Finally got my hands on this book and it. is. AWESOME! Mostly images, which is great because to read who he's written for (various pop culture rags like Spin, the Village Voice, currently a contributing editor for Paper), it comes as somewhat of an eyebrow-raiser that Steven Blush writes like one of my undergrads. Simple, declarative sentences that don't really relate to each other and kind of just pile on with no real structure of being an actual paragraph save for the fact that a designer made it sit on its own on a page, hence the block of random text takes on the visual appearance of a paragraph.
But for the most part grammar doesn't even matter, because the book is SO photo heavy -- amazing stuff I'd never seen before, and not the usual Neil Zlozower. Not that I don't love his stuff, but the lack of Zloz is probably what makes this book feel so fresh; these aren't pics you've seen a zillion times before.
And what Blush lacks as a writer, to whatever extent he was in charge of the content here, he does a lovely job as a curator. You've got obscure bands like Teeze and Nitro cheek by jowl with Poison and Motley Crue. And most of the text isn't even his; instead, he's culled choice quotes from interviews in Rip, Circus, Hit Parader, Metal Edge, etc. to give the book a flavor of what the boys in these bands were saying about them AT THE TIME, instead of in some watered-down, Behind the Music musing.
The other thing I will say that I liked a lot about this book -- even though, again, in terms of style and grammar the author could really benefit from a critical editor -- is how much it focuses on some of the more sociological perspectives on metal. He actually touches on topics like the politics of whiteness, the tension between androgyny and homophobia, and the overall conservatism of the genre. In an interesting way, this book seems to fit best as a photo and caption-heavy companion to musicologist Robert Walser's Running with the Devil, in my opinion the best book ever written about the genre.
And oh, did I mention the pictures!?!?! Clear, full-color, uncluttered... I want to wallpaper my house with pages from this book. Also, I wish I could give it an extra star just for making me pause to remember the existence of DIAL MTV.