What do you think?
Rate this book


280 pages, Paperback
First published November 1, 1993
There can be little doubt of the role that partisan politics played in Gabriel's thinking. In mid-April (1800), just one day before notifying Jefferson of the Republican victories in the preliminary spring elections, (Virginia governor) James Monroe informed the vice president of odd rumors that had surfaced "of a negro insurrection." But whatever news had leaked to authorities quickly died down, and the governor thought no more about it.In a related but more straightforward claim, Egerton informs us that, contrary to later fiction, Gabriel was apparently not religious. There is no contemporary evidence that Gabriel involved religious belief or rhetoric in his plot; he said not a word about either Christianity or African belief. Egerton argues that this made it harder for Gabriel to recruit followers, which seems like a reasonable claim. Also reasonable is Egerton's inference that Gabriel's ambiguous place in Richmond society led him to dreams of liberty. Gabriel was a skilled laborer who worked away from his master's plantation, at a time when Virginians did not closely supervise their slaves and when many of them expressed regret about the institution of slavery. All of this makes sense, but Egerton assumes too much coherence in Gabriel's political consciousness. Egerton also dismisses a key claim made by one of the witnesses: "'that the two White Frenchmen (were) the first instigators of the Insurrection'" -- on the strange grounds that "Gabriel needed no convincing." He provides no evidence for this feat of telepathy.