Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Hawthorne Harbor #0.5

The Day He Left Town

Rate this book
He’s waiting for a promotion to come through. She’s back in her hometown after a humiliating break-up. Can Tony and Cat make their second chance stick this time?

Anthony Herrin has never wanted to live in Hawthorne Harbor. He’s followed his older brothers into public service, but he’s anxious to get back into the Forest Service. He’s waiting for his final interview to be scheduled, so running into his high school and college girlfriend at the top of one of their favorite hikes…not in his plans.

The Forest Service separated Catherine Magleby from Tony once before, and while their hikes and mutual love of the outdoors begins to heal the wounds from her recent relationship failure, Cat’s not sure she should just follow Tony wherever he’s going.

She’s got a gypsy spirit too, and she’s not keen to stay in the small town where she grew up, but her heart is in no condition to be broken again.

Will Tony and Cat be able to work past the obstacles keeping them apart to find their off-beat brand of happily-ever-after?

This is a sweet/clean contemporary beach romance in the vein of your favorite Hallmark movie by USA Today bestselling author Elana Johnson.

Read all the Hawthorne Harbor
1. The Day He Left Town
2. The Day He Drove By
3. The Day He Stopped In
4. The Day He Said Hello
5. The Day He Let Go
6. The Day He Came Home
7. The Day He Asked Again

131 pages, Kindle Edition

Published April 2, 2023

453 people are currently reading
590 people want to read

About the author

Elana Johnson

178 books2,080 followers
3-time USA Today bestselling author Elana Johnson writes adult contemporary beach romance. She is the author of over 130 books across two names, and there's nothing better than sun, sand, and swoon-worthy kisses! Unless it's a sweet-and-sexy cowboy - read those under her pen name of Liz Isaacson. Or an emotional, heartfelt women's fiction novel - read those under her pen name of Jessie Newton.

Learn more at:
www.elanajohnson.com
www.lizisaacson.com
www.authorjessienewton.com

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
296 (37%)
4 stars
222 (28%)
3 stars
180 (22%)
2 stars
65 (8%)
1 star
29 (3%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 53 reviews
Profile Image for Jennifer Lara.
1,140 reviews4 followers
June 24, 2023
The Day He Left Town by Elana Johnson is the first book in the Hawthorne Harbor series. Anthony “Tony” Herrin is the youngest of the Harrin brothers and followed the family tradition into public service. He never expected to live in Hawthorne Harbor and eagerly awaits news of a job with the Forest Service. Catherine “Cat” Magleby didn’t want to be back in her hometown but after a humiliating break-up, she had no choice. She also definitely didn’t want to run into her ex-boyfriend. Despite their mutual love of the outdoors, Tony and Cat seem to be on different paths while still being drawn to each other. Can they find a second chance at a happily ever after?
I like Elana Johnson’s clean second chance romances. They are fun, inspiring and a great weekend read. Unfortunately, The Day He Left Town didn’t have the same feel. It was a short read, almost too short. I felt as if I didn’t have time to get invested in Tony and Cat’s relationship. I didn’t care for Tony and Cat as individuals, at first. By the end, I enjoyed seeing them together. I was interested in the side characters which will probably be featured in future books. Overall, Tony and Cat’s story was enjoyable and I am interested in reading the rest of the series. I recommend The Day He Left Town.

The Day He Left Town is available in paperback and eBook



Profile Image for Elena Maccagni.
77 reviews5 followers
May 14, 2024
Tony Herrin, amante dell’ aria aperta e della natura, già da qualche anno fa il vigile del fuoco presso la caserma di Hawthorne Harbor, paese in cui è nato e cresciuto e da cui vorrebbe andarsene, infatti sta aspettando una promozione che lo porterà in Oregon.
Ma il destino ha piani un po’ diversi, infatti durante un’ escursione con il proprio cane, incontra per caso, Cat Ashford, una ragazza con cui si era frequentato tempo addietro, ma per colpa della lontananza fisica tra i due, era finita.
Entrambi spiriti liberi, non riescono a stare fermi a lungo nello stesso luogo, infatti anche lei è in attesa di una risposta lavorativa che la porterà parecchio lontano dall’ Oregon.
Questa volta l’ amore riuscirà a spuntarla sui loro animi ribelli?

A volte si ha proprio bisogno di staccare la spina e questa è la storia giusta, leggera ma non scontata, una trama da farfalle nello stomaco e luccichìo negli occhi, ti fa venire voglia di vivere e soprattutto di riprovarci.

La scrittura è scorrevole e i personaggi sono strepitosi, soprattutto i fratelli Herrin, che ritroveremo nei prossimi libri della serie “Hawthorne Harbor”, non vedo l’ ora di leggere le loro vicende ed immergermi ancora tra le parole di questa autrice.
Tony è davvero affascinante, però sono davvero curiosa di conoscere la storia di Drew, il fratello di mezzo, da cui sono profondamente ammagliata.
Profile Image for Parhelion.
97 reviews1 follower
November 16, 2023
I read this book as part of my research in clean romances. Based on the author's credentials and reviews of the book, I had high hopes.

Those hopes were dashed by the end of page one.

Perhaps my expectations for good writing are inappropriate for modern romance novels, particularly clean romances, as I am not well-read in these areas, but I will honestly say that this book, along with the other clean romances I have recently read, make me believe that the reason why romance novels have such a poor reputation in the broader field of fiction is that they are so poorly written."

For this book specifically, I could not get into the story. I did not like the characters. I did not care about them. I found their chemistry unconvincing. I was constantly told how they felt rather than shown, having their backstories shoved in my face in a truncated fashion to try to produce "mystery", descriptions felt like almost blow-by-blow deary-diary entries of things that happened rather than scene and event building. Honestly, more was done to describe the main dude whistling to his dog Alfie than the build-up of chemistry between the main characters. The sentences were poorly constructed as well, making it hard to get into the book because it was jarring. The pacing was... ugh. For example, on their first date a fair amount of page time was spent describing their car trip to the restaurant as they reconnected, then suddenly "dinner is over". Erm what??? Did I miss them arriving and eating at the restaurant? Maybe I did. I skimmed a lot.

Like another clean romance I read, it felt like the author smashed out a first draft of the novel to make sure all of the plot was down, went through and spell-checked it, then got it published, rather than going back and fleshing it out.

Right now I feel very jaded about clean romances. I don't know if there is a need for decent writing in this area, or if readers genuinely want to read half-baked, uninteresting garbage. If you read this review and have recommendations for well written clean romances, please send them my way.
Profile Image for Ela.
76 reviews3 followers
December 26, 2024
"Tony amava le cose dinamiche che non sembravano così pericolose come in realtà erano, come il fuoco. Come l'acqua. Come l'amore."
- Elana Johnson


Tony e Cat, due persone che amano avventurarsi in mezzo alla natura e viaggiare, si rincontreranno in un un momento di svolta per la vita di entrambi e dovranno decidere se far sbocciare e crescere l'amore tra loro due o rinunciare e partire per il prossimo capitolo della loro vita separatamente.
Cat e Tony sono molto diversi caratterialmente e hanno un bagaglio personale che pesa sulle loro spalle, ma scopriranno di avere una grande intesa fin da subito, come se il tempo fra loro due non fosse passato, e che tutto quel bagaglio non è così pesante se condiviso con una persona che tiene a te.
Cosa sceglieranno? Si daranno una possibilità dopo tutti questi anni o lasceranno di nuovo che le loro strade si dividano?
Ho trovato questa storia davvero bella e dolce.🥰
Mi sono riconosciuta in alcuni atteggiamenti o sentimenti dei protagonisti ed è una cosa che apprezzo perché mi permette di entrare meglio nella storia.
I posti che Cat e Tony hanno esplorato durante le loro escursioni mi hanno fatto venire una gran voglia di vederli dal vivo, essendo un amante della natura e nonostante non adori le escursioni, e per questo devo ringraziare l'autrice per il bellissimo lavoro che ha fatto con la loro descrizione.🥰
Devo dire che non ero così certa della scelta che avrebbero fatto e questo mi è piaciuto, non fa sembrare la storia scontata.
Posso solo dirvi che vi consiglio questa lettura leggera e dolce. Vi scalderà il cuore.❤️

Nota personale: preferisco quando, all'inizio del capitolo, viene spiegato di quale protagonista sia il pov, ma non è assolutamente una nota negativa del libro.
Profile Image for Shental.
96 reviews1 follower
November 8, 2023
A short simple read!

This is Tony's and Cat's story.

This is book one in the Hawthorne Harbor Roamnce Series.

Okay, I liked this story. It was a cute story, even sweet of a second chance between Cat and Tony. It's a short easy clean romance. For the story itself, I'd gone it 4 stars.

What I didn't like was how this story was formatted! This book is about 175 pages long. The first 112 pages are about Tony and Cat. That makes it a quick story and, to me, there's pieces missing from their story . And that's annoying!

But the rest of the book has a "bonus" section. Now while I love bonuses, this was done in such a way that I found it frustrating. This bonus consists of 5 chapter of the events around Tony and Cats wedding.

Having the characters' wedding at the end is awesome! I always like to see a finish like that in a story. What I didn't like was how little of those chapters were about Tony and Cat.

Instead they were about Tony's brothers. Now I understand that story loops are an author's advanced storytelling tool, I get that but when I read entire, long chapters about another character and not the main one I want to be reading about, especially when i have sooooo many unanswered questions, i get annoyed.

Okay, I know these chapters are great lead ins for the upcoming books, but to me they detracted from Tony's and Cat's story because, in this case, they took too long.

And because of that I would only give this a 2 star rating. To average it out, it'll be 3 stars.
Profile Image for Chalice.
3,681 reviews112 followers
October 15, 2023
The couple: Tony and Cat

Romance trope: second chance
Series: Hawthorne Harbor
Length: 175 pages

Plot: Tony is finally making a move that will help fulfill a dream. He's applied for a job with the Forest Service. But now the girl that got away is back in town and he and Cat might have a second chance at their young love. What will happen when he moves away this time?

Commentary: What a couple of weirdos! In a good way? Usually, it's "she's not like other girls" (and that's an annoying trope), but they're each that (he's not like the other boys, obviously - we're definitely hit over the head with that throughout the whole book). I guess there couldn't be anyone else for each of them because this is a case of nobody else understanding them. The thing with the shorts! Her randomly wanting to be a nurse for the Forest Service (who even knew that was a thing!). Both of them unable to settle down - wanderlust galore! It was such a strange romance at first - he almost seemed to have an attitude of "yeah, good enough." By the end I believed they loved each other, but it was close for a while. At any rate, I hope the police chief brother gets the woman with the kid that he was helping - I wanted to see that more than anything.
And I don't intend this meanly (although they are just fictional people (even if the author is not)) - I just found the couple to be so strange. I couldn't tell what was more important to them - each other or joining the Forest Service.

Next book in the series: The Day He Drove By
116 reviews1 follower
September 2, 2025
Clumsy writing, with weird changes in character focus. Why so many details about side characters? I felt like I’d turned the wrong page of a choose your own adventure story.

Unnecessary details and descriptions which made for clunky reading.

Really poor, incomplete editing to the point where a sentence isn’t finished before a new (unrelated) paragraph starts. Lots of obvious issues.

Unlikable characters that I felt I didn’t get to know.

Appalled by a character making phone calls as she drives (reaching for her phone, tapping out the number)
And the behaviour of some of the characters is just horrid (those parents needed to put their daughter ahead of a family rift) and jokes about somebody in a wheelchair.

This book felt like it was at beta stage.
Profile Image for JoAnne.
3,150 reviews32 followers
May 21, 2023
A second chance romance that's the beginning of a series. The book is set in the west with family, friends and first loves. Life gets in the way and Tony and Cat break up and go their separate ways. Ten years have passed and there seems to be chemistry when their paths unexpectedly cross again.

There is a good flow to the story and lots of scenic descriptions. There's some turmoil and angst but will love win out? There's a happily ever after in the offing along with closure. I liked that there's an excerpt for the next book in the series and I'm definitely looking forward to reading more of her books and not just those in this series.
711 reviews14 followers
April 12, 2025
The story about Tony and Cat was very sweet. They were sweethearts when they were young and Tony’s job took him away. Cat went on her own adventures and now years later find herself back in Hawthorne Harbor. Tony has been back in Hawthorne Harbor working as a firefighter but applying for jobs on the other side of the country. But Cat and Tony accidently run into each other and they start to reconnect. Except now they are both offered jobs that are over hundreds away from each other. What will they do? Are they really ready to admit that they love each other or will they go their own ways again? You will have to read to find out. It was a good story.
220 reviews9 followers
September 21, 2023
Do you like second chance romances? Cat and Tony were high school sweethearts. After graduation, they went their separate ways. Now, seven years later, they find themselves back in their hometown and the attraction is stronger than ever. Both are making career changes but neither job is in the same town and are in separate states. Will their relationship survive or will they go their separate ways yet again?
731 reviews
April 10, 2023
Grabbing a second chance is a winner,

I thoroughly enjoyed the excitement of this couple. They were back in their home town after many years where they had gone seperate ways. When they meet again sparks fly. They are kindred spirits and ready for whatever challenges come their way.
319 reviews7 followers
April 25, 2023
Great story about finding love again! Years apart, now with more maturity, they are able to make their love work.

Thanks to the author for providing this book for my honest review!

Reasons I enjoyed this book:
Page-turner Happily Ever After Easy-to-read Realistic Wonderful characters Original Romantic
Profile Image for Bonny Rambarran.
1,521 reviews21 followers
July 5, 2023
He left town -- does he want to go back? He left town for a job . . . and then he moved home. And found his old girlfriend on a hike. Something they love to do together!!! But then he gets a new job - and she gets a new job - both in different towns. Now what? This is a superb book of what can happen if you really want it!!
Profile Image for Pam Merrill.
309 reviews3 followers
September 6, 2023
Sweet Romance

Tony has decided decided to change jobs and is planning on leaving town. He meets a former girl friend who is visiting their home town. She is also looking for a job somewhere else. What will win out, jobs or love? A cute story about two restless souls who finally decide what will make them happy.
Profile Image for Ruthanne.
37 reviews
July 15, 2024
Terrible audio: Matt, Digital voice. Ugh!
This review is due to the audio, not the book. The digital voice narration is horrible on this book. It truly ruined the experience for me. Flat and monotone with no clear breaks in the narration, making a very choppy experience. I will be watching out for digital narration books in the future. To be sure that I don't waste my time or money on them. I
can only assume the digital voice was used to cut corners and save money. This is a disservice to the author's time and talent.
8 reviews2 followers
July 20, 2025
I liked it alright. The narrator was so blah. I wanted to know more details of the characters. I am however going to be reading the next book in this series and hoping for a different narrator 🙂 I like that Eliana Johnson doesn’t go into explicit love scenes so it is a clean romance 💘 I would give it a four if…it had a better narrator and there were more details of the characters.
Profile Image for Mary Jane McLeod.
2,918 reviews6 followers
April 13, 2023
Great Series Beginning

I always enjoy this author's books. She has a way of drawing me into a story that makes me feel like I know the characters and could be their friend. I loved Tony and Cat's story. A really great read that I read straight through.
2,237 reviews3 followers
April 27, 2023
ebook

He’s ready to move on when the woman that got away 10 years before comes home. They start dating and it’s good. Then he gets his forestry job and she gets offered a job not close by. What will they decide, split up, follow each other but which place?
1,033 reviews4 followers
September 6, 2023
I really enjoyed this second chance romance between Tony and Cat. The way the author wrote the story made you feel like you were there. I definitely recommend reading this book.

I received a free book, and this is my honest opinion.
1,119 reviews5 followers
November 14, 2023
'The Day He Left Town' was such a sweet tale. The plot was filled with a second chance at love and a monumental decision. Cat and Tony, the protagonists, worked very hard to achieve their HEA and oozed chemistry. I liked the vividness the author created. Overall, I liked the charming narrative.
779 reviews6 followers
December 24, 2023
A very good story about two families. Cat and Tony were high school sweethearts from a small town in Washington. Many years have passed since they graduated and followed different paths. Both have returned home and met unexpectedly while hiking a favorite trail.
10 reviews3 followers
December 28, 2023
Which way do we go?

I chose this book because it sounded like an easy read.
I like books that are romantic.
I was capable of reading in no time. I would recommend it as a night read.
It is relaxing. There is no swearing nor sexual content.
1,923 reviews5 followers
February 28, 2024
The Day He Left Town

This is the story of two young people who broke up to go their separate ways with the careers they had chosen only to end up back home in their hometown and getting married. This is my review and mine alone. Norma Gorrill
1,006 reviews
May 13, 2024
I've missed you

This was a nice second time around contemporary romance. They were a couple many years ago and now were both back in town. Their first new date they both knew this wad real. A nice read.
1,074 reviews6 followers
July 7, 2024
This is such a sweet story of Cat and Tony, who are looking for their second chance and realize that they are right for each other, and both willing to sacrifice to help each other, but luckily it works out for them both and they are able to find their HEA! I loved reading this great story.
1,226 reviews2 followers
December 4, 2024
Very enjoyable book!

Tony and Cat go way back. Cat broke up with him and continued on with her life. Years went by , but things didn't work out for Cat like she thought. She returned to her home town and met up with Tony. Can they make a relationship work this time?
Profile Image for Joann.
286 reviews13 followers
April 14, 2023
I enjoyed reading this book. I just love reading a love story.
29 reviews1 follower
May 15, 2023
Sweet read

Engaging characters, great lead to the happy ever after.
Nicely considered story.
First of Elana’s works that I’ve read. Happy to read more
Profile Image for Christine.
334 reviews
May 27, 2023
enjoyed this story light hearted but very readable
983 reviews3 followers
July 1, 2023
Enjoyed it from the beginning.
Is love better the second time around
Displaying 1 - 30 of 53 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.