“The Story of Astrophysics in Five Revolutions,” by Ersilia Vaudo is an interesting read, although why it was shelved with my local library’s “best” new books I can’t say. Translated from the original Italian by Vanessa DiStefano, its publishers seem to have thought—and who knows, they may be be proven right—that Vaudo, whose writing reads like a lesser imitation of fellow Italian physicist and blockbuster pop-science writer Carlo Rovelli, would sell as many books as Rovelli has. And Vaudo’s writing is certainly reminiscent of Rovelli’s: she has the same poetic bent as Rovelli (and the same tendency to frequently quote famous poets); like him she favors short, crisp sentences; and she has a penchant for offbeat analogies. But where Rovelli’s unconventional analogies—as well as his habitual poetic allusions and philosophical digressions—almost always tend to reveal something deeper about his subject, Vaudo’s similar tendencies fall somewhat flat for me. To be sure, this may just be more a matter of personal taste. Others might find Vaudo’s book to be as refreshingly novel and fascinating as I found Rovelli’s early publications to be (most especially “Reality Is Not What It Seems” and Seven Brief Lessons on Physics” - notice how the title of Vaudo’s book conveniently echoes that of Rovelli’s most popular [both of which echo Richard Feynman’s evergreen classic “Six Easy Pieces”]).
But maybe I’m being a snob. After all, Vaudo’s book can be quite engaging. For me, though, there just isn’t much to differentiate it from the absolute glut of pop science books published every year. For anyone with an interest in physics who hasn’t yet read much on the subject, Vaudo helpfully recapitulates many of the major breakthroughs in physics (focusing on seven of the most important, as the title suggests), from Brahe and Kepler to Schrödinger and Fermi, and she never gets overly technical. This can surely be regarded as a feature for many who, as I said, have an interest in science but are just starting to explore the subject. For anyone with more than one or two popular physics books already under their belt, however, it will probably seem a bit repetitive, not to say overly didactic. And if you are just beginning your physics journey, there are approximately twenty thousand incredible books on the subject that you should read before this one—and the aforementioned books by Feynman and Rovelli would make it twenty thousand and three.