Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Gabriel's Rebellion

Rate this book
Gabriel's Rebellion tells the dramatic story of what was perhaps the most extensive slave conspiracy in the history of the American South. Douglas Egerton illuminates the complex motivations that underlay two related Virginia slave the first, in 1800, led by the slave known as Gabriel; and the second, called the 'Easter Plot, ' instigated in 1802 by one of his followers. Although Gabriel has frequently been portrayed as a messianic, Samson-like figure, Egerton shows that he was a literate and highly skilled blacksmith whose primary goal was to destroy the economic hegemony of the 'merchants, ' the only whites he ever identified as his enemies. According to Egerton, the social, political, and economic disorder of the Revolutionary era weakened some of the harsh controls that held slavery in place during colonial times. Emboldened by these conditions, a small number of literate slaves -- most of them highly skilled artisans -- planned an armed insurrection aimed at destroying slavery in Virginia. The intricate scheme failed, as did the Easter Plot that stemmed from it, and Gabriel and many of his followers were hanged. By placing the revolts within the broader context of the volatile political currents of the day, Egerton challenges the conventional understanding of race, class, and politics in the early days of the American republic.

280 pages, Paperback

First published November 1, 1993

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Douglas R. Egerton

27 books11 followers
A specialist in the history of late 18th and early 19th-century America, Douglas Egerton is Professor of History at Le Moyne College.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
13 (14%)
4 stars
33 (37%)
3 stars
31 (35%)
2 stars
9 (10%)
1 star
1 (1%)
Displaying 1 - 5 of 5 reviews
Profile Image for Jonathan.
222 reviews
July 28, 2009
Well-researched and well-written in part, but poorly argued and constructed.

In this book, Egerton gives us the only full-length study of two failed slave uprisings. The first was Gabriel's Rebellion, an abortive 1800 slave revolt centering on Richmond, Virginia. The second was the Easter Plot, an 1802 conspiracy fomented along Chesapeake waterways. Both conspiracies ultimately involved too many people, including some with divided loyalties, to succeed. Their scope astonished white Virginians, however, and briefly caused some of them to seriously consider the possibility of compensated emancipation and colonization.

Egerton argues that Gabriel, a 24-year-old slave blacksmith who hired his time in Richmond, was inspired to launch his rebellion by the political struggle between Federalists and Republicans in the 1790s. Egerton claims that Gabriel expected actual warfare between these parties, and that he expected white artisans in Virginia to join him in a class struggle. They would slaughter and dispossess merchants and planters as well as to win freedom for slaves. Egerton's evidence for this, however, is thin. Some of the evidence is circumstantial: Gabriel could read, Egerton explains, so he must have been aware of the volatile political situation; and it appears that two white Frenchmen (or a Frenchman and a German) were involved in planning the rebellion. Some of the evidence comes from brief statements made by informers, which are reasonably persuasive but indirect. And some of it comes from weird non sequiturs. Here, for example, is the entire last paragraph of chapter three:
There can be little doubt of the role that partisan politics played in Gabriel's thinking. In mid-April (1800), just one day before notifying Jefferson of the Republican victories in the preliminary spring elections, (Virginia governor) James Monroe informed the vice president of odd rumors that had surfaced "of a negro insurrection." But whatever news had leaked to authorities quickly died down, and the governor thought no more about it.
In a related but more straightforward claim, Egerton informs us that, contrary to later fiction, Gabriel was apparently not religious. There is no contemporary evidence that Gabriel involved religious belief or rhetoric in his plot; he said not a word about either Christianity or African belief. Egerton argues that this made it harder for Gabriel to recruit followers, which seems like a reasonable claim. Also reasonable is Egerton's inference that Gabriel's ambiguous place in Richmond society led him to dreams of liberty. Gabriel was a skilled laborer who worked away from his master's plantation, at a time when Virginians did not closely supervise their slaves and when many of them expressed regret about the institution of slavery. All of this makes sense, but Egerton assumes too much coherence in Gabriel's political consciousness. Egerton also dismisses a key claim made by one of the witnesses: "'that the two White Frenchmen (were) the first instigators of the Insurrection'" -- on the strange grounds that "Gabriel needed no convincing." He provides no evidence for this feat of telepathy.

Gabriel's planned uprising was discovered thanks to the conflicted consciences of Pharaoh and Tom, both slaves of Mosby Sheppard, who apparently treated them well. White Virginia leaders scrambled to mobilize the state militia and apprehend and interrogate the conspirators. The state eventually hanged 27 slaves, including Gabriel. Because Governor Monroe and his party leader, Thomas Jefferson, were bothered by the idea of mass execution of men seeking liberty, several other conspirators were sentenced to death but were instead transported, presumably to be worked to death in the West Indies, and a few were even casually acquitted despite relatively solid evidence against them. Egerton narrates these trials in tedious detail, padding his account with unnecessary and redundant quotations from the trial records.

About a year later, a slave named Sancho, who worked on the Chesapeake as a ferryman, began planning another mass rising in Virginia and North Carolina. Sancho, it seems, had been peripherally involved in Gabriel's plot; now he wished to try again, this time with an uprising on or around Easter 1802. This plot, however, was organized less effectively than Gabriel's, and it too was discovered. The usual interrogations, hangings, and transportations ensued. Once again, Egerton is prolix.

In the aftermath of these rebellions, Virginia leaders tried to make their slave system more secure, passing various laws to increase oversight of slaves and get skilled slaves out of the free labor market. They also took up a pair of interesting proposals. First, they tried to interest President Jefferson in a proposal to set aside land (somewhere outside of Virginia) as a place to transport enslaved criminals, an alternative to selling them off to French and Spanish colonies. Second, they considered a proposal by George Tucker (brother of St. George) to establish a colony for other slaves as well -- a place to which Virginia's slaves could be gradually manumitted without letting them mix with whites. Jefferson and Monroe toyed with these ideas before abandoning them as impractical. Years later, word of this proposal would inspire Charles Fenton Mercer to found the American Colonization Society.

All in all, this book does not live up to its promise. This was a great opportunity to tell a great story. But its key academic claims could have been made more effectively in a pair of articles, and its storyline gets too bogged down in repetitive procedural detail to hold the attention of readers trying to imagine a lost world.
Profile Image for Mr. Monahan.
32 reviews2 followers
January 26, 2019
“How does could the Revolutionary mindset that carried the War for Independence be stopped?” In both Shays’s Rebellion and Gabriel’s Rebellion, disaffected portions of the American populous sought to institute radical changes in the still-forming republic. What is all the more significant is that this is done under the rhetoric of the Declaration of Independence. If fully understanding the conditions of America’s ‘peculiar institution’ is a most challenging task in of itself; understanding the motives behind slavery are even more present a myriad of problematic conundrums.

Contemporary scholarship on slavery has been predominately focused on American Slavery, and David Brion Davis argues that this is problematic. He argues, or rather challenges, scholars and teachers to consider the global history of slavery as a means of understanding the history of slavery. In a groundbreaking course at Yale, Davis traces the origins and practices of slavery from the Old Testament, through Antiquity, the Renaissance, and Colonial Europe. The tendency of Southern plantation owners to give their slaves Biblical or Romanesque names takes on new significance after Brion’s history of bondage. In an essay published in the American Historical

Review, Brion makes a compelling argument around the significance of slavery as characteristic of—or even crucial to—colonialism. He weaves a narrative that demonstrates the decline of feudalistic quasi-slave serfs whom satisfied a Medieval society, and rise of literally bonded slaves who fulfilled the more ambitious nationalistic colonial monarchies. According to Brion, who challenges more research on the topic, American Slavery is part of a much ‘bigger picture’ or social schematic, that has not in fact disappeared, but rather disguised itself in the form of modern industrialism and/or global conglomeration. I find Brion’s essay and the subject of his course compelling on and fascinating. While his work is an essay and thus based more in opinion that scholarship, I would certainly like to see (and read) a branch of research emerge on the topic of Global Slavery.

In his Gabriel’s Rebellion, Douglas Egerrton argues through a mostly narrative account that some the radicalism which fueled the American, French, and Hatian Revolutions ‘spilled over’ (as could be expected) into great Richmond, Va. Egerton makes a quite valid point when he asserts that scholarship on Gabriel’s 1800 Slave Revolt is most lacking. I checked the 2006 edition of the US History textbook being used at my high school, and sure enough the account of Gabriel’s Rebellion was quite brief and lacking and essential conclusion. This is probably why Egerton poured over all the available, but also extremely limited, evidence surrounding this uprising. Egerton describes the climate of 1800 thoroughly enough that the reader can feel the drop in pressure the precedes a major (in this case political) storm. With the spirit of revolution, in essence radicalism, resounding from 1776 and echoing from France and Haiti, it is only logical and natural that America’s large slave population should revolt. However, where Egerton’s work bogs down is also the same reason for the lack of scholarship that he accuses the topic of having: lack of pre-rebellion documentation. While Gabriel and several of his lieutenants were indeed literate, they did leave behind a manifesto, political newspaper, or series of diaries that would allow future generations to study the failed rebellion. In this sense, much of what Egerton asserts is done so in the unsatisfactory manner of “Gabriel probably did _______” or “The Rebels must have __________.” This type of speculative detective work, although potentially correct, does not sit well with this student.
Profile Image for Gail.
Author 5 books6 followers
May 13, 2018
I knew nothing of these slave conspiracies, which I just don't understand how one gets to be my age and not know about this. I was amazed by the thorough research, and how the author created these true stories based on historical records.
Profile Image for Brianna.
43 reviews3 followers
August 5, 2012
Gave a really interesting explanation of two notable slave conspiracies. Also offered a valuable account of resolutions to gradually abolish slavery that were never passed and other political issues at the time.
Profile Image for Marsha.
134 reviews6 followers
February 4, 2014
Interesting analysis of the Virginia slave uprisings of 1800 and 1802.
Displaying 1 - 5 of 5 reviews