I’ll start with the technicalities and then move to the storyline. I understand that this novel is a debut, so there will be some things that aren’t written as well as novels by long-time authors. However, I do think that whether you are a beginner or an expert, if you are writing a book then your grammar should at least be up to snuff. Obviously grammar isn’t all that a book is about, but grammar helps to properly portray stories/conversations, etc. and when grammar is poor, it can be distracting from the storyline. I found that the general structure of the sentences was not great. For instance, the author used of a lot of commas rather than periods; she accidentally switched between past/present tense when the story is set in the present; and she would repeat the same lines / explanations throughout the story. An example of this last point is when Shane and Max get back together at the end of the story, and then the Epilogue begins with a recap of everything that had happened only a few pages earlier. In real-life conversations, yes, recaps are necessary and fine; in a book, we can assume that the reader knows all of this and does not need a full rundown of events that happened a few pages prior. For some people, like myself, if a piece of writing does not grammatically flow, it becomes tough to appreciate the storyline. This is what I found in this novel; every time a sentence was structured poorly, I’d be distracted by how immature the writing sounded.
The storyline itself was pretty good, however a lot of the scenes just kind of seemed unrealistic to me. One of my least favourite things to occur in a romance story is when the characters fall head over heels for each other without knowing each other at all — as if they’re only falling in love because the story calls for it, not because they actually are in love. Max, who’s this wounded, grumpy, walls-up kind of guy, meets this girl, and within like, a day of knowing her, starts to say how this girl is different from all the others and how she’s it for him. I don’t know, just seemed kind of rushed; let them get to know each other first before making huge proclamations. Also, maybe just a me thing, but I didn’t love how much Max winked. I have never genuinely winked at someone once in my life, and Max winks about 2x per conversation — kind of overkill. Furthermore, I get the whole Sunshine nickname thing, but I didn’t love how that was literally the only thing Max called her — I feel that in real life, it’s more of a mix between name and nickname. Finally, I wish this story included more in it than just Shane/Max interactions. It felt like every scene was just them being hot for each other, and it didn’t really depict much of their lives outside of these interactions (yes, a few minor scenes, but even those felt underdeveloped/cut short).
Overall, the storyline was cute, I just think the writing was a little bit immature. It felt like reading the short stories I used to write in 9th grade, and I think this could have been helped with some reviews/editing prior to publish.