What do you think?
Rate this book
Wishing Well Seminary #2
Miss Robinson and the Unsuitable Baron
A proper schoolmistress, an aristocratic nincompoop, and an improper proposal.
When Ellen Robinson seeks out Baron Edmund Tewkbury in London to deliver his ward, he wheedles her into staying—as his wife.
Edmund Graves, Sixth Baron Tewkbury, is in a pretty pickle after lying to his friend about being married. To save face, he must introduce a fictitious wife at a high-society house party. But where does one obtain a wife at the snip of one’s finger, especially when one isn’t keen on being married?
Miss Ellen Robinson is a respectable school mistress with no prospects of marriage. All she wants is to deliver Baron Tewkbury’s ward and return to her beloved seminary in Bath. When the baron makes her a shockingly improper proposal in exchange for assistance with her own family troubles, she finds it impossible to resist.
As she gets sucked into a whirlwind of scandal and deceit, Ellen discovers a most surprising thing: behind the mask of the nincompoop hides a very different man. Navigating the duplicity of their fake marriage, Ellen and Edmund realizes their feelings for each other might not be as feigned as they thought. But how can true love prevail in this web of lies?
This is the second book of the Wishing Well Seminary Series, which can be read as a standalone.
When Ellen Robinson seeks out Baron Edmund Tewkbury in London to deliver his ward, he wheedles her into staying—as his wife.
Edmund Graves, Sixth Baron Tewkbury, is in a pretty pickle after lying to his friend about being married. To save face, he must introduce a fictitious wife at a high-society house party. But where does one obtain a wife at the snip of one’s finger, especially when one isn’t keen on being married?
Miss Ellen Robinson is a respectable school mistress with no prospects of marriage. All she wants is to deliver Baron Tewkbury’s ward and return to her beloved seminary in Bath. When the baron makes her a shockingly improper proposal in exchange for assistance with her own family troubles, she finds it impossible to resist.
As she gets sucked into a whirlwind of scandal and deceit, Ellen discovers a most surprising thing: behind the mask of the nincompoop hides a very different man. Navigating the duplicity of their fake marriage, Ellen and Edmund realizes their feelings for each other might not be as feigned as they thought. But how can true love prevail in this web of lies?
This is the second book of the Wishing Well Seminary Series, which can be read as a standalone.
266 pages, Kindle Edition
Published May 11, 2023
365 people are currently reading
139 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 78 reviews
September 27, 2024
Not enjoying this series as much as the author's Merry Spinsters, Charming Rogues books, but I give credit for tackling a foppish hero and making him likable. It was unique!
May 1, 2023
I went in to this story completely blind as to its plot. I have read some of Sofi Laporte's books from a different, yet loosely connected series. It took me a while to decide if I was going to like these characters.
Overall, I enjoyed the book and the outcome, but I do feel there could have been a little more description of the development of the connections Edmund has with others in the book.
One aspect that I felt was done very well was the descriptions of the house party games. They were so cringe worthy! While I was reading the book, I was thinking how much I'd learned from Holli Jo Monroe's Regency Parlour Games book. Then in the acknowledgements at the end, Holli Jo and her book were mentioned as being helpful. Homestly, I recognized her influence and was proud of myself.
This is probably not a book that will stick with me over time, but I enjoyed the read as it went for the most part. And I will look for the next in the series when it is released.
Thanks to the author for gifting me an advanced digital copy. Nothing was required in return, but I wanted to leave an honest review.
Overall, I enjoyed the book and the outcome, but I do feel there could have been a little more description of the development of the connections Edmund has with others in the book.
One aspect that I felt was done very well was the descriptions of the house party games. They were so cringe worthy! While I was reading the book, I was thinking how much I'd learned from Holli Jo Monroe's Regency Parlour Games book. Then in the acknowledgements at the end, Holli Jo and her book were mentioned as being helpful. Homestly, I recognized her influence and was proud of myself.
This is probably not a book that will stick with me over time, but I enjoyed the read as it went for the most part. And I will look for the next in the series when it is released.
Thanks to the author for gifting me an advanced digital copy. Nothing was required in return, but I wanted to leave an honest review.
May 10, 2024
3.5 stars
A wonderful story that warmed my heart. The female lead is a school teacher, and a very good one. The male lead suffers from dyslexia. His childhood memories of teachers are laced with pain and shame. Of course, their romance is bound for a rocky start, which makes their HEA all the sweeter.
A wonderful story that warmed my heart. The female lead is a school teacher, and a very good one. The male lead suffers from dyslexia. His childhood memories of teachers are laced with pain and shame. Of course, their romance is bound for a rocky start, which makes their HEA all the sweeter.
May 11, 2023
Sofi Laporte‘s writing is refreshing and once you start YOU. CAN. NOT. PUT. IT. DOWN.
Miss Robinson and the Unsuitable Baron is part of the Wishing Well Seminary Series but you can totally read it as a standalone.
There is not one thing I did not like about it, except that it had to end at some point. But that‘s what rereads are for. 😉
Ellen Robinson is one of Miss Hilversham‘s most valued school mistresses at her seminary at Bath. When one day a young boy is delivered at the girl school‘s doors, it falls to Miss Robinson to bring Young Nino back to his ward to London.
Enter Edmund Graves, Baron of Tewkbury. Probably one of the best male characters I‘ve ever experienced.
(How does she do it? I have read all her romance novels and there has never been a dull or repetative male character! Each and everyone is perfectly crafted, goes through personal development and leaves you swooning.)
He‘s the pink of the town, all about appearances. And apparently he‘s newly wed. Or so he told his friends. Where does one find a wife? Maybe the right one will show up at his doorsteps…
As you can guess, it‘s a marriage of convenience trope and it‘s so well done. I loved both characters so much. Ellen is wonderful, she‘s brave, well-spoken, independent, has experienced hardship and despite it all maintained kind and loving. Edmund is so complexe and closed off- I LOVE IT. There‘s a reason for all that he does and the way he goes about things. Seeming superficial and arrogant, he is everything but. I cannot express how much I loved getting to know him and experience Ellen leaving cracks in his shiny armour.
Highly recommend!
Miss Robinson and the Unsuitable Baron is part of the Wishing Well Seminary Series but you can totally read it as a standalone.
There is not one thing I did not like about it, except that it had to end at some point. But that‘s what rereads are for. 😉
Ellen Robinson is one of Miss Hilversham‘s most valued school mistresses at her seminary at Bath. When one day a young boy is delivered at the girl school‘s doors, it falls to Miss Robinson to bring Young Nino back to his ward to London.
Enter Edmund Graves, Baron of Tewkbury. Probably one of the best male characters I‘ve ever experienced.
(How does she do it? I have read all her romance novels and there has never been a dull or repetative male character! Each and everyone is perfectly crafted, goes through personal development and leaves you swooning.)
He‘s the pink of the town, all about appearances. And apparently he‘s newly wed. Or so he told his friends. Where does one find a wife? Maybe the right one will show up at his doorsteps…
As you can guess, it‘s a marriage of convenience trope and it‘s so well done. I loved both characters so much. Ellen is wonderful, she‘s brave, well-spoken, independent, has experienced hardship and despite it all maintained kind and loving. Edmund is so complexe and closed off- I LOVE IT. There‘s a reason for all that he does and the way he goes about things. Seeming superficial and arrogant, he is everything but. I cannot express how much I loved getting to know him and experience Ellen leaving cracks in his shiny armour.
Highly recommend!
November 16, 2024
Family
Such a good book about the true meaning of family and the intricacies of love and the joy of finding it.
Such a good book about the true meaning of family and the intricacies of love and the joy of finding it.
May 13, 2023
the basic plot was silly
That a responsible owner of a prestigious girls school would send her best teacher off without a thought with a child is hard to believe. Left with a note? Who was paying the school? Then a marriage to a stranger who looks weird? No big deal. It just got worse from there. Sorry. I have so loved much of her books.
That a responsible owner of a prestigious girls school would send her best teacher off without a thought with a child is hard to believe. Left with a note? Who was paying the school? Then a marriage to a stranger who looks weird? No big deal. It just got worse from there. Sorry. I have so loved much of her books.
May 11, 2023
What's a man to do when he accidentally tells his best friend he's married, and his best friend tells... everybody? Well, get married, obviously. Or pretend to get married. Something like that; does it matter? If people think he's married, they'll quit throwing women at him, which is the important thing.
The characters in this book are flawed and real and endearing. They're full of the contradictions inherent in the human condition. Both unreliable and steadfast. Kind and thoughtless. Self-aware and in denial. Intelligent and... well. Poor at planning ahead, shall we say?
Contradictions are a major theme in this book. In addition to what goes on within the characters is what goes on without. Serious topics are leavened with those tropes we all know and love, which makes for a relatively light and entertaining read. After all, what's family estrangement when there's only one bed?
Now for the other things I usually want to know before I decide whether to pick up a book:
CONTINUITY: This novel reads fine without the background of the other books in the original Wishing Well series and its Seminary continuation.
HEAT: The heat level is medium-low and consists mostly of scandalous parlour games, appreciation for someone's physical attributes, and a possibly-married couple sharing some intense kissing, sometimes in bed.
MORALITY: The morality of the protagonists is tonnish. Edmund kept a mistress, though he hasn't seen her in a year. He gets drunk enough to forget taking responsibility for a ward. He subscribes to the "might makes right" philosophy inherent to dueling. He and Ellen say vows they don't mean and heap lies upon lies, speaking them to others and hiding things from each other (and also the reader; there are a few serious plot twists). All of which is perfectly acceptable to the highest echelons of Society, of course, especially when it makes entertaining gossip.
HISTORICAL CORRECTNESS: This book is largely accurate to the best of my knowledge, but you'll have to suspend disbelief a little if you happen to be unusually informed regarding historical family law, though there's nothing that's not ubiquitous to this genre. The parlour games are well researched, and there are little historical details scattered throughout, such as a mention of a famous cartoonist and the use of corsets in men's fashion.
I'll reread this book in the future, so I give it four-and-a-half stars rounded up.
I received an advance copy of this book for review purposes. All opinions my own.
The characters in this book are flawed and real and endearing. They're full of the contradictions inherent in the human condition. Both unreliable and steadfast. Kind and thoughtless. Self-aware and in denial. Intelligent and... well. Poor at planning ahead, shall we say?
Contradictions are a major theme in this book. In addition to what goes on within the characters is what goes on without. Serious topics are leavened with those tropes we all know and love, which makes for a relatively light and entertaining read. After all, what's family estrangement when there's only one bed?
Now for the other things I usually want to know before I decide whether to pick up a book:
CONTINUITY: This novel reads fine without the background of the other books in the original Wishing Well series and its Seminary continuation.
HEAT: The heat level is medium-low and consists mostly of scandalous parlour games, appreciation for someone's physical attributes, and a possibly-married couple sharing some intense kissing, sometimes in bed.
MORALITY: The morality of the protagonists is tonnish. Edmund kept a mistress, though he hasn't seen her in a year. He gets drunk enough to forget taking responsibility for a ward. He subscribes to the "might makes right" philosophy inherent to dueling. He and Ellen say vows they don't mean and heap lies upon lies, speaking them to others and hiding things from each other (and also the reader; there are a few serious plot twists). All of which is perfectly acceptable to the highest echelons of Society, of course, especially when it makes entertaining gossip.
HISTORICAL CORRECTNESS: This book is largely accurate to the best of my knowledge, but you'll have to suspend disbelief a little if you happen to be unusually informed regarding historical family law, though there's nothing that's not ubiquitous to this genre. The parlour games are well researched, and there are little historical details scattered throughout, such as a mention of a famous cartoonist and the use of corsets in men's fashion.
I'll reread this book in the future, so I give it four-and-a-half stars rounded up.
I received an advance copy of this book for review purposes. All opinions my own.
May 5, 2023
This is such a fun story with some witty dialogue and fun descriptions of Baron Tewkbury. There were also some parts that made me sad in finding out the past of the H and h. You know its a good a story when you cannot put the book down and the time just seems to fly by as you read chapter after chapter. Even though some characters from the previous book are mentioned, this book is a stand alone story.
This story starts in the Seminary when a little boy is just dropped off on the doorstep with a note. Since it is a Girl's Seminary, the little guy who doesn't seem to speak cannot stay there. The handwriting on the note is very illegible but they finally conclude a name and address. Miss Eleonore Hilversham who is now married and the Duchess of Rochford, sends Miss Ellen Robinson, one of her best schoolmistresses to bring the boy back to his guardian. She also has family in London that she will be visiting before she returns to Bath. When she finds the guardian Baron Edmund Tewkbury, he is dresses in flamboyant colors and has makeup on his face. Soon after their introduction, he offers to pay her much more than her normal pay to stay and care for the boy Noni. Then he takes her by surprise when he asks her to marry him, which has her running out of the house. When she finds out that her family is having some troubles with the oldest son who has been put in jail, she decides to help by marrying the baron.
Edmund Graves, Sixth Baron Tewkbury, wants to avoid the matchmaking that will be going on at his best friend's house party. He knows his friend's wife is intent on finding him a match so to avoid her traps, he tells his group of friends that he has just gotten married the day before. When his friend insists that he bring his new wife to the house party, he now has to come up with a wife. so when a woman suddenly shows up on his doorstep with glorious red hair, before he knows it, he is proposing.
Within a short time, they are married using a special license, getting her a new wardrobe and off to the house party to introduce his new wife. Since these two are virtual strangers, they have a lot to learn about each other. As Edmund has told his friends, he married quickly because it was a love match, will these two end up separating or become a true love match?
I received a copy of this book from the author and this is my honest unbiased review.
This story starts in the Seminary when a little boy is just dropped off on the doorstep with a note. Since it is a Girl's Seminary, the little guy who doesn't seem to speak cannot stay there. The handwriting on the note is very illegible but they finally conclude a name and address. Miss Eleonore Hilversham who is now married and the Duchess of Rochford, sends Miss Ellen Robinson, one of her best schoolmistresses to bring the boy back to his guardian. She also has family in London that she will be visiting before she returns to Bath. When she finds the guardian Baron Edmund Tewkbury, he is dresses in flamboyant colors and has makeup on his face. Soon after their introduction, he offers to pay her much more than her normal pay to stay and care for the boy Noni. Then he takes her by surprise when he asks her to marry him, which has her running out of the house. When she finds out that her family is having some troubles with the oldest son who has been put in jail, she decides to help by marrying the baron.
Edmund Graves, Sixth Baron Tewkbury, wants to avoid the matchmaking that will be going on at his best friend's house party. He knows his friend's wife is intent on finding him a match so to avoid her traps, he tells his group of friends that he has just gotten married the day before. When his friend insists that he bring his new wife to the house party, he now has to come up with a wife. so when a woman suddenly shows up on his doorstep with glorious red hair, before he knows it, he is proposing.
Within a short time, they are married using a special license, getting her a new wardrobe and off to the house party to introduce his new wife. Since these two are virtual strangers, they have a lot to learn about each other. As Edmund has told his friends, he married quickly because it was a love match, will these two end up separating or become a true love match?
I received a copy of this book from the author and this is my honest unbiased review.
May 12, 2023
I really enjoyed this story as a whole. Many missteps by many people conspire to build the path to a marriage of convenience that blossoms into love. Both main characters have facades of layers from their histories and past struggles. I found Ellen and Edmund engaging. Edmund had created such a caricature of himself as a foolish fop. The narrative provided many moments and events that shook the foundations of his protective barriers. The house party was full of many interesting moments. There were also some excellent kisses and swoony moments. I enjoyed most of the story so much that I decided to stick with the five stars, in spite of a few issues that I had with the book. First, I found the main characters’ view and understanding of the legality and realness of the marriage inconsistent and illogical. I understand that in marriage of convenience stories it is common to treat the marriage as a pretence and then eventually have it become “real” as feelings develop. What I found strange was the flip-flopping on their beliefs of the legality of the marriage. They married legally, and it didn’t seem to be in question, and then they would question it for seemingly no reason. When there was a detail that would legitimately make one wonder about it, it wasn’t really addressed. It felt a bit more Iike a whim as to whether or not they wanted to consider it legal or not. My other significant issue was that Edmund was made to appear such an excessive fop early on, but then it felt like it was never really resolved where he landed between his natural and real interests in fashion and scent, and the character he had conceived as a shield. It’s like the excess either disappeared unexplained or just continued the same with no mention. Some of the early details, like the face painting, were so excessive that for them to not be mentioned later on one way or the other leaves it feeling unresolved to me. The story has an epilogue, which I usually love, but I finished it feeling a little disappointed, I think because of the lingering uncertainty I felt from what I mentioned above. I did really like this book, my complaints aside. I think most readers will also enjoy it. While reading the previous book in the series does provide some background, this story can be read as a standalone. It is a clean story with no harsh language.
May 4, 2023
I received a free ARC for my honest review, so here I am honestly reviewing. 🤔
This is the second book in the Wishing Well Seminary series, but can be read as a standalone. I don’t often say that regarding books that are interconnected by character/plot/setting so you can trust me on this one. Yes, there are mentions of characters from prior novels but they aren’t integral to this story.
Characters - both MMC and FMC were likable, if not as fleshed out as I would have liked. The MMC’s inner monologue spoke more for him than his actions and words. I would have liked to have seen more individual personality development and more interactions between our two mains to show how they became attached to one another. Their relationship kind of went from 0 to 100 without warning. Our FMC had a moment out of nowhere that I didn’t see coming, so that was a nice little surprise.
There were many side characters and I did at times have trouble keeping track.
Plot - not going to lie here, I’m not a fan of the fake relationship trope. If it’s well written, I’m all in. I was all in. Side plots did get overwhelming at times, and the story seemed to lose focus in a few spots. Overall, this did not detract from my enjoyment.
There were some darker undertones in this novel when compared to her prior work. Nothing is described in detail, but the themes are there and they run as an undercurrent throughout the entire book. It helps to explain both the MCs motivations and the personalities they have each developed, which can be seen as a sort of shield against regency society at large. I’m going to put a few trigger warnings at the bottom for anyone who may stumble upon this review.
Setting - they did travel more than I realized…four settings although the bulk of the story seemed to be at a house party. The house party made me feel uncomfortable for our FMC so again, well written as I’m guessing that was the effect Mrs. Laporte was going for. 🫣
Final thoughts - not my favorite in this series (including the prior Wishing Well novels under this umbrella) but still a fun, light read. I stayed up reading way later than anyone my age has any business doing because I couldn’t put the book down. 3.5 stars
TW: discussion of abuse (physical, emotional)
This is the second book in the Wishing Well Seminary series, but can be read as a standalone. I don’t often say that regarding books that are interconnected by character/plot/setting so you can trust me on this one. Yes, there are mentions of characters from prior novels but they aren’t integral to this story.
Characters - both MMC and FMC were likable, if not as fleshed out as I would have liked. The MMC’s inner monologue spoke more for him than his actions and words. I would have liked to have seen more individual personality development and more interactions between our two mains to show how they became attached to one another. Their relationship kind of went from 0 to 100 without warning. Our FMC had a moment out of nowhere that I didn’t see coming, so that was a nice little surprise.
There were many side characters and I did at times have trouble keeping track.
Plot - not going to lie here, I’m not a fan of the fake relationship trope. If it’s well written, I’m all in. I was all in. Side plots did get overwhelming at times, and the story seemed to lose focus in a few spots. Overall, this did not detract from my enjoyment.
There were some darker undertones in this novel when compared to her prior work. Nothing is described in detail, but the themes are there and they run as an undercurrent throughout the entire book. It helps to explain both the MCs motivations and the personalities they have each developed, which can be seen as a sort of shield against regency society at large. I’m going to put a few trigger warnings at the bottom for anyone who may stumble upon this review.
Setting - they did travel more than I realized…four settings although the bulk of the story seemed to be at a house party. The house party made me feel uncomfortable for our FMC so again, well written as I’m guessing that was the effect Mrs. Laporte was going for. 🫣
Final thoughts - not my favorite in this series (including the prior Wishing Well novels under this umbrella) but still a fun, light read. I stayed up reading way later than anyone my age has any business doing because I couldn’t put the book down. 3.5 stars
TW: discussion of abuse (physical, emotional)
May 14, 2023
Read it for the:
- fake marriage
- opposites attract
- house party setting
- learning disability representation
- Hidden identities
- Complex family relationships / found family
Content: past death of parent, past mention of bullying
Romance: Sweet, Kissing only
Final rating: 4.5/5
Sofi Laporte delivers another fun and surprising story in Miss Robinson and the Unsuitable Baron. I was hooked from the first chapter and couldn't put it down.
The heart of this book was the characters. Laporte’s talent really shines in creating complex, entertaining, characters No one is who they seem, and the layers that Edmund and Ellen had were slowly peeled back as the story progressed. I loved Ellen's headstrong but kind nature and her confidence. But Edmund was, surprisingly, my favorite. He was not at all the traditional hero- with his obsession with clothes and unique hobbies. His expressions and actions made for some great comedy, but he also had some heart-tugging moments as well. Edmund and Ellen's connection grew as their time together increased. I loved how their fake marriage progressed and how they grew to trust each other. Their romance had palpable chemistry- I think they might hold first place for most kissing.
Possibly my favorite part of this novel was the time taken to showcase a learning disability that affects so many today. It was handled with tack and added a level of realism to ground the story, Without spoiling too much, I love how Laporte was able to express the struggles and insecurities that come along with having a learning disability. Brilliant representation.
Another aspect that I enjoyed about this story was the plot and how the research was presented. Regency house-party games were insane-and the plot was able to showcase that. I also liked how family relationships were highlighted. Edmund and Ellen both had a complex family history and it added depth to the plot and it contributed to the development of their characters.
It was also nice to see two of my favorite characters from the previous book appear, a nice touch for fans. This was a quick, but heartwarming Regency romcom that I recommend.
*I received a complimentary copy of this book. The opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own.
- fake marriage
- opposites attract
- house party setting
- learning disability representation
- Hidden identities
- Complex family relationships / found family
Content: past death of parent, past mention of bullying
Romance: Sweet, Kissing only
Final rating: 4.5/5
Sofi Laporte delivers another fun and surprising story in Miss Robinson and the Unsuitable Baron. I was hooked from the first chapter and couldn't put it down.
The heart of this book was the characters. Laporte’s talent really shines in creating complex, entertaining, characters No one is who they seem, and the layers that Edmund and Ellen had were slowly peeled back as the story progressed. I loved Ellen's headstrong but kind nature and her confidence. But Edmund was, surprisingly, my favorite. He was not at all the traditional hero- with his obsession with clothes and unique hobbies. His expressions and actions made for some great comedy, but he also had some heart-tugging moments as well. Edmund and Ellen's connection grew as their time together increased. I loved how their fake marriage progressed and how they grew to trust each other. Their romance had palpable chemistry- I think they might hold first place for most kissing.
Possibly my favorite part of this novel was the time taken to showcase a learning disability that affects so many today. It was handled with tack and added a level of realism to ground the story, Without spoiling too much, I love how Laporte was able to express the struggles and insecurities that come along with having a learning disability. Brilliant representation.
Another aspect that I enjoyed about this story was the plot and how the research was presented. Regency house-party games were insane-and the plot was able to showcase that. I also liked how family relationships were highlighted. Edmund and Ellen both had a complex family history and it added depth to the plot and it contributed to the development of their characters.
It was also nice to see two of my favorite characters from the previous book appear, a nice touch for fans. This was a quick, but heartwarming Regency romcom that I recommend.
*I received a complimentary copy of this book. The opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own.
May 13, 2023
Miss Ellen Robinson, a school mistress at Miss Hilversham’s Seminary for Young Ladies, is tasked with taking a young mute boy back to his guardian in London, after he’s dropped off on the school’s doorstep. A school for young ladies has no place for a four-year-old boy. What she doesn’t realize is that the letter the boy is delivered with contains easily mistaken information. When Miss Robinson delivers the child to the home of Baron Tewkbury, she’s drawn into a scheme that will have consequences beyond what any of them think possible.
Miss Robinson is a proper young woman who only wants to drop the boy off, make a quick visit to her family, and return to the school. Baron Tewkbury is a dandy with a penchant for fine clothes, fine smelling scents, and a bit of a wild streak. When the two meet, neither is particularly enthused with the other, but they both see the importance of taking care of young Noni. When the baron proposes an arrangement in which they pretend to be married, he makes it do financially worthwhile that Miss Robinson cannot refuse.
\
This was a delightful story. The house party they all attend at the baron’s friend Dobberham’s is a delight. Dobberham’s wife Louise keeps everyone on their toes as she endeavors to pair everyone up. I laughed at some of her games that were filled with silly and embarrassing moments.
I enjoyed watching as the relationship between Miss Robinson and Baron Tewkbury evolves and as both come to love Noni. This is a great addition to the Wishing Well Seminary series. It's a quick and entertaining read, and I highly recommend it. While it's the second book in the series, it isn't necessary to read the first book in the series. While that book is equally enjoyable, this book can stand on it's own.
I received an advanced reader copy of this book from the author. I thank her for her generosity, but it had no effect on this review. All opinions in this review reflect my true and honest reactions to reading this book.
Miss Robinson is a proper young woman who only wants to drop the boy off, make a quick visit to her family, and return to the school. Baron Tewkbury is a dandy with a penchant for fine clothes, fine smelling scents, and a bit of a wild streak. When the two meet, neither is particularly enthused with the other, but they both see the importance of taking care of young Noni. When the baron proposes an arrangement in which they pretend to be married, he makes it do financially worthwhile that Miss Robinson cannot refuse.
\
This was a delightful story. The house party they all attend at the baron’s friend Dobberham’s is a delight. Dobberham’s wife Louise keeps everyone on their toes as she endeavors to pair everyone up. I laughed at some of her games that were filled with silly and embarrassing moments.
I enjoyed watching as the relationship between Miss Robinson and Baron Tewkbury evolves and as both come to love Noni. This is a great addition to the Wishing Well Seminary series. It's a quick and entertaining read, and I highly recommend it. While it's the second book in the series, it isn't necessary to read the first book in the series. While that book is equally enjoyable, this book can stand on it's own.
I received an advanced reader copy of this book from the author. I thank her for her generosity, but it had no effect on this review. All opinions in this review reflect my true and honest reactions to reading this book.
May 16, 2023
When a little boy with a note shows up outside the girls seminary she works at, Ellen agrees to see him home. But when she gets him there, she finds a foppish baron who appears to know nothing about the boy but accepts him - then asks her to stay on as his wife, offering enough money to get her family out of trouble. Edmund hides his true self from society under flamboyant clothing and outlandish behaviour. But when a small lie turns into a big lie and he ends up with a wife, he finds he can't always hide himself from her. Worse, he's not altogether sure whether he wants to. As Ellen gets to know her husband better, she uncovers layers she'd never guessed existed - but can a marriage built on lies ever turn into something true?
I have to admit that parts of the descriptions of the house party did leave me somewhat uncomfortable. I'd still call it all clean, but it gave off vibes that didn't quite feel so (I can't think of a better way to describe it). However, once they got away from the house party, or even just away from the games and activities, I really enjoyed it. There's something special about gradually uncovering the layers of someone who seems trivial on the surface but is really trying to hide from the cold hard world - and that's what we see with the baron. They don't have an easy start to a relationship, but I really enjoyed watching them build something together, however little they initially intended to. All in all, a great read and I look forward to the next book.
Note that I received a complimentary copy of the book from the author. I was not required to write a positive review and this is my considered opinion of the book.
I have to admit that parts of the descriptions of the house party did leave me somewhat uncomfortable. I'd still call it all clean, but it gave off vibes that didn't quite feel so (I can't think of a better way to describe it). However, once they got away from the house party, or even just away from the games and activities, I really enjoyed it. There's something special about gradually uncovering the layers of someone who seems trivial on the surface but is really trying to hide from the cold hard world - and that's what we see with the baron. They don't have an easy start to a relationship, but I really enjoyed watching them build something together, however little they initially intended to. All in all, a great read and I look forward to the next book.
Note that I received a complimentary copy of the book from the author. I was not required to write a positive review and this is my considered opinion of the book.
September 27, 2023
I really liked this for the main two but there were a few things that felt like trope cutout plot points. The old flame shows up out of nowhere just because the plot needs it as a big moment. The end drama feels very rushed and formulaic and the child ward is more like a prop than a person for 95% of the book. This needed another 100 pages, in my opinion. Most of these books are under edited but this is the rare exception where it's the other way. Also, the ton and Regency setting felt very skin deep because most of the story takes place at a house party with no rules. I think this story taking place amidst a London season would've made it even better, but author seemed to feel the matchmaking house party was more efficient for the family drama and romance.
I think Edmund is one of the best dandies I've read and Ellen holds up for the most part but her backstory is ridiculous, though maybe I just think that because of how it gets revealed. I thought she would've been a bit more assertive in conversation after she gets introduced as a confident woman early on, but there isn't really much of that. Edmund was pretty unique as a main character and I thought his problems gave him depth. He's definitely the highlight of this book.
Most of this review is negative but the read is so pleasant otherwise that it's still good despite these very definitive flaws. I still think it's a 7.5/10 even with weak, sometimes forced plotting.
I think Edmund is one of the best dandies I've read and Ellen holds up for the most part but her backstory is ridiculous, though maybe I just think that because of how it gets revealed. I thought she would've been a bit more assertive in conversation after she gets introduced as a confident woman early on, but there isn't really much of that. Edmund was pretty unique as a main character and I thought his problems gave him depth. He's definitely the highlight of this book.
Most of this review is negative but the read is so pleasant otherwise that it's still good despite these very definitive flaws. I still think it's a 7.5/10 even with weak, sometimes forced plotting.
June 5, 2023
4.6 stars
At first glance Edmund is a fop and a fool! Three hours on his his dress and prep alone!
Mary Ellen Aka Ellen was charged to go to London and deliver a child to his guardian ad he was a male at an all girls school!
Edmund’s clothes alone was full of humor but there is personal heartbreak from his past that haunts him and his wardrobe!
He also is a perfume maker, another man with several layers who also protects his own!
Ellen has secrets to ones she did not disclose even to Miss Hilversham school.
The school was a new beginning for her! Once she arrives at Edmund home (which is in London). You will need to know this later.
She thinks Edmund is quite mad as he proposes to her at first sight!
Edmund was desperate and confessed at the Haymarket fencing club he is a married man!
Not just married but in love. This is another madcap and sometimes tear jerker rocky and rollercoaster ride to HEA. You will laugh, cry and laugh again as two people stumble into a love for the ages! Bravo!
*I received an ARC copy for my unbiased opinion!
At first glance Edmund is a fop and a fool! Three hours on his his dress and prep alone!
Mary Ellen Aka Ellen was charged to go to London and deliver a child to his guardian ad he was a male at an all girls school!
Edmund’s clothes alone was full of humor but there is personal heartbreak from his past that haunts him and his wardrobe!
He also is a perfume maker, another man with several layers who also protects his own!
Ellen has secrets to ones she did not disclose even to Miss Hilversham school.
The school was a new beginning for her! Once she arrives at Edmund home (which is in London). You will need to know this later.
She thinks Edmund is quite mad as he proposes to her at first sight!
Edmund was desperate and confessed at the Haymarket fencing club he is a married man!
Not just married but in love. This is another madcap and sometimes tear jerker rocky and rollercoaster ride to HEA. You will laugh, cry and laugh again as two people stumble into a love for the ages! Bravo!
*I received an ARC copy for my unbiased opinion!
May 17, 2023
I enjoyed this book as much as I enjoyed the first in the series. There is depth to her characters and a love story woven with many threads.
Miss Ellen Robinson was a schoolmistress who was tasked with returned a ward to his guardian in London. While that seemed to be a simple and straightforward task, she got caught up in a measure of deceit and scandal. When she accepted an improper proposition/proposal, she never expected her life to be so changed.
Lord Edmund Tewkbury was a fop and a dandy of the highest order. But, was it all an act? As Ellen got to know him better and got a glimpse under his many layers, she began to discover that he was not the man he appeared to be at all to the rest of the world. Would he allow her into his "world" to see the man he really was and would she like what she found?
I was given an arc copy of this book and I willingly offer my honest review.
Miss Ellen Robinson was a schoolmistress who was tasked with returned a ward to his guardian in London. While that seemed to be a simple and straightforward task, she got caught up in a measure of deceit and scandal. When she accepted an improper proposition/proposal, she never expected her life to be so changed.
Lord Edmund Tewkbury was a fop and a dandy of the highest order. But, was it all an act? As Ellen got to know him better and got a glimpse under his many layers, she began to discover that he was not the man he appeared to be at all to the rest of the world. Would he allow her into his "world" to see the man he really was and would she like what she found?
I was given an arc copy of this book and I willingly offer my honest review.
May 18, 2023
The thing about Sofi LaPorte is that I enjoy her books so much while I’m reading them, but I can’t remember them. They are just so light and fluffy. This one is less so because Edmund is such a wonderful character! A Tulip of the ton who creates perfume, yet he’s a master fencer, with real muscles under those garish clothes, which he dons like armor. Unfortunately, there is so much time spent on ridiculous parlor games, we get very little time with Ellen. Her story isn’t revealed until the end when we have no time left to empathize with her. We have figured out what Edmund’s issue is, but she doesn’t figure it out until the book is almost over. By then it’s too late for them to really discuss it. I feel like we needed a couple more chapters and a lot more private time with Edmund and Ellen. I want a sequel with these two. I definitely need more Edmund Tewkbury. And one more thing: Iphigenia? Seriously?
June 13, 2023
I really enjoy reading Sofi Laporte's books and was of course looking forward to reading Miss Robinson's story. Edmund is definitely what they would call a Fop and I didn't really know how to take his character. It was so extreme, more so than I've read in the other historical fiction books that I've read. I really like the character of the Scarlet Pimpernel and know that he also created a facade so others wouldn't see who he really was, as did Edmund, but I had a hard time getting over the rouge, eye liner, awful color combos, etc. i was hoping that as Ellen and Edmund came to love each other and find acceptance, that maybe some of his facade would drop, but it didn't. He was putting on a show and I wanted to see under those flashy layers to who he really was. Overall, Ellen and Edmund are a fun couple and this was a diverting book to read. The house party is kind of crazy and many shenanigans ensue but helped Ellen and Edmund to see other for who they really are.
August 19, 2023
Mystery Humor Secrets in a Endearing Romance
An apparently outrageous aristocrat, Edmund shocks Ellen. In her proper schoolmistress role, she intends to deliver a four-year-old boy to his ward. She doesn’t expect a proposal of marriage! Ellen, Edmund, and Noni are eventually revealed to have secrets. Each of them have a stunning background story. Since the proposed marriage has a financial benefit for Ellen and a social protection for Edmund, I was a bit skeptical. Yet, a house party reveals strong character traits that develop into mutual admiration. Their shared humor gives them courage in difficult situations. Ellen shows an audacious ability to defend Edmund. Edmund gallantly defends Ellen in a fencing duel. When the shame each of them suffers from their families softens their relationship, they have some decisions to make. This leads to a surprising climax for this enchanting tale. I loved it.
An apparently outrageous aristocrat, Edmund shocks Ellen. In her proper schoolmistress role, she intends to deliver a four-year-old boy to his ward. She doesn’t expect a proposal of marriage! Ellen, Edmund, and Noni are eventually revealed to have secrets. Each of them have a stunning background story. Since the proposed marriage has a financial benefit for Ellen and a social protection for Edmund, I was a bit skeptical. Yet, a house party reveals strong character traits that develop into mutual admiration. Their shared humor gives them courage in difficult situations. Ellen shows an audacious ability to defend Edmund. Edmund gallantly defends Ellen in a fencing duel. When the shame each of them suffers from their families softens their relationship, they have some decisions to make. This leads to a surprising climax for this enchanting tale. I loved it.
May 20, 2023
I read a glowing review of this book by a friend and had to pick it up right away. I read it almost entirely in one afternoon!
Ellen, a schoolteacher, is sent to deliver a boy to his guardian in London. The guardian, Edmund, has told all of his friends that he is married in order to avoid their matchmaking schemes. When Ellen shows up on his doorstep, he asks if she will pose as his new bride in exchange for him helping her family out.
This story was so utterly charming. The characters are easy to love, the setting (a house party with scandalous games!) was fun and unique, and the conflict was raw and emotional. At first, I wasn't sure I was going to like Edmund as he is a bit eccentric, but over time, he really grew on me. Especially because of the sweet relationship he has with Noni. And Ellen was so kind and genuinely just wanted the best for everyone around her.
Another note, this is the first time I've ever read about a character who has a learning disability in Regency romance. I was very impressed with how Sofi wrote about it and felt like, even though I myself don't struggle with this disability, it was easy to put myself in the shoes of those who do and empathize with their struggles.
Heat: Just kisses, some mentioning of appreciation of opposite sex's bodies
TW: bullying due to learning disability, mention of a prostitute, drunkenness
Ellen, a schoolteacher, is sent to deliver a boy to his guardian in London. The guardian, Edmund, has told all of his friends that he is married in order to avoid their matchmaking schemes. When Ellen shows up on his doorstep, he asks if she will pose as his new bride in exchange for him helping her family out.
This story was so utterly charming. The characters are easy to love, the setting (a house party with scandalous games!) was fun and unique, and the conflict was raw and emotional. At first, I wasn't sure I was going to like Edmund as he is a bit eccentric, but over time, he really grew on me. Especially because of the sweet relationship he has with Noni. And Ellen was so kind and genuinely just wanted the best for everyone around her.
Another note, this is the first time I've ever read about a character who has a learning disability in Regency romance. I was very impressed with how Sofi wrote about it and felt like, even though I myself don't struggle with this disability, it was easy to put myself in the shoes of those who do and empathize with their struggles.
Heat: Just kisses, some mentioning of appreciation of opposite sex's bodies
TW: bullying due to learning disability, mention of a prostitute, drunkenness
April 27, 2023
Miss Robinson and the Unsuitable Baron is book two in the Wishing Well Seminary series. I was absolutely enthralled by this story and couldn’t put it down. This author weaves magic into her tales. Ellen Robinson is charged by her employer to return a young ward, who shows up on the school’s doorstep, to his guardian in London. But when she makes the acquaintance of the dandy Baron Tewkbury her world is turned upside down. I think I fell in love with the “nincompoop” hero Edmund, Baron Tewkbury. He is so much more than a fashion minded peacock. So far, I have absolutely adored every one of this author’s books. I can’t wait for the next installment in this series. This is a sweet romance.
May 2, 2023
Miss Robinson and the Unsuitable Baron is a wonderful story. I loved the strength of the characters in overcoming hard things in their pasts and finding ways to be content despite what they went through. Edmund’s struggle especially hit home to me as my own daughter struggles in a similar way. I loved how his strengths were showcased, because we all have strengths, even those who struggle with things that most do not. Still, their contentment is not joy and they find that true happiness comes after being completely honest with themselves and each other, in forgiving, being vulnerable, and loving one another.
This book had just the right amount of sexual tension while still being absolutely clean and wholesome. If you have read Sofi’s Wishing Well Series, you’ll love this series too!
This book had just the right amount of sexual tension while still being absolutely clean and wholesome. If you have read Sofi’s Wishing Well Series, you’ll love this series too!
May 12, 2023
I absolutely loved this book! It was very enjoyable and also very different from other regencies I’ve read.
I thought it was unique how the main character had a learning disability- that somewhat explains his personality and the odd way he dresses and acts. I also thought it was refreshing how the 2 main characters were straight forward with each other (no hiding of their thoughts and feelings). They were both so likable.
I loved the little bits about the perfume mixing. I also thought it was awesome that the author had the historical notes at the end.
I picked this book up and couldn’t set it down till I was finished with it. It was such a fun and entertaining read and it had a happy ending. Can’t wait for the next one!
I thought it was unique how the main character had a learning disability- that somewhat explains his personality and the odd way he dresses and acts. I also thought it was refreshing how the 2 main characters were straight forward with each other (no hiding of their thoughts and feelings). They were both so likable.
I loved the little bits about the perfume mixing. I also thought it was awesome that the author had the historical notes at the end.
I picked this book up and couldn’t set it down till I was finished with it. It was such a fun and entertaining read and it had a happy ending. Can’t wait for the next one!
May 16, 2023
It was a bit surprising that schoolteacher Ellen would be tasked with returning little Noni by herself when the headmistress is a Duchess with resources but that leads her to meeting the unlike hero of the story Edmund with his peacock clothes and ways. At first, I didn’t like him with his condescending attitude, but it’s part of a front to hide the true man inside who had been scarred by the past. Noni was adorable and worms his way into both their hearts. Ellen and Edmund both have faults, secrets, and misunderstandings. But she will do anything for those she considers family who took her in when no one else would, even marry a man who likes garish colors and has friends who invite them to house parties with outrageous party games.
April 27, 2023
I enjoy the Wishing Well books. I loved the characters in this story and my heart ached for Edmund for the pain he endured because of his dyslexia. Such cruelty at the hand of so many. Ellen also endured some cruelty but in a completely different way. They understood each other having experienced pain themselves. And they understood Noni better too. Edmunds sweet relationship with Noni was so tender. I love Edmunds, fop that he is. I have a little hope burning that Edmund will be able to repair his relationship with his family in the future. The potential was there. This was an enjoyable read for me.
Sex: some innuendo
Language: no
Violence: some
Sex: some innuendo
Language: no
Violence: some
May 5, 2023
I received an ARC of this book. This is my honest review:
I like Sofi's books very much, not least because they're clean. This book is very much in her usual style of a good story coupled with insight into aristocratic life of the day. However, I found the amount of time she spent on the wild (and basically immoral) house party excessive. Despite being an "escapist" reader, I do appreciate authenticity and a fair amount of realism, but the goings-on at the party at the Dobberhams' left me feeling disgusted.
Despite my criticism, the book is well-written. The character I liked the most was Noni.
I like Sofi's books very much, not least because they're clean. This book is very much in her usual style of a good story coupled with insight into aristocratic life of the day. However, I found the amount of time she spent on the wild (and basically immoral) house party excessive. Despite being an "escapist" reader, I do appreciate authenticity and a fair amount of realism, but the goings-on at the party at the Dobberhams' left me feeling disgusted.
Despite my criticism, the book is well-written. The character I liked the most was Noni.
January 7, 2025
A DELIGHTFUL HISTORICAL ROMANCE, 5 STARS
Sofi Laporte is really presenting us with a most unique historical romance drama in this quirky yet also poignant storyline with her 5 STARS Book 1 Series: Wishing Well Seminary. Love the characters in this fast paced story with some of the craziest antics I have read. Our main characters attend a houseparty & the hostess in my opinion is hilariously crazy. I kinda get what she is doing & why, after all she is a matchmaker.
Our main questions here are will Ellen & Edmund fall in love & can Noni speak? Let us have hope. I really enjoyed this different slice of looking at things.
RECOMMEND
Sofi Laporte is really presenting us with a most unique historical romance drama in this quirky yet also poignant storyline with her 5 STARS Book 1 Series: Wishing Well Seminary. Love the characters in this fast paced story with some of the craziest antics I have read. Our main characters attend a houseparty & the hostess in my opinion is hilariously crazy. I kinda get what she is doing & why, after all she is a matchmaker.
Our main questions here are will Ellen & Edmund fall in love & can Noni speak? Let us have hope. I really enjoyed this different slice of looking at things.
RECOMMEND
May 11, 2023
Ellen and Edmund have such a unique story. I was so excited to read it and my goodness I was floored! Edmunds character is extremely fashionable. To the point of hair powders and face paint. I thought it was a joke at first! But no, he really is a nincompoop! Or at least he appears to be! Which leads to the question, why on earth would he pretend to be something he is not? I won’t give the answer but it’s fun to try and figure out and finally see the reveal.
Ellen finally gets her story!!! She has her life all figured out until a little boy named Noni is left at the seminary for girls. Ellen is tasked with returning him to his home. Seems simple right?! It is, until she arrives with Noni at Edmunds home with a child he does not know.
The result being a marriage of convenience, for reasons I will let you find out yourself. The depth of each character was so much fun to see. They both have a lot they try to hide about themselves and so much is brewing just beneath the surface.
The marriage of convenience trope is an absolute favourite of mine. Being forced together, and in this case pretending a love match at a house party, it was so much fun!
The face painting aspect of Edmunds character did have me a little thrown. He wears coal under his eyes even. Which combined with the time period, I struggled to picture. But it makes me very curious about the extreme fashions of that time period!
Thankyou to the author, Sofi Laporte, for the complimentary e-arc in exchange for a review. All opinions expressed are my own.
Content: clean
Romance: mild; kissing, closed door/ fade to black
Violence: none
Language: none
Ellen finally gets her story!!! She has her life all figured out until a little boy named Noni is left at the seminary for girls. Ellen is tasked with returning him to his home. Seems simple right?! It is, until she arrives with Noni at Edmunds home with a child he does not know.
The result being a marriage of convenience, for reasons I will let you find out yourself. The depth of each character was so much fun to see. They both have a lot they try to hide about themselves and so much is brewing just beneath the surface.
The marriage of convenience trope is an absolute favourite of mine. Being forced together, and in this case pretending a love match at a house party, it was so much fun!
The face painting aspect of Edmunds character did have me a little thrown. He wears coal under his eyes even. Which combined with the time period, I struggled to picture. But it makes me very curious about the extreme fashions of that time period!
Thankyou to the author, Sofi Laporte, for the complimentary e-arc in exchange for a review. All opinions expressed are my own.
Content: clean
Romance: mild; kissing, closed door/ fade to black
Violence: none
Language: none
May 13, 2023
A clean story. I thought this was a good story. The storyline was a little different and both main characters have secrets. I would have liked to have understood quite why Lady Cynthia acted so possessively towards Edmund at the party. Likewise it is unclear how long the gap was before they visit Bath in the epilogue. There is no mention when Ellen leaves Bath that Miss Hilversham is expecting, yet when they arrive she has a baby, which surprises Ellen. Would it really have taken what must have been months before they visited Bath? However I enjoyed the book.
May 15, 2023
I loved this book. Sofi has succeeded in writing another great book in the Wishing Well Seminary series! I enjoyed the fun, laughed out loud and learned more about a child’s challenge with having a leaning disability that lasts a lifetime. The story of Noni being passed about to strangers was thought provoking as were the party games. The story of Ellen and Edmund was well done, misunderstandings and all. Noni was such a sweet addition. It was well worth the wait for this next book. I highly recommend it! I read an ARC, purchased the book, and this is my honest review.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 78 reviews