I don't know how to rate this. It was mildly entertaining, but the entire time I read it was just wondering what the heck the point of it was.
This is a series of short essays about a bunch of books without any particular focus. So it's not just lesser-known great books. (The Great Gatsby is in here, ffs; Kakutani opens her review by acknowledging that most of her audience will have written a paper about it in middle or high school. I know I did, and she didn't have anything to say that Mrs. Dosher didn't already teach me.) It's not just older books. (For example, On Earth We're Briefly Famous is in here, which was released in 2019, probably just before Kakutani started writing this book.) It's not on any special theme, though it feels like about half of the books are related to Trump, fascism, totalitarianism, and the decline of actual truth. (Is this stressful reading? Why yes. Yes, it is.) It's just some essays about some books she loves.
And that's part of the problem. She clearly loves these books, and she is unsurprisingly great at describing the central premise and pulling a few excellent quotes to give you a sense of the book. But one hundred raves in a row gets old. I would have loved to see some essays in here on books she hates, just so it was a little less one-note.
Another part of the problem is that, okay, sure, I didn't know about all these books. That 1981 book about Hollywood's classic romantic comedies? I'm thrilled to learn it exists! I would LOVE to read it! And I can't fucking find it, because it was published forty years ago. Meanwhile, the books I can easily get -- Educated comes to mind -- I already knew about. My mind was made up about whether to read them or not long before I read this book, and reading it didn't change anything.
Also, Kakutani is, as I said, unsurprisingly and wildly well-read, but she doesn't cover every genre with equal deftness. (No human could.) I really wish she had focused on just the areas she knows well and reads in widely, because some of her essays about books in the genres I know best made me go, "Okay, you think this is innovative because you've never read anything else in this subgenre."
The best essays are definitely the ones where she talks about what the book means to her, specifically, and links it to a time in her life or a mental state. This book would be SO much better if it were structured around any kind of theme, but I think the one I'd most like to see is her life in books. (I would read that from almost ANYONE. Tell me what books were important to you or very present in your life when you were four! Fourteen! Fifty! Whatever.)
I don't know. I can't dislike this, I can't recommend it, I can't find a feeling to have about it. It's a perfectly fine book, but I honestly cannot understand why it exists.