way that Andrews described the site was so visual, I felt like I was there. Even the author’s references to Ditch Lillies were fantastic (we have them planted in our garden!).
The narrator, Bernadette Dunne, is an award winning audiobook narrator. She’s narrated a ton of well-known books (e.g., The Devil Wears Prada, Memoirs of a Geisha) including autobiographies. After listening to this book, the narrator obviously has a lot of artistic range. But the narrator has a natural gravelyness to her voice that made Meg seem older than she appeared to be in the book. In fact, before I knew that the MC’s parents and grandparents were still alive, the narration for the MC’s voice made me think that she was an elderly lady, like a Great Aunt. I think the narrator should have opted for a different tone when narrating for the MC.
The author made sure to include some diversity in her book, which is greatly appreciated. The body appeared at the end of Chapter 5, approximately 14% after the book began. It would have held my interest longer if the murder had occurred either by the end of Chapter 3 or at 10%-12% after the beginning of the story.
This novel included all of the elements that one expects to find in a Cozy Mystery: tongue-in-cheek humor, no scary parts (i.e., blood, gore, etc.), no dramatic politicization, and a body. When I first requested this book, I wasn’t aware that this is the author’s 33rd novel in the series. Yes, you read that right—her **33rd novel in the series**.
Other readers may have a different opinion, but for me, I found it difficult to connect with most of the characters because I haven’t read any of the prior books in the series. And although the story line was good, it just didn’t grip my interest, so I likely won’t go back and read the series from the beginning. When I discovered that this book was the 33rd novel in a series, it reminded me of a girl that I knew in graduate school.
XX (name redacted) was nearing the completion of her MA, but refused to submit her thesis to her committee. When I asked her why, she told me that her MA was financially guaranteed, but her PhD studies were not. XX told me—and this is verbatim—that she was, “…gonna ride that pony ‘till it collapses…” In other words, XX was going to milk the MA assistantship for $$$ as long as humanly possible. When the funding finally ran out, XX did successfully defend her thesis. But even though she was accepted into the doctoral program, she dropped out. She got married, had kids, and has absolutely nothing to do with our field now.
People that read Cozy Mysteries ***love*** series. With a series, readers gets to know the MC and learn to love them. The author is a really good writer and understands the cozy readership. But 33 novels in a series is, well…let’s just say that it’s akin to animal abuse. Like the Life Alert lady, the pony has fallen and it can’t get up.
It is clear that the author understands country living. She also understands what is expected of writers in the Cozy Mystery genre. I would like to read a series written by Andrews where I can become intimate with the MC and the other characters, but hope that the author will limit that series to a number that is more easily digestible for the average reader (and more humane to that poor pony). Although I did like the character in this novel, I just wasn’t invested enough in the story to go back and read all 32 previous novels.